Adult Year 2 · Semester 4 — Places, arts, and the road ahead
Four lessons for this semester. When you are ready, take the test for this semester.
Lesson 1: The sacred mountain — like Bear Butte or the Black Hills and the river and the fishing grounds
Year Two's final semester opens with the covenant's sacred geography at its most contested and most instructive: the sacred mountain and the sacred waters — Bear Butte and the Black Hills, the river and the fishing grounds — the places where the doctrine that the land is a relative meets the surrounding world's law, in the cases the whole continent now studies. The mountain first, in its two exemplars. Bear Butte — Mato Paha — in South Dakota, is the Lakota and Cheyenne's mountain of prayer: the place where, in the Cheyenne account, the prophet Sweet Medicine received the Sacred Arrows and the nation's laws; where the Lakota's vision seekers have climbed for the hanblecheya since the keeping of memory; a mountain set apart by its geology — rising alone from the plains, an island of stone — and by its use, the prayer ties and the cloth offerings of the present year's seekers bright on its slopes today, the mountain a working sanctuary in the present tense. The Black Hills — Paha Sapa, the heart of all that is, in the Lakota phrase — are the nation's country entire as a sanctuary: the hills of the people's emergence-adjacent geography and their ceremonial round, guaranteed to the Lakota by the Treaty of 1868 as part of the Great Sioux Reservation, taken by the United States in 1877 after the gold discovery — the taking the Supreme Court itself, in 1980, called, in the judgment's famous sentence, a case of a ripening theft — awarding money the nation has refused for forty years and refuses still, the award grown past a billion dollars in its trust, untouched: the hills, in the nation's standing formulation, are not for sale, and the refusal is the doctrine's most expensive sentence ever uttered by any people in the building — the school pausing on it as such: a nation offered a fortune for its sanctuary and answering, across two generations of poverty, that the relative is not a price.
The river and the fishing grounds are the geography's second half, and their cases complete the doctrine's legal portrait. The treaty fisheries of the Pacific Northwest — the usual and accustomed grounds of the Stevens treaties — were the subject of the Boldt decision of 1974, which read the treaties' plain words — the right of taking fish in common with the settlers — as the nations' understanding had always read them: a half share of the harvest and a co-manager's seat, the ruling restoring, as the history lesson recorded, the spears and the nets to the rivers. The fishing place is, in the nations' account, not a resource but a relative's address: the falls where the families have fished since the ice — Celilo, the great fishery of the Columbia, drowned by the Dalles Dam in 1957 in a single spring, the nations watching the water rise over a ten-thousand-year-old sanctuary in the name of the navigation and the power — the drowning being, in the school's record, the geography's Celilo-shaped wound: the proof that the surrounding world's law, even at its most lawful, could not see a sanctuary where it saw a dam site, the two peoples looking at the same falls and one seeing a relative and the other a kilowatt. The school's student should hold the two cases as the doctrine's pair: at the Hills, the nation refuses the money for the mountain; at Celilo, the nation was not asked — the geography's whole modern history being the oscillation between those two treatments, and the recovery's work being, in large part, the slow legal labor of moving the continent's practice from the second toward the first.
The sacred geography's present keeping is the lesson's third subject. The mountains and the rivers are kept today in the double custody the recovery has built: the nations' own — the tribal historic preservation offices, the nations' sacred-site protocols, the prayer seasons at Bear Butte protected, after the nations' litigation and negotiation, by the voluntary closures the climbers and the bikers of the nearby rally are asked, with increasing success, to observe — and the law's, in its partial recognitions: the Religious Freedom Act's promise and its judicial disappointments, the executive orders on sacred sites, the co-management regimes of the rivers where the Boldt precedent's logic spreads. The school's account of the geography's theology closes the lesson's survey where the foundations began: the mountain is a relative, and the relation is kept as relations are kept — by visiting, by praying, by defending, by refusing the sale — and the continent's other peoples are learning, in the climate century, to read their own places in the grammar the nations never lost: the watershed as a relative, the forest as a relation, the whole land ethic of the surrounding world's best modern thought being, in the nations' gentle and standing observation, a homecoming to the address their covenants never left.
The lesson's last word is the geography's claim on the student, stated in the nations' public teaching. The student will likely never climb Bear Butte — and the teaching is that he is not asked to: the mountain's sanctity does not need his visit; it needs his vote, his court's respect, his rally's restraint, his dam's reconsideration — the geography asking of the outsider not devotion but the one civic virtue the texts semester named: the keeping of the word, the treaties' and the law's, toward the places the word protects. It is the continent's oldest geography lesson, and the school's student carries it into every planning meeting and zoning hearing of his life: that a place can be a person, that a people's sanctuary can be older than the state that surrounds it, and that the measure of the surrounding civilization is, in the nations' standing test, what it does at the falls it covets and the mountain it cannot buy. The places proceed from the wild sanctuary to the built one: the longhouse and the powwow grounds — the covenant's architecture, where the relations are housed.
Lesson 2: The longhouse and the powwow grounds
The second places lesson takes the covenant's built sanctuaries: the longhouse and the powwow grounds — the architecture in which the relations are housed, from the Haudenosaunee longhouse that is a constitution you can live in, to the arena that is a nation's living room under the sky. The longhouse first, in its form and its meanings. The Haudenosaunee longhouse — the bark house of the eastern woodlands, extended in sections as the matrilineal clan-family grew — housed the extended family along its central fires: the clan mother's household, her daughters' families in their compartments, the stored corn in its lofts, the whole being the kinship system built in bark and pole — the architecture from which the confederacy took its own name and figure: Haudenosaunee, the People of the Longhouse, the five nations as the fires of one house under the Great Law's roof, the Mohawk at the eastern door and the Seneca at the western, the Onondaga fire at the center. The school's account of the figure's genius follows the law's keepers: a constitution imagined as a house makes citizenship a kinship and the state's geography a family's floor plan — the doors kept, the fire kept, the rafters the law's own image for its succession — and the modern longhouses, the ceremonial buildings where the confederacy's faith is kept today, inherit the figure entire: the Longhouse religion of Handsome Lake's code, the midwinter ceremonies, the longhouse as the Haudenosaunee's church and council in one room, as it was designed to be. The nations' other architectures answer the same brief in their countries' materials: the plank houses of the northwest coast, whose house-fronts and poles are the crests' archive in cedar; the Navajo hogan, the house built as a prayer, its door to the dawn; the earth lodge and the tipi of the plains, the one the village's permanence and the other the camp's philosophy in hide — that a house should be raisable in an hour by the women who own it, and that the circle is the only floor plan the relations require.
The powwow grounds are the built sanctuary's modern form, and the lesson gives them their architecture. The grounds are, at their simplest, a circle and a center: the arena, blessed at the season's opening in many communities, its center the drum's place and, in the grounds' keeping, a spot treated with the circle's whole courtesy; the arbor or the bleachers at the edge for the elders and the families; the MC's stand, the sound system, the vendors' and food rows behind — an architecture of almost nothing, raised on fairgrounds and school fields and the nations' own grounds from spring to fall, whose sanctity is in its use and its center and not in its materials. The school's account of the grounds' meaning is the celebrations' theology built: the circle is the covenant's shape — no head, no foot, the drum at the center as the fire was — and the grounds are the one sacred architecture in the building designed to be temporary, on the doctrine the tipi taught: that the sanctity is carried by the people and the rite, not stored in the stones — a portability that was, in the banning centuries, the architecture's survival and is, in the recovery, its freedom: the nations need no one's permission and no cathedral, only a field, a drum, and the relations, to raise the sanctuary entire in an afternoon. The permanent grounds — the nation's own powwow grounds with their arbors and their memorials — add the year's anchor: the home gathering, the ground where the nation's own dead are honored and its own royalty crowned, the arena as the nation's front yard, kept mowed by the people's own committee like a churchyard, and loved like one.
The two architectures together are the lesson's third subject, as the covenant's answer to the building's question of sacred space. The longhouse says: the sacred is the house — the relations under one roof, the law as a floor plan, the fire at the center of the dwelling. The grounds say: the sacred is the gathering — the relations in a circle, the drum at the center of the field. And between them the nations' whole built world declares the system's signature: the center is never a throne and never an altar of sacrifice; it is a fire or a drum — a warmth or a heartbeat — around which the persons sit in the round, the architecture's every line an egalitarian geometry with the mystery at the middle and the people, all the people, at the same distance from it. The school's comparative note closes the survey: the temple courts the god at the center of the courts; the cathedral lifts the eye to the god above the altar; the longhouse and the arena seat the people around the presence at their own level, in their own circle, at their own fire — the most democratic sacred architecture in the building, and the oldest on its continent, and the one whose plan a child can draw: a circle, a center, and everyone home.
The lesson's last word is the architecture's claim, which is the covenant's claim in built form. The longhouse still stands at the center of its nation's self-understanding — a people who call themselves a house will understand every political question as a household question: who keeps the fire, who keeps the doors, whose children are under the roof — and the powwow grounds still rise every summer weekend on a hundred fields, the sanctuary that fits in a truck. The school leaves the student at the arena's edge in the evening, the drum sounding, the arbor's elders in their chairs, the dancers' bells in the grass — with the architecture's lesson in his hands: that a sacred place is not found but made, by a people's gathering in the shape of their relations, and that the shape, once learned, can be raised anywhere the relations gather, which is why the covenant's sanctuaries survived the loss of the covenant's country: the people carried the floor plan in their kinship, and the kinship fit in the heart. The places turn last to the covenant's self-portrait: the arts — the carving, the beadwork, the story, and the song — in which the nations see and show themselves.
Lesson 3: Art, music, and literature of Primal Indigenous
The final places lesson turns to the covenant's arts — the carving and the beadwork, the song and the story, and the modern literature — the media in which the nations see themselves and show themselves, taken as the arts semester the brief joins to the places, because in this system the art is a place: the pole in the village, the drum at the center, the story at the fire. The visual arts first, in their covenant grammar. The northwest coast's formline — the carved and painted system of ovoids and crest figures on the poles, the house-fronts, the boxes, and the regalia — is a written language of the crests: the pole is a family's public archive and title deed, read by the witnesses at its raising, its figures the at.óow, the clan's sacred property, in the Tlingit term the museums now use. The plains' arts carry the history in their media: the painted hide, the winter count's pictography, the beadwork that succeeded the quillwork — each bead, in the modern master's phrase, a prayer — the patterns the families' property and the designs' meanings graded, as all the archive is graded, between the public and the kept. The southwest's pottery and weaving, the woodlands' birchbark and wampum, the Arctic's carving in stone and ivory: the continent's arts are, in the school's summary, the relations made durable — the crest a relative, the pattern an inheritance, the material a gift of the animal and the plant persons, thanked in the making — and their modern market, policed by the Arts and Crafts Act against the counterfeits, is the covenant's aesthetics in the recovery's economy: the Native artist as the archive's living producer, her work the nation's face in the world's galleries, on the nation's own terms at last, the museums that hold the grandmothers' confiscated masterpieces now borrowing the granddaughters' new ones for the exhibitions of the present tense.
The music is the arts' second form, and its center is the drum of the lessons throughout — with the flute beside it, the love flute of the plains whose courting songs are the continent's tenderest music, and the song itself as the archive's most portable art: the song owned, in the nations' law, as the crest is owned — a person's and a family's and a ceremony's property, given and inherited and never taken — the song's ownership being the doctrine by which the nations' intellectual property law is older, in continuous principle, than the republic's copyright. The modern music carries the archive into the world's forms without leaving its own: the powwow drum groups' recordings, the Native flute's world career, the rock and the hip-hop of the nations' young — the sampling of the old songs in the new tracks being, in the artists' own account, the intergenerational archive at work in the studio — and the school's note is the musicians': the beat under the new music is the drum's, the heartbeat the powwow names, and the young artists' claim — that they are not crossing over but carrying on — is the recovery's aesthetic manifesto in one sentence, which the school records without adjudicating, as it records all the nations' internal debates, noting only that the drum, at least, is audible in the result.
The literature is the arts' third form, and the semester's natural crown, because the nations' modern literature is where the whole course's matter is being re-told by its owners. The renaissance the history lesson named runs from the elders' dictated teachings through the novelists and poets — Momaday's House Made of Dawn opening the modern era in 1968 with the Pulitzer the republic's letters had never before given a Native author; Silko's Ceremony, the novel that is itself a healing rite for its veteran hero and, in the critics' consensus, the recovery's central text; Erdrich's and Alexie's and the present generation's shelves — to the children's literature of the immersion presses, where the archive's future is being printed in the languages. The school's account of the literature's doctrine is the writers' own: the story is not about the covenant; the story is the covenant, in its traveling form — the novel as the winter telling's heir, the poem as the song's, the memoir as the elder's dictated teaching's — and the literature's great subject is the course's great subject: survival, and the price of it, and the humor that paid the installments — the trickster presiding over the modern shelf as he presided over the fire's, Coyote in the city being the renaissance's presiding spirit exactly as the peoples-and-stories lesson promised. The school leaves the shelf with the reader's instruction the writers give their own: these books are the nations talking; the student's office is the guest's office at the feast — listen in the order given, credit the tellers by their nations' names, and carry away the teaching, not the costume.
The lesson's last word gathers the arts into the course's judgment. The pole and the drum, the bead and the book: the covenant's arts are its memory made beautiful and its beauty made useful — nothing in the system is merely decorative, the crest being a deed, the song a property, the story a law, the pattern a prayer — and the arts' modern flourishing is therefore not a renaissance of taste but of custody: the archive, at last, in its owners' hands, producing. The student who has walked the places — the mountain refused for sale, the longhouse's fire, the arena's circle, the gallery's pole, the shelf's novels — has the covenant's whole estate in view, and the course's final lesson asks the only question left: the road ahead — what the oldest teaching on the continent does next, in the century that is, at last, beginning to listen to it, and what the student who has studied it owes the road.
Lesson 4: Continuing to learn about Primal Indigenous
The course's final lesson is its door left open: how to continue learning about the primal Indigenous traditions — the nations' own guidance for the student who has finished the survey and stands, as the building's courses leave their students, at the threshold of a living world that is not his to enter uninvited and is very much his to honor, support, and keep learning from in the open. The first guidance is the sources' order, which the nations' teachers state plainly: learn from the nations. The books by the nations' own authors, published by the nations' and the universities' presses; the tribal nations' own websites and cultural departments, which publish, for the public, exactly what the nations wish the public to know — the school's student treating those publications as the feast's menu: what is served is served generously, and what is not on it is not owed; the museums that work in partnership with the nations, whose labels now carry the nations' own texts; the public lectures and the open houses of the immersion schools and the cultural centers; the powwows, attended as the guest Year One trained. Against these, the teachers set the sources to refuse: the popularizers who sell the costume, the 'shamanic' workshops of the plastic medicine people — the nations' own term for the sellers of imitations, whose exposure is a standing feature of the nations' press — and every source that offers the closed as the open, the secret as the purchasable, the ceremony as the weekend's product. The school's rule for the student's shelf is the semester's keepsake: if it is for sale as an experience, it is not the nations'; the nations' teaching is given, in the open, at the feast's terms — and the difference between the gift and the product is the whole education this course exists to give.
The second guidance is the conduct's continuation: the student's learning is to issue in the civic position the texts semester named. The treaties are the student's business as a citizen of the republics that signed them; the languages' funding, the objects' return, the sites' protection, the jurisdiction's respect are voted and testified and budgeted in the councils where the student, and not the nations' elders, holds the citizenship's ordinary powers — the study's fruit being, as the course has insisted, not an experience but a position, taken in the particular: this river's co-management, this museum's repatriation, this curriculum's accuracy, this dam's reconsideration. The nations' teachers are specific about the student's scale: the work is local because the nations are local — the student's own county has its nation, its treaty, its drowned or defended fishery, its language in its nest — and the course's last assignment, given in the elders' own form, is geographical: learn whose country you live in; learn it from them; and stand, in that country's councils, where the covenant's keeping requires standing. It is, the school notes, the only homework in the building that cannot be done in the library, and the only one whose grading is done by the future — the seventh generation of the student's own place, whose question the values semester supplied: did you keep it?
The third guidance is the humility of the road, because the course's completion is the beginning of the student's real instruction, which is conducted by the nations at their pace and not his. The survey has given him the map; the territory is the nations' present life, into which he is admitted exactly as far as the invitations run — the powwow's arena, the open house, the published book, the public lecture — and no farther, the boundary being, as the course has taught at every station, not the obstacle to the learning but its content: the nations' self-possession is the first fact about them, and the student's respect for the closed door is the certificate of his education that no test in this school can issue. The school's final caution is the teachers' own against the survey's besetting sin: the student now knows the general account of a continent of nations, and the general account is the beginning of knowledge and the end of nothing — every nation he now encounters is a particular people, in a particular country, with a particular history that the survey's averages do not contain, and he is to meet them as the course taught him to meet the first lesson's fire: as a guest, by name, in their own terms, grateful for what is given and incurious about what is not.
The course's last word is the school's farewell to its student, in the form the building's courses close. The primal Indigenous traditions are the continent's senior teaching: the covenant of the relations, kept through the ice's retreat and the republics' assault, in the languages and the ceremonies and the kitchens of the peoples who received it — and the student's two years in its school have been, in the elders' phrase for such things, a visiting: he has been fed at the fire, told the stories, shown the belts and the grounds and the mountain that is not for sale, and sent away with the guest's proper portion, which is the teaching and the obligation. The school leaves him at the arena's edge in the summer evening, the drum sounding for the intertribal — the dance to which everyone, even the guest, is invited into the circle — with the whole course in one invitation: come into the circle for the part that is yours; honor the parts that are not; and keep, in your own country and your own councils, the word you have been taught to keep. Mitakuye oyasin — all my relations: the school's last words are the covenant's first, and the student's road ahead runs, as the nations' road has run for fifteen thousand years, through the relations, home.