Adult Year 1 · Semester 3 — Texts and teachings
Four lessons for this semester. When you are ready, take the test for this semester.
Lesson 1: Singing the Living Tradition — the hymnal: a guided overview
The texts semester opens with the book this creedless faith actually lives by: Singing the Living Tradition — the hymnal of 1993, the grey book of the pews — a guided overview of the closest thing Unitarian Universalism has to a scripture in daily use. The book first, in its making. A hymnal in a creedless church is a theological act, and the record of this one's making is the faith's self-portrait: commissioned by the Association, compiled across years by the Hymnbook Commission's sifting of the tradition's music and the world's, published in 1993 (with its teal companion for the readings and the later supplements — Singing the Journey of 2005 among them), the book holds some four hundred hymns and more than seven hundred readings in its two great sections — the singing and the reading bound in one volume, the congregation's whole Sunday voice between two covers. Its editorial principles are the faith's: the language inclusive (the old hymns' 'man' and the masculine God reworked or retired — the revision that cost the editors their hardest fights and the book its sharpest critics, the record noting both), the sources universal (the hymns of the Christian tradition beside the Jewish, the humanist anthems beside the earth songs, the spirituals and the freedom songs of the movements in the canon of the pews), and the readings a library of the six Sources in miniature (the Psalms and the prophets, the Buddha and Laozi, the scientists and the poets, the Transcendentalists and the civil rights preachers — the service's lectern supplied, in one book, with the whole breadth of the foundations' third lesson). The school's account of the book's rank follows the tradition's: it is not scripture (nothing in this room is), but it is the faith's canon-in-use — the texts the members actually know by heart being, overwhelmingly, its hymns and its readings, quoted at the bedsides and the gravesides as other rooms quote their scriptures.
The contents, in guided outline, are the overview's second subject. The hymns are ordered by the service's and the year's round — the gathering songs, the chalice songs, the seasons' and the life's passages — and the canon includes the faith's own anthems: 'Spirit of Life' (Carolyn McDade's song of 1981, become by acclamation the denomination's signature — sung, in the record, at more UU occasions than any other, its 'roots hold me close, wings set me free' the faith's whole anthropology in a couplet), the chalice-lighting responses, the freedom songs ('We Shall Overcome' in the pew book of a church whose members sang it in the streets), and the old Unitarian and Universalist hymnody carried forward (the parents' songs in the child's book, edited for the child's conscience). The readings are the book's second treasure: the numbered readings (727 and counting in the tradition's citation) that the ministers and the lay leaders draw for the Sunday's theme — the ancient and the modern in one sequence, the Tao and the Testaments, Mary Oliver and Martin Luther King — the readings' very juxtaposition being the doctrine performed: the sources on one page, the search in the reader's ear. The school's account of the book's use follows the record: it is the most-thumbed book of the UU household and the minister's working tool, its readings the denomination's common memory — the phrases ('the cathedral of the world,' 'the turning of the year,' in their several readings) passing into the members' speech as the building's scriptures pass into their rooms' speech.
The book's career is the overview's third subject. The hymnal of 1993 succeeded the parents' books (the Unitarian and Universalist hymnals of the earlier century, and the joint Hymns for the Celebration of Life of 1964 — the consolidation's first book, whose readings had already made the breadth a liturgy) and it has itself become the object of the faith's continuing argument: the supplements adding the new music (the Spanish-language and the multicultural supplements of the present century, the online hymnal projects), the critics and the defenders of the language revisions rehearsing, at each General Assembly's hymn sing, the faith's standing question of how a living tradition sings its dead without lying about its life. The school's account of the book's meaning in the room's library follows the tradition's likely judgment: in a faith without a canon, the hymnal is where the canon went — the doctrine carried not in a confession but in a repertoire, the members' theology being, in the record's wry summary, what they can sing. The student who would know what UUs believe is directed, by the tradition's own ministers, to the grey book's index of first lines: there, and not in any creed, is the faith's confession — set to music, in four parts, with the alto line carrying the search.
The overview's last word places the hymnal among the building's texts by its office. It binds no one (the congregation may sing from anything), it is believed in nothing (its readings contradict each other by design), and it is used by everyone — the school submits that it is the perfect text of a creedless faith: an anthology with a tune, a library that sings, the covenant's memory in a book that opens flat on the piano. The texts proceed to the faith's nearest approach to a confession: the Seven Principles themselves — now expressed as the shared values — the covenant's text, its history, and its interpretation as the church's working scripture of promises.
Lesson 2: The Seven Principles (now expressed as shared values): a guided overview
The second text is the covenant itself: the Seven Principles — affirmed by the congregations since 1985 in the form the world knows — and their restatement, in the Article II adopted in 2024, as the faith's shared values. The text first, in its famous form, because the student should have the words the tradition has lived by for forty years. The congregations of the Unitarian Universalist Association covenant to affirm and promote: (1) the inherent worth and dignity of every person; (2) justice, equity, and compassion in human relations; (3) acceptance of one another and encouragement to spiritual growth in our congregations; (4) a free and responsible search for truth and meaning; (5) the right of conscience and the use of the democratic process within our congregations and in society at large; (6) the goal of world community with peace, liberty, and justice for all; (7) respect for the interdependent web of all existence of which we are a part. The school's account of the text's grammar follows the tradition's teachers: the Principles are not beliefs but promises — the covenant's verbs are 'affirm and promote,' addressed not to God but to one another; they bind congregations in their common life, not consciences in their private conclusions; and their authority is the authority of a promise kept — the text being, in the record's phrase, the faith's scripture of intentions, unique in the building as a sacred text whose entire content is what its readers undertake to do.
The restatement is the overview's second subject. The Article II Study Commission (appointed 2020) was charged with the covenant's renewal for the century, and its work — adopted at the General Assembly of 2024 after the years of congregational study the process required — expresses the covenant as shared values: six values in a circle — Justice, Equity, Transformation, Pluralism, Interdependence, Generosity — with Love at the center, defined in the new text's own words (Love being, in the Article's phrase, the power that holds us together and is at the center of our shared values — the faith's covenant grounded, at last and explicitly, in the affections). The new Article carries the old Principles' substance in the values' definitions (the worth of persons in the Pluralism's and Equity's charges, the search in the Pluralism's welcome of the diverse beliefs, the web in the Interdependence's, the democracy in the covenant's congregational sections) and adds the covenant's accountability language (the congregations promising to hold one another, gently and firmly, to the values — the 'covenant' given teeth of the softest and strongest kind: the community's mutual claim). The school's account of the change follows the record's both pans: the defenders reading continuity (the same values, re-housed for a century that thinks in values rather than principles, with Love named as the heart the old text left implicit), the critics mourning the seven sentences' poetry and their explicit search (the fourth Principle's phrase being the one the lamenters quote) — the tradition's own verdict being, characteristically, not yet rendered: the covenant will be what the congregations make of it, as the covenant always has been.
The text's career is the overview's third subject. The Principles of 1985 became, in the record, one of the most successful religious texts of the American century's end: printed on the orders of service of a thousand congregations, carried in the members' wallets, posted in the fellowship halls, quoted in the newspapers' accounts of the faith (the Principles being, for the public, the UU definition — the creedless church known by its promises), and exported to the partner churches and the world's fellowships as the faith's visiting card. Their pedagogical career matches their public one: the children's religious education built on them (the rainbow of the Principles in the church school's posters — each Principle a color, a promise a child can carry — the faith's catechism being, in the event, seven sentences a seven-year-old can memorize and a seventy-year-old cannot finish practicing). The school's account of the text's rank in the room's library follows the tradition's: it is the UU scripture in the only sense the room allows — the text the community has promised to be judged by — and its study, in the congregations' adult programs, proceeds accordingly: not 'what does it mean' in the scholar's sense but 'what does it ask' in the covenant's, the Principles read as the Directions of the last room were read: by the principle drawn for the case at hand.
The overview's last word places the Principles among the building's texts by their office. The building has texts that describe God, texts that narrate the saving, texts that command the life; this room's central text undertakes the life — a list of promises in the first person plural, revisable by vote, binding by consent, and kept, in the record, with a fidelity that has made it the faith's definition to the world. The school submits that the student who understands why a creedless church guards its promises more jealously than other churches guard their creeds has understood the room entire. The texts proceed to the faith's working library in the service itself: the wisdom from the world's religions, read aloud on Sunday — the readings, the sources, and the discipline of the open lectern.
Lesson 3: Wisdom from the world's religions, read in services: a guided overview
The third text is the faith's working library in action: the wisdom from the world's religions as it is actually read in UU services — the open lectern, the Sunday's readings, and the discipline by which a creedless congregation hears the building's whole library as its own teachers. The practice first, in its Sunday form. A UU service's readings are chosen by the minister or the lay leader for the day's theme, and their range is the Sources' range: the Hebrew Bible and the Christian scriptures (read as wisdom and as the parents' heritage, in the record's ordinary use — the Psalms and the prophets and the Gospels' parables in the lectern's regular rotation), the Quran and the Hadith's wisdom, the Hindu and the Buddhist texts (the Gita's counsel, the Dhammapada's verses, the sutras' parables), the Tao Te Ching and the Analects, the Sufi poets (Rumi above all — the record's most-read poet in the UU lectern of the present century), the earth traditions' prayers and the indigenous teachings (read, in the modern care, with the sources named and the permissions honored), the humanist and the scientific writers (Sagan's 'pale blue dot' being the modern canon of the lectern, read at the funerals and the earth days), and the poets of the living generations (Mary Oliver's instructions for living a life — attention, amazement, telling — being the nearest thing the modern UU service has to a psalter of its own). The school's account of the practice's form follows the record: the reading is introduced by its source and heard in the congregation's silence as a teaching — not as the inerrant word (the lectern makes no such claim for any text) and not as a museum piece (the reading is chosen because it speaks to the day's theme in the congregation's life) — the discipline being, in the tradition's phrase, to hear the wisdom as wisdom: addressed to us, examinable by us, and binding only as it persuades the conscience it addresses.
The discipline's rules are the overview's second subject, because the open lectern is governed, in the tradition's mature practice, by cares the school should name. The care of accuracy (the reading given in a translation of standing, its context honored — the verse not torn from a text whose whole would rebuke the use), the care of credit (the tradition named, the people acknowledged — the reading from another's scripture being a borrowing, and the borrowing confessed in the introduction's 'from the Buddhist tradition' as a matter of the covenant's honesty), the care of proportion (the parents' own heritage not exiled in the enthusiasm for the exotic — the Psalms holding their place in the rotation of a faith whose grandparents prayed them), and the care of the living owners (the closed practices and the restricted texts of other traditions not read — the distinction, taught in the modern religious education, between the world's published wisdom, which is the lectern's rightful library, and a people's private ceremonies, which are not the congregation's to perform). The school's account of the rules' ground follows the foundations': they are the first Principle applied to books — every tradition's dignity inherent, every people's heritage their own — the open lectern being, in the tradition's intent, an act of respect performed weekly, not an act of collection.
The practice's career is the overview's third subject. The readings' breadth is as old as the parents (the Transcendentalists reading the Hindus in their journals — Emerson's 'Brahma' and Thoreau's Bhagavad Gita at Walden being the American lectern's founding documents), institutionalized in the consolidation's first hymnal (1964's readings making the breadth a liturgy), stocked by the grey hymnal's seven hundred, and extended in the present century by the internet's library and the congregations' own thematic collections (the reading for the earth day, the reading for the grief service, the reading for the child's dedication — the lectern's calendar matching the community's life). The school's account of the practice's effect on the congregation follows the surveys the foundations cited: the religious literacy of the UU pew is the open lectern's harvest — a congregation that has heard the Dhammapada and the Quran and the Tao in its own sanctuary across a decade of Sundays carries a map of the world's wisdom that no other American worship pattern reliably produces — and its effect on the traditions read is the record's fair note: the lectern has been, for many of the building's rooms, an ambassador (the neighbors first met, by many UUs and not a few of the neighbors' own children, in a UU reading) — the school noting the ambassadorship's etiquette as the modern teaching's pride: the guest tradition presented by its own texts, in its own terms, with its name spoken in gratitude.
The overview's last word places the open lectern among the building's textual practices by its office. Other rooms read their scriptures as the word; this room reads all scriptures as the wisdom — the lectern being the search's altar, the library's pulpit, the place where the congregation practices, weekly and aloud, its founding conviction: that truth is no tradition's property and wisdom no people's monopoly. The school submits that the student who has sat through a year of the readings has taken the faith's real scripture course — the building's whole library, in excerpts, with the congregation's conscience as the commentary. The texts close in the present: how the hymnal, the covenant, and the world's wisdom are interpreted and studied now — by the congregations that sing them, by the scholars who edit them, and by the searchers who carry the wallet cards.
Lesson 4: Interpretation and study today
The texts semester closes in the present: how this creedless faith reads, studies, and argues its texts now — the hymnal, the covenant, and the world's wisdom — in the congregations, the academy, and the members' own study. The congregations' study first. The UU adult religious education (the faith's proud department, in its adult form) runs on the texts the semester has surveyed: the Principles and the Article II values studied in the covenant groups and the adult classes (the 'Building Your Own Theology' curriculum being the tradition's signature adult course — the members guided, across its sessions, to articulate their own considered beliefs, the search given a syllabus and the articulation a community: the course's very existence being the creedless church's answer to the catechism), the hymnal studied by the choirs and the hymn sings (the congregation learning its repertoire as its theology), the world's religions studied in the Neighboring Faiths and the world-religions curricula for adults as for youth, and the sermon itself as the week's study session (the UU sermon being, in the tradition's form, an essay argued before the congregation — with the talkback and the coffee-hour disputation as its seminar: the record's ministers testifying that no other pulpit in the building is answered as promptly and as learnedly as theirs, the congregation of searchers being, by constitution, a room full of examiners). The school's account of the congregational reading follows its teachers: it is a reading for the search — the text taken as the day's provocation, the covenant as the life's intention, the wisdom as the conscience's provender — the texts' authority residing, in the members' practice, in their attested power to deepen the search and to widen the heart, attested afresh by each reader.
The academic study is the lesson's second subject. The scholarship of UU texts is a field of the historians and the textual scholars: the study of the parents' literatures (the Channing and the Ballou corpora, the Transcendentalists' journals, the Racovian and the Transylvanian documents in their modern editions — the Association's own Skinner House and the scholarly presses keeping the parents in print), the hymnology (the grey hymnal's making and remaking as a case study in a tradition's self-editing, in the musicologists' literature), the Article II process as a live specimen for the scholars of religion-and-law and of denominational polity (a creedless church amending its covenant by a democratic process, documented entire — the field's gift of a constitutional convention in real time), and the UU historians' own guild (the Unitarian Universalist History and Heritage Society and its journals — the faith keeping, characteristically, a learned society for a past it refuses to be bound by). The student's counsel is the standing one: read the Principles with the Article II debates beside them, the hymnal with its supplements open, the world's wisdom in the translations of standing — and let the congregation's practice, the next semester's chalice and concerns and singing, arbitrate as the interpretation that finally counts in a room whose texts all point at the life.
The members' reading is the lesson's third subject, because it is this room's distinctive fact: the primary copy of the UU text in the modern world is the wallet card and the order of service — the Principles carried in the pocket and printed on the Sunday bulletin of a thousand congregations, the covenant thereby read weekly by more eyes than own the hymnal — and the primary UU interpretation is the sermon answered at coffee hour, the reading argued in the covenant group, the value applied in the justice committee's Tuesday meeting. The school's account of the whole follows the tradition's likely judgment: a library produced by two old churches and a century of searchers has become, in five generations of consolidation, the working furniture of a faith that owns no scripture and reads everything — not by the texts' conquest of the universities (the field remains a specialist's) but by their conquest of the Sunday: the hymn in the ear, the value in the wallet, the wisdom in the lectern — the library as a congregation's furniture, used weekly and worn smooth.
The lesson's last word, and the texts semester's, returns to the school's standing question for this room: what do these texts ask of the student? The hymnal asks to be sung — its doctrine is not believed until the voice knows it in four parts; the covenant asks to be kept — its values are not understood until they are practiced at some cost; the world's wisdom asks to be heard — with the judgment awake and the gratitude spoken. It is, the school submits, the building's most usable canon: three shelves whose whole labor is to get the searcher back into the search, with better company. The course turns from the texts to the life they serve: the chalice lit at the worship's opening, the joys and concerns shared in the service's heart, the singing that is the congregation's voice — and the family's round in which the chalice, the concerns, and the songs are actually lived.