Adult Year 2 · Semester 3 — Values, ethics, and service
Four lessons for this semester. When you are ready, take the test for this semester.
Lesson 1: Respect for all relations and generosity as ethics
Year Two's values semester opens with the covenant's two foundational virtues in their ethical depth: respect for all relations, and generosity — the pair from which the whole Indigenous moral system unfolds, taken now at the adult level as the nations' teachers state them. Respect first, in its exact sense. The respect of the foundations — minaadendamowin and its cognates — is not politeness and not tolerance: it is the practiced recognition that every being in the circle is a person with its own standing, its own gift, and its own claim on one's conduct — a recognition that issues, as the foundations taught, in protocols: the offering before the taking, the permission asked of the place, the greeting of the relations at the day's beginning, the restraint in the harvest, the thanks in the using. As an ethic for human society, the same recognition assigns every person their standing before their usefulness: the elder's authority is the respect's institutional form, the child's protection its first charge, the stranger's guest-right its extension, and the enemy's humanity — the Great Law's combing of Tadodaho being the respect's supreme case — its proof under load. The school's formulation for the adult student is the teachers': respect is the covenant's metaphysics become manners — the doctrine that the world is persons, practiced as the habit of treating it so — and its opposite is not rudeness but the object-world's founding act: the treatment of a person, a place, an animal, a river, as a thing, from which every other wrong in the system's catalogue follows as the applications follow the axiom.
Generosity is respect's active form, and the lesson gives it its full economics. The giveaway of the celebrations is the virtue's ceremony; its ethics are the year's round: the hunter's first kill given away entire, in the old rule; the successful household's store open to the kin by the kinship's standing claim; the chief's greatness measured, in the nations' immemorial formula, by what he has given — the poorest chief being, in the plains' proverb, the one whose people are hungry, and the richest man in the camp being, by the same accounting, the one with nothing left because he has given it all and stands, therefore, owed by everyone and owned by no one. The school's analysis of the system's logic is the economists' as well as the elders': the giveaway economy is a banking system in a world without vaults — the surplus converted, at the feast, into the only currency that does not rot: obligation, honor, and the memory of the fed — so that the generous person's wealth is stored in the people's bodies and stories, retrievable in his own bad year from a hundred hearths, the interest paid in the coin of the standing that no market in the building's other rooms can purchase. The ethic's edge, for the modern student, is its judgment on the accumulation the surrounding world calls prudence: the hoard is the system's one unforgivable posture — the Raven story's chief with his boxes being the coast's eternal portrait of it — not because wealth is evil but because the unshared surplus is a relation refused, a theft from the circle that produced it, the corn rotting in one lodge while the relatives hunger being the southeast's definition of the only sin the busk's amnesty could not always reach.
The two virtues together are the lesson's third subject, as the system's root and branch. Respect without generosity is sentiment — the relations acknowledged and unfed; generosity without respect is the potlatch of vanity — the giving that humiliates, the charity that keeps the giver above the gift — and the system's discipline joins them exactly: the gift given as to a person, with the protocols, in the order of the relations, the receiver honored as the gift's completer, since in the covenant's grammar the one who accepts completes the circuit and does the giver the greater service — the doctrine by which the nations' poor are never, in their own houses, the objects of pity: the elder receiving the first salmon is not being helped; she is performing her office in the economy of the relations, which is to be honored first, and the young hunter's giving is his privilege and not her dependence. The school's student should mark the completeness of the inversion this works on the surrounding world's charity: in the covenant's ethics, the flow of goods follows the flow of honor, and both flow toward the elders, the children, the guests, and the dead — the system's whole distribution being, in the end, the metaphysics of the first lesson drawn as an economy: all my relations, fed in their order, as the form respect takes when it is given hands.
The lesson's last word weighs the two virtues as the covenant's exportable core — the part of the system the nations themselves offer, in their public teaching, to the world's students as practice, not merely as study. Respect and generosity are, of all the course's matter, the least enclosed: the ceremonies are the nations'; the virtues are urged on everyone, the elders' public teaching being unambiguous that the world's present disorders are, in their diagnosis, the hoard and the object-world at the scale of the planet, and the cure the covenant's own, at the scale of the student's week: treat the beings of one's own place as persons, and hold one's surplus as the circle's. The school does not soften the diagnosis's scale: the nations' ethicists are describing the climate and the market in the grammar of the giveaway, and their prescription is not a metaphor. The values proceed from the root pair to their guardians: bravery and wisdom, the elders' paired virtues, by which the relations are defended in the crisis and governed in the calm.
Lesson 2: Bravery and wisdom from elders as ethics
The second values lesson takes the covenant's paired guardian virtues: bravery and wisdom — the virtues of the crisis and of the calm — as the nations' ethics state them, with the elders as wisdom's address and bravery's school. Bravery first, in its Indigenous register, which differs instructively from the warrior stereotype the surrounding culture sells. The nations' bravery is not fearlessness and not aggression: the plains' highest martial honor was counting coup — touching the armed enemy and escaping, the deed that proved the warrior's nerve while sparing the enemy's life — the honor economy of the old warfare ranking the touch above the kill, the rescue of a comrade above both, and the giveaway of the captured horses above the keeping of them. The ethic inside the honors is the school's subject: bravery, in the covenant's definition, is the governance of fear in the service of the relations — the hunter's patience in the cold, the mother's endurance, the speaker's truth in the council where the truth is unwelcome, the chief's refusal of the popular war — the virtue being, in the elders' teaching, available in every station and required in all of them, its battlefield being as often the sickroom, the council fire, and the family's hard year as the warpath. The school's comparative note is owed: the building's rooms all distinguish the soldier's courage from the martyr's and the citizen's; the nations' distinction is drawn by the coup stick's logic — the bravest act is the one that risks the self while sparing the other — a standard under which the rescue outranks the raid and the peace chief's stand against his own young men may be the bravest act in the nation's annals, as in the record it sometimes was.
Wisdom is bravery's governor, and its address is the lesson's second subject: the elders. Wisdom, in the covenant's account, is not intelligence and not information: it is the knowledge that has been lived long enough to know its own limits — the elder's qualification being not the years themselves but the years attended to, the experience digested in the presence of the relations and the stories, until the person becomes what the nations' offices recognize: a keeper of the precedents, a reader of the signs, a person whose counsel is a public utility. The school's account of the office's mechanics follows the foundations: the elder is consulted because the archive is consulted — the precedents for the drought, the feud, the treaty, the child's trouble are in the elder's memory or nowhere — and the consultation's form is the ethic's form: the gift brought, the question put once and not pressed, the answer received in its own time and genre, the story that answers obliquely being not evasion but precision, the elder's indirection delivering the counsel at the depth the direct answer could not reach. The modern recovery has restored the office's institutions — the elders' councils advising the tribal governments, the elders-in-residence of the schools, the sentencing circles' elder at the offender's side — the state's own systems now borrowing, in their restorative programs, the office they spent a century trying to extinguish, the school recording the borrowing with its usual note: the office is the nations', and its loan to the republic's courts is the covenant's generosity, not its surrender.
The pair together are the lesson's third subject, because the ethics join them as governor and engine in a single discipline. Bravery without wisdom is Coyote — the energy that made death final by arguing before he had grieved; wisdom without bravery is the counsel hoarded — the elder who will not speak the hard precedent in the council where it costs. The nations' formation joins them in the biography the elders prescribe: the young are given the brave acts to do — the fast, the vigil, the service, the war's or the work's dangers — under the elders' direction, so that the nerve is trained while the judgment is borrowed, and the middle years convert the borrowed judgment, by the digestion of the brave acts' consequences, into the person's own wisdom — the elder being, in the formula the school adopts, a brave person whose fear has been educated by everything it survived. The school's student should mark the formation's difference from the surrounding world's: the modern order trains the nerve and the judgment in separate institutions — the gym and the seminar — and wonders at their divorce in the graduates; the covenant trains them in one biography, under one council of relations, toward one office, and its product is the person the nations' introductions honor with the title the whole system works to make common: a good relative — the phrase being, in the elders' usage, the highest ethical commendation the language holds, superior to 'a good person' precisely in its grammar: goodness as a relation kept, not a quality possessed.
The lesson's last word sets the pair in the modern student's reach, as the ethics lessons do. The student cannot borrow the nations' elders — they are not his — but the virtues' discipline is the same one the nations' public teaching commends to all: do the brave acts under direction while the judgment ripens; consult the long memories of one's own house before the loud novelties of the moment; rank the rescue above the victory and the truth-telling in council above the comfort of the consensus; and measure the life, at its end, by the title the system awards — not the bravest, not the wisest, but the good relative, whose nerve and whose counsel were both, their whole length, at the relations' service. The values proceed from the guardians to the tempering virtue: humility — the covenant's check on every other virtue's pride — joined, in the brief's pairing, with the seventh generation, the humility that thinks forward a hundred and fifty years because it knows its own sight is short.
Lesson 3: Humility and thinking of the seventh generation as ethics
The third values lesson joins the brief's final pair: humility, and the thinking of the seventh generation — the covenant's tempering virtue and its longest law — taken together because, in the nations' ethics, they are one discipline seen from two ends: the self made small in the present, so that the future's persons may be large in one's counsels. Humility first, in its Indigenous register. The covenant's humility is not self-abasement and not the denial of one's gifts: the great hunter's skill and the great speaker's tongue are the relations' property held in trust, and the humility is the trustee's posture — the skills acknowledged as gifts, credited to the givers (the teachers, the animals, the Creator), and exercised without the one posture the system cannot use: the self as the center of the account. Its forms are the etiquette the student has met throughout: the speaker who begins by disclaiming his worthiness to speak; the chief who serves the feast and eats last; the artist who attributes the pattern to her grandmother; the hunter who thanks the deer — the whole grammar of a world in which the ego's inflation is not a foible but a structural danger, the hoard's first cell and the feud's first spark. The school's analysis is the ethicists': in a system where every good is a relation's gift, pride is a bookkeeping error — the crediting of the gift to the holder — and humility is simply accuracy, the ledger kept honestly; the nations' humble person is not thinking less of himself but thinking of himself, exactly, as what he is: a node in the web, gifted and owing, whose distinction is real and whose source is not himself.
The seventh generation is humility projected in time, and the lesson gives the law its full statement, as the foundations introduced it and the Haudenosaunee law carries it. The chiefs, in the Great Law's charge, are to deliberate with the faces of the coming generations before them — in the common rendering, the seventh generation ahead — the unborn holding, in the council's imagination, a seat and a claim: the decision is lawful only if it can be justified to the faces. The school's account of the law's mechanics is the practitioners': it is not a prediction exercise — no one at the fire claims to know the seventh generation's world — it is a discipline of regard: the decision-maker must look at the river, the forest, the language, the treaty right, through the eyes of the descendant for whom it is the whole inheritance, and must answer, in the council, the descendant's one question: did you keep it? The law's modern career — its entry into the environmental vocabulary of the whole continent, its citation in the courts and the constitutions-in-drafting of the climate age — is the recovery's most visible export, and the nations' ethicists receive it with the mixture the school records: pride in the teaching's reach, and the standing correction that the phrase is a discipline and not a slogan — the seventh generation being not a poster but a practice, kept or broken in the particular decisions of the particular councils, including the ones about the mine, the dam, and the lease, where the law's price is counted in the present's money and its keeping is therefore, as the nations' own debates show, an argument and not an ornament.
The pair together are the lesson's third subject, as the covenant's constitution for the ego and for time. Humility answers the question of the self's size; the seventh generation answers the question of the self's span — and the surrounding world's twin disorders are, in the nations' diagnosis, the pair's twin absences: the ego enlarged to the cosmos's center in the present, and the future shrunk to the quarter's returns in the counsels — the hoard in space and the hoard in time, the boxes of Raven's chief stacked now along the years as well as across the room. The school's student should weigh the diagnosis's fairness as the ethicists state it: the climate is the seventh generation's subject exactly; the descendant's question — did you keep it? — is the one the present's councils, in every capital, are structured not to hear; and the nations' law is offered, in their public teaching, not as an antiquity but as the missing article in the world's constitutions, available to any council willing to seat the unborn. The offer's terms are the covenant's usual ones: the law is a practice, not a phrase; it is kept in the decisions or it is not kept at all; and its keeper must begin where the pair begins, in the humility that knows the present's sight is short — the law being, in the school's formulation, humility with a calendar.
The lesson's last word is the school's weighing of the pair as the values semester's center of gravity. Respect and generosity govern the circle's present; bravery and wisdom govern its crises; humility and the seventh generation govern its duration — the virtues by which a covenant outlives its makers, which is the only test the nations' history sets: the teaching was kept through the catastrophe not by the bravest generation or the richest but by the humblest in the system's exact sense — the grandmothers who credited the gift to its givers and kept it for the faces they would never see, the seventh generation being, in the event, themselves: the unborn for whom the councils of 1750 deliberated are the elders of the present recovery, and the law's proof is that the faces arrived and found the river, the language, and the fire — diminished, defended, and kept. The values close with the virtues' issue: service — the charity and the justice in which the whole system, like every system in the building, finally spends itself on the world beyond its own fire.
Lesson 4: Service, charity, and justice in Primal Indigenous
The values semester and Year Two's teaching close with the covenant's outward issue: service, charity, and justice — the forms in which the primal Indigenous ethics spend themselves beyond the nation's own fire, and the nation's own account of what it owes, and is owed by, the world around it. Service first, in its internal form, because the covenant's charity begins — as every room's charity begins — at home, in the institutions the course has built: the kinship's standing claim on the successful; the clan's and the moiety's appointed service of the bereaved; the giveaway's redistribution; the elders' and children's first place at the feast — a welfare system, as the values have shown, without an office, administered by the relations as a function of their existence. Its modern forms extend the same grammar into the recovery's institutions: the tribal governments' services — the housing, the clinics, the elder meals, the language nests — funded by the nations' enterprises and governed as the nation's care for its own, in the idiom the system has always used: not clients but relatives, the tribal service office's client being somebody's grandchild, in the small world's accounting, and known to be. The school's note on the internal service is its completeness as an ethic: the covenant does not distinguish the charity from the structure — there is no separate virtue of giving laid over the kinship; the kinship is the giving, structured — and the modern student's first lesson from it is the one the nations' teachers state to the welfare debates of the surrounding republics: a people does not have a welfare problem where it has a working kinship, and the repair of the kinship is therefore the first social policy, before the programs that substitute for it.
Charity outward is the lesson's second subject: the nations' giving beyond their own fire, in the record's instances. The guest-right of the foundations extends to the stranger at the camp's edge as a matter of the system's honor; the diplomacy of the covenant chain fed and sheltered the nations' allies as its ordinary cost; and the modern record carries the pattern at its most instructive scale in the disaster reliefs: the tribal nations' convoys to the hurricane coasts, the Navajo Nation's water and supplies sent to the cities in the pandemic's first spring, the Standing Rock camp's kitchen feeding, at the resistance's height, a small city of the nations' guests — the water protectors' camp being, in the school's reading, the giveaway at its largest modern scale: a nation's hearth opened to the continent, the visitors fed in their thousands by the relations' economy, the whole funded by the donations the camp's example drew from the world's households. The school's analysis of the outward charity is the ethicists': the nations give outward from the same root as inward — the circle of the relations does not end at the nation's border because it never was a border; it is a gradient — and the stranger's claim is real though lesser, graded by the relations' order, and discharged, characteristically, in food and shelter and presence rather than in money at a distance, the covenant's charity being incurably personal in an age of the transfer.
Justice is the lesson's third subject, and it is the covenant's hardest word in the modern world, because the nation's account of justice runs in both directions: the justice it practices and the justice it is owed. The justice practiced is the restorative order the course has met: the peacemaking and the sentencing circles, the clan's rebalancing, the Great Law's condolence — justice as the relations repaired, the offender restored, the victim's grief lifted, the whole aimed at the community's wholeness rather than the offender's pain — the order the republic's restorative programs now borrow. The justice owed is the record the history semester kept: the treaties' plain words, the land's taking, the schools' graves, the objects in the museums — and the nation's present claims are stated, in its own forums, in the covenant's own grammar, which the school reports exactly: the claim is not vengeance and it is not, in the first instance, money; it is the keeping of the word — the treaties honored as the belts record them, the ancestors and the objects come home, the languages funded as the debt's smallest installment, the jurisdiction respected — justice, in the nation's formulation, being the surrounding republics' admission into the covenant's own first virtue: respect, practiced at the scale of states, as the keeping of the promises made to the relations. The school's judgment on the claim's standing is its record's: it is argued, in the courts and the councils, by the nation's lawyers and elders in the nation's own terms, and it is — the history's evidence being what it is — the oldest unpaid account on the continent, presented, with a patience the record honors, by the continent's most patient creditors.
The lesson's last word, and the values semester's, is the school's summary of the covenant's ethics entire, as Year Two's course completes its survey. Respect names the world; generosity moves its goods; bravery and wisdom guard it; humility and the seventh generation extend it in worth and in time; and service and justice spend it — inward as the kinship's structure, outward as the stranger's welcome, and upward, as it were, as the demand that the world's powers keep their word as the nations have kept theirs. It is, the school submits, the most complete ethic in the building that was never written as an ethic: no commandments were carved, no treatise composed — the whole system is a practice, a calendar, a seating chart, and a story cycle, from which the ethicists of the nations now draw, for the world's students, the propositions this semester has stated. The course's last semester turns from the conscience to the country: the sacred mountain and the river, the longhouse and the powwow grounds, the arts in which the covenant sees itself — and the road ahead, on which the oldest teaching on the continent walks, in the present tense, into the continent's future as its senior partner and its standing reminder of how long a kept covenant can last.