Adult Year 1 · Semester 3 — Texts and teachings
Four lessons for this semester. When you are ready, take the test for this semester.
Lesson 1: Dianetics: The Modern Science of Mental Health (1950): a guided overview
The texts semester opens with the movement's founding book: Dianetics: The Modern Science of Mental Health, published in May 1950 — the volume from which the whole movement, church and controversy alike, descends. The book first, in its form. It is a large, systematic work — some five hundred pages in its standard editions — written at speed, in the author's pulp manner, and organized as a complete theory and therapy of the mind: Book One sets out the theory of the dynamics and the mind's parts; Book Two, the engram and the reactive mind in their detail, including the theory's most debated extension, the engrams recorded before birth; Book Three, the therapy — the auditing procedure of the original Dianetics, in which the patient (the book's term is preclear) recounts incidents under the auditor's guidance until the engram's charge is released, the book's famous instruction being that the auditor does not evaluate or interpret but guides the preclear back through his own recordings. The school's overview follows its rule: the book's contents are summarized as the book presents them — a theory offered by its author as a modern science, with case histories as its evidence — and its public standing is noted in the record's terms: the scientific and medical establishments of its day did not accept its claims, the American Psychological Association's 1950 resolution urging caution being among the period's documents, and the book's claims remaining outside the mainstream of psychology and medicine to this day. What is not in dispute is the book's effect: it was one of the best-selling books of its decade, it founded a mass movement within months, and it remains in print, in the church's editions, as the movement's first scripture.
The book's doctrines, in guided outline, are the overview's second subject. The mind's goal is survival; its perfect state is the Clear — the person whose reactive mind is emptied of engrams, whose intelligence is thereby raised, whose psychosomatic ills (the book attributes a wide range of them to engrams) are relieved, and whose emotions are his own. The villain of the system is the engram's content, and especially its verbal content: the words recorded in pain — 'I'm no good,' 'leave me alone,' the quarrels overheard from the womb in the theory's account — thereafter restimulated as literal commands upon the adult's behavior, the book's case histories turning on such phrases with a detective story's satisfactions. The school's reading of the system's appeal follows the historians': Dianetics gave its readers a complete, mechanical, hopeful account of their unhappiness — a cause that was not sin, not character, not fate, but recorded pain, erasable by a procedure any two friends could perform on each other from the book — the democratization of therapy being, in 1950, a revolutionary offer, and the book's do-it-yourself auditing chapters its revolutionary instrument. The church's present editions frame the book with the movement's later doctrine — the thetan and the Bridge standing behind the engram in the modern reader's path — so that the book is read today, inside the movement, as the first chapter of a longer work, and outside it, as the founding document of a controversy.
The book's career is the overview's third subject. Published to a fanfare in the science fiction press, it made its author famous and its publisher rich within the year; it made its movement, unmade it in the bankruptcy of 1952, and survived its own collapse to be republished as Scientology's foundation text — the only scripture in the building to have been, for a season, the property of a creditor. Its textual history is the modern church's own subject: the editions multiplied, the 2007 'Basics' reissue presenting the book, in the church's account, restored to the author's original from the manuscripts, the critics reading the reissues with their standing suspicion — the school noting the dispute as it noted it for the whole corpus, and noting also the undisputed: the book in the church's bookstores today is presented as the author's unaltered word, and the church's rule of Keeping Scientology Working makes that presentation a doctrine and not merely a publishing claim. The scholars of religion read the book in their own way: as a primary document of postwar America's therapeutic culture, the self-help century's founding text, and the seed — whatever its science — of a world religion, a combination that guarantees it readers in the universities long after its therapy has been argued to a standstill in the journals.
The overview's last word places Dianetics among the building's texts by its office. It is a scripture that claims to be a science — the building's only one in quite that form — and its office in the movement is therefore double: it is believed as the church's foundation and it is used as the auditor's manual, the text and the technology in one volume. The school submits that a student who understands that doubleness understands the movement's whole literary character: every text in this room is an instrument, written to be applied, and judged by its author and his church by the single test the founder set for all his work — does it work, in the session, on the person? The texts proceed from the founding book to its systematic companion: Scientology: The Fundamentals of Thought, the founder's own primer of the whole subject, in which the thetan and the dynamics and the communication formula are laid out as a system.
Lesson 2: Scientology: The Fundamentals of Thought: a guided overview
The second text is the movement's primer: Scientology: The Fundamentals of Thought, first published in 1956 — the book the church itself designates as the basic text of the whole subject, the one-volume system in which Hubbard laid out the philosophy entire for the general reader. The book first, in its form and office. It is short where Dianetics is long, systematic where Dianetics is narrative: a sequence of chapters on the dynamics, the parts of man (the thetan, the mind, and the body, in the teaching's triad), the axioms of Scientology — the book's distinctive feature, a numbered set of logical statements the founder presents as the subject's foundations, in the manner of a geometry — the theory of communication, the conditions of existence (the triad of affinity, reality, and communication, abbreviated ARC, whose joint increase the church calls understanding), and the processes by which the philosophy is applied. The school's overview presents the book as the church presents it: the ABC of the subject, the text with which the student's course in the church's own academies begins, written by the founder to stand between the newcomer and the library — the library being, as the next lesson shows, oceanic. Its office in the movement is therefore foundational in the strict sense: the Fundamentals is the map of the whole territory, against which the rest of the corpus is read, and its concepts — ARC, the dynamics, the tone scale of emotions that the book introduces — are the movement's everyday vocabulary, used by members as the common coin of their analysis of life.
The book's system, in guided outline, is the overview's second subject. Its center is communication: the formula — cause, distance, effect, with intention and attention and duplication — by which the church analyzes every exchange, and from which its practices of auditing and training are derived, the auditing session being, in the system's terms, a controlled communication cycle between auditor and preclear. Around the center the system arranges its instruments: the emotional Tone Scale, grading human emotion and behavior from death and apathy through anger and boredom to enthusiasm and serenity, used in the church's ethics and human evaluation; the axioms' account of the thetan's nature and the games of life; the theory of problems, games, and the parts of man. The school's reading of the system's character follows the scholars': the Fundamentals is a systematizer's performance — a complete vocabulary and a complete set of relations among its terms, self-consistent in the manner of a constructed language — whose persuasiveness, for its readers, lies in the system's usability: the member armed with ARC and the Tone Scale possesses, or experiences himself as possessing, an instrument for reading every human situation, and the church's courses are largely the training of that instrument's use. The critics' reading of the same system — that its terms are the founder's inventions, answerable to no outside check — is the record's other column, and the school leaves the system's truth, as it leaves the doctrine's, to the student's judgment of the whole course's evidence.
The book's place in the movement's life is the overview's third subject. The Fundamentals is the first book of the church's 'Basics' — the sequence of eighteen books and their lectures that the modern church sets before its members as the foundation of their study, to be read in chronological order in the church's course rooms under the study technology's discipline. Its concepts govern the movement's daily speech to a degree unusual even in this building: the member speaks of 'ARC breaks' and 'being in communication,' grades his fellows on the Tone Scale in his analysis, and understands his auditing as the repair of the communication formula at the level of the reactive mind — the primer's vocabulary having become, as a living language does, invisible to its speakers as a system and present to them simply as how things are. The school's student should mark the achievement the book represents for the movement's founder, whatever the judgment on its truth: Hubbard built, in one short volume, a complete interpretive kit for human life, portable enough for a paperback and total enough for a lifetime's study — the kind of instrument that, in the building's long record, is the usual seed of a durable movement, from the Analects to the Shorter Catechism.
The overview's last word sets the Fundamentals among the building's texts by its office. Dianetics is the movement's epic — the founding narrative of the mind's fall and clearing; the Fundamentals is its catechism — the system in questions the reader asks himself — and the two together are the movement's whole scripture in miniature: a story and a system, a wound and a geometry. The school submits that the student who has read the two overviews possesses the doctrine's skeleton entire, and is ready for the corpus's true scale: the works and lectures of L. Ron Hubbard in their totality — the millions of words, the thousands of tapes, the policy and the poetry — which the next lesson surveys as the largest single-author scripture in the building, and the most deliberately preserved.
Lesson 3: The works and lectures of L. Ron Hubbard: a guided overview
The third text is not a book but a library: the works and lectures of L. Ron Hubbard in their totality — the corpus the church preserves as its scripture entire. The scale first, in the record's figures. Hubbard's religious and philosophical output comprises, by the church's count, more than a thousand books and booklets' worth of material in the wider bibliography and some three thousand recorded lectures, together with the thousands of policy letters and bulletins that govern the church's administration and the delivery of its practices — the whole amounting, in the church's frequently cited figure, to tens of millions of words, the largest body of doctrine and direction ever issued by a single religious founder and preserved entire. To this the record adds his fiction — over a thousand short stories and novels in the pulp count, capped by the enormous science fiction works of his last decade, Battlefield Earth (1982) and the ten-volume Mission Earth series — which the church's publishing houses also keep in print, the founder's two careers bound together in the movement's bookstores as they were in his life. The school's account of the preservation follows the church's own: the corpus is archived on indestructible media in vaults (the church's archives project, with its stainless steel and titanium time capsules, being a documented enterprise), reissued in the corrected 'Basics' and 'Golden Age' editions, and administered under the rule that nothing of it may be altered — the founder's death having closed the canon in 1986, in the most literal sense the building affords: a scripture with a known final page.
The corpus's kinds are the overview's second subject. The books of doctrine: Dianetics and its successors, the Fundamentals, Science of Survival (1951, with its Tone Scale chart of human evaluation), A History of Man, The Creation of Human Ability, and the rest of the eighteen Basics. The lectures: the great series — the Saint Hill courses, the congresses, the Philadelphia Doctorate Course of 1952 in which the thetan doctrine was first set out at length — delivered to the movement's students and preserved on tape in the founder's own voice, so that the church's scripture is, uniquely in the building, substantially an audio scripture, the founder's cadence and humor part of the text as the cantillation is part of the Torah's. The administrative corpus: the policy letters that constitute the church's management system, read by its executives as binding instruction. And the ethical and social writings: The Way to Happiness, the Narconon and study-technology materials. The school's reading of the corpus's unity follows the church's: it is one work — 'the technology' — of which the doctrine, the practice, the ethics, and the administration are departments; the student's difficulty, which the scholars share, is that the corpus's sheer size makes its mastery a life's work, which is, the church answers, precisely the Bridge's design: the corpus is not read; it is climbed, level by level, in the order the founder built.
The corpus's custody is the overview's third subject, because in this movement the text's government is the church's constitution. The Religious Technology Center holds the trademarks and licenses the corpus's use; the church's rule of Keeping Scientology Working (from Hubbard's 1965 policy letter) makes alteration of the technology the system's supreme internal offense ('squirreling'); the editions' history — the reissues and their disputes — has been given in the history semester. The school's account of the custody's consequence for study is the scholars': the corpus is the most controlled scripture in the building — its texts available in the church's editions, its upper levels (the Operating Thetan materials) confidential and issued only in the church's settings, its unauthorized circulation pursued in the courts with the copyright laws as the instrument — so that the student of this movement meets, in its library, the building's sharpest case of a text that is at once published to the world and fenced from it, the fence itself being one of the movement's most debated features in the public record, defended by the church as the protection of a technology that can harm if misapplied and attacked by the critics as the protection of the movement's central mystery from the scrutiny its lower levels invite. The school states the fence and the two defenses of and attacks on it, and reproduces none of the confidential material, in accordance with its rule for all the building's restricted teachings.
The overview's last word places the corpus among the building's scriptures by its mode of authority. The scroll is authoritative as God's word through the prophet; the oral archive, as the ancestors' memory through the keepers; Hubbard's corpus is authoritative as the founder's demonstrated technology through the organization he built to keep it standard — an authority of the manual and the laboratory notebook, claiming not inspiration but results, and preserving not a revelation but a procedure. The school submits that this is the corpus's true distinctiveness and the key to the movement's whole literary life: its members do not, in the main, quote Hubbard as the faithful quote the psalms; they apply him, as engineers apply a handbook — and the handbook's author, having written the ethics and the management and the aesthetics as well, stands behind every department of their common life as no other founder in the building stands behind his church's filing system. The texts close with the present: how this most preserved of scriptures is interpreted and studied now — by the church that may not alter it, by the independents who apply it without license, and by the scholars for whom it is the modern age's most complete archive of a religion's self-documentation.
Lesson 4: Interpretation and study today
The texts semester closes in the present: how Hubbard's corpus and the movement's teachings are interpreted and studied now — by the church, whose rule forbids interpretation in the usual sense; by the independent practitioners; and by the scholars. The church's study first, because it is the corpus's primary reading and its method is the movement's signature. In the church's course rooms, the student studies the founder's texts under the 'study technology' — Hubbard's own method, with its three barriers to study (the misunderstood word above all, to be cleared by the dictionary until the text yields its meaning) — checking out on each section with a twin or a supervisor, the aim being not interpretation but duplication: the student's understanding must reproduce the text's meaning exactly, the founder having written, in the church's conviction, precisely what he meant. The school's account of this hermeneutic follows the scholars': it is the most literalist reading regime in the building — a fundamentalism of the manual rather than of the prophecy — in which the question 'what did the author mean?' has been answered in advance ('what he wrote') and the student's whole labor is application. The regime's fruits are the movement's famous uniformity: the auditing delivered in Clearwater and Copenhagen is, by the system's design and its inspectors' enforcement, the same auditing, word for word — the corpus's interpretation being, in the end, an engineering specification, and its study a training.
The independents' study is the lesson's second subject. The Free Zone and independent Scientologists — practitioners outside the church, many of them former members of long standing — study the same corpus with a reader's freedom the church denies: selecting among the editions, preferring the older printings in many cases, interpreting the founder against his church, and delivering the technology, in their account, as Hubbard intended and the organization has betrayed. The school's account of the schism's textual character follows the record: it is a dispute, at bottom, over custody — who owns the founder's words, who may deliver his procedures, whose edition is the true one — of a kind the building knows well (the keepers against the readers, in every age) with this modern peculiarity: the disputed property is protected by trademark and copyright, so the schism is litigated as an intellectual-property matter, the church's suits against the independents' use of its marks being the legal form of a theological argument about succession. The scholars watch the Free Zone as the movement's control experiment: the same texts, the same procedures, minus the organization — its survival and character being evidence, for the record, on the question of how much of the movement is the technology and how much the church.
The scholars' study is the lesson's third subject. Scientology has become, in the universities, a standard case in the study of new religious movements — taught for its documentation (no movement's paper trail is fuller), its legal history (its litigation reshaped the law of religions in several countries), and its controversies (which the field studies as data about the society that produces them as much as about the movement). The scholarly literature divides, as the school's method requires it to note, between the sympathetic and the critical — with the field's senior figures having moved, across the decades, toward the position this course occupies: the movement described in its own terms first, the record stated entire, the verdicts left to the evidence's cumulative weight in the reader. The primary sources' accessibility shapes the field: the church's own publications and the founder's corpus are open to any purchaser at the lower levels; the court records — the Snow White files, the tax litigation, the custody and disconnection cases — are the public archive against which the church's presentations are read; and the memoir literature of the former members, from the first generation's accounts to the executives' books of the present century, constitutes the field's fastest-growing shelf. The school's student is directed, as the texts semester's keepsake, to the proportion the scholars themselves observe: for every hour with the argument about the movement, an hour with the movement's own texts — the founder's voice being, whatever the verdict on it, the primary fact of the whole subject.
The lesson's last word, and the texts semester's, returns to the school's standing question: what do these texts ask of the person who studies them? Dianetics asks to be tried; the Fundamentals, to be applied; the corpus, to be climbed; and the whole library asks, in the founder's own formula, to be judged by the only test he acknowledged: does it work? The school's course has not run that experiment and does not report its result; it has done the other thing a school can do — it has taught the student what the texts say, who wrote them, how they are kept, and what the world has made of them — and it leaves the founder's question standing at the door of the practice semester, where the technology the texts describe is actually delivered: the auditing session with its meter, the course room with its dictionaries, and the family's ordinary week inside the most argued-about faith of the modern world.