Age 12 · Semester 3 — Values and choices
Four lessons for this semester. When you are ready, take the test for this semester.
Lesson 1: Respect for all relations and generosity
Two values stand near the centre of Indigenous life across North America: respect for all relations, and generosity. Respect comes first, because it follows from the teaching that everything is related. To respect a relation is to treat it as a someone, not a something: to listen before speaking, to take carefully, to waste nothing, to keep promises made to people and to the land. Elders model this in small things — greeting the day, thanking the water, speaking well of the absent — because respect that only appears at ceremonies is not respect at all.
Generosity is respect in action toward people. In many nations, the giveaway is a formal institution: at feasts, namings, memorials, and honours, the family gives goods — blankets, food, craftwork, money — to guests and to those in need, and the family's standing rises with its giving. A person known to share meat, time, and skill without keeping score is rich in the only wealth these teachings finally honour. The opposite — stinginess, hoarding, letting a neighbour go hungry beside your full storehouse — is remembered with shame long after the goods themselves rot.
These two values correct each other usefully. Respect without generosity can become mere politeness; generosity without respect can become showing off. Together they form the everyday test of the whole tradition: Did I treat every relation — human, animal, plant, water, ancestor, stranger — as a someone? Did I share what I had? A student who wants one sentence to carry from this lesson can take this one: in a world where all things are relations, respect is how you speak to the world, and generosity is how you prove you meant it.
The two values also govern speech, which students sometimes forget. To speak respectfully of the absent, to refuse gossip that tears the circle, to thank people by name and in public — these are generosity with words and respect in the tongue. A community can often be judged by this small currency: where thanks is common and honour is given away freely, the great ceremonies rest on solid ground.
Lesson 2: Bravery in daily life
Bravery is honoured in every Indigenous nation, but the teachings define it more deeply than battlefield courage. In the well-known Plains formulation, bravery is one of the four great virtues — alongside generosity, fortitude, and wisdom in Lakota teaching — and it means doing the right thing in the presence of fear, not the absence of fear. A person who feels no fear may simply not understand the danger; a brave person understands it fully and acts rightly anyway, for the sake of others.
Most bravery in these teachings is daily bravery. It is the hunter providing in a hard winter, the mother defending her children, the elder speaking an unwelcome truth to a powerful person, the young person refusing to join in cruelty, the addict choosing recovery one day at a time, the language learner speaking imperfect words aloud despite embarrassment. Ceremonies honour warriors, but the stories honour this wider courage just as much: the muskrat diving past his strength, Sky Woman's animals risking the deep — small beings doing the brave thing at the size of their own lives.
Counting coup — touching an enemy in battle and escaping unharmed — was honoured on the Plains above killing, because it proved courage at maximum risk with minimum harm, and it teaches students the tradition's own scale of values: nerve in service of the people, restrained by honour. For a student today, the transferable teaching is exact: bravery is not loudness, size, or daring for applause. It is the quiet decision, repeated daily, to protect what is entrusted to you, to tell the truth, and to do the hard right thing while your heart is pounding.
Fortitude, bravery's close companion, completes the picture: bravery begins the hard thing, and fortitude continues it through the long middle when applause has stopped. The elder who cares for grandchildren for decades, the community that rebuilds a language nest class by class — these are fortitude's works, and the teachings honour them as highly as any single daring act, because most of life is the long middle.
Lesson 3: Right and wrong in Primal Indigenous
Primal Indigenous traditions do not usually hand down a single written list of commandments. Right and wrong are learned instead through the web of relations: an action is right when it strengthens the circle — of family, community, land, and the unseen world — and wrong when it tears the circle for selfish gain. Elders teach the standard through stories, through the example of respected lives, and through direct correction, and the community itself enforces it through honour and shame, through making amends, and in serious cases through councils and, historically, banishment.
Certain wrongs appear across nations with striking consistency. Hoarding while others hunger is wrong. Breaking one's word is wrong. Disrespecting elders, mocking the sacred, wasting the gifts of animals and plants, and harming the vulnerable — children, elders, strangers under one's protection — are wrong. So is taking more from the land than it can give back, because that steals from the seventh generation. The pattern beneath the list is always the same: wrong is whatever treats a relation as a thing to be used; right is whatever treats a relation as a someone to be honoured.
Just as important is how wrongs are repaired. In many nations the emphasis falls on restoration rather than punishment alone: the wrongdoer makes amends, gives restitution, apologizes publicly, and is woven back into the circle when the repair is real — the pattern students will meet again in the Green Corn Ceremony's yearly forgiveness and in the Great Law of Peace. A student comparing traditions should notice the centre of gravity: right and wrong are not finally about rulebooks but about relationships — kept, broken, and mended — in a world where everything is related.
One more feature deserves notice: the standard is communal, but conscience is personal. No elder can make another person's choice, and the stories are full of individuals who stood alone for the right — the scout who approached the sacred woman with respect while his companion mocked. The web of relations guides the conscience; it does not replace it. Maturity, in this tradition, is learning to hear the whole circle and still answer with one's own heart.
Lesson 4: Making hard choices
Every tradition is tested at the point of hard choices, and Indigenous teachings offer a distinctive toolkit for them. The first tool is time: decisions are slowed down. Councils talk until the matter is clear; a person sleeps on a grave question; elders are consulted because they have seen the pattern before. The second tool is the circle: a hard choice is examined from every side — its effect on children, on elders, on the land, on the ancestors' honour, and on the seventh generation to come. A choice that looks good for one season but poisons seven generations fails the test.
The third tool is story. Faced with a dilemma, a person asks which story they are in: Am I the hoarding chief whose boxes kept the world dark? Am I Coyote, about to choose the clever thing I will grieve? Am I the muskrat, small but willing? Stories do not make the decision, but they reveal its shape, and many a hard choice has been clarified by recognizing the tale. The fourth tool is humility: the teachings assume no one sees the whole, so a hard choice is made in prayer, with counsel, and with willingness to be corrected by the community.
Students can practice this toolkit on ordinary ground. A hard choice at school — whether to report a friend, how to spend scarce money for a family, whether to speak against a popular cruelty — can be slowed down, circled around from every relation's side, matched against the stories, and decided humbly. The tradition does not promise that the right choice will be painless; the muskrat's dive was not painless. It promises something better: a way of choosing that a person can stand behind for seven generations, because it was made with respect for all relations and not in selfish haste.