Adult Year 1 · Semester 3 — Texts and teachings
Four lessons for this semester. When you are ready, take the test for this semester.
Lesson 1: The Power of Now (Eckhart Tolle): a guided overview
The texts semester opens with the movement's most influential modern book: Eckhart Tolle's The Power of Now (1997), the guide to spiritual enlightenment whose quiet sentences carried the milieu's core teaching — presence — to the largest audience any of its texts has reached. The author and the book's birth first. Tolle (born Ulrich Tolle in Germany, 1948) was a research student at Cambridge when, at twenty-nine, in the depth of the depression and anxiety that had marked his life, he underwent the experience the book's introduction recounts: a night of unbearable self-loathing in which the thought 'I cannot live with myself any longer' split, in his attention, into the 'I' and the 'myself' it could not live with — and the self he had been dissolved, leaving a silence and a peace from which he spent two years in a kind of benumbed bliss on park benches before becoming, by slow degrees, a teacher. The Power of Now, written in Vancouver and published by a small press in 1997, spread by word of mouth until Oprah Winfrey's advocacy carried it to millions; its sequel, A New Earth (2005) — its title the movement's own promise — was the subject of a ten-week online class with Winfrey in 2008 that drew audiences counted in the millions, the largest seminar in the movement's history. The school's note on the man belongs to the overview: Tolle holds no lineage, founds no organization, sells no levels — the anti-guru of the milieu, whose teaching is a single point to which the book returns as the meditation returns to the breath.
The teaching, in guided outline, is the book's whole content and can be stated in its own architecture. The human being's suffering is made by the mind's two habits: dwelling in the past, which no longer exists, and projecting into the future, which does not exist yet — the ego, the false self built of thoughts and identifications, living in psychological time while the life itself is always and only now. 'You are not your mind,' the book's first chapter insists: the thinker is not the thoughts, and the discovery of the watcher — the awareness behind the thinking — is the awakening's beginning. Presence is the practice: attention rested in the present moment, in the body's inner field, in the senses' immediacy, until the compulsive stream of thought gaps and the stillness underneath shows itself — the book's name for the condition toward which all its question-and-answer chapters lead. Pain, in its teaching, accumulates in what Tolle calls the pain-body, the stored residue of old suffering that feeds on new unhappiness, and dissolves, like the ego, under presence's light rather than under analysis. The school's student should hear the sources in the synthesis, because Tolle states them himself: the Zen of the present moment, the Advaita of Ramana Maharshi, the Christian mystics' eternal now, the Course in Miracles' forgiveness — the perennial shelf, distilled by a teacher whose originality is the distillation's clarity, and whose Germanic plainness of style became, paradoxically, the milieu's most recognizable voice.
The book's reception and criticism complete the overview. Its readers' testimony fills its own genre: the depressed, the anxious, the bereaved reporting the park-bench peace at second hand, the book kept by the bed like the psalms of an older shelf — a function the school records without surprise, the text being engineered, in its question-and-answer form and its marked pauses, as a meditation device as much as an argument. The critics' two standing objections are given in their strength: that the teaching, taken whole, counsels a withdrawal from history and politics — the world's suffering answered by presence while the world's causes go unaddressed, a charge Tolle's defenders answer with A New Earth's doctrine that the transformed person is the world's only real reformer; and that the synthesis, for all its acknowledgment of sources, flattens the disciplines it draws from — Zen without the monastery, Advaita without the guru's years — into a technique of feeling, the milieu's characteristic transaction stated in its most successful case. The school's judgment is its standing one: the book is the movement's classic, to be read as its people read it — slowly, as a practice — and to be placed, as the historians place it, as the point where the séance century's river reached the modern mainstream's widest delta.
The overview's last word sets the book among the building's texts by its use, as the guided overviews do. The Torah is read to be obeyed, the Eddas to be remembered, the grimoire to be done; The Power of Now is read to be stopped — its ideal reader laying it down mid-page, overtaken by the presence it describes, the text succeeding exactly when it is abandoned for its subject. That is a rare ambition for a book and the measure of its author's intent: a finger pointing at the moon, in the Zen phrase Tolle would approve, whose readers' millions suggest the finger, at least, was seen. The texts proceed from the present moment to the mirror: Louise Hay's You Can Heal Your Life, the movement's other household classic, in which the healing of the foundations becomes a daily practice of affirmations addressed to the self in the glass.
Lesson 2: You Can Heal Your Life (Louise Hay): a guided overview
The second text is the movement's other household classic and its healing doctrine's breviary: Louise Hay's You Can Heal Your Life (1984) — the book of affirmations and the list of diseases and their 'probable causes' that sits, forty years on, in more bathrooms and beside more mirrors than any other volume the milieu has produced. The author first, because in this house the life is the credential. Louise Hay (1926–2017) was born in Los Angeles to poverty and an abusive childhood she recounted without varnish; she became a model in New York, married and was left, and found her way to the Church of Religious Science, whose New Thought teaching — thought is causative, the mind's patterns make the life's conditions — she studied until she became one of its practitioners, counseling clients through the connection between their beliefs and their circumstances. In the late 1970s, diagnosed with cancer, she undertook — as she told it for the rest of her life — her own healing by the method she taught: forgiveness of the past, release of resentment, affirmation and nutritional care, declining the surgery her doctors advised; the cancer, she reported, was gone within six months. The school's record must be exact at this point, as its method requires: Hay's account of her healing is her testimony, central to her teaching's authority and unverifiable in its particulars; the book's readers receive it as testimony, and the movement's responsible voices repeat the warning of the foundations — the method as complement, not substitute, for medicine. The little book that preceded the classic, Heal Your Body (1976), was her practitioner's pamphlet; the classic of 1984 made her, in her late fifties, the movement's most beloved teacher, and the publishing house she founded on its success, Hay House, became the milieu's own press — the movement, in her person, acquiring an institution at last, built by an author for authors.
The teaching, in guided outline, has three moving parts. The first is the diagnosis of the self: we are each responsible, in Hay's strong New Thought sense, for the patterns of our lives — not blamed, she insists, but empowered, since what thought made, thought can remake; the patterns were learned, mostly in childhood, from the voices around us, and their core is almost always the same sentence wearing different clothes: 'I'm not good enough.' The second part is the list — the book's famous appendix, the table of physical problems with their probable mental causes and the new thought pattern for each: the back's burdens, the throat's unspoken words, each ailment read as the body's metaphor for the mind's state. The school's handling of the list follows its rule: it is the movement's most influential specimen of the strong healing claim, received by its readers variously — as literal diagnosis, as a mirror for reflection, as poetry of the body — and the evidence for its literal readings is not established, which the overview states once and plainly, as it stated the law of attraction's shadow: the list's danger is the guilt it can lay on the sick, and its defenders' answer — that Hay taught self-love, never self-blame, and that the list is an invitation to reflection — is part of the record too. The third part is the practice, and it is the book's living core: the affirmations — present-tense, positive sentences spoken to the self, classically before the mirror, until the new pattern wears a groove where the old one ran: 'I love and approve of myself' as the master affirmation, forgiveness of everyone including oneself as the master work, gratitude as the day's frame.
The book's empire completes the overview. Hay House grew from the classic's success into the movement's publishing institution, issuing the milieu's whole shelf — the angel books, the channeled teachings, the memoirs of the teachers — and surviving its founder as a going concern, the only house in the building's modern rooms founded by the teacher it publishes. Hay's own later work carried the teaching to the AIDS crisis's heart: her support group, the Hay Ride, begun in her living room in 1985 with six men, grew to hundreds at the epidemic's height, when the movement's healing message — you are lovable, your life is now — reached the dying whom the churches of that hour were largely failing, a chapter of the movement's history that its historians set against every easy mockery of the affirmations: whatever the metaphysics, the love was operational. The school's judgment on the classic follows: it is New Thought's purest popular form, a century after Quimby — the causative mind, the loving universe, the self as the site of salvation — made grandmotherly, quotable, and kind, which is precisely its historical importance: the doctrine that began in a Maine clockmaker's sickroom became, in Hay's mirror work, a daily practice for millions who never heard the words New Thought.
The overview's last word places the book by its use, in the series the semester is building. Tolle's book is read to be stopped; Hay's is read to be repeated — its ideal reader not finishing it but installing it, the affirmations passing from the page to the mirror to the mind's default voice, the text succeeding when it has been memorized into the self's furniture. The two classics are the movement's two hands: presence and pattern, the stillness that dissolves the old self and the sentences that build the new — and the student who holds both has the milieu's practical system entire, as its millions practice it. The texts proceed from the two classics to the shelf they anchor: the modern books of meditation and affirmation, the almanacs and card decks and workbooks by which the movement's teaching reaches its people in daily doses.
Lesson 3: Modern books of meditation and affirmations: a guided overview
The third text of the semester is, as in the last course, a shelf rather than a book: the modern literature of meditation and affirmation by which the movement actually teaches — the manuals, the workbooks, the daily readers, the card decks — the paper infrastructure of the path of one's own. The overview walks the shelf by its kinds. First, the meditation manuals proper, the shelf's spine: from the Eastern classics in their modern translations — the Tao Te Ching and the Dhammapada in the versions the milieu reads, the Yoga Sutras and the Tibetan Book of the Dead in their paperback afterlives — through the Western interpreters who naturalized them: Alan Watts, whose books of the 1950s and 60s taught Zen and Tao to the counterculture in a prose of unmatched ease; Ram Dass, the Harvard psychologist Richard Alpert remade by his guru into the author of Be Here Now (1971), the movement's most beloved single artifact, a hand-drawn, brown-paper gospel of the path that has never gone out of print; Jon Kabat-Zinn, whose Full Catastrophe Living (1990) carried mindfulness into the hospital as MBSR and thereby into the evidence base; Pema Chödrön, the American Tibetan nun whose When Things Fall Apart (1997) became the shelf's book of consolation; Thich Nhat Hanh, the Vietnamese Zen master whose dozens of gentle volumes made him the milieu's second adopted conscience after the Dalai Lama. The school's note on the kind: these are teaching books in the strict sense, meant to be practiced from — the manual at the cushion, its chapters paced to the sitter's weeks — and their authority is the grimoire's of the last course: they work, they are beautiful, they fed us.
The second kind is the affirmation and manifestation shelf, the milieu's other engine: the descendants of New Thought in their modern dress — Florence Scovel Shinn's The Game of Life (1925) as the shelf's rediscovered grandmother, her spoken-word affirmations quoted by Hay's generation entire; Napoleon Hill's Think and Grow Rich (1937) carrying the causative mind into the business shelf, where it never left; the Secret and its progeny; the workbooks with their thirty-day programs, the journals with their morning pages — Julia Cameron's The Artist's Way (1992) as the shelf's creative branch, its morning pages and artist dates practiced by millions who would not call themselves New Age at all; the daily readers, a page per date, the milieu's breviary form, from Hay's own to the angel dailies; and the card decks — affirmation cards, angel cards, oracle decks — the shelf's most original format, the book dissolved into a shuffle, its teaching delivered one drawn card at a time, at the breakfast table and the healing session alike. The school's judgment on the kind is the texts' recurring one: the format is the theology — a movement of paths will publish not a canon but a kit, and the kit's pieces are designed for the hand and the day, not the library and the lifetime.
The third kind is the channeled and visionary literature, the shelf's most distinctive and most contested: the Seth books, with which the history began; A Course in Miracles (1976), scribed by Helen Schucman from an inner voice she identified as Jesus, whose thousand pages of text and workbook — a lesson a day for a year — constitute the milieu's most demanding book and its nearest approach to a scripture, studied in its thousands of groups with a discipline that belies the movement's looseness; the Abraham books of Esther Hicks; the Conversations with God of Neale Donald Walsch (1995), the milieu's other modern bestseller of direct divine speech; the Akashic and angelic dictations of the smaller presses. The school's handling of the kind follows its rule for all such claims in the building: the texts are reported as their receivers present them — messages from beyond the author's ordinary mind — and read, by the school and by many of the movement's own scholars, as literature of the inspired interior, their value for their readers lying in the teaching's fruits rather than the transmission's mechanics, on which the school takes, as its office requires, no position. What the historian notes is the form's antiquity in the movement's own line: the channeler's trance is the séance's, professionalized and put into print — Spiritualism's grandchildren are books.
The overview's last word, and the texts' survey's, sets the shelf beside the building's other canons for the student's final judgment of the movement's textual culture. The Torah's canon is closed; the grimoire is a population; the Eddas are an archive; the New Age shelf is a kit in a market — manuals for the cushion, sentences for the mirror, cards for the table, dictations for the study group — unified, as the last course's shelf was unified, by use: every item is for doing, and its authority is the recipe's. The movement's critics call the shelf a supermarket, and its historians answer with the supermarket's defense: it stocks what the neighborhoods ask for, in the portions their days can hold, and its best items — Watts's prose, Ram Dass's gospel, the Course's workbook, Chödrön's consolation — stand comparison with any century's devotional shelf. The school leaves the student at the shelf with its standing counsel: judge each item by the rule the texts semester ends with — what it knows, how it knows it, and what it makes of the reader who practices it. The practice semester now does what the books direct: it sits down to meditate, stands up to do yoga, and takes the crystals in hand — the movement's embodied life, in the forms its millions actually keep.
Lesson 4: Interpretation and study today
The texts semester closes in the present tense: how the movement's texts are interpreted and studied now — by the practitioners in their groups, by the scholars of the academic study of esotericism and new religious movements, and by the ordinary reader at the mirror and the cushion. The practitioners' interpretation first. In the study groups — the Course's thousands of circles above all, the book clubs of the wellness world, the teachers' followings online — interpretation is practical before it is critical: the text is read for the day's use, the lesson applied, the affirmation installed, the passage tested against the reader's week and kept or released by the path's own standard, which is fruitfulness. The movement's hermeneutic has a name in its own literature: resonance — the true passage is the one that strikes the reader as addressed to him, the 'chills' and the opened-at-random page being the milieu's folk forms of the ancient bibliomancy, the book as oracle. The school's note is the one its comparative duty requires: every room has its devotional reading — the lectio divina, the psalm for the day — and the milieu's is distinguished by its sovereignty: no commentary tradition, no authorized reading stands between the seeker and the sentence that resonates, the author's intent being, in the movement's working theory, merely the envelope of a message the universe addressed to the reader. It is an interpretation theory exactly fitted to a movement of paths, and its cost — the text made a mirror in which the reader may meet only himself — is the one its own best teachers name, counseling the groups and the commentaries and the slow re-readings by which the mirror is made, at intervals, a window.
The scholars' interpretation is the lesson's second subject. The academic study of the milieu proceeds under two flags: the study of Western esotericism, institutionalized in the universities of Amsterdam and Exeter and their journals, which reads the movement's ancestry — Hermeticism, Theosophy, the occult revival — with the philologist's tools; and the study of new religious movements within religious studies and sociology, which reads the movement itself — its demographics, its media, its healing claims — with theirs. Between them they have produced the shelf the school's course is built on: Hanegraaff's New Age Religion and Western Culture (1996) as the field's foundation, Heelas's The New Age Movement (1996) for the sociology, the historians of Theosophy and channeling, the medical researchers testing the healing arts claim by claim. The discipline's peculiarity mirrors the last course's: its scholars include sympathizers and its subjects read its journals, and its findings — the milieu is modernity's own religion, the self's sacralization as the West's late faith — have passed into the movement's self-understanding, the teachers quoting the professors who quote the teachers. The school's student should note the arrangement's rarity and its fruit: a movement that buys its own scholarship gets, as the pagans got, a mirror that does not flatter — the genealogy without the antiquity, the claims with the evidence attached — and the milieu's better bookshops stock the mirror beside the merchandise, which is more than most rooms in the building can say.
The ordinary reader's interpretation is the lesson's third subject, and in this movement the ordinary reader is the institution. His study is the morning page and the evening card, the podcast on the commute and the teacher's clip in the feed — an interpretive world, as the history lesson found the milieu's whole modern condition, of total access and no gatekeeping, in which Tolle's stillness and the conspiracy feed arrive in the same scroll. The movement's elders answer as the family's elders answered: with better books, with the scholars popularized, with the discernment taught as a practice in itself — the 'spiritual discernment' of the serious teachers being exactly the critical faculty the academy teaches, baptized in the milieu's vocabulary: test the teaching by its fruits, the teacher by his life, the claim by your own experience honestly examined — experience being, in the movement's epistemology, the court of final appeal, provided, its teachers add, the examination is honest. The school gives the student the formulation as the semester's keepsake, because it is the milieu's interpretive rule at its best: resonance opens the book, but only examination keeps it — the chills propose, the conscience disposes.
The lesson's last word, and the texts semester's, returns to the school's standing question: what do this movement's texts ask of the person who studies them? The creeds' texts ask belief, the law's ask judgment, the pagans' asked participation; the New Age shelf asks transformation — the reader is the text's real subject, his patterns the manuscript under revision, the affirmations and the lessons being editorial marks on a self that the movement holds to be, like its own shelf, forever in draft. The student leaves the texts with the kit in his hands — the stillness and the sentences, the manual and the mirror — and the practice semester now embodies them: the meditation cushion and the yoga mat, the crystal in the healer's hand, and the movement's life at the desk and the dinner table, where the path of one's own is walked in the hours the books were written for.