Minister Destiny Marie Morgan Ministries, Inc.

Minister Destiny Testimony Schools

District: AWAKENING

Ministry name: Taoism

Lessons — Adult Year 1, Semester 3

Adult Year 1 · Semester 3 — Texts and teachings

Four lessons for this semester. When you are ready, take the test for this semester.

Lesson 1: The Tao Te Ching (Laozi): a guided overview

The texts semester opens with the building's shortest scripture entire: the Tao Te Ching — the Classic of the Way and its Power — eighty-one chapters, some five thousand characters, the whole of it readable in an afternoon and studied, in the tradition's practice, for a lifetime. The book first, in its form and its making. It divides, in the received form, into the Tao Ching (chapters 1–37, on the Way) and the Te Ching (38–81, on the Power, the de — the virtue or efficacy by which the Tao acts in things) — the division and the order being the Han editors' work, the Guodian slips showing an earlier age's different arrangements of a sayings-collection still in motion. The style is the doctrine's: rhymed, aphoristic, paradoxical — the chapters of a few lines each, the voice impersonal (the 'I' rare, the sage referred to in the third person), the teaching proceeding by reversal (the chapter's first line asserting, its second overturning, its third resting in the overturning's truth). The school's overview follows the tradition's own reading counsel, which is also the scholars': the book is not an argument to be followed but a set of lenses to be looked through in rotation — the chapters contradicting one another as the viewpoints of a single mountain contradict, the mountain being the point — and its famous obscurities are, in the main, the compression of an oral wisdom-literature whose allusions its first hearers carried in their heads and we have lost, the commentaries (two millennia of them, from Heshang Gong's and Wang Bi's down) being the tradition's attempt to carry them for us.

The contents, in guided outline, are the overview's second subject — the school walking the book's great themes as its readers have always grouped them. The Tao itself (the opening chapters: the unnameable mother, the uncarved block, the valley spirit undying); wu wei and the sage's government (the middle chapters' statecraft of restraint, the people saying 'we did it ourselves'); the reversals (the doctrine of return — 'reversal is the movement of the Tao' — the weak overcoming the strong, the water chapters, the soft and the lowly enthroned); the critique of the Confucian virtues (chapter 38's famous ladder: when the Tao was lost, there was virtue; when virtue was lost, benevolence; then righteousness; then ritual — 'ritual is the husk of faith and loyalty, and the beginning of disorder' — the school noting the passage as the two teachings' whole quarrel in one genealogy); the war chapters (weapons as instruments of ill omen, the victor enjoined to receive his victory with funeral rites — the book's pacifism being as absolute as its politics are quiet); the simplicity chapters (the thinned desires, the uncarved block restored, the small state with few people — chapter 80's utopia of the village content with its own cooking smells while the next village's dogs are heard and never visited); and the closing chapters' bequests (the three treasures, the water's praise, the final chapter's summary of the whole method: true words are not beautiful; beautiful words are not true — the book signing off with its own warning against its readers' admiration).

The book's career is the overview's third subject. In China it was a classic of the first rank for two thousand years: commented by emperors, memorized by schoolboys of the Tang's Taoist examinations, carried by the recluses, quoted by the poets (the Chinese poetic tradition is inconceivable without its reversals), and painted by the artists (the landscape painting of the Song being, in the art historians' account, the book's vision made visible — the empty spaces, the small man in the vast mountains, the water everywhere). Abroad it became, from the Jesuits' first Latin renderings and the nineteenth century's English ones, the world's book: the translations multiplying past every count (the school repeating the record's: among the most translated texts on earth, the English versions alone in their hundreds), the versions ranging from the scholars' cribs to the poets' recreations — the famous problem of the text being that its compression invites the translator to become its co-author, the modern reader's Tao being always partly his translator's, a fact the tradition, with its doctrine of the nameless, receives with its usual shrug. The school's student is directed to the proportion the tradition's readers observe: read two translations against each other and the commentaries after; the book is short enough that the argument among its versions is itself the reading.

The overview's last word places the Tao Te Ching among the building's scriptures by its office. It is not believed (it proposes no creed), not obeyed (it issues no commandments), not worshipped with (its religion's liturgies are other books) — it is consulted, as a spring is consulted: the reader comes with a situation, opens the book, and finds — the tradition's readers testify across twenty-five centuries — the chapter that reverses it. The school submits that the little book is the building's most efficient scripture: five thousand characters carrying a metaphysics, a politics, an ethics, a psychology, and a style of life, with enough left unsaid to employ two thousand years of commentators. The texts proceed to its great companion: the Zhuangzi — the carnival to the Tao Te Ching's aphorisms, the book in which the teaching learns to laugh.

Lesson 2: The Zhuangzi: a guided overview

The second text is the tradition's carnival: the Zhuangzi — the book of Master Zhuang Zhou (c. 369–286 BC) — thirty-three chapters in the received form (the Inner Chapters, the first seven, held the master's own; the Outer and Miscellaneous gathered by his school and edited by the fourth-century commentator Guo Xiang, whose edition and commentary fixed the book for the tradition), and by the agreement of its readers across the languages, one of the most dazzling books of the ancient world. The book first, in its method, because the method is the teaching: where the Tao Te Ching aphorizes, the Zhuangzi argues by story, dialogue, parody, and dream — the 'goblet words,' in its own famous classification of its speech (words that tip and refill, never holding a fixed position), spoken through a carnival cast: Confucius appears as a Taoist sage and as a fool by turns, the robber Zhi lectures the King on the virtues of robbery, a skull explains to the horrified master that death is better than life, a hunchback catching cicadas teaches the concentration of the spirit, a deformed man draws more followers than the handsome — the book's whole literary machinery existing to prevent the one catastrophe its philosophy dreads: the reader's settling into a position, any position, including the book's.

The great episodes are the overview's second subject, in their canonical selection. The butterfly dream (the master dreaming he was a butterfly, and waking to the question the school has met at every turn of this course: whether Zhuang Zhou dreamed the butterfly or the butterfly is dreaming Zhuang Zhou — the transformation of things stated as a riddle without an answer, the riddle being the answer's form). The happy fish (the master and the logician Huizi on the bridge over the Hao: 'the fish are happy' — 'you are not a fish; how do you know?' — 'you are not I; how do you know I don't know?' — the argument ending in the master's return to the starting intuition: I know it by standing here on the bridge — the school noting the dialogue as the tradition's charter of knowledge by sympathy against knowledge by logic, the two men's friendship across the argument being the episode's real doctrine). Cook Ding (the blade through the ox, nineteen years unblunted, finding the spaces — the texts' wu wei masterpiece, told entire in the commentaries of every age). The useless tree (the great gnarled oak, worthless for timber, preserved by its uselessness — 'everyone knows the use of the useful; no one knows the use of the useless' — the survival doctrine of the Warring States' refusers). The death of the master's wife (found drumming on a tub and singing — the grief examined and dissolved into the transformation's acceptance: she was not, then she was, as the seasons turn — the school presenting the episode as the tradition's whole consolation in one scandal). And the free and easy wandering of the first chapter's title: the great Peng bird's ninety-thousand-li flight and the little quail's laughter at it, each in its own element's measure — the relativity of the great and the small, the book's master key.

The book's career is the overview's third subject. In China the Zhuangzi became the second classic of the teaching and the first of its literature: the Wei-Jin age's salon masterpiece (the Pure Conversation's text, the Seven Sages of the Bamboo Grove living its doctrines as a style — the wine, the music, the refusal of office), the poets' and painters' inexhaustible source, the Chan (Zen) Buddhists' beloved cousin (the two traditions interbreeding in the Chinese centuries until the student's shelf cannot always tell the grandchildren apart), and the commentary tradition's playground — Guo Xiang's reading (the things so of themselves, each content in its own nature) standing as the book's second founding. In the West it arrived with the translations of the last century and a half and was received as the Tao Te Ching's necessary other half: the aphorisms' system dissolved in the stories' laughter, the pair together — the school adopting the tradition's own figure — being the teaching's yin and yang in print: the Laozi yang of the maxim, the Zhuangzi yin of the joke, each containing the other's seed, the reader who has only the one having, by the diagram's own law, exactly half.

The overview's last word places the Zhuangzi among the building's texts by its office. The Tao Te Ching is consulted; the Zhuangzi is inhabited — its office being not to state the teaching but to perform the state the teaching describes: the mind wandering free and easy among the standpoints, uncommitted, delighted, undulled. The school submits that it is the building's most joyful scripture and its most subversive: a sacred book whose hero dreams he is a butterfly and whose theologian is a skull, preserved by a civilization's schoolchildren as a set text and by its rebels as a charter, in the same binding. The texts proceed to the elder book both this school and the Confucian share: the I Ching, the Book of Changes — the oracle of the broken and unbroken lines, the oldest continuously used book in the building.

Lesson 3: The I Ching — the Book of Changes (shared with Confucianism): a guided overview

The third text is the building's elder: the I Ching — the Book of Changes (the Yijing) — the oracle and wisdom-book of the broken and unbroken lines, older than both the schools that claim it, shared between this room and the Confucian as the two traditions' common grandfather. The book first, in its layers, because the layers are its biography. The core is Bronze Age: the sixty-four hexagrams — the figures of six lines, broken (yin) and unbroken (yang), whose combinations exhaust, in the system's claim, the possible configurations of a situation — each with its Judgment (the brief oracular text attributed by the tradition to King Wen, the Zhou founder, composing in his prison) and its line-texts (attributed to his son, the Duke of Zhou): the diviner's manual of the early Zhou, consulted by the yarrow stalks and later the coins, the answers read in the hexagram's image and its changing lines. Around the core grew the Ten Wings — the commentaries of the Warring States and Han, attributed by the tradition to Confucius (the scholarship assigns them to his school across the centuries) — which performed the book's transformation from an oracle into a philosophy: the wings' universe of ceaseless change, of the superior man's timeliness, of the lines' moral algebra, making the Changes the metaphysics of the whole Chinese inheritance — the Confucian school canonizing it among its Five Classics, the Taoist school reading its flow as the Tao's own diagram, the physicians and the generals and the architects consulting it in their arts, the book becoming, in the record's phrase, the operating system of a civilization.

The method is the overview's second subject, in its practice. The consultation, in its classic form: the question posed, the fifty yarrow stalks divided and counted through the rite's slow arithmetic (the modern shortcut of the three coins beside it in the record), the hexagram built line by line from the bottom, the changing lines marking the situation's motion — the answer being not the hexagram alone but the hexagram and its transformation: the present configuration and the one it is becoming, the oracle's genius lying in the doubleness (the Changes never show a state without its tendency, a fortune without its seed of reversal — the foundations' diagram temporalized: the book is the yin-yang doctrine with a plot). The reading is the reader's work: the Judgment's image, the lines' counsel, the wings' philosophy brought to bear on the questioner's situation — the book functioning, in the school's analysis of its three millennia of use, less as a fortune-teller than as a structured meditation: the randomizer breaking the questioner's fixed standpoint (the Zhuangzi's catastrophe) and the texts' archetypes giving the freed mind a pattern to recognize itself in — the divination as a technology of perspective, whatever the metaphysics the user brings to it, the school noting that the tradition's own best readers have always read it so: the superior man of the wings consults the book not to learn the future but to learn his situation's shape and his own duty within it.

The book's career is the overview's third subject. In China it stood at the head of the classics for two thousand years — the examination system's summit, the scholars' lifelong study, the state's consultations at the reigns' crises — and its commentaries are a library of the civilization's philosophy (Wang Bi's Taoist reading, the Cheng-Zhu school's Confucian metaphysics built substantially on its wings). Abroad it became the West's first Chinese classic: the Jesuits' Latin, the nineteenth century's German (Wilhelm's translation, with Jung's famous foreword — the psychologist testifying to the book's uncanny answers in his own consultation, the foreword standing in the record as the West's most distinguished testimony to the oracle's power over a modern mind), the artists' and the composers' uses (Cage's chance operations conducted by its coins — the avant-garde's divination), the counterculture's nightstand beside the Tao Te Ching. The school's account of the book's modern standing holds the record's two pans in the room's usual manner: the metaphysical claim (the universe answering through the stalks) is the tradition's, the psychological account (the archetypes and the broken standpoint) is the scholars', and the book's three-thousand-year consultation record is the fact both pans must carry — the oldest continuously used book in the building, still consulted daily, in the age of the computer, by a civilization that also builds the computers.

The overview's last word places the I Ching among the building's texts by its office. The Tao Te Ching is consulted as a spring; the Changes are consulted as a council — the difference being that the Changes answer in a form the questioner must interpret, the book's office being not to decide but to converse: across three millennia, the kings and the farmers of China have laid their situations before the sixty-four figures and received, in return, not a verdict but a mirror with a memory. The school submits that the student who understands why the oracle shows the becoming with the being has understood the deepest common doctrine of the Chinese rooms: that nothing is only what it is, and the wise man's first question is never what a thing is but what it is turning into. The texts close in the present: how the three books are interpreted and studied now — by the temples that keep them, by the scholars who date them, and by the world that reads them on the nightstand and consults them in the park at dawn.

Lesson 4: Interpretation and study today

The texts semester closes in the present: how the three books are read and studied now — by the tradition, by the academy, and by the world readership that is this room's distinctive modern fact. The tradition's reading first. In the temples and the associations, the Tao Te Ching is read as scripture and as self-cultivation's manual (the morning readings of the Quanzhen monasteries, the lay study groups of the diaspora's temples), the commentaries of the lineage (Heshang Gong's and the inner alchemy's readings) kept beside the scholars' in the tradition's own pluralism; the Zhuangzi is the recluses' and the literati's book still; the Changes are consulted in the temples' divination halls and the almanac's daily page, the block-print lots and the coins of the folk practice running beneath the classics' philosophy in the same civilization's two registers, exactly as they have for two millennia. The school's account of the traditional reading's character follows its teachers: it is a reading for use — the chapter for the situation, the hexagram for the decision, the story for the temper — the books kept not as objects of study but as instruments of a life, their authority residing not in their inerrancy (a category this room never developed) but in their attested usefulness, attested afresh by each reader.

The academic study is the lesson's second subject. The modern scholarship of the Taoist texts is a flourishing and a fractious field: the textual archaeology (the Guodian and Mawangdui finds rewriting the Tao Te Ching's early history in the student's own lifetime — the silk manuscripts of Mawangdui, buried in 168 BC, carrying the book in the reverse order, the Te before the Tao, with other lost classics bound in — the school noting the finds as the field's modern foundation: the text's fluidity in its first centuries is now a document, not a conjecture), the authorship debates (settled, in the broad consensus, against the single founder and for the anthology — the tradition's fog at its source ratified by the spade), the Zhuangzi's stratification, the Changes' Bronze Age strata and the wings' dating, and the religious studies of the canon entire (the Daozang's thousand volumes at last catalogued and increasingly translated — the scholarly project's present frontier being the religion's own library, the philosophy's two little books having had their centuries of the translators while the church's thousand volumes waited). The student's counsel is the standing one: read the texts in two translations, the tradition's commentators and the academy's in pairs, and let the practice — the next semester's reading, movement, and breath — arbitrate as the interpretation that finally counts in a room whose books all point past themselves.

The world reading is the lesson's third subject, because it is this room's modern singularity: the Tao Te Ching is, by the translators' counts, among the most read books on earth — and the great majority of its readers are not Taoists, not Chinese, and not scholars: the nightstand readership of the whole planet, for whom the little book functions as the building's one scripture without a congregation. The school's account of the phenomenon follows the record: the translations' very plurality is the readership's form (each age and temperament finding its version — the scholar's, the poet's, the executive's, the surfer's), the text's compression and authority-free voice making it the one classic that a reader can adopt without joining anything — the doctrine of the unnamed achieving, in the world republic of letters, its purest success: the book is everywhere, the institution nowhere, the teaching traveling without its church as the water travels without the vessel's shape. The risks are the history's own: the reduction of a civilization's wisdom to a calendar's aphorisms, the sage as a lifestyle's ornament — the tradition's teachers' grief and gratitude in their usual proportions — and the school's judgment is its standing one for the building's living books: the text is safest where it is used whole, and the nightstand abridgments are, at worst, the finger's shadow — the moon being where it always was, in the five thousand characters, for the reader who goes the whole way in.

The lesson's last word, and the texts semester's, returns to the school's standing question for this room: what do these texts ask of the student? The Tao Te Ching asks to be consulted and then closed — its last chapter warns against the beautiful words, including its own; the Zhuangzi asks to be laughed with and then released — its butterfly releasing every reader it catches; the Changes ask to be asked — and then answered by the life, not the book. It is, the school submits, the building's most self-effacing canon: three books whose whole labor is to return the reader to the world they describe — the river, the seasons, the situation's turning — with his standpoint loosened and his forcing hand stayed. The course turns from the texts to the life they serve: the reading itself as a practice, the tai chi's slow flow, the qigong's breath — the teaching at the scale of the morning.

Back to all lessons · Take this semester’s test