Adult Year 1 · Semester 2 — History
Four lessons for this semester. When you are ready, take the test for this semester.
Lesson 1: The origins of Primal Faith
The history semester opens with the origins — which is to say, with the origins of religion itself, as far as the evidence reaches. The school's first precision is the record's own: primal faith has no founder and no founding century because it is not an invention but an inheritance — the religious life of humankind before writing, before cities, before the building's every other room — and its 'origins' are therefore the subject of archaeology and inference rather than of chronicle. The evidence, in its order: the burials — the Neanderthal graves of a hundred thousand years ago with their posed dead and their grave goods, the early modern humans at Qafzeh and Skhul buried with ochre and shells, testifying that the dead were accompanied, in the survivors' minds, somewhere; the red ochre itself, the blood-colored pigment ground and used across Africa for a hundred millennia, in what looks like ritual's first material; the painted caves — Chauvet's lions and horses of thirty-six thousand years ago, Sulawesi's still older pigs, Lascaux and Altamira — images made in dark and difficult places for no domestic purpose anyone has proposed, by artists whose mastery is not in question; the carved figures, the Lion-Man of Hohlenstein-Stadel at forty thousand years, part human and part beast, the oldest unambiguous evidence of a being that does not exist in nature and therefore of the imagination that peoples the world with spirits; the standing stones and the earthen mounds of the farming millennia that follow. The school's reading of the record follows its method: what these things prove is behavior — the dead accompanied, the caves painted, the therianthrope imagined — and the beliefs behind the behavior are reconstructed, by analogy with the living primal peoples whom the rest of the record concerns, with a confidence that decreases, honestly, with every millennium of distance.
The living traditions' own antiquity is the lesson's second subject, because the primal peoples are not the past — they are its heirs, and the line between the painted cave and the present ceremony is a line of custody, not of extinction. Aboriginal Australian traditions claim, and the archaeology of their occupation supports, a custody of country running past fifty thousand years — the oldest continuous cultural tradition on earth by any measure — their Dreaming neither a survival in amber nor a modern invention but a living law that has absorbed, in its time, ice ages and sea-rises and recorded them, in the judgment of the researchers who have checked the coastal stories against the drowned landscapes, with a fidelity that staggers the literate imagination. The San of the Kalahari, whose rock art fills the southern African ranges and whose trance dance the ethnographers have documented as the living context of the paintings' interpretation, carry a tradition whose roots the geneticists reckon among the deepest of any people's. The school's point is the building's recurring one, here at its maximum: continuity is a claim to be examined people by people — and where it is real, as in Australia, it is the single most impressive fact in the religious history of the species: a library kept alight, without writing, across a span in which every empire of the book rose and fell and rose again unrecorded by it.
The naming and the study of the primal world by outsiders is the lesson's third subject, because the history of the description is part of the history. The ancient empires met the primal peoples at their borders and described them as the center always describes the margin — Herodotus's marvels, Rome's barbarians. The age of exploration carried the descriptions worldwide and weaponized them: the peoples without the book were read as peoples without religion — the judgment that licensed, in law, the taking of their lands as vacant of true possession — and the nineteenth century's new science of religion arranged the world's faiths on a ladder with the primal at its foot: Tylor's animism as religion's minimum definition and first stage, Frazer's magic ripening into religion ripening into science, the whole scheme flattering its makers by placing them at the top. The twentieth century dismantled the ladder: the anthropologists who lived in the primal houses — Evans-Pritchard among the Azande and the Nuer, whose witchcraft and whose God proved as logical and as lofty, respectively, as any in the building — reported systems that the ladder could not hold, and the discipline's verdict settled where this school stands: the primal traditions are not religion's childhood but its longest adulthood, the form in which the species has done most of its religious living. The ladder's ghost walks still — in the word 'primitive' discarded, in the tourist's condescension — and the course's vigilance against it is the history's first lesson applied.
The lesson's last word fixes the origins' significance for the course. To study primal faith is to study the headwaters: not a pure source — the school has no pure sources anywhere — but the condition from which the building's rivers all descend and beside which most of humankind, for most of its history, has actually lived its religious life. The student leaves the origins with the timescale corrected, which is the history's gift: the religions of the book occupy the last three thousand years of a story at least forty thousand long, and the primal traditions are not the story's preface but its main text, of which the rest is a recent and brilliant commentary. The history proceeds to the keepers of that text: the elders and the storytellers, and the community they carried through the millennia before the storms came.
Lesson 2: The elders and storytellers and the early community
The second history lesson takes up the carriers: the elders and storytellers, and the early community they held together — the human institution by which the primal world transmitted itself across the millennia. The elder first, as an office. In the primal houses, age is not a retirement but a promotion along a graded road: the child learns, the adult provides, the elder knows — and the knowing is of a specific kind, the archive's mastery: the genealogies that run a people's title back to the first ones, the stories in their exact words and their licensed variations, the ceremonies' sequences, the plants' and the places' knowledge, the precedents by which disputes are judged. The elder's authority rests on the archive and is exercised as the archive's reading: in council, where the elders deliberate until the consensus forms — the decision procedure of the primal world, slow by the clock and, in the record of its durability, among the most successful ever used; in judgment, where the precedent is a story and the sentence is its application; and in teaching, which is the office's daily work and the texts semester's subject. The school's note on the office's economics is owed: the elder is kept by the community he keeps — the best meat, the seat by the fire, the exemption from labor — a pension system whose premium is reverence and whose fund is the archive, the only retirement plan the species had for its first forty thousand years, and one whose solvency depended, exactly, on the young believing the old were worth feeding: the tradition's transmission was its social security, a fact whose modern inversion the modern-world lesson will weigh.
The storyteller is the elder's public voice, and the lesson distinguishes the craft. The stories — the myths of the first times, the trickster's cycles, the heroes' journeys, the cautionary tales — are not entertainment with a moral pasted on; they are the archive's circulating form, the law and the map and the natural history and the theology of the people carried in the one medium that survives without materials: a trained memory performing before a fire. The craft's standards are exact and are enforced by the audience, which knows the stories too: the words in their order for the sacred recitations, the licensed improvisation for the evening's tales, the voices and the gestures of the master whose performances the ethnographers' recordings preserve — sessions of hours, in the great cases of whole nights and returning nights, the epic of a people delivered by one old person's memory entire. The school's comparative note sets the craft in the building: the storyteller is the primal room's scripture, clergy, and theater in one person, and his vulnerability is the archive's: what he carries dies with him unless it has been carried into another memory — the fact that makes the initiation of the young into the stories the community's central act of self-preservation, and the fire's circle its library's reading room.
The early community, in the historians' reconstruction, is the lesson's third subject: the band and the village, the clan and the age-set — the social architecture within which the faith was a way of life rather than a department of it. Its scale was the face-to-face world: the band of dozens, the village of hundreds, the tribe of thousands bound by language and marriage and the great periodic gatherings where the ceremonies too large for one hearth were kept — the corroboree, the potlatch, the festival of the first fruits — the community assembling, like the last course's pagans at their festivals, to be for a season the whole of itself. Its economy was the gift and the obligation: the hunt shared by rule, the harvest feasted in common, the prestige of the giver measured against the shame of the hoarder — the ethic of the values semester in its institutional form. And its religion was not separable from any of it: the hunt began with the rite, the planting with the ceremony, the dispute ended at the shrine, the child was named into the ancestors' company and the dead were returned to it — the school's summary being the one the whole course assumes: in the early community, 'religion' as a separate word would have been unintelligible, the faith being not a part of the life but the life's own account of itself. It is the condition every other room in the building began from and departed from, and the primal peoples' distinction is only that many of them, alone, declined to depart.
The lesson's last word is the school's weighing of the carriers' achievement, stated plainly because the record earns it. A community of a few hundred people, without writing, metals, or the wheel in many cases, maintained — across spans beside which the building's empires are episodes — a complete civilization's operating system: its law, its medicine, its map, its history, its ethics, its arts, in the memories of its elders and the performances of its storytellers, audited nightly by the only review process the system had or needed, which was the survival of the people themselves. The student who is tempted to call such a system fragile should reckon its service record against the literate world's: the archive of the fire outlasted the libraries of Alexandria and a hundred capitals, because it was copied, every generation, into living minds that needed it to live. The history turns now to the storms: the growth that is really the record of contact and catastrophe, the changes forced and chosen, and the reforms — the word the building's courses use for a tradition's self-correction — by which the primal peoples have answered the modern world.
Lesson 3: Growth, change, and reform
The third history lesson carries the record's hard middle: what the building's courses call growth, change, and reform is, for the primal peoples, the story of contact and its catastrophes, of adaptations forced and chosen, and of the recoveries now under way. The contact first, in its general shape, because the particulars fill a library of grief. From 1492 in the Americas and across the following centuries on every continent, the primal world met the expanding empires of Europe — and the meeting's first fact was disease: the smallpox and the measles running ahead of the soldiers into populations with no immunity, killing, in the American catastrophe's worst regions, nine of every ten within generations, the archive dying with the elders faster than any army could have killed it. The second fact was dispossession: the land taken by the doctrines the origins lesson named — the vacant land, the improvement that alone made property — the peoples removed to the reserves and the missions, their ceremonies banned in law (the potlatch in Canada, the Sun Dance in the United States, the whole of Aboriginal ceremony under the protection regimes of Australia), their languages punished in the boarding schools whose motto, in the American founder's words, was to kill the Indian and save the man. The school's record states these things without varnish and without relish, as its method requires: they are the documented policy of the states concerned, most of which have now formally apologized for them, and they constitute the largest destruction of religious traditions in the building's whole history — whole libraries of the fire burned, not by time, but by intention.
The changes within the catastrophe are the lesson's second subject, because the peoples were not only victims of the record but its authors under constraint. The faiths went underground and survived as secrets: the ceremonies kept in the hills and the night, the languages whispered, the archive carried by the grandmothers whose keeping is the reason anything remains. They syncretized, as the building's faiths under pressure always do: the saints acquiring the old gods' faces in the Afro-Atlantic world the sister course studied, the peyote road becoming the Native American Church — chartered 1918, the primal sacrament defended in the new world's own legal forms — the cargo and the prophet movements of the Pacific and the plains, Handsome Lake's Longhouse religion among the Seneca joining the old ceremonies to a moral code for the new world, Wovoka's Ghost Dance of 1890 promising the ancestors' return and the buffalo — a promise the United States cavalry answered at Wounded Knee, where the school's record pauses, as it should, on the three hundred Lakota dead in the snow as the emblem of the whole encounter's cost. And they adapted their transmission: the story recorded, the language written at last in the colonizer's letters by the people's own scholars, the ceremony filmed by the elders' own decision for the grandchildren — the archive changing its medium under duress, with the argument, in every community, between the keepers of the old custody and the savers by any means, which the texts semester's heirs will recognize as the primal form of a universal dilemma.
The reforms — the recoveries — are the lesson's third subject, and they belong to the last half-century. The legal turn came first: the American Indian Religious Freedom Act of 1978, the repatriations of the ancestors' remains and the sacred objects from the museums under NAGPRA in 1990, the land settlements and the apologies, the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples of 2007 — the world's states conceding, in law, the rights whose denial the record documents. The cultural turn followed: the language nests — the Māori kōhanga reo of 1982 and the Hawaiian Pūnana Leo — raising the first fluent generations from the last fluent elders, in the movement that has become the primal world's model of resurrection; the ceremonies re-emerging into the open, the potlatch and the Sun Dance kept in daylight by the grandchildren of those who kept them in hiding; the young returning to the elders with the recorders, and the elders, in community after community, deciding what may be recorded and what remains in the memory only — the old custody reasserting itself in the new medium's terms. The school's summary judgment on the whole middle history is the one its evidence supports: the primal world was subjected to the most thorough attempt at religious extinction in the modern record, and it failed — not everywhere, and not without losses that are absolute — because the archive's medium was the people's own bodies and affections, which could be punished but not confiscated.
The lesson's last word sets the reforms in the building's frame. Every room in this school has its centuries of persecution and its recoveries; the primal peoples' are distinguished by the persecution's totality — it aimed at the transmission itself, at the children — and by the recovery's agent: not a church or a state but the families, the grandmothers' line, keeping the fire in the kitchen when it was banned in the clearing. The history closes in the present tense, where the recovery meets the newest century's terms: the land claims argued in the language of the oldest theology, the languages rising from their nests, and the question the modern world asks of the primal peoples — whether they are the past, as the ladder taught, or, as their own teachers now say in the world's forums, the future's instructors in the one subject the modern world failed: how to live in a place forever.
Lesson 4: Primal Faith in the modern world
The history semester closes in the present: the primal faiths in the modern world — their numbers, their cities, their screens, and their strange new office as the teachers of the species that displaced them. The numbers first, with the counters' caution. The world's indigenous peoples number, by the United Nations' reckoning, some 476 million in ninety countries — and the primal traditions, in their pure and their braided forms (the African traditional religions entire, the folk traditions of Asia's peoples, the Native nations' ceremonies, the Aboriginal laws), are practiced, by the demographers' estimates that must guess where the censuses blend, by hundreds of millions more: the African continent's traditionalists alone are counted in the tens of millions, and the braided practice — the ancestor fed by the church member, the diviner consulted by the professor — multiplies the count past any census's categories. The school's note is the demographers' own: the primal world is not a remnant; it is one of the great religious facts of the present earth, and its invisibility to the northern reader is a fact about the reader's media, not about the world's peoples.
The modern forms are the lesson's second subject, because the primal peoples live, now, where everyone lives: in the cities and on the screens as well as on the country. The urban reality is the majority's: the Aboriginal family in Sydney keeping the law in the suburbs' idiom, the Native professional in Phoenix driving to the ceremony on the weekend, the Yoruba tradition maintained in Havana and the Bronx in its diaspora's full splendor — the faiths proving, as the building's faiths have all proved, that the city does not kill them but edits them, the ceremony compressed to the weekend, the archive to the phone's recordings, the elder consulted by video call across the reserve's distance. The diaspora is the modern form's extreme: the traditions carried across the oceans by the enslaved and the emigrated, rebuilt in the new soils — the African diaspora's religions of the sister course, the powwow circuit's intertribal culture that the Plains nations' gatherings created and the whole of Native North America now shares, a new primal commons built, ironically, by the boarding schools' forced mixing and reclaimed as a nation's own. And the screen is the newest country: the language apps built by the young from the elders' recordings, the ceremony's calendar kept in the group chat, the storytellers' channels — the archive's third medium, after memory and print, adopted under the elders' protocols with the old argument, in every family, about what the new vessel may hold.
The new office is the lesson's third subject, and it is the modern world's most unexpected turn. The peoples the ladder placed at religion's foot now stand, in the world's forums, as the authorities on the century's central question: the land. The facts are the record's: the territories the indigenous peoples still hold — a quarter of the earth's land surface — shelter, by the conservationists' own audits, the great majority of its remaining biodiversity; the management that kept them — the fire-stick farming, the closed seasons, the sacred groves of the foundations — is studied by the ecologists as the longest-running experiment in sustainability on earth; and the doctrine that underlies it, the land as a relative under law, has entered the world's jurisprudence in the personhood of rivers and the rights of nature written into constitutions. The primal teachers at the climate summits and the interfaith tables are therefore not there as folklore: they are there as the senior practitioners of the only way of life that has never yet destroyed its own ground — an authority the school's student should weigh exactly, neither romanticizing it into the ecological sainthood the introduction warned against nor discounting it into the ladder's old contempt, but recording it as the century's judgment: on the subject of living in a place forever, the oldest teachers have the floor.
The lesson's last word, and the history semester's, is the school's summary of the arc entire. The faith that began around the first fires was pronounced dying by every century since the sixteenth — by the missionary, the administrator, the anthropologist of the ladder, and the modernizer in turn — and it has outlived every one of its obituarists, because its medium is the one the obituaries never reckoned with: not an institution that can be closed but a people's way of being a people, which ends only with the people, and the people, in the event, declined to end. The student leaves the history with the timescale of the origins restored to the present: the oldest faith on earth is also a contemporary one, argued in the courts, taught in the language nests, danced at the powwows, and consulted at the climate summits — and the course turns from its past to its scriptures, which are not written: the stories and the songs, the painted rocks, and the elders' voices, in which the whole of it is carried.