Minister Destiny Marie Morgan Ministries, Inc.

Minister Destiny Testimony Schools

District: AWAKENING

Ministry name: Primal Indigenous

Lessons — Adult Year 1, Semester 3

Adult Year 1 · Semester 3 — Texts and teachings

Four lessons for this semester. When you are ready, take the test for this semester.

Lesson 1: Oral traditions — winter counts and wampum belts: a guided overview

The texts semester opens with the continent's scriptures, which are carried in memory and in objects: the oral traditions in their North American forms, and the two great mnemonic instruments the brief names — the winter counts and the wampum belts — by which the plains and the woodlands nations wrote without letters. The winter count first, in its form and its use. A winter count — waníyetu iyáwapi, in the Lakota — is a pictographic calendar of a band's years, kept by a designated keeper on a hide or a cloth: one image for each year, chosen by the council of the elders to name the year by its most memorable event — the year the stars fell (1833, the Leonid storm, in count after count), the year of the deep snow, the year of the peace, the year the smallpox came. The count is not read as a book is read; it is recited from — the keeper touching each image in order and unfolding the year it holds, the whole band's history delivered in an evening's telling, the images serving as the archive's index to a text that lives, as the primal archive always lives, in the trained memory. The school's student should grasp the instrument's elegance: it stores a century in a blanket, it cannot be read by an enemy who captures it, and its keeper is not an owner but an officer — the count passing, at his death, to the successor trained in its recitations, the band's constitution providing, in the count's custody, for the continuity of its own memory as carefully as any state's archive law.

The wampum belt is the woodlands' counterpart and the lesson's second text. Wampum — the purple and white beads of the quahog and whelk shells, drilled and strung and woven into belts — was the Haudenosaunee and their neighbors' instrument of record: the belt given at the council embodies the words spoken, its patterns encoding the treaty's terms, the alliance's renewal, the condolence's message, so that the belt is not a decoration on the agreement but the agreement's body, without which the words are wind. The belts are read by their trained readers — the wampum keepers, whose office survives at Onondaga, the confederacy's capital, where the belts of the Great Law and the treaties are still kept and still read on the occasions the law prescribes. The Two Row Wampum of 1613 — the Guswenta, two purple rows on the white, the Dutch ship and the Haudenosaunee canoe traveling the same river side by side, neither steering the other — is the belt the world's diplomats now cite as the first treaty between the nations and the Europeans, and its doctrine is the text's whole content in one pattern: coexistence without absorption, the covenant as a relation between vessels that remain distinct. The school's handling of the belts follows its rule for all the continent's texts: they are described from the nations' published teaching; they are not the student's to handle, to copy for craft, or to treat as art objects, the belts in the museums being, in their keepers' standing account, documents on loan from a government that still exists.

The oral tradition around the instruments is the overview's third subject, because the count and the belt are the archive's indexes and not the archive. The archive is the telling: the winter's nights of the history lesson, the council's recitations, the naming ceremonies where the genealogy is spoken whole — a body of story, song, law, and instruction whose transmission the texts of the companion course described in its general form and whose North American particulars include the continent's own instruments of fidelity: the requirement, in the Haudenosaunee council, that the speaker hold the wampum as he speaks, the words witnessed by the belt; the plains' practice of the public crier and the camp's heralds, by which the council's decisions entered every lodge's memory the same night; the song that belongs to the story and cannot be separated from it, the melody as the checksum of the words. The school's comparative note sets the instruments in the building: the scroll fixes the text in letters; the count and the belt fix it in images and patterns that only the trained memory can voice — a writing that cannot be read by the uninitiated being, in a world of enemies and confiscations, not a defect of the technology but one of its features, as the nations' survival of the archive through the banning centuries demonstrates in the only laboratory that matters.

The overview's last word places the continent's texts among the building's scriptures by their use, as the guided overviews do. The Torah is read to be obeyed; the Eddas, to be remembered; the oral archive of the primal world, to be told; the winter count is kept to be recited from, and the belt to be held while the words are spoken — texts whose ideal custodian is not a reader but a keeper, whose office is a public trust, and whose loss is therefore not a library fire but a death in office without a successor. The school leaves the student in the council house with the belt in the keeper's hands, and turns to the greatest of the texts the belts embody: the Great Law of Peace itself, the constitution the Peacemaker gave the nations, which is at once this continent's scripture, its law, and its longest-running political achievement.

Lesson 2: The Great Law of Peace of the Haudenosaunee: a guided overview

The second text is the continent's constitution and this school's most remarkable document: the Great Law of Peace — Kaianere'kó:wa — of the Haudenosaunee, the confederacy of the Mohawk, Oneida, Onondaga, Cayuga, Seneca, and later the Tuscarora, whose union under the Peacemaker's law predates the European arrival by, in the nations' reckoning and the scholars' contested estimates, somewhere between the twelfth and the fifteenth centuries, and whose council fire at Onondaga burns to this day. The founding first, in the nations' telling, as their teachers publish it. In the time of the feuding — when the five nations warred on each other in the cycle of the blood feud and the sorcerers' terror — came Deganawida, the Peacemaker, a man of peace born among the Hurons, and with him the Onondaga chief Hiawatha — not the figure of the poet Longfellow's romance, from whom the school distinguishes him at once — who, broken by the loss of his daughters to the feud, was met by the Peacemaker and became his voice, the Peacemaker's own speech being, in the telling, impeded. Together they carried the Great Peace from nation to nation: the weapons buried beneath the Great Tree of Peace, whose white roots run to the four directions for any nation to follow to shelter; the feuds ended by the Condolence, the ceremony that lifts the grief that drives the vengeance — Hiawatha's own grief being the first consoled, the strings of wampum of the Condolence being, in the tradition, the first wampum made, fashioned from the shells of the lake shore in his mourning. And they converted, last and hardest, the Onondaga sorcerer Tadodaho, whose hair was snakes and whose body was twisted by his evil — the Peacemaker and Hiawatha combing the snakes from his hair in the ceremony the confederacy still performs at every chief's raising, Tadodaho becoming, converted, the keeper of the council fire and the first of the fifty chiefs: the law's final doctrine in its founding act, that the worst enemy is not destroyed but condoled, combed straight, and given the fire to keep.

The Law's provisions, in guided outline, are the overview's second subject, read from the versions the Haudenosaunee publish. The confederacy is a longhouse in its constitution's own figure: the five nations as the fires of one household under one roof, the Mohawk and Seneca as the elder brothers, the Oneida and Cayuga as the younger, the Onondaga as the firekeepers and the wampum's custodians. Fifty chiefs — rotiyaner — sit in the Grand Council, their titles perpetual and their succession in the gift of the clan mothers, the women of the matrilineal clans who nominate the chiefs, hold their titles, and may depose — 'dehorn' — the chief who fails the law, a provision the world's constitutional historians note with the attention it deserves: the franchise of the matrons is older, in continuous operation, than any parliament's. The council decides by the Great Law's procedure: the matter passing from the elder brothers to the younger to the firekeepers, deliberated until the one mind is reached — unanimity being the law's requirement, the 'one dish with one spoon' of the treaties' later figure — and the law's whole spirit is stated in its name: it is a law of peace, whose weapons are buried, whose instrument is condolence, and whose foreign policy is the extension of the peace by adoption and alliance, the roots of the Tree running outward for the nations who will take shelter in the law's shade. The seventh generation's counsel of the foundations is this law's deliberative rule, and the clan mothers' custody of the titles is its guardianship: a constitution in which the future and the mothers hold, between them, the veto on the present's passions.

The Law's career in the world is the overview's third subject. The confederacy it made endured as a sovereign power for three centuries of the colonial age, playing the empires against each other from the strength of its union; its forms impressed the colonists who dealt with it — the Albany Plan and the federal idea itself carrying, in the judgment argued by the historians and acknowledged by the United States Congress in 1988, the confederacy's contribution to the republic's own constitution, an acknowledgment the school records with its standing care: the influence is debated in its degree and is, in its existence, the consensus of the record's fair readers. The Law endured its own catastrophe: the Sullivan campaign's burning of the towns in 1779, the land takings, the boarding schools, the Indian Act's and the Dawes Act's assaults on the clan system itself — and it endures still, the Grand Council sitting at Onondaga under the law's own succession, the clan mothers raising and dehorning the chiefs, the Condolence performed at every raising as the Peacemaker performed it for Hiawatha. The school's student should mark what that endurance means in the building's terms: the Great Law is the oldest continuously operating constitution in the school's whole keeping — older than the republic that surrounds it by centuries, carried not in a document but in the wampum, the ceremony, and the council's memory — the oral archive's supreme vindication, standing in the present tense.

The overview's last word sets the Great Law among the building's texts by its nature, which is singular. The Torah is a law given by God to a people; the Great Law is a peace made by a prophet among peoples — a constitution whose scripture is a ceremony, whose archive is a belt, whose supreme court is a condolence, and whose first article, in effect, is that grief is the root of war and must be lifted before any other business can be done. The school submits that a student who understands the combing of Tadodaho's hair understands the deepest political teaching in this course: that the enemy's crookedness is straightened, not avenged; that the fire is given to the converted sorcerer to keep; and that a law so founded has, in the event, outlasted every empire that was founded on the opposite. The texts proceed from the Law to the archive's modern vessels: the recorded teachings of the elders and the language books, in which the nations are now writing down, on their own terms, what the fire kept.

Lesson 3: Recorded elder teachings and language books: a guided overview

The third text of the semester is the archive's new vessel: the recorded teachings of the elders and the language books — the body of print, audio, and film in which the nations, in the last half-century, have set down their traditions on their own terms, for their own grandchildren first and for the world's students second. The overview begins with the distinction that governs the whole shelf: these are not the ethnographers' books about the nations, of which the academies have libraries; they are the nations' books by themselves — the elder teachings transcribed and published under the elders' authority, the language grammars and dictionaries written by the nations' own linguists, the story collections told by the tellers in their own names, the curricula of the immersion schools. The shelf's founding generation is the one the history lesson met: the elders who, in the 1960s and 70s, decided that the recording machine their grandparents had refused would be, in their hands, the archive's lifeboat — and who dictated, into the microphones of their own communities' projects, the teachings they judged publishable, in the full knowledge of the distinction the whole course has observed: what is for the world, what is for the nation, what is for the family, and what dies, by law, with its keeper. The school's student should understand that every item on this shelf represents a decision of that kind, made by its custodians — the shelf is not a leak in the archive but its considered publication, and it is to be read with the gratitude and the restraint that a considered gift requires.

The kinds are the overview's second subject. The elder teachings proper: the dictated autobiographies and the teaching cycles — the Lakota elders' accounts of the sacred ways, the Navajo elders' tellings of the history and the ceremonies' meanings, the Inuit elders' land-knowledge recorded in the place-names projects that are at once atlases, histories, and title deeds — in which the old people's voices carry, even in print, the fire's cadence and the pedagogy's grading, the published teaching being the surface of a depth the reader is told, in the elders' own prefaces, that he is not being given. The language books: the grammars and the dictionaries, from the nineteenth century's missionary compilations — used now, in the record's irony, by the nations' own revival schools against the extinction the missions' century intended — to the modern nations' own linguistic institutes, whose dictionaries of languages with a handful of first-language elders left are being written at the speed of an emergency service, the linguists racing the calendar the history recorded. And the children's shelf, which the school counts the most consequential of all: the picture books in the languages, the stories retold for the immersion classroom, the whole apparatus by which the archive is being re-housed in the generation for whom it was kept — the immersion graduate reading to her own child, in the tongue, from a book her nation's press printed, the story her great-grandmother told in a kitchen the schools were built to empty.

The interpretation of the new vessels is the overview's third subject, because the vessel changes the teaching in ways the nations themselves debate, in print, with their usual frankness. The written teaching can be read by the unready and the unentitled — the graded disclosure's old dilemma in its sharpest form — and the nations' answers divide by item and by house: this teaching published entire, this one published in its surface, this one kept in the memory only, the decisions recorded in the books' own front matter as the custodians' standing instructions to their readers. The recorded voice can be heard after the elder's death — the grief and the gift of it debated in the communities where the dead's voices are, in the traditions' own doctrines, presences not to be summoned lightly — the protocols for the archives' listening being among the new vessels' most carefully drawn rules. And the printed language can standardize what the oral language kept various — the dialect of the next valley flattened into the textbook's norm — a cost the linguists name and accept, in the emergency's arithmetic, as the price of the language's survival at all. The school's judgment on the whole debate is its standing one: it is the nations' debate, conducted by the archive's owners about their own property, and the student's office is to learn its terms, not to settle it.

The overview's last word places the new vessels among the building's texts by their direction of travel, which is the opposite of every other shelf in the building. The scrolls and the printed canons of the other rooms traveled outward — from the temple to the world, the text proselytizing as it spread. The nations' books travel inward: written in the languages, published by the nations' presses, aimed at the nations' children, with the world's students admitted as guests to a family publication — a literature whose first edition is a homecoming. The school leaves the student at that shelf with its etiquette in his hands: read what is published with thanks, cite it by its people's name, buy it from the nations' own presses where you can — the royalty being the archive's newest form of the old reciprocity — and never mistake the published surface for the whole of a tradition whose depths remain, by its custodians' law, where they have always been: in the keeping of the people, at the fire, in the language, on the land. The texts semester closes with the present: how the nations' teachings are interpreted and studied now — by the nations' scholars, by the academies that came late to listen, and by the student, whose whole study is itself one of the interpretations.

Lesson 4: Interpretation and study today

The texts semester closes in the present tense: how the Indigenous teachings are interpreted and studied now — by the nations' own scholars, by the academies, and by the ordinary student — in the field where the politics of reading are, as the primal course found, the sharpest in the building, because the texts are living nations and the reading has consequences for the read. The nations' interpretation first, in its sovereignty. The interpretive office belongs, by the nations' own law, to the nations: the wampum is read by its keepers, the winter count by its officer, the Great Law by the council it constitutes, the stories by the elders who hold them — and the new scholarship of the Native intellectuals is the extension of that office into the academy's forms, not its surrender to them. Its founding text for the modern field is Vine Deloria Jr.'s God Is Red (1973), which set the nations' religious case — land against time, place against history, the covenant against the creed — before the republic in its own philosophical idiom, and its present flowering is the Indigenous studies of the universities, where the nations' scholars read the archive with the academy's tools and the fire's authority in both hands, and where the first interpretive rule is the one this whole course has practiced: the tradition means what its custodians say it means, in its own categories, and the frameworks of the outside — religion, myth, folklore, even 'spirituality' — are tools to be used where they serve and refused where they deform.

The academies' interpretation is the lesson's second subject, and its present state is the ladder's ruin built upon. Anthropology has completed, in its better part, the turn the primal course recorded: the ethnography written with the nations, the archives repatriated in digital form under the nations' protocols, the discipline's own history taught to its students as a caution. The legal academy has become an interpreter of consequence: the treaty texts read, in the courts' best moments, by the standard the nations have always demanded — as the nations understood them, in the councils where they were made — a hermeneutic with land and fish and jurisdiction riding on it, in which the wampum's reading is not an antiquarian exercise but a live act of constitutional interpretation, the Two Row's doctrine argued in the briefs. And the wider culture's interpretation — the school curricula, the museums' new labels, the land acknowledgments — is the nations' teaching entering the continent's common memory under the nations' own editorship, slowly and against resistance, in the form the recovery intends. The school's student should note the pattern that unifies the three: in every arena, the interpretive authority is moving, by law and by scholarship and by courtesy, in one direction — from the describers to the described — and the movement is the single largest fact in the modern study of these traditions.

The ordinary student's interpretation is the lesson's third subject, and its rule is the semester's keepsake, stated here in its North American form. The teachings that the nations publish are given to be learned from; the ceremonies that the nations close are closed, and the student's absence from them is not a deprivation but a datum — the boundary is itself part of the teaching, the nations' way of instructing the world in the difference between a gift and a commodity. The student who honors the boundary learns the second lesson the boundary teaches: that a tradition which can say no to the world's curiosity is a tradition in possession of itself, and that the world's curiosity, schooled by the refusal, becomes the better instrument the nations actually need — an informed respect that votes, that testifies, that buys the nations' books and returns the nations' objects and argues the nations' treaties in the common councils of the continent. The school's formulation for the student's shelf is the custodians' own, rendered once: learn about, never take from; credit the nation, not 'Native wisdom,' for every teaching you repeat — the generic Indian being, in the nations' standing complaint, the final form of the theft, in which the particular peoples disappear into a mist of available spirituality at the exact moment their particular rights are being argued in the particular courts.

The lesson's last word, and the texts semester's, returns to the school's standing question: what do these texts ask of the person who studies them? The scroll asks obedience, the shelf transformation, the primal archive custody — and the continent's texts ask allegiance of a specific and limited kind: not belief, not membership, but the student's standing, as a citizen of the continent the nations' covenants describe, on the side of the covenants' keeping — the treaties honored, the languages funded, the objects returned, the boundaries respected — the study's fruit being not an experience but a position. It is, the school submits, the most civic demand any room in the building makes of its students, and the one most exactly proportioned to the history the student has learned: the nations do not ask the continent to become them; they ask it to keep its word, which the belts record. The student leaves the texts with the belt in the keeper's hands and the count on its hide, and the practice semester now enters the life those texts carry: the smudge's smoke and the sweat's heat, the drum at the powwow and the household's round — the covenant as it is kept, in the body and in the week, by the peoples whose it is.

Back to all lessons · Take this semester’s test