Minister Destiny Marie Morgan Ministries, Inc.

Minister Destiny Testimony Schools

District: AWAKENING

Ministry name: Neopaganism

Lessons — Adult Year 1, Semester 3

Adult Year 1 · Semester 3 — Texts and teachings

Four lessons for this semester. When you are ready, take the test for this semester.

Lesson 1: The Book of Shadows (in Wicca): a guided overview

The texts semester opens with the family's most characteristic book — characteristic precisely because it is not one book: the Book of Shadows, the Wiccan grimoire, the handwritten or kept volume of rituals, spells, and lore that each coven, tradition, and solitary practitioner maintains as the working text of their practice. The overview begins with the name and the thing. A grimoire is a book of magic — the word is the old French for a grammar, a book of the art's rules — and the Book of Shadows is the modern witch's grimoire: containing, in its traditional form, the rites of the Wheel's festivals, the initiations of the degrees, the circle's casting and the spells' recipes, the laws of the tradition (the Ardanes, in Gardner's text), the charges and the runes and the herbal lore — copied by hand, in the old rule, from the initiator's book into the initiate's, by candlelight in the tradition's romantic memory and by photocopier and shared file in its actual present, the copying itself being part of the transmission, the book a lineage made paper. The name is Gardner's era's coinage — he claimed an antiquity for it the historians do not confirm — and the thing it names is older than the name in everything but text: every magical tradition in the building keeps such a working book, and Wicca's distinction is to have made the grimoire, rather than a scripture, its central text.

The book's history is the overview's second stop, and it is a detective story the school tells with pleasure because the movement itself now tells it so well. Gardner's original Book of Shadows — the Ye Bok of Ye Arte of Witchcraft of his manuscripts — was assembled in the 1940s and 50s from the sources Hutton catalogued: the Key of Solomon and the grimoires of the occult revival, Crowley's rituals and poetry, the Golden Dawn's technology, Masonic forms, Kipling and the classical authors, and the folk magic of the cunning craft — a magpie text, as its critics said and its defenders now cheerfully agree, whose borrowings Valiente's editing pruned and whose liturgy she substantially rewrote, the Charge and the Rede among the texts whose present form is largely hers. From Gardner's book descend the traditions' books — Alexandrian, Gardnerian, the American lines — each coven's copy diverging by its priesthood's hand, so that the Book of Shadows exists today not in an edition but in a population, like a folk song: no two alike, all recognizable, the textual condition the scholars call a living tradition and the practitioners call simply the Craft's way. The printed Books of Shadows that fill the bookshops — the Farrars' Witches' Bible above all, which published the Gardnerian-Alexandrian rites entire in the 1980s, to the initiates' mixed horror and relief — made the secret text a public one, and the solitary's own book, begun blank and filled from print and practice, became the movement's standard form: the grimoire as journal, spellbook, and commonplace book in one, the practitioner's own hand as its final editor.

The book's theology — for it has one, and the overview must state it — is the doctrine of the text as tool. The Book of Shadows is not believed; it is used. It carries no revelation whose truth the practitioner must confess, no history he must affirm, no commandments beyond the Rede's counsel and the tradition's laws of courtesy and secrecy; its authority is the authority of a recipe book that has fed generations — tested in the circle, corrected by results, argued over by cooks. The school's student, arriving from rooms where the book is the law, the revelation, the very body of the divine, should mark the inversion precisely, because it explains the family's whole textual culture: where the Torah's scroll is copied letter-perfect by a scribe under law, the Book of Shadows is copied by the practitioner for himself, under no law but efficacy and beauty; where the Talmud's argument is preserved entire, the grimoire's variants are pruned without anxiety; the text is the servant of the rite, and the rite of the practitioner's life — a scripture, if the word must be used, that knows it is a notebook. Even the secrecy follows the logic: the oath-bound portions are kept not because the text is holy but because the transmission is — the initiation, not the information, being the thing the oath protects, as the publication of the rites entire did not, in the event, dissolve the initiatory traditions that keep them.

The overview's last word places the Book among the building's books, as the guided overviews do, by its use at the moment of need. The Torah is read to be obeyed and argued; the Eddas, the next lesson's text, are read to be remembered; the Book of Shadows is read to be done — opened on the altar, propped against the cauldron, its page for the festival in hand consulted like a score by musicians who will improvise around it. The school's closing judgment is the practitioners' own, which the scholars endorse: the book's authority is the circle's, its text the tradition's memory in working form, and its blank pages — for every kept Book of Shadows has them, awaiting the owner's own rites, dreams, and corrections — are the truest statement of the family's theology of texts in the whole curriculum: the book is not finished, because the path is not, and the last editor of every grimoire is the life of the person who keeps it. The tour proceeds from the witch's notebook to the north's great archive: the Eddas of the Heathens.

Lesson 2: The Eddas — Norse tales (in Heathenry): a guided overview

The second text is the northern archive: the Eddas of Iceland, the two books — the Poetic Edda and the Prose Edda — in which the myths of the Norse gods survived their religion's conversion, and from which modern Heathenry rebuilds its knowledge of the old gods. The overview begins with the books' strange nativity, because it governs everything the student must understand about their use. The poems of the Poetic Edda — some thirty mythological and heroic lays, in the alliterative verse of the old north — were composed across the pagan centuries, in Norway, Iceland, and Greenland, and preserved by oral tradition until Icelandic scribes wrote them down in the thirteenth century, two hundred years after Iceland's conversion, in manuscripts of which the Codex Regius, the King's Book, found in a farmhouse and given to the Danish king in 1662, is the chief. The Prose Edda is one man's work: Snorri Sturluson (1179–1241), Iceland's great chieftain, historian, and poet, who wrote his handbook of the old mythology around 1220 — as a manual for Christian poets, who still needed the myths to understand the kennings of their art — and thereby, intending a textbook, became the old religion's unlikely savior, his prose retellings preserving myths whose poems are lost and ordering the whole into the narrative the world now knows. The school's student should hold the paradox entire: Heathenry's scriptures are a convert culture's archive, assembled by Christians for literary reasons, through which the gods speak in their own stories — the archive's fidelity vouched by the poems' pagan temper, its gaps and Christian colorings argued by the scholars line by line.

The contents, in guided outline: the Poetic Edda opens with Völuspá, the seeress's prophecy, the corpus's masterpiece and the movement's most sacred text — the world's creation from the void and the giant's body, the gods' golden age, the binding of the wolf, and Ragnarök, the doom in which Odin falls to Fenrir and Thor to the serpent and the world burns and sinks — and rises again, green from the sea, with a new generation of gods and two humans surviving in the wood, the cycle the pagan imagination sets against every ending. Around it stand the wisdom poems — Hávamál, the Sayings of the High One, Odin's own counsel of prudence, hospitality, and measured speech, the closest thing the corpus has to an ethics text — and the mythological lays: the Thrymskvida, of Thor dressing as a bride to recover his hammer, the corpus's great comedy; the Lokasenna, the flyting in which Loki insults every god in turn; Skírnismál, Vafthrúdnismál, the lays of the gods' wisdom contests and loves; and the heroic half, the lays of Sigurd the dragon-slayer, Brynhild, and the fall of the Burgundians, where the pagan heroism passes into the tragedy the German Nibelungenlied also carries. The Prose Edda retells and extends: Gylfaginning's frame of the Swedish king questioning the gods' own hall, Skáldskaparmál's treasury of myth for poets, the whole systematized — sometimes, the scholars warn, past the poems' own untidiness, Snorri the editor smoothing the myths into a narrative their original tellers might not recognize entire.

Heathenry's use of the books is the overview's third subject, and it returns the student to the reconstructionist turn of the history semester with the texts in hand. The Eddas are the Heathen's lore — the word the movement prefers to scripture, and the preference is the theology: the lore is honored as the ancestors' testimony, the record of how the old ones knew their gods, but it binds as evidence, not as law; the Heathen's practice is rebuilt from it critically, with the sagas, the histories, the archaeologists' spades, and the folklore archives as its fellow witnesses, and the arguments of the movement's journals — over Snorri's Christian filter, over the poems' dates, over whether a given rite is attested or invented — are conducted exactly as the scholars conduct theirs, because in this movement the scholars and the worshippers are substantially the same people. The school's contrast with the previous lesson is deliberate and instructive: where the Book of Shadows is a tool copied by its user, the Eddas are an inheritance copied by monks; where Wicca's text is valued for efficacy, Heathenry's is valued for fidelity — two theologies of the book within one family, arguing amicably at the same festivals about whether a text is a recipe or a relic, and agreeing that it is, in either case, read best in company and argued over a horn.

The overview's last word is a reading instruction, in the building's manner. Read the Eddas as the movement reads them: in translation entire — the student has his choice of a dozen, from the literal to the poetic, the argument among the translations being itself a Heathen pastime — and read them as what they are, the remains of a world: violent, funny, fatalistic, and tender in a proportion no modern editor would invent, in which the gods themselves are mortal and know it, and go to the last battle anyway. That knowledge — the doom accepted, the deed done in the doom's despite — is the corpus's gift to its modern readers and the core of the Heathen ethic the values semester will draw: courage without guarantees, generosity without a heaven to bank it in, loyalty to gods who will lose. The school leaves the student at the seeress's final vision, the earth rising green from the sea a second time, and turns to the family's third kind of book — the modern festival and ritual books, in which the revival wrote down, for anyone who could buy a paperback, what the covens once copied by hand.

Lesson 3: Modern pagan books of festivals and rituals: a guided overview

The third text of the semester is not a book but a shelf — the modern pagan literature of festivals and rituals, the paperback corpus by which the revival taught itself: the festival guides, the ritual manuals, the books of shadows published for the solitary, which together constitute the family's real canon in the sociologist's sense — the books its practitioners actually read, lend, argue with, and keep by the altar. The overview walks the shelf by its kinds. First, the founders' and popularizers' works, which the history semester has already shelved: Gardner's Witchcraft Today and The Meaning of Witchcraft, Valiente's books, the Farrars' Witches' Bible and their Eight Sabbats for Witches, which gave the Wheel's festivals their standard modern liturgies — the rites, in the Farrars' generous and scholarly presentation, that a generation of covens and solitaries adopted entire, so that a Sabbat in Ohio and a Sabbat in Kent might be, in the 1980s, recognizably the same rite, a uniformity the family's history had never known. Beside them stand the Druid and Heathen standards: the Order of Bards, Ovates and Druids' course materials and rite books; the Heathen handbooks that teach the blot and sumbel from the sources; and the feminist spirituality shelf — Budapest's Holy Book of Women's Mysteries, Starhawk's Spiral Dance with its rituals for the wheel and the work — each kind carrying its house's theology in the form of things to do.

The second kind is the solitary's handbook, the shelf's largest and the movement's most characteristic: the books addressed to the practitioner alone with his altar — Scott Cunningham's Wicca: A Guide for the Solitary Practitioner (1988) above all, the gentle, clear manual that taught more modern pagans than any coven ever initiated, its author a solitary who wrote for solitaries and whose Earth Power and herbals and encyclopedias made him the movement's household tutor; Silver RavenWolf's To Ride a Silver Broomstick, the 1990s' engine of the teenage witch phenomenon, beloved and argued over in the movement's journals with a heat that measures its reach; and the whole tide of the Llewellyn and Weiser lists — the almanacs that give each year's moons and Sabbats with their rites, the spellbooks for every occasion of a life, the correspondences' encyclopedias — a publishing ecology without parallel in the building's other rooms, in which the family's teaching office is exercised, in the main, by commercial publishers answering a market of seekers. The school's student should register the fact's weight: this is a religion whose scriptures are substantially a bookshop section, whose canon is a sales category, and whose orthodoxy is policed, insofar as it is policed at all, by reviewers and by the readers' choice of the next book — a condition the movement's critics call its corruption and its historians call its Reformation, the printing press doing for the pagans what it did for the Protestants, with the same mixture of liberation and chaos.

The third kind is the festival book proper — the literature of the Wheel as a lived year — and it brings the overview home to the semester's subject. These are the books organized not by doctrine but by the calendar: the Sabbat guides that walk the practitioner through the eight festivals with their myths, their foods, their crafts, and their rites — the Llewellyn Sabbat Essentials series as the current standard, a volume per festival, history and ritual and recipe in one; the older and beloved household manuals, like Pauline Campanelli's Wheel of the Year, which teach the year as a domestic liturgy of garden, kitchen, and altar; and the children's shelf — the pagan picture books and family yearbooks by which the second generation is being raised in the tradition, a literature whose existence is itself the history semester's open question beginning to be answered. The school's note on the kind is its theology once more: a religion whose central text is a calendar will write books that are calendars, and the festival book — part almanac, part cookbook, part liturgy — is the exact literary form of a faith whose doctrine is a turning year and whose church is a household. The student who wants to know what modern pagans believe will learn it faster from these than from any creed, because the belief is in the doing the books direct: the bread baked for Lughnasadh, the ancestor plate set at Samhain, the seeds blessed at Imbolc.

The overview's last word, and the texts semester's, sets the shelf beside the building's other canons for the student's final judgment of the family's textual culture. The Torah's canon is closed and letter-perfect; the Talmud's argument is preserved entire; the Book of Shadows is a population of manuscripts; the Eddas are a convert culture's archive; and the modern shelf is a market — five theologies of the text in one small family, which between them exhaust, the school suggests, most of the ways a religion can keep its memory. What unifies the shelf is the use to which every volume is put, and with which the semester began: these are books for doing — the rite at the festival, the spell at the need, the year at the table — and their authority, from the Farrars' liturgies to Cunningham's gentle instructions, is the grimoire's authority of the first lesson, the recipe's: it works, it is beautiful, it fed us. The practice semester now does what the books direct: it walks the Wheel of the Year festival by festival in its rites, casts the circle in the wood and the living room, and keeps the moon's phases in the practitioner's week.

Lesson 4: Interpretation and study today

The texts semester closes in the present tense: how the family's texts are interpreted and studied now — by the practitioners in their circles, by the scholars of the new discipline of Pagan Studies, and by the ordinary reader whose bookshop shelf the last lesson surveyed — in a movement whose interpretive situation is, as the student is now equipped to see, unlike any other in the building: a tradition whose ancient texts are another religion's archive, whose modern texts are a market, and whose authority to interpret belongs, by its own constitution, to whoever shows up with a book and a circle. The practitioners' interpretation first. In the coven and the grove, interpretation is liturgical before it is academic: the Charge is spoken and re-spoken until its phrases become the speaker's own theology; the Eddas are read aloud at the sumbel and argued over the horn; the festival books are adapted — the word the practitioners use without embarrassment — each rite rewritten for this place, this company, this year's need, the adaptation being not a concession but the method, since a text whose authority is efficacy is interpreted by being performed and corrected by the performance. Study, in the initiatory traditions, is graded like the initiations: the degrees' curricula, the orders' Bardic courses with their years of lessons by post and now by screen, the Heathen's language classes in Old Norse and Icelandic — a people's university without walls, whose examinations are the rites themselves and whose doctorate is the community's recognition of a goði, a priest, an elder whose learning the kindred trusts.

The scholars' interpretation is the lesson's second subject, and it is the building's youngest discipline. Pagan Studies — named as a field in the 1990s, with its journal (The Pomegranate), its conferences, and its presence in the religious-studies associations — studies the movement with the academy's tools: Hutton's historiography as its foundation, the sociologists' surveys as its demography, the textual scholars editing the founders' papers — Gardner's manuscripts in their Toronto archive, the Farrars' and Valiente's papers in the movement's keeping — as other disciplines edit their classics. The discipline's peculiarity is its overlap with its subject: many of its scholars are practitioners, many of its practitioners read its journals, and its conferences share their hotels and sometimes their evenings with the festivals — a condition the field debates about itself with becoming honesty, the insider's knowledge and the insider's blindness being, as in every room's scholarship, the same fact in two lights. The school's student should note what the discipline has already given the movement: a past it can trust, because it was written by the record's rules; a mirror in which its claims are tested by people who wish it well and will not flatter it — the combination the movement, alone among the building's younger religions, went out and bought for itself from the universities, an act of institutional self-confidence the school finds worthy of the student's respect.

The ordinary reader's interpretation is the lesson's third subject, and in this family it is the main event, since the solitary with his shelf is the movement's median member. His study is the bookshop's and the screen's: the almanac's year, the podcast's Edda, the online kindred's reading list, the social media's runes and festivals — an interpretive world of extraordinary fertility and no quality control whatever, in which the Eddas' best modern translations and the wildest forgeries circulate in the same feed, and the reader's discernment is the only magisterium on duty. The movement's elders have answered with the tools the family trusts: better books, open archives, the scholars' work made popular, the festivals' teaching tracks — and with the counsel that is the tradition's own interpretive rule, which the school gives the student as the semester's keepsake: test the text by the practice and the practice by the sources, hold the founders to the record and the record to the conscience, and remember that in this family a text is finally interpreted by the life it produces in the reader — the grimoire's standard, applied to the whole library. The student who keeps that rule can read the family's whole shelf, from the Codex Regius to the almanac, without being gulled by the one or condescending to the other.

The lesson's last word, and the texts semester's, returns to the school's standing question for every room: what does this subject ask of the person who studies it? The creeds ask belief, the law asks judgment; the pagan texts ask participation — the rite done, the festival kept, the horn raised — and their school can only describe the doing, as this course has, from the respectful outside, leaving the circle's casting to the practitioners whose it is. The student leaves the texts with the family's library in his hands: a notebook that is a population, an archive that is a convert's gift, a shelf that is a market, and a rule for reading them all. The practice semester now enters the circle the texts describe: the eight festivals in their turning, the rite in the wood and the room, and the moon in her phases over the practitioner's ordinary week — the religion as it is lived, which is the only place, its practitioners insist, where it has ever entirely existed.

Back to all lessons · Take this semester’s test