Adult Year 2 · Semester 4 — Places, arts, and the road ahead
Four lessons for this semester. When you are ready, take the test for this semester.
Lesson 1: The Shinto shrine (jinja) and its torii gate and Ise Grand Shrine
The final semester opens with the places, and the first is the shrine itself — the jinja — in its anatomy, with its gate, and at its summit in the Grand Shrine of Ise. The anatomy first, in the order of the visit the practice taught. The torii stands at the boundary: two pillars, two crossbeams, the top beam curving in the classic myojin form — the gate that is not a gate, having no doors, marking the passage from the ordinary ground to the sacred, its vermilion (in the Inari and the imperial style) or its bare wood or stone or, at the modern shrines, its concrete and steel keeping the form across every material. Its origin is the record's honest uncertainty — the perch for the offering fowl, the continental gate's descendant, the native invention — the tradition unbothered, the form being the meaning: the visitor bows, passes under, and is in the kami's ground. Within: the sando, the approach, lined with the stone lanterns (the donors' gifts, lit at the festivals) and the guardian pair at the hall's approach — the komainu, the lion-dogs, one with the mouth open (a, the first sound) and one with it closed (un, the last) — the whole cosmos in a pair of statues, the school notes, at the door of every considerable shrine. The temizuya; the haiden, the worship hall, where the visitor stands; behind it, screened and unseen, the honden, the main sanctuary, where the shintai rests — the architecture's whole theology in the arrangement: the god's house behind the people's hall, the presence near and veiled, the visit a call at the door of a house one does not enter. The precinct (keidai) completes the anatomy: the grove, the auxiliary shrines, the treasure house, the kagura stage, the office — the parish's civic center in its sacred dress.
Ise is the anatomy's summit, and the lesson's second subject: the Ise Jingu, the Grand Shrine, in Mie — not one shrine but a complex of 125, centered on the Naiku, the Inner Shrine of Amaterasu (the imperial ancestress, the mirror in her shintai), and the Geku, the Outer Shrine of Toyouke, the food goddess, five kilometers apart in their forests of ancient cedar. The school's account follows the record's superlatives, which are earned: Ise is the tradition's holiest place, the imperial house's shrine and the nation's in one, its priesthood headed (in the modern form) by the chief priestess drawn from the imperial family, its rites the calendar's summit (the Kannamesai, the offering of the first rice, standing at the year's head), its pilgrimage — the okage mairi of the Edo period, when millions walked to Ise in the great spontaneous pilgrimages that swept the country in waves — the pre-modern nation's largest popular movement, the shrine's hold on the people's heart measured in the road's dust. The architecture is the tradition's manifesto: the Naiku's sanctuary in the shinmei-zukuri style — the raised floor, the forked finials (chigi) and the log-weights (katsuogi) on the thatched roof, the unpainted cypress glowing — a granary of the ancient world, preserved as the god's house, in the plainness that the tradition sets against every other room's splendor: the holiest building in Japan is a beautiful barn, and the school submits that the student who understands why has understood the tradition's aesthetics entire.
The rebuilding is Ise's wonder, and the lesson's third subject: the Shikinen Sengu, the ceremonial rebuilding of the Grand Shrine on the adjacent site every twenty years — the sixty-second rebuilding completed in 2013, the sixty-third in preparation for 2033 — in which the sanctuary is rebuilt exactly, in new cypress, by the hereditary craftsmen, the treasures and garments remade entire (some seven hundred items), the shintai transferred in the night rite, and the old building's timbers distributed to the shrines of Japan for their own rebuildings. The rite's meaning is the tradition's philosophy of permanence, and the school gives it its full weight: Ise is thirteen centuries old and never more than twenty years old — permanence through renewal, the form eternal because the matter is replaced, the crafts (the cypress forestry, planted two centuries ahead; the thatching; the joinery without nails) preserved by the rebuilding's necessity as the norito are preserved by the festivals'. The Sengu is, in the record's account, the largest regular act of cultural preservation on earth — its cost borne by the shrine and the nation's donations, its schedule kept through war and occupation (the cycle delayed but never broken since the seventh century, the interruptions themselves recorded and repaired) — the school's student directed to the rite as the tradition's answer, in timber, to the question every room of this building answers in its own material: how does a sacred thing last? This room's answer: by being remade, exactly, forever, by the hands it trains for the purpose.
The lesson's last word is the shrine's claim, gathering the places' theology. The torii says the sacred has a boundary and the boundary is open; the honden says the god is present and the presence is veiled; Ise says the holiest house is a granary rebuilt forever in a forest — the three together being the tradition's whole doctrine of place, in a religion that has built, across its islands, eighty thousand versions of the same proposition: here, the kami is; come, wash, bow. The school submits that the shrine is the building's most successful sacred architecture by the only measure that finally counts — it is used, daily, by millions, at the scale of the neighborhood and the errand — the jinja as the parish church of a religion without a church, perfected. The places proceed from the built to the grown: the sacred mountain of Fuji and the shrine that stands in the sea at Itsukushima — the land's own shrines, where the place is not the kami's house but the kami itself.
Lesson 2: Mount Fuji, a sacred mountain and Itsukushima Shrine standing in the sea
The second places lesson takes the land's own shrines: the sacred mountain and the shrine in the sea — the places where the site is not the kami's house but the kami. Fuji first. Mount Fuji — 3,776 meters, the islands' highest, a volcano of perfect symmetry — is a kami in its own right, worshipped as the goddess Konohanasakuya-hime (the blossom princess of the chronicles, enshrined at the Fujisan Hongu Sengen Taisha at the mountain's foot and in the Sengen shrines in their hundreds across the country) and climbed, in the season, as a pilgrimage: the Fuji-ko confraternities of the Edo period organizing the climbs by the tens of thousands, the white-clad pilgrims ascending by the torch-lit paths to the shrine at the summit and the sunrise from the crater's rim — the goraiko, the coming of the light, greeted with the banzais — the climb surviving in the modern season's three hundred thousand climbers, the pilgrims among the tourists, the mountain keeping both. The school's account of Fuji's sanctity follows the record: the mountain was feared before it was loved — its eruptions (the last in 1707, raining ash on Edo) the kami's anger in the chronicles' register — and the cult is the propitiation's long success: the feared power enshrined, climbed, painted (the Hokusai and Hiroshige views that made the mountain the nation's portrait), and at last inscribed, in 2013, on the world's heritage list not as a natural site but as a cultural one — 'a sacred place and source of artistic inspiration' — the official formula conceding, in the modern bureaucracy's Latin, what the Sengen shrines always said: the mountain is a god with a view.
Itsukushima is the lesson's second subject: the shrine that stands in the sea, on the island of Miyajima off Hiroshima — the island itself the goddess, worshipped entire, the shrine built out over the water on its pier-like platforms precisely so that the sacred island's ground would not be wounded by the building, the worshippers approaching by boat through the great vermilion torii that stands in the bay, sixteen meters of camphor wood in the tide. The shrine's deities are the three Munakata goddesses, the sea's daughters; its founding in its present grandeur is the work of Taira no Kiyomori, the twelfth-century warlord who made the shrine his clan's cult and rebuilt it in the shinden style of the court's palaces — the corridors over the water painted vermilion, the stages for the bugaku dances, the whole floating at high tide as the famous view shows it: the shrine as a palace adrift on the goddess's element, the worshipper arriving as a guest comes to a great house by water. The island's purity regime is the record's famous severity: for centuries no births and no deaths were permitted on the island — the kegare of both exiled to the mainland, the island kept in the state of a shrine entire, its deer sacred, its monkeys, its maple valleys — the regime relaxed in the modern period, the island inhabited now, the shrine and its torii inscribed with the world's heritage, the tide still rising twice a day through the shrine's floors as it has since 1168. The school's account of the pair — the mountain and the sea shrine — states their common doctrine: in this tradition the land's great features are not symbols of the sacred; they are its senior instances, the kami at the scale of geography, and the buildings (the summit shrine, the floating halls) are the human courtesy extended to powers that were worshipped before any roof was raised for them.
The wider sacred geography is the lesson's third subject, in its pattern. The tradition's map is dense with the land's sanctity: the three sacred mountains (Fuji, Haku, Tateyama) and the Dewa Sanzan of the ascetics; the sacred islands (Miyajima, Enoshima, Chikubu) where the goddesses of the sea are housed; the great trees and the waterfalls and the rocks with their ropes (the wedded rocks of Futami, joined by their great shimenawa, from between which the sun rises); the imperial shrines in their forests and the parish shrines in their groves — the whole archipelago inscribed, at every scale, with the proposition that the land is inhabited by powers and beautiful with their presence. The school's student should mark the geography's consequence for the nation's eye: a people whose mountains are gods and whose shrine stands in the tide does not develop the idea of nature as scenery until very late — the landscape painting of the tradition is portraiture, the traveler's diary a pilgrim's record — and the modern conservation instinct in Japan draws, as the values lesson recorded, on a reservoir the geography filled: the land was never empty, and it was never merely land.
The lesson's last word is the places' claim, completing the semester's survey of the tradition's housing. The built shrine houses the kami in the parish; the mountain and the island are the kami in the landscape; between them the tradition has sacralized an entire country — not, the school insists on the proportion, by covering it with doctrine but by covering it with addresses: eighty thousand shrines, three sacred mountains, the goddesses in the bay — a map on which every district has its power, every power its house or its hill, and every person a sacred geography within walking distance of his door. It is the building's most complete realization of the idea with which the foundations began: the world is inhabited — yaoyorozu, the eight hundred myriads — and the places are their census. The semester closes with the arts the tenancy has made — the kagura's dance, the gagaku's ancient orchestra, the literature of the myths' retelling — and then the course's farewell: how the student continues to learn about a tradition that is learned, finally, by visiting it.
Lesson 3: Art, music, and literature of Shinto
The third lesson takes the arts the tradition has made — with the school's standing honesty about the category: Shinto has no separate sacred art in the building's usual sense — no icons to venerate (the shintai is hidden), no fresco cycles of the myths on the shrine's walls (the halls are bare) — its arts being, characteristically, the arts of the festival and the offering: the dance, the music, the poetry, and the retelling, performed arts in which the tradition's imagination lives in time rather than in objects. The dance first: kagura, the kami's entertainment, descending — in the tradition's own account — from Uzume's dance before the cave, and kept in two great lines: the mikagura of the imperial court, the slow, stately songs and dances performed in the palace sanctuary and at Ise and the great shrines by the court's musicians, in forms a thousand years old; and the sato-kagura, the village kagura, the masked dance-dramas of the myths performed by the local troupes through the winter nights — the Takachiho companies' thirty-three dances telling the whole mythology in a night, the Iwami kagura's serpents of paper and bamboo filling the stage with Orochi's eight heads — the village theater as the mythology's living book, the farmers dancing the gods they cannot read in the Kojiki's script. The miko's dance, the sacred maiden with her bell-tree (kagura suzu) at the shrine's kitou, is the art's daily form: the tradition's dance offered, in the present tense, at every formal prayer in every considerable shrine.
The music is the lesson's second subject: gagaku, the court's ancient orchestra — the oldest continuously performed orchestral music in the world, in the world's own heritage lists — which serves the imperial rites and the great shrines' festivals: the sho's clusters of sound (the mouth organ's chords sustained like light through leaves), the hichiriki's penetrating reed, the transverse flute, the great drums — the repertory's pieces a millennium and more in the performing, the continental imports of the first millennium naturalized into the rite's own voice. Beside the court's music stand the festival's: the matsuri-bayashi of the floats and the processions — the flute, the small drum, the bell — each town's tunes its own, the children drilled by the elders in the autumn evenings, the music as the festival's memory made audible; and the norito themselves, in the priests' chanting, as the tradition's vocal art: the archaic Japanese delivered in the formal voice, the words' sound part of their kotodama power. The school's account of the tradition's music follows its general law for this room: it is an art of performance preserved by use — nothing written down in the modern sense until the modern transcriptions, the court's and the villages' repertories carried in the bodies of the players across the centuries, the chain of hands and breaths unbroken — the music being, like the norito and the Sengu's carpentry, one of the tradition's technologies of exact transmission, in which the art and the rite are the same act.
The literature is the lesson's third subject: the myths' written afterlife. It begins with the chronicles themselves — the Kojiki's prose and its hundred songs standing as the Japanese literature's fountainhead, its tales the seedbed from which the whole tradition grows: the cave and the serpent and the hare of Inaba retold in the medieval setsuwa collections, dramatized in the noh (the plays of the gods, the kamimono, in which the kami appear and dance their stories for the audience — the noh stage as the shrine's theater), versified in the waka of the anthologies (the Man'yoshu's four thousand five hundred poems being, in their largest share, the kami's world sung by the court's poets: the mountains and rivers addressed as powers, the sovereigns hymned as manifest kami), and carried into the modern novel and the animated film in the culture's unbroken habit of retelling. The school's student should mark the literature's distinctive custody: the tradition's stories were never fenced — no canon police, no heresy of the retelling — the myths being the people's common property, free to the noh master and the picture-book artist and the game designer alike, the school's account holding the freedom as the myths' survival strategy entire: a story that anyone may retell is a story that everyone keeps telling.
The lesson's last word is the arts' claim, completing the places' survey of the tradition's housing in matter and in time. The shrine houses the kami in space; the arts house the stories in time — the dance in the village's winter, the orchestra in the court's calendar, the poems in the language's memory — and between the housing and the telling, the tradition persists as a performed inheritance, its treasures not in a vault but in a schedule. The school submits that this is the deepest sense of the Sengu's lesson, now generalized: in this room, everything sacred is kept by being done again — the building rebuilt, the norito respoken, the dance redanced, the myth retold — permanence as a verb. The course's final lesson turns to the student himself: the road ahead — how to continue learning about a tradition whose final examination is not an essay but a visit — the books and the places and the courtesies by which the study of Shinto continues for the rest of a life.
Lesson 4: Continuing to learn about Shinto
The course's final lesson is its farewell and its map: how the student continues to learn about Shinto after the school — in the books, in the places, and in the practice of the courtesies the course has taught. The books first, briefly and in the school's order. The myths are to be read whole: the Kojiki in the modern translations (the school's standing counsel — the tale before the theories), and the Nihon Shoki's age of the gods beside it, the variants teaching the tradition's plurality in the reading itself. The studies follow: the historians' Shinto (the revisionists and the shrine world's scholars in their argued balance), the ethnographers' village studies, the Association's own presentations read as the tradition's self-account, the art and architecture surveys for the eye's education. And the living literature: the novels and the films in which the myths walk in modern dress, the picture books that carry them to the next generation — the student's shelf being, in the school's figure, a small sando: the chronicles at the gate, the scholars along the path, the stories at the hall. The school's counsel on the reading is its last methodological word in this room: read the tradition's friends and its critics in pairs, and let the shrines themselves — the visits of the next paragraph — arbitrate: a religion of practice is finally studied in the practicing, the books being the map and the parish the territory.
The places are the road's second stage, and the course's geography is now the student's itinerary. The school's counsel: begin with the parish shrine of wherever one lives or lodges in Japan — the ujigami's grove, the temizuya, the visit in its form — the tradition being, by its whole theology, local first, the neighborhood shrine's quiet being its native register; then the great shrines in their kinds: Ise for the summit (the forests, the Sengu's sites, the first-rice calendar), Izumo for the cession's other pole (the October gathering, the great rope), a Munakata or an Itsukushima for the sea, a Sengen shrine and the mountain for the land; a festival in its parish — the student bearing his turn of watching, and where the parish welcomes it, of carrying; a kagura night at Takachiho in the winter; the museums (the Kokugakuin's and the shrines' own treasure houses) for the objects. The courtesies travel with the itinerary, as the practice taught them: the bow at the torii, the washed hands, the path's edge, the coin, the two bows and the two claps and the bow — and the rule above the rules, which the school now states as the tradition's own etiquette toward the student: the shrine does not ask what you believe; behave as a guest, and you are one.
The road's third stage is the study's continuance in the student's own place, for the school's students are the world's. The tradition does not export itself — there is no mission, no conversion, no Shinto of the diaspora except the emigrants' own shrines (the Hawaii and Brazil and California shrines of the Japanese communities, serving their parishes abroad as the parish shrines serve at home) — and the student's continuance is therefore of a particular kind: not practice, unless the student's life takes him within a parish's bounds, but regard: the ethic carried without the cult. The school's farewell counsel names the carrying plainly, as the values semester furnished it: the gratitude at the table; the washing of the approach to any work; the grove kept, in whatever latitude, as the tenant's trust; the festival of one's own community kept with the parish's seriousness about joy; the stranger received as the shrine receives, without a doctrinal examination. It is, the school submits, the most exportable of the building's ethics precisely because it was never a system of belief: the temper travels where the cult cannot, and the student who has learned to wash, to thank, to celebrate, and to keep the grove has learned the tradition's exportable whole.
The last word is the school's farewell to the student of this room, in the tradition's own manner — which is to say, briefly, and with a bow. Two years: the foundations' world of powers and its bath; the history's conscription and liberation; the texts' mythology and its living liturgy; the practice's fountain and forms; the persons — the storm schooled, the foxes at the granary, the sun fetched laughing from the cave, the islands born of the brine; the celebrations' year of gratitude; the values' ethic of the clean and thankful tenancy; and the places, from the parish grove to the Grand Shrine rebuilt forever. The student has not been asked to believe any of it, and the tradition would not ask it now: it asks — as it asked at the first temizuya — only that the hands be washed and the heart be, for the visit's length, sincere. The school thanks the student for the company of the course, and leaves him at the torii of his own road, with the tradition's blessing in its own form, which is not a formula but an arrangement: a clean basin, a running stream, a grove kept green, and a gate that has no doors. Go in peace — and come back for the festivals.