Adult Year 2 · Semester 3 — Values, ethics, and service
Four lessons for this semester. When you are ready, take the test for this semester.
Lesson 1: Helping others survive and thrive and honesty as ethics
Year Two's values semester opens with the church's ethical center, as the church states it: helping others survive and thrive — the dynamics' calculus in action — and honesty as the ethic's instrument. The helping first, in the doctrine's own logic. The foundations taught that an act is good insofar as it enhances survival across the greatest number of dynamics; the values semester draws the consequence the church draws: the highest activity open to a person is the enhancement of others' survival — help — and the church's whole enterprise is, in its self-description, a helping enterprise: the auditor helping the preclear, the teacher helping the student, the Volunteer Minister helping the disaster's victims, the member helping his family and his group up the dynamics together. The school's account of the ethic's distinctive shape follows the church's ethics materials: help, in this system, is not sentiment and not alms; it is the application of a technology to a person's survival — the help that helps being the help that works, measurable by the helped person's improved condition across the dynamics — and its opposite is not selfishness alone but the harmful act, the 'overt,' whose commission (and concealment, the 'withhold') degrades the doer's own survival in the system's exact accounting: the person who has committed overts against a dynamic cannot thrive on it, the ethics being, in the church's phrase, a matter of reason and not of morals — a technology of the good life, self-enforcing through the dynamics' arithmetic.
Honesty is the ethic's second plank, and the lesson gives it its place in the system. In the church's teaching, honesty is survival's instrument: the person who deals in falsehood corrupts the data on which his own and others' survival depends — 'seek to live with the truth' being the Way to Happiness's formulation — and the system's central practices are, at bottom, honesty machines: the auditing session's recall, in which the preclear faces his own record; the ethics' handling of overts and withholds, in which the concealed act is brought into the open and its charge discharged (the confessional element the practice semester noted); the communication formula, in which the duplicated message — understood exactly as sent — is the honest exchange. The school's account of the ethic's public argument is required by its method: the church's honesty doctrine stands in the record beside the documented criticisms of the church's own public statements — the biography disputes, the statistics disputes, the Snow White record itself, in which the Guardian's Office's deceptions were proved in court — and the student is to hold the doctrine and the record together, as the course has held them throughout: the teaching is the teaching, stated entire; the record is the record, stated entire; and the distance between a movement's ethic and its officers' practice is a datum the student of every room in the building must learn to weigh without either cynicism or blindness.
The two planks together are the lesson's third subject, as the system's working morality. Help without honesty is, in the system's terms, a fraud upon the dynamics — the help that flatters, the help that conceals, the help that serves the helper's image; honesty without help is a sterile accuracy, the truth hoarded (in the Rasta course's phrase for another house's sin) rather than spent on survival. The church's ideal member unites them in the figure the system everywhere proposes: the auditor — the person whose profession is to help another face the truth of his own record, in a room where nothing else is done — the ethic's whole content being present in that room's two chairs: one person helping, one person being honest, both surviving the better for it, in the doctrine's account of what the session is. The school's comparative note sets the ethic among the building's: the primal generosity moves goods toward the relations; the Rasta truth-speaking moves words toward the circle; the Scientology ethic moves a person toward his own record and his fellows' survival in one motion — the most procedural of the building's moralities, and, in its adherents' testimony, the most practical: an ethics, as the church likes to say, that can be applied on Tuesday.
The lesson's last word weighs the ethic as the movement's offer and its test. The offer is real and is the movement's recruiting strength in every era: a morality without sin, a help without humiliation, an honesty without a priest — the good life as a technology, open to any person willing to be trained in it. The test is the movement's own, and the course leaves it where the values semesters leave all their tests: in the record of the practice — the helped who testify and the harmed who testify, the ethics applied and the ethics alleged to have been weaponized (the former members' accounts of the ethics system used as an instrument of control being among the record's most detailed, and the church's answer — that ethics is the member's own self-discipline, administered at his own request for his own survival — being its standing reply). The student carries both into the next lesson: the responsibility and the communication by which, in the doctrine, the helped person becomes the helper and the honest word becomes the world's repair.
Lesson 2: Personal responsibility and communication as ethics
The second values lesson joins the brief's pair: personal responsibility and communication — the two virtues by which, in the church's teaching, the individual recovers his power over his own life and his relations with others. Responsibility first, in the doctrine's exact sense. In Scientology's usage, responsibility is not blame and not duty: it is the ability and willingness to act as cause — to be, in the system's phrase, at cause over a thing rather than at effect from it. The thetan's decline, in the doctrine, is a decline of responsibility: area by area, the person has withdrawn from being cause — over his body, his family, his work, his past — assigning the cause to others (the parents, the society, the engram itself) and living at effect, the victim of his own abdications. The recovery the technology promises is therefore a recovery of responsibility, level by level: the preclear, facing his record in the session, discovers his own part in it — the doctrine's hard edge being that even the engram's victim is restored by taking responsibility for his present relation to it — until, at the summit the system describes, the Operating Thetan stands at cause over matter, energy, space, and time themselves. The school's account of the doctrine's double edge is required: the same teaching that empowers — the survivor of a hard life discovering, in the session, that he is not its product but its author going forward — is charged by the critics with the opposite cruelty, the victim blamed for his victimhood in the doctrine's name; and the record contains both testimonies in quantity, the student's judgment of the doctrine's use being, as throughout, his own on the whole evidence.
Communication is responsibility's instrument, and the lesson gives the formula its ethical depth. The Fundamentals taught the communication cycle — cause, distance, effect; intention, attention, duplication — as a mechanism; the values semester reads it as a morality: to communicate, in the system's full sense, is to take responsibility for another's understanding — to intend the message, to attend to its reception, to duplicate it in the other's mind — and the failures of communication are therefore ethical failures, the ARC break (the drop in affinity, reality, or communication) being the system's name for every quarrel, estrangement, and war in miniature. The ethics of communication follow: the honest word (the last lesson), the word actually delivered and duplicated (not merely uttered), the listening that is the cycle's other half — the auditor's trained attention being the system's model of the moral listener, who receives another's communication without evaluation or invalidation until it is wholly in. The school's comparative note is owed: every room in the building disciplines speech; this room makes speech the master key — the doctrine holding, in its boldest form, that communication is the universal solvent, the one process by which any condition between persons can be improved — a claim whose scope the student may measure against the building's other solvents (love, forgiveness, justice, time) and whose practice, in the movement's course rooms and marriages, is attested by its adherents as the technology's most daily miracle.
The pair together are the lesson's third subject, as the system's anthropology of the free person. Responsibility without communication is a sealed omnipotence — the thetan at cause over a world he cannot reach; communication without responsibility is mere traffic — words exchanged by persons at effect from all of them. The doctrine's free person unites them: at cause, and in communication — originating his intentions, duplicating others', repairing the breaks, owning his record — a figure the system calls, in its summary term, 'in-ethics' across the dynamics, and whose social form is the movement's ideal community: persons at cause, in ARC, helping each other survive. The school's student should mark the ideal's modernity, because it is the movement's most characteristic note in the building: the free person of this system is not the monk, the knight, the elder, or the saint of the older rooms, but something like a perfect communicator-engineer of his own life — the virtues being skills, the skills being trainable, the training being the church's business — an anthropology perfectly fitted to the century of the self-help shelf and the management seminar, from which the movement came and to which, in its licensed technologies, it continues to speak.
The lesson's last word is the school's weighing of the pair as the ethic's engine. Responsibility and communication are the two doctrines a student of this movement will meet in every room of it: the session is their liturgy, the course room their school, the ethics officer their referee, the family's quarrel their parish. Their promise — that no person need remain the effect of his past or of his fellows, that every break can be repaired by a cycle honestly run — is the movement's pastoral offer in its purest form, and its price, in the record's other column, is the total claim the doctrines can make when an organization administers them: the member never off duty from responsibility, never out of communication's audit, in the total environment the practice semester described. The school holds both, as it has held the whole course's pairs, and proceeds to the ethic's remaining virtues: the hard work and the study, and the better world they are meant, in the church's stated aims, to create.
Lesson 3: Hard work and study and creating a better world (as the church's aims state) as ethics
The third values lesson takes the church's stated aims as its ethics: the hard work and the study, and the better world they are for — in the words of the Aims of Scientology, written by Hubbard in 1965 and read in the church's services: 'A civilization without insanity, without criminals and without war, where the able can prosper and honest beings can have rights, and where Man is free to rise to greater heights.' The aims first, as the ethic's horizon. The school's account of the aims' place follows the church's: they are the movement's social gospel in one sentence — the dynamics' Fourth and beyond, written as a program — and every ethic in this semester is their instrument: the helping, the honesty, the responsibility, the communication, all aimed at a civilization-scale result. The aims' absoluteness is the student's to note: not less insanity but none, not fewer criminals but none — the founder's characteristic totalism, which the church reads as a goal's proper statement (a target is a target) and the critics read as the system's signature overreach; the school records the sentence entire, as the church reads it aloud, and the two readings as the record's. What is not disputed is the aims' function: they convert the member's private ascent into a public mission — the Bridge climbed not for oneself alone but as the civilization's therapy, one Clear at a time — and thereby give the movement's immense labors their stated meaning.
Hard work is the aims' first instrument, and the lesson gives the ethic of work its depth. The church's culture is, by every account in the record, a working culture: the staff's long weeks, the Sea Org's total labor, the public member's evenings given to the courses after the day's employment, the founder's own legend — the millions of words, the lectures by the thousand — standing as the work ethic's icon and warrant. The doctrine beneath the culture is the dynamics' again: work is survival in action, the able person's contribution to the dynamics he serves; idleness and incompetence are, in the system's ethics, not misfortunes but conditions to be handled — the Way to Happiness's precepts 'be industrious' and 'be competent' being the popular form, and the church's internal statistics — every post measured, every week graphed — being the institutional form, the whole forming the most thoroughly quantified work ethic in the building. The school's account of the ethic's two testimonies follows the course's method: the members' — of purpose, of skills gained, of lives organized from chaos by the discipline of the post and the checksheet; and the departed's — of exhaustion, of the statistics wielded as a whip, of the Sea Org's hundred-hour weeks in the pressured seasons — the record's columns standing, at this point in the course, in their familiar places, the work itself being the undisputed fact between them: this movement works, harder and longer than any other in the building, and argues about what the work means.
Study is the aims' second instrument, completing the pair. In this system, study is not the ornament of the religious life but its substance — the Bridge's training side, the perpetual curriculum of the practice semester — and its ethic follows: to study is to arm oneself for the aims; the misunderstood word is a moral failure in miniature (a survival tool left broken); the graduate is the ethic's saint, the person whose competence has been certified by the checksheet and the session's results. The school's comparative note sets the study ethic among the building's: the primal archive made memory the virtue; the madrasa and the yeshiva made the text's mastery a life's crown; Scientology makes study a technology with a method, a barrier-list, and a pass — the democratization and the mechanization of the learned piety in one system — and its product, the trained member, is the aims' infantry: the auditor for the insane world, the course supervisor for the criminal's rehabilitation, the literate citizen of the civilization without war. The ethic's demand on the ordinary member is therefore unremitting and, in the members' testimony, exhilarating in the manner of all total curricula: there is always a next level, always a misunderstood word between the student and the summit, and the summit — the civilization itself — always worth the dictionary.
The lesson's last word weighs the aims ethic as the values semester's center of gravity. Help and honesty govern the person; responsibility and communication govern his relations; work and study govern his days — and the three pairs together aim him at the largest object any ethic in the building proposes on a Tuesday: the repair of the civilization by the application, person by person, of a technology of the spirit. The school submits that the student who grasps the aims' function — the conversion of private salvation into public works, at industrial scale and with industrial measurement — grasps the modern church's whole temper, in its grandeur and in its shadow alike: the same totalism that fills the course rooms fills the statistics boards, and the same sentence that inspires the volunteer exhausts the staffer, the record's two columns being, at the last, two readings of a single, enormous, documented exertion. The values close with the exertion's outward forms: the service, the charity, and the justice of the movement — its disaster tents and its human-rights campaigns and its long war, in the name of justice, with the psychiatric profession and the state.
Lesson 4: Service, charity, and justice in Scientology
The values semester and Year Two's teaching close with the movement's outward issue: service, charity, and justice — the church's organized works in the world, and its account of the justice it practices and demands. Service first, in its organized forms, which the celebrations semester met at the tents: the Volunteer Ministers, the church's disaster and community corps; the social betterment programs administered through its affiliated bodies — Narconon in drug rehabilitation, Criminon in the prisons' correspondence courses, Applied Scholastics in education, the Way to Happiness Foundation in moral education, and the Citizens Commission on Human Rights in its campaigns — the whole constituting, in the church's presentation, the technology's application to the civilization's wounds, at a scale its literature quantifies in the movement's characteristic figures. The school's account of the programs' standing follows its method with care, for each program carries its own public record: Narconon's methods and efficacy are disputed between the church's claims and the evaluations of medical reviewers, some favorable placements and some jurisdictions' rejections both being documented; Applied Scholastics' study technology is used in schools in several countries and criticized in others; the CCHR's campaigns have contributed, in the record, both to genuine reforms of psychiatric abuse — the exposure of deep-sleep therapy's deaths in Australia being the critics' own conceded instance — and to a total opposition to psychiatry that the psychiatric profession regards as a danger to its patients. The school states the programs, their claims, and their standings program by program in that form, and leaves the aggregate judgment, as it has left each, to the student's weighing of the whole record.
Charity is the service's second form, and its doctrine in this system is the dynamics' own: the gift is an enhancement of survival, and its purest form is the technology itself — the church's charity being characteristically not alms but training: the free introductory services, the disaster assists, the literacy and the rehabilitation offered as the means by which the helped become the helpers. The school's account of the charity's economics is the record's plain part: the church's core services — the auditing and the training of the Bridge — are delivered for fixed donations that the record has noted, and the charitable works are funded from the movement's resources and its members' volunteering, the two economies — the paid Bridge and the free tent — standing side by side in the church's life as they stand in its critics' account (as the funnel and the front, in the hostile reading; as the engine and the gift, in the church's) — the school's student having, by now, the whole course's evidence with which to read the pair. What the record does not dispute is the labor: the volunteers at the disasters are there, the correspondence courses reach the prisoners who write for them, the tents are pitched — the service's existence being the fact, its interpretation the argument, as with the Sea Org's uniform and the birthday's statistics before it.
Justice is the lesson's third subject, and it runs, in this movement's account, in both directions at full volume. The justice the church demands is the record of its legal wars: the recognition of its religious status, the tax exemption won in 1993, the court victories it counts by the hundred in its own telling — against the governments that raided it, the deprogrammers who seized its members (a practice the courts ended and the church counts among its justice's triumphs), the press whose accounts it has sued over with mixed results. The justice it practices is its internal ethics system — the ethics officers, the committees of evidence, the knowledge reports — which the church presents as a self-disciplinary order for the member's own survival and the former members describe, in the accounts the values semester has noted, as the movement's instrument of internal control; and its justice toward the world is the CCHR's campaign form: the exposure of abuses, in psychiatry above all, in the name of the human rights the church's Creed proclaims — 'that no agency lesser than God has the power to suspend or set aside' man's rights — the Creed's ringing clauses being, the school notes, the movement's most conventional and most quoted public doctrine, printed at the front of its churches' services while its wars over their application fill the courts of three continents. The school's summary of the justice account is its record's: no movement in the building has asked more of the law or given the law more to do; the law's answers, across seventy years and a dozen countries, have been as mixed as the movement itself — recognition here, conviction there, exemption here, observation there — and the argument, at the course's writing, continues in every one of those jurisdictions.
The lesson's last word, and the values semester's, is the school's summary of the movement's ethics entire, as Year Two's course completes its survey. Help names the end; honesty the instrument; responsibility and communication the virtues; work and study the days; service and justice the spend and the demand — the whole being, the school submits, the most completely systematized ethic in the building: a morality with a formula, a calculus, a training course, and an enforcement arm, composed by one man and administered by his church with an exactness that is either the ethic's genius or its refutation, depending — as the whole course has depended — on the student's judgment of the record entire. The course's last semester turns from the conscience to the country: Clearwater's marble mile and the Int Base's fences, Saint Hill's manor and the Apollo's decks, the Freewinds on the Caribbean — the places where the technology is kept — and the arts and the road ahead, on which the modern world's most documented religion walks, at seventy, into its second generation of argument with the world it aims to clear.