Adult Year 2 · Semester 1 — People and stories
Four lessons for this semester. When you are ready, take the test for this semester.
Lesson 1: Mary Sue Hubbard: life and legacy
Year Two opens with the persons, and the first person of this movement's second year is the founder's wife and the movement's most fateful officer: Mary Sue Hubbard (1931–2002) — the third wife of L. Ron Hubbard, the mother of four of his children, the head of the church's Guardian's Office, and the central figure of its gravest scandal. Her life first, in the record's outline. Born Mary Sue Whipp in Texas, educated at the University of Texas, she came to Dianetics in Wichita in 1951 as a student of the new science, met Hubbard in its circle, and married him in 1952, at the refounding's moment — becoming, from the first, his closest collaborator: the co-worker of the Phoenix years, the companion of Saint Hill, the mother of Diana, Quentin, Suzette, and Arthur, the children raised inside the movement their parents were building. As the church grew, her office grew with it: she became the Controller — the head of the Guardian's Office, the church's intelligence, public-relations, and legal arm, established in 1966 — which made her, in the organization of the 1970s, the second most powerful person in Scientology, directing its dealings with the world: its lawyers, its investigators, its responses to its enemies. The school's account of her position follows the record: she was not a consort but an executive, and the Guardian's Office under her direction conducted, among its legitimate defenses of a harassed church (in her and the church's account), the programs that became Operation Snow White.
The fall is the life's second movement, and it is documented in the courts. Operation Snow White — the Guardian's Office program, run through the 1970s, to purge unfavorable records about Scientology and its founder from government files — involved, as the prosecutions established, the infiltration of some 136 government agencies and private organizations, the theft and copying of documents, wiretapping, and the framing of at least one critic, the journalist Paulette Cooper, in the related Operation Freakout. FBI raids of July 1977 — among the largest in the Bureau's history to that date — seized the Guardian's Office files; Mary Sue Hubbard was indicted, pleaded guilty in 1979 to conspiracy against the United States in a stipulated record, and served a prison sentence (of a five-year term, she served roughly a year in custody with work release arrangements, by the record's varying accounts of the time actually served), while her husband, named an unindicted co-conspirator in the government's papers, was never charged and always, through the church, denied directing the operations. The school's account holds the record's elements exactly: the crimes were the Guardian's Office's and were proved; Mary Sue Hubbard accepted legal responsibility in her plea; the question of her husband's direction remains, in the documentary record, a matter of the government's allegations and the church's denials, and the student is to hold it as such — a documented dispute at the very center of the movement's history.
The aftermath is the life's third movement, and the record's saddest in this course. On her release, Mary Sue Hubbard did not resume her place: the Guardian's Office was disbanded in the early 1980s amid the church's reorganization, its functions passing to a new Office of Special Affairs; and she herself receded — removed, in the accounts of former members and journalists, from the movement's life, living in Los Angeles in increasing obscurity, her communications with her husband in his seclusion mediated and then, by those accounts, ended. She died on November 25, 2002, in Los Angeles. The school's account of her eclipse follows the record's care: the church's official histories give her little place — a striking absence, the scholars note, for the movement's co-builder of thirty years — and the reasons for her removal are among the record's genuinely obscure matters, the church not explaining and the former members' accounts differing. What the record does establish is the shape: the movement's second person for three decades, the executrix of its hardest wars, absorbed the legal consequence of those wars alone of the founding pair, and was written, in her lifetime, out of the story she had half authored.
The legacy's last word is the school's weighing of her place. Mary Sue Hubbard is this movement's figure of the lieutenant's tragedy, a type the building knows — the deputy whose loyalty becomes the instrument of her ruin — with the modern difference that her record is a court record, every stage documented: the student can read the indictment's stipulation, the plea, the sentence, and the silence that followed, and can therefore judge, as few such figures can be judged, on evidence. The school submits that her life poses the movement's hardest internal question in its sharpest form: what a church owes the officer who took its orders into the illegal and took the punishment alone — a question the movement has never publicly answered, and whose unanswering is itself part of the record the student carries into the rest of this year. The people-and-stories semester proceeds from the wife to the order she never commanded: the Sea Org's members in their naval uniforms, the billion-year clergy whose collective life is the movement's second person.
Lesson 2: The Sea Org members in their naval-style uniforms: life and legacy
The second person of the semester is a collective person: the members of the Sea Organization — the church's religious order, founded in 1967, whose naval-style uniforms, ranks, and billion-year contracts make them the most distinctive body of religious in the modern world. Their life first, in the church's account and the record's outline together. The Sea Org began as the founder's shipboard retinue and became the church's cadre: the corps from which its executives are drawn, staffing the senior organizations — the Flag Land Base, the Int Base, the Advanced Organizations — living communally, eating in common messes, wearing the uniform of dark blue with its ranks and its Sea Org symbol (the laurel and star), addressing their seniors as 'sir' under a discipline modeled on the founder's naval service, and holding, in the church's structure, the movement's standard in trust for the religion's eternity. Their commitment is the famous one: the contract of a billion years, signed in the doctrine's logic — the thetan returns, life after life, and the Sea Org member pledges his next billion years of lives to the cause — a vow whose term is the doctrine of reincarnation written as an enlistment. Their material terms, in the record, are those of a religious order of the traditional kind in modern figures: housing, food, medical care within the order's provisions, and a weekly allowance that the record puts, for most of the modern era, at around fifty dollars — the order's members owning little and needing, by the order's design, little, their whole lives inside the institution they serve.
The life's texture is the lesson's second subject, and it must be given in the record's two columns with particular care, since no part of the movement is more differently described by its inhabitants and its departed. In the church's account and the serving members' testimony: the Sea Org is a life of purpose — the elite of a world-saving movement, its discipline a privilege, its camaraderie the deepest bond of their lives, its austerity the ordinary price of a religious order, comparable to the monasteries and the missions of the older faiths. In the former members' accounts — now a large literature, including senior executives of decades' service: the hours run routinely past a hundred a week in the pressured seasons; sleep, family contact, and privacy are subordinated to the organization's emergencies; marriages are within the order and at its convenience; children, since a 1986 order, are not permitted to members serving at the senior bases, a rule that has ended pregnancies and postings alike in the accounts; and the discipline includes the Rehabilitation Project Force — the RPF — a regime of physical labor, isolation, and study for members in disfavor, lasting months or, in some accounts, years. The school's account does not average the columns: it states the institution's own description entire, and the departed's description entire, and notes what is not disputed by either — the uniform, the contract, the communal life, the allowance, the RPF's existence — as the ground on which the student must form, from the testimonies, his judgment of the life.
The legacy is the lesson's third subject. The Sea Org is, institutionally, the movement's answer to the problem every young faith in the building has faced: how to keep the founder's fire at its founding heat after the founder — and its answer is the most thorough in the school: a permanent, uniformed, celibate-in-effect (in its senior discipline), property-less cadre, vowed for a billion years, from which alone the church's command is drawn. Its legacy in the wider record is double. It preserved the movement: the church's survival of the founder's death, its legal wars, and its schisms without a succession crisis is credited, across the record's divides, to the Sea Org's cohesion and its command structure. And it became the movement's chief exhibit in the world's argument about it: the uniforms and the billion years read by the sympathetic as devotion's modern form and by the critical as the total institution's uniform, the same photographs serving both arguments — a doubleness the school has met in this course at every station and which the Sea Org embodies, literally, in cloth. The school's comparative note is owed: the building's religious orders — the monks, the friars, the Salvation Army's officers with their own naval-adjacent ranks — all present the same riddle of a life that is freedom to its volunteers and captivity to its critics; the Sea Org is the riddle's most modern instance, distinguished by its term of vow (a billion years being the building's record), its founder's recency, and the fullness of the documentary record on both sides of its walls.
The legacy's last word is the school's instruction for reading the Sea Org's story. The order's members are the movement's second person because they are its permanent present tense: the founder is a voice on tape, the wife is a court record, but the Sea Org is at Clearwater this morning, in uniform, at its posts — the faith's claim that its eternity is organized, visible to any passerby. The student is to hold the two testimonies about that visible life as the course has taught him — the server's purpose and the departee's injury, both firsthand, both detailed, neither canceling the other — and to understand that the argument between them is, in the end, the argument of the whole modern study of religion in miniature: whether a total commitment, freely entered by adults under a doctrine they affirm, is a vocation or a capture, and who — the member, the departee, the state, the scholar — has the standing to say. The stories proceed from the order to its founding moments: the winter of 1950, when a pulp writer sat down to write the book that started everything; and the summer of 1967, when he took his church to sea.
Lesson 3: Hubbard writing Dianetics in 1950: the story in full
The third lesson tells, in full, the story of the movement's creation moment: the writing of Dianetics in the winter of 1949–50, and its eruption into the world in May 1950 — told as the record gives it, the church's account and the documents together. The setting first. In 1949 L. Ron Hubbard was thirty-eight, a pulp writer of formidable speed whose market was dying — the pulps collapsing as the paperbacks rose — living between engagements, his finances as precarious as his health (he drew a veteran's disability pension for his wartime injuries, the extent of which is one of the biography's documented disputes). He had been developing, in letters to his friend and editor John W. Campbell Jr. of Astounding Science Fiction, the ideas he called Dianetics: a therapy of the engram, worked out, in his account, from researches reaching back to the 1930s. Campbell — the most influential editor in science fiction, a man hungry for a science of the mind as he had been hungry for every science — took the system up with an editor's whole force: he tried the therapy, he promoted it in his magazine's pages, he recruited the physician Joseph Winter to lend it medical dress and the publisher Hermitage House to issue the book. The school's account of the winter's writing follows the record: Hubbard wrote the book at speed — at Bay Head, New Jersey, and in the circle's accounts at a pace of dictation and typing that matched his pulp legend — producing, in a matter of weeks, the five hundred pages that Campbell's May issue would announce to the world with the most famous editorial fanfare in the magazine's history: the claim that here was a science of the mind comparable, in Campbell's words, to the discovery of fire.
The eruption is the story's second movement. The article appeared in Astounding's May 1950 issue (on the stands in April); the book followed on May 9 — the date the movement still keeps as Dianetics Day. The response exceeded every party's expectation: the book entered the bestseller lists and remained for months; the Dianetics Foundation, established at Elizabeth, New Jersey, was overwhelmed with students; auditing groups formed spontaneously in city after city — the do-it-yourself chapters being taken up by thousands who audited each other in living rooms with the book open between them; Hubbard lectured to packed halls in New York and Los Angeles, the new Clear-making demonstrated on stages; Winter's own introduction lent the book its medical voice even as Winter himself, within the year, would break with Hubbard over the movement's direction — the first of the defections that punctuate the story from its first season. The school's account of the phenomenon's meaning follows the historians': Dianetics was the right offer at the exact hour — a cheap, hopeful, mechanical therapy for a nation of unspoken war wounds and expensive analysts, delivered not by a clinic but by a book, in the idiom of the century's rising faith, which was science. The movement it made was the first mass self-help movement of the therapeutic age, and its form — the lay practitioner, the weekend course, the bestseller as scripture — is the template the age has followed ever since.
The collapse is the story's third movement, and it belongs to the story entire, as the movement's own telling also now includes it. The professions closed ranks against the claims; the demonstrations faltered in public; the money — the Foundation's enrollments and the book's royalties entangled with the movement's debts — ran out with the speed it had come; other Dianetics leaders broke away with their own versions (the first squirrels, in the movement's later term, being Dianetics' own first lieutenants); and by the winter of 1951–52 the structure was in bankruptcy, the rights to Dianetics sold to the Wichita backer Don Purcell and then entangled in the proceedings from which Hubbard emerged, in April 1952, announcing not a repaired Dianetics but a new and larger subject. The school's judgment on the two years is the record's: they contain the whole movement in embryo — the brilliant systematizing offer, the mass enthusiasm, the professional rejection, the schisms, the financial collapse, and the founder's refusal, at the bottom, to stop — the pattern that would repeat at larger scales for the rest of the century, in the church that rose from the book's ashes within three years of its publication. The student should mark the speed of the whole arc: from the typewriter to the bestseller list to the bankruptcy court in twenty-four months — the fastest founding in the building, and the template of the fastest century.
The story's last word is the movement's own keeping of it, which the school records as the lesson's close. Dianetics Day, May 9, is kept annually as the book's birthday; the book itself, in the church's Basics edition, is presented to every new student as the movement's foundation; and the winter's writing has entered the church's lore in the founder's own accounts of it — the research of the preceding decades, the cures claimed, the manuscript's production — which the faithful receive as the technology's nativity and the critics read against the letters and the ledgers. The school leaves the student at the typewriter in Bay Head, the pages rising beside it, Campbell's fanfare already set in type — the moment before the eruption, when the whole enormous sequel was a stack of paper and one man's certainty that he had found the mind's secret — and it turns to the second creation: the summer of 1967, when the same man, his book become a church and his church become a fleet, put to sea with his most devoted followers and founded the order that still crews his religion.
Lesson 4: The Sea Org beginning on ships in 1967: the story in full
The final story lesson tells the second creation entire: the founding of the Sea Organization in 1967, when L. Ron Hubbard took his movement to sea. The setting first. By 1966 Hubbard had resigned his formal directorship of the churches, settled the movement's research at Saint Hill, and — in the church's account — completed the upper levels' breakthroughs (the Operating Thetan materials of the period); in the record's account, he was also a man increasingly embattled in Britain, where the press and Parliament were turning hostile and the government's inquiries were beginning. In 1967 he purchased, through the movement's arrangements, three ships — most famously the Royal Scotman, a former Irish Sea ferry, renamed the Apollo, which became his flagship — and in August of that year he formally founded the Sea Organization, its first members the loyal staff who followed him aboard. The school's account of the founding's stated purpose follows the church's: the Sea Org was to be the movement's ethical backbone — a disciplined corps, modeled on the founder's naval service (Hubbard had served as a U.S. Navy officer in the Second World War, commanding small vessels, the record of that service being, as the biography lesson noted, one of the record's documented disputes) — which would carry Scientology's standard free of the landside world's interference, auditing and training at sea while the churches ashore grew under its example. The reality the record adds is the fleet's function as the founder's mobile headquarters and refuge: for eight years the Apollo and her consorts cruised the Mediterranean, the Atlantic, and the Caribbean, putting into the ports of Spain, Morocco, Portugal, Madeira, and the islands, the Commodore directing a world movement by telex from a ship that no single government could easily summon.
The shipboard life is the story's second movement, in the record's two columns as the Sea Org lesson established them. In the church's and the loyalists' account: the Apollo years were the movement's heroic age — the Commodore's daily presence, the research continuing, the crew's training at the highest level, the missions dispatched ashore to found and reform the organizations, the whole ship a floating monastery and university of the technology, its discipline the making of the executives who run the church to this day. In the departed's accounts — the memoirs of officers who served aboard, including the founder's own former aides: the discipline at sea was of another order — the punishments for failed production including the 'overboarding' of erring crew (thrown from the ship's side into the harbor, a practice the church has described as a religious ritual of the period and the memoirs describe as terror), the chain locker confinements of children in the memoirs' gravest passages, the founder's rages and the messengers' feared authority. The school's account states the practices' documentation exactly: the overboardings are attested in the church's own publications of the era as a Sea Org discipline, and described in the memoirs at a length and consistency the student can weigh; the chain locker accounts rest on the memoirs' testimony, which the church disputes; and the whole stands, in the record, as the founding generation's contested inheritance — the order's own official histories dwelling on the missions and the research, and the critical literature on the punishments, with the documents of the period — the ship's logs, the ethics orders, the photographs of the crew in their uniforms on the Apollo's decks — available to the student's judgment in the archives of both.
The fleet's end is the story's third movement. The ports closed one by one: the Apollo expelled from harbor after harbor as the controversies traveled with her — Corfu, where the Greek junta's welcome curdled; Madeira, where a riot against the ship in Funchal in 1974 (the 'rock festival' incident of the accounts, the crew pelted and the ship's motorcycle party answered by a crowd) marked the cruise's deterioration; Spain's and Portugal's cooling — until, in 1975, the Sea Org came ashore: the 'land bases' established, the Flag Service Organization planted at Clearwater under the arrangements the history recorded, the Apollo sold by 1977, and the order translated from a fleet into a land navy, its uniforms and ranks and discipline intact in the office buildings of Florida and California. The school's student should mark the translation's success as the record's undisputed fact: institutions rarely survive the loss of their founding form; the Sea Org survived the loss of the sea itself, its identity proving to be not maritime but organizational — the vow, the uniform, and the chain of command having been the ship all along, portable into any building the order occupies. Hubbard himself came ashore into the seclusion of his last decade, directing through the messengers the order had trained — the fleet's final product being the command structure that succeeded him.
The story's last word is the school's weighing of 1967. The Sea Org's founding is the movement's most consequential institutional act after the church's own: it created the permanent cadre that carried the faith through its founder's death and its hardest decades, and it created, in the same act, the setting of the record's gravest allegations — the two legacies sailing, like the Apollo herself, in one hull. The school leaves the student on the Apollo's deck in the Mediterranean light — the uniformed crew at their drills, the telex chattering with a world's churches, the Commodore on the bridge of his own religion — an image in which the whole movement, its grandeur and its shadow, is present at once, which is the only honest way the record permits it to be seen. The course turns from the stories to their keeping: the celebrations of the movement's year — the founder's birthday in March, Dianetics Day in May, the Sunday services and the course rooms and the yellow tents of the Volunteer Ministers — the calendar in which the persons of this semester are honored and the work of the stories is continued.