Adult Year 1 · Semester 2 — History
Four lessons for this semester. When you are ready, take the test for this semester.
Lesson 1: The origins of Neopaganism
The history semester begins with the origins, and the school's method with this subject is the one the introduction promised: the tradition's own story and the historians' reconstruction in their separate columns, with the unusual feature of this room being that the columns agree on the plot and differ only on its meaning. The tradition's story, as its founders told it, runs thus: the old religions of Europe never entirely died; driven underground by the Church's triumph, the worship of the Goddess and the Horned God survived in the folk customs, the herb-wives and cunning folk, and — in the boldest form of the claim, Margaret Murray's witch-cult thesis of 1921 — in an organized underground religion whose members were the men and women burned as witches in the great persecutions, until, in the twentieth century, the survivors could emerge: Gerald Gardner, initiated in 1939 by the New Forest coven, publishing Witchcraft Today in 1954 with the retired witch-trials' shadow just lifted by the repeal of the Witchcraft Act, and carrying the Old Religion into the light. It is a magnificent story, and the movement's first generations believed it, built on it, and drew from it the dignity of the persecuted — the Burning Times, in the movement's own name for the witch trials, standing in its memory where martyrology stands in the older rooms.
The historians' column, assembled by Ronald Hutton of Bristol above all — whose Triumph of the Moon (1999) is the movement's scholarly monument, written by a historian sympathetic to his subject and accepted by most of its practitioners — dismantles the survival and replaces it with something the school finds more interesting. The witch-cult thesis fails the archives: the trials' victims were not pagans but overwhelmingly Christians accused by Christians, the confessions extracted by torture from the demonology of the accusers, and no coven, goddess, or horned god of Gardner's kind appears in the record. What the record does show is the revival's real genealogy, in three streams. The first is literary and antiquarian: the Romantic movement's recovery of nature and the folk, the folklore collectors, Frazer's Golden Bough with its dying-and-rising gods, the classical scholarship that made the Greek and Norse pantheons the furniture of every educated imagination. The second is occult: the Hermetic Order of the Golden Dawn and the whole Victorian magical revival, which built the ritual technology — the circle, the quarters, the elemental weapons — that Gardner would inherit and simplify. The third is the counterculture of the English countryside itself: the woodcraft movements, the naturists, the folk-dance revival, the nudist colonies of the New Forest among whom Gardner lived — the soil, Hutton shows, in which a retired colonial civil servant with a museum of witchcraft and a genius for synthesis planted, in the 1940s and 50s, a new religion assembled from all three streams and presented, as new religions often are, as the oldest.
Between the columns stands the movement's own maturity, which the lesson gives as the origins' third act, because it is the part the student will actually meet. The first generation needed the survival story; the second and third, reading Hutton — whom the movement, to its credit, adopted rather than anathematized, making him a welcome guest at its festivals — rebuilt their self-understanding on the revival's truth: that the old gods were honored anew not because their worship never ceased but because it was worth resuming; that a religion founded in 1954 can be as real in its practice as one founded in 1254; and that the Burning Times, reconceived, honor the trials' actual victims — the accused, mostly women, mostly innocent of everything — better as a warning about persecution than as a pedigree. The school's phrase for the settlement, offered as this lesson's keepsake, is that Neopaganism is the building's most honest new religion about being new — its antiquity a matter of inspiration honestly confessed, its authority resting, as the foundations taught, on the path's fruits and not its family tree.
The origins lesson's last word follows the seed into its first soil: the early community of the next lesson — the Goddess's return in the feminist and environmental centuries, the covens and groves of the founding decades — and the school pauses only to mark the pattern the whole history will repeat. Every stream of the revival runs through the nineteenth and twentieth centuries' great changes: industrialization driving the romantics back to the land, empire carrying the colonials home with the world's religions in their luggage, the women's movement, the environmental crisis, the collapse of the churches' monopoly in the West. Neopaganism, on the historians' showing, is modernity's own paganism — the old gods recalled to answer new questions, about nature, about the female, about the body's holiness, about authority — and the movement's best teachers do not dispute the description. They embrace it: the gods, they say, were never dependent on the antiquity of their altars, and a world that has paved the groves needs the groves' gods precisely now. The early community that first enacted that embrace is next.
Lesson 2: The Goddess in her many faces and the early community
The second history lesson takes up the figure at the revival's heart and the community that formed around her: the Goddess — in her many faces, as the lesson's title has it — and the first generations of the modern movement, from Gardner's coven to the feminist spirituality that made the Goddess a world figure. The Goddess's modern career begins, like the movement's, in the scholars' studies before it reaches the circles: the nineteenth century's discovery, in the figurines of old Europe and the myths of the Mediterranean, of a great mother goddess whom the era's writers — Bachofen with his mother-right, the classical scholars, and in the twentieth century Robert Graves, whose White Goddess (1948) made her a poet's muse of triple form — assembled into a single figure behind the many goddesses of the ancient world. Marija Gimbutas, the archaeologist of Old Europe, gave the figure her most scholarly form: a peaceful, goddess-honoring civilization of the Neolithic, overthrown, in her reconstruction, by the patriarchal horsemen from the steppe — a thesis the archaeologists argue over still, and which passed, largely unargued, into the movement's imagination as its prehistory: the age of the Goddess, whose fall the modern revival exists to reverse. The school's student should hold the scholarly argument and the religious use in their separate columns, as this room has taught him: the Goddess of the modern movement is a real presence in her worshippers' lives whatever the figurines' original meaning, and the figurines are evidence of something whatever the movement makes of them.
The early community formed in two waves, and the lesson distinguishes them because their union made the modern movement. The first wave was Gardner's: the Bricket Wood coven in Hertfordshire and its daughters, the priestesses — Doreen Valiente above all, Gardner's High Priestess from 1953, who rewrote his rough book of rituals into the liturgy the whole tradition now uses, discarding, with a poet's ruthlessness, much of the borrowed occultism and keeping the Goddess at the center — her Charge of the Goddess, adapted from older sources and her own gift, being the movement's most beloved text, spoken in circles on every continent: 'I am the beauty of the green earth, and the white moon among the stars, and the mystery of the waters.' Around the covens grew the first orders and their cousins: the Druid orders refounded in their modern form — the Order of Bards, Ovates and Druids from 1964 under Ross Nichols, Gardner's friend, the two old men dividing the English esoteric summer between witchcraft and Druidry like friendly kings — and in America, the Church of All Worlds from a science-fiction novel's inspiration, Feraferia, and the first Heathen kindreds, the revival sprouting in the 1960s' California soil with a speed England's covens watched in amazement.
The second wave was the Goddess's own: the feminist spirituality movement of the 1970s, which took the Goddess out of the covens' secrecy and made her a public theology. Zsuzsanna Budapest founded the Susan B. Anthony Coven No. 1 in Los Angeles in 1971 — Dianic Wicca, women-only, the Goddess without the God, witchcraft as the women's religion reclaimed from the Burning Times' memory; Starhawk — Miriam Simos — whose Spiral Dance (1979) became the movement's most influential book, joined the Goddess to the environmental and anti-nuclear movements, and taught a generation to cast circles at protest camps as readily as at festivals; and the theologians and poets — Carol Christ asking, in her famous essay of 1978, why women need the Goddess, and answering that a culture whose god is male will call maleness divine — built the movement its intellectual house. The school's balance on the wave is its usual one: the feminist Goddess movement gave Neopaganism its numbers, its public voice, and its ethics of the earth; it also began the arguments — over gender's essence, over the God’s place, over who may stand in the circle — that the modern movement conducts still, in its journals and at its festivals, as the sign of its life.
The lesson's last word is the community's shape as the founding generations left it, because the student will meet that shape in every modern pagan gathering. It is a community without a center that nevertheless coheres: covens of thirteen at most, splitting by design when they grow, like cells; groves and kindreds and circles, each sovereign; solitaries beyond counting; and over the whole, no authority but the festivals, the publishing houses, and the internet, where the family's arguments and its teaching now chiefly live. The Goddess in her many faces presides over the shape as its fitting emblem: one figure, as the soft polytheists say, in every goddess; many persons, as the hard polytheists answer, in every face — the community's theology and its sociology being, as so often in this building, the same fact stated twice. The growth, change, and reform of the movement's maturity follow: the reconstructionists' turn to the sources, the tradition's reckoning with its founders' shadows, and its arrival, in the student's century, as one of the West's established alternative religions.
Lesson 3: Growth, change, and reform
The third history lesson follows the movement through its maturity — the decades, from the 1970s to the student's present, in which Neopaganism grew from a scattering of covens into a recognized religious family, and changed, as living traditions do, by arguing with itself about sources, founders, and the terms of its own welcome. The first great change was the reconstructionist turn: the decision, taken independently in several of the family's houses, that inspiration was not enough and the sources must rule. Heathenry led it — the Asatru and Theodish movements rebuilding the Germanic religion from the Eddas, the sagas, and the archaeologists' reports, learning Old Norse and Icelandic for the purpose, correcting the founders' inventions out of their rites as fast as the scholarship supplied better; Hellenic and Roman and Celtic reconstructionisms followed, each with its journals, its calendars rebuilt from the ancient evidence, its internal police of accuracy. The turn changed the family's center of gravity: the eclectic synthesis of the founding generation — a little Gardner, a little Graves, a little of everything — found itself answerable, in the movement's own forums, to a standard of evidence it had not expected to meet, and the argument between the reconstructionist and the eclectic, the historian's paganism and the poet's, became the family's most productive quarrel, each side keeping the other honest in its characteristic direction.
The second change was the reckoning with the founders' shadows, and the lesson gives it in the depth the school's honesty requires, because the movement's handling of it is among its distinctions. Gardner's legacy carries the era's marks: the skyclad rite — worship naked, his tradition's 'sky-clad' practice — and the scourge in the rituals, the initiations' secrecy and the founders' sexual frankness, all of which the modern movement has examined in public, keeping what its members judge sacred and revising what they judge the founder's era or the founder's appetites, the Book of Shadows itself being edited by each generation of its priestesses as a living text. A darker shadow fell on parts of Heathenry: the folkish current, which ties the Germanic religion to ethnic ancestry and, at its fringe, to the racial politics that disgraced the symbols it uses — the runes and the hammer carried, in the student's century, by movements the mainstream Heathen organizations have formally repudiated, declaring, in the words of the Declaration of Deeds and its sister documents, that their religion is open to all who hear the gods' call, of every ancestry — the repudiation being itself a natural part of this lesson, since a family without a magisterium can only excommunicate by declaration and by example, and has done both. The school's summary is the record's: the movement's reforms have been conducted in the open, in its own press, by its own members, which is more than every older room in this building managed at the same age.
The third change was institutional arrival. The movement that began in secrecy acquired, across the decades, the furniture of an established religion: legal recognition and its long train of cases — the pentacle approved, after a decade of advocacy, for the headstones of American veterans in 2007, the school's emblematic date for the arrival; pagan chaplains in prisons, hospitals, and universities, and in several countries' armed forces; handfastings recognized as marriages where the law allows celebrants; pagan charities, seminaries, and a scholarly discipline — Pagan Studies, with its journal and its chairs — studying the movement in the universities while the movement studies the past in its groves. The numbers followed the furniture: the censuses and surveys of the English-speaking world recording pagans by the hundreds of thousands and, in some counts, past a million, with the growth concentrated, every survey agrees, among the young, the educated, and the women — a demographic the founding generation, a handful of retired colonials and their priestesses, could not have imagined and would mostly have welcomed. The school adds the sociologists' note that completes the picture: the movement's growth has been almost entirely by conversion and almost entirely adult — a religion chosen, in a century of chosen religions, whose retention of its own children is, as the foundations foresaw, its open experiment.
The lesson's last word is the pattern of the changes, stated as the movement's philosophy of its own history, because by now the student can state it himself. Neopaganism reforms by recovery and by argument: it corrects its present by its sources — the Eddas against the founders, the archaeology against the romance — and it corrects its sources by its conscience, discarding the founder's scourge and the fringe's racism in the name of the very gods the sources attest, read by the light the practitioners bring to them. A tradition with no creed can only reform in this double motion, and the motion's product, across fifty years, is visible: a family more various than its founders dreamed and more self-critical than its critics expected. The modern world, in which the movement now stands as the West's homegrown alternative to the churches it left, is the final history lesson's subject — its festivals in the fields, its arguments in the networks, and its gods in the cities.
Lesson 4: Neopaganism in the modern world
The final history lesson surveys the movement's present estate — a family now old enough to have a past of its own, established enough to keep charities and chaplains, and young enough, still, that its average member found it within living memory. The survey begins with the map. The movement's heartlands remain the English-speaking world and northern Europe — Britain, where it began and where the census now counts pagans in the tens of thousands and the solstice at Stonehenge draws its thousands under the heritage authorities' negotiated peace; the United States, its largest population, where the movement's diversity is widest and its institutions thickest; Canada, Australia, and New Zealand in the first rank after them; and the Germanic and Scandinavian countries, where Heathenry has achieved a recognition its founders would have thought impossible — Iceland's Ásatrúarfélagið, recognized since 1973, building the first Norse temple raised in a thousand years outside Reykjavík, its high priest a composer, its membership a measurable fraction of the nation's. Beyond the heartlands the family follows the bookshops and the networks: Latin America's brujería-adjacent eclectic circles, South Africa's and Australia's indigenous-European syntheses argued over in the movement's journals, and everywhere the internet's covens and kindreds, where the solitary majority of the movement now chiefly lives its communal life — a fact the sociologists record as the family's characteristic modern form, a religion of the screen and the seasonal gathering, dense in neither parish nor temple.
The modern movement's public life is the survey's second subject, and it runs on the two rails the course has followed throughout: the earth and the argument. On the earth rail: the movement's environmental vocation, from Starhawk's protest circles to the tree-sitters' and pipeline camps' pagan chaplains, the rewilding projects and the sacred-site campaigns — Stonehenge's long road to open access at the solstices being the type — in which the family's theology of the sacred land becomes, as its teachers intended, a practice with planning applications and arrest records. On the argument rail: the movement's internal public sphere, now one of the most vigorous in the building — the journals and the podcasts, the conferences (PantheaCon in California drawing its thousands until its recent close, the Pagan Federation's decades of advocacy in Britain), and the controversies conducted at full volume: the gender arguments over the Dianic tradition's women-only circles and the place of trans practitioners, which split festivals and founded new ones; the cultural-appropriation arguments over the eclectic borrowings from living indigenous traditions, in which the movement has developed, painfully and in public, an ethic of borrowing that the sister courses in this curriculum — Primal Faith and Primal Indigenous — will let the student judge from the other side; and the perpetual argument over the founders, the sources, and the money, without which, the movement's elders say, it would know it was dead.
The survey's third subject is the movement's place in the West's religious settlement, which has changed past recognition in two generations. The pagan is no longer, in the heartland countries, a figure of the occult fringe in the public mind: he is a colleague with a festival leave request, a chaplain with a security pass, a parent at the school gate whose handfasting the registry office recorded — the movement having won, case by case and census by census, the ordinary standing that the older rooms took centuries to win and that this one won in decades, partly by the law's logic and partly by the culture's: a religion of nature, choice, and the female divine arrived exactly when the West's seekers were looking for one, and its growth curve is the demand curve's portrait. The school's balance requires the shadows in the same frame: the movement's recognition is uneven — refused or precarious in many countries, its practitioners still concealable at many workplaces even in the heartlands — and its public image still carries the caricatures the introduction dismissed, in the tabloids' Halloween vocabulary and the horror film's coven. The movement's own teachers are characteristically unsentimental about both: the standing was never going to be given entire, and the work of the next generation is the work of this one, at the festivals and in the forums.
The lesson's last word, and the history semester's, belongs to the continuity the four lessons display. A student who entered the semester with a retired civil servant's synthesis in a New Forest wood has arrived at a world family: temples rising in Iceland, circles cast on six continents, a scholarly discipline, a martyrology honestly revised, and a calendar — the Wheel — kept by more people this year than last, in the teeth of the century's secularization that emptied the churches the movement's members left. The school's closing judgment is modest and exact: Neopaganism in the modern world is neither the survival its founders dreamed nor the fad its first critics dismissed, but a new religious family in its third generation — the age at which, in this building's experience, a movement discovers whether its children will keep it, and its gods, now honored by people who chose them freely in full knowledge of their histories, have perhaps the strangest and strongest claim of any in the curriculum to be exactly what their worshippers say they are: old powers, newly loved. The texts semester opens the family's books — a witch's book of shadows, a Norseman's Eddas, and the festival books of the modern groves.