Minister Destiny Marie Morgan Ministries, Inc.

Minister Destiny Testimony Schools

District: AWAKENING

Ministry name: Natural Law

Lessons — Adult Year 2, Semester 1

Adult Year 2 · Semester 1 — People and stories

Four lessons for this semester. When you are ready, take the test for this semester.

Lesson 1: Cicero of Rome: life and legacy

Marcus Tullius Cicero (106–43 BCE) is the natural-law tradition's first complete life — the doctrine's earliest teacher whose biography, writings, and death all survive in detail — and Year Two opens with him because the tradition has always read the man and the doctrine together. He was a new man, a novus homo, from Arpinum, the first of his family to reach the Roman senate, who rose by the only ladder open to talent without ancestry: the law courts and the tongue. His consulship of 63 BCE was his life's summit and its curse — he detected and crushed the Catilinarian conspiracy, executing five conspirators without trial under the senate's emergency decree, an act that won him the title Father of the Fatherland and the charge, pressed by his enemies for the rest of his life and by historians since, of having violated the very law he served: the citizen's right to trial, provocatio, which his own doctrine held sacred. The school gives the contradiction without varnish, because the tradition does: its first teacher's greatest act is also its first case study in the doctrine's hardest question — what the law's servant may do when the law's forms are the conspiracy's shield.

The exile and the return made the philosopher. Driven from Rome in 58 BCE by the law his enemy Clodius aimed at him personally, his house burned and his property confiscated, Cicero spent a year in Greece in a despair his letters do not hide, was recalled in triumph, and spent the republic's last decade dividing himself between the courts, the senate, and the villas where, in an astonishing final flowering — much of it composed while the republic died around him and his beloved daughter Tullia's death in 45 broke his private world — he wrote the works that created Latin philosophy: On the Republic, On the Laws, On the Nature of the Gods, On Duties, the Tusculan Disputations, On Friendship, On Old Age. The school's student should grasp what the corpus is: a statesman with a broken career translating Greek philosophy into the language of Roman law, and in the translation inventing the vocabulary — humanitas, societas, officium, lex naturae — in which the West would conduct its moral business for two thousand years. The doctrine of natural law is not one item in the corpus; it is the corpus's load-bearing conviction, stated in the dialogues and applied in the speeches, where the advocates' Rome heard, perhaps for the first time, a defense lawyer argue from the law that is not written.

His death is the life's final lesson, and the tradition has never separated it from the doctrine. After Caesar's assassination — which Cicero had not conspired in and rejoiced at — he staked everything on the Philippics, the speeches against Mark Antony modeled on Demosthenes, attempting to save the republic by the senate's authority and the young Octavian's sword. When the triumvirate formed, Antony demanded Cicero's name on the proscription list as his price; Octavian, the tradition's sources say, argued two days for his old patron and yielded on the third. Cicero was overtaken on the road from his villa in December 43 BCE; he ordered his litter set down, leaned out, and bared his neck to the centurion — the detail every account preserves, the orator composing his death as he had composed his speeches. His head and his hands — the hands that wrote the Philippics — were nailed to the rostra in the forum, where Antony’s wife, in the historians' most notorious detail, pierced the tongue with her hairpin. The school does not tell the death for its horror: it tells it because the doctrine's first teacher died by an enactment — a proscription list, law in form — that his doctrine pronounced no law at all, and the tradition has read the rostra's display ever since as the unjust law's self-portrait and its refutation in one image.

His legacy is the transmission itself. The empire that proscribed him taught him in its schools; Quintilian made him the canon of Latin prose; the Church Fathers — Lactantius, Ambrose, Augustine, who credited a book of Cicero's with turning his own life toward philosophy — quoted the natural-law passages as the pagan world's witness to the truth; the monks copied him; Petrarch's rediscovery of his letters in 1345 is conventionally dated as the Renaissance's beginning; the Salamanca scholastics and Grotius cite him as their Roman authority; the American founders read him in school and quoted him in Congress. And the doctrine's sentence — right reason in agreement with nature — passed through him into every subsequent statement of the tradition, Aquinas's included. The school's closing word for the life is the proportion the record strikes: other teachers gave the doctrine more system, and the next life in this semester gave it more consequence, but Cicero gave it its voice and its martyrdom — the proof, renewed at the rostra, that the law above laws has always been defended, when it came to it, by persons and not by institutions, and at the price persons pay.

Lesson 2: John Locke: life and legacy

John Locke (1632–1704) is the tradition's great translator — the philosopher who converted natural law from the schools' Latin into the political vernacular of rights, consent, and revolution, and whose life, quieter than Cicero's by design, is the doctrine's biography in the age of print and exile. Born in Somerset to a Puritan lawyer's family, educated at Westminster and Christ Church, Oxford — where he found the scholastic curriculum so arid that his mature work reads as its repudiation — he trained in medicine, served as physician and secretary to the Earl of Shaftesbury, and was drawn by that patron's politics into the center of England's constitutional struggle. The works of his maturity were all written in danger's shadow: the Essay Concerning Human Understanding, philosophy's new foundation, composed over two decades; the Letter Concerning Toleration; and the Two Treatises of Government, published anonymously in 1689 as the Glorious Revolution's justification — though the scholarship of the last century, redating the composition to the Exclusion Crisis years before, has shown the Treatises to be not the revolution's apology but its preparation, a revolutionary's handbook written when writing it was treason. Locke spent 1683 to 1689 in Dutch exile, under a false name, on the same refugee circuit as the Huguenots and the English dissenters, and returned in the fleet that brought Mary to the throne — a philosopher smuggled home by a revolution his book had helped to arm.

The doctrine he taught must be stated in his own transformation of it, because the transformation is the legacy. Where Aquinas grounded the natural law in the eternal law and the inclinations of nature, Locke — a Christian who held reason and revelation in careful alliance — grounded it in workmanship and property: we are God's workmanship, sent into the world by His order and about His business, and therefore no man's property to destroy — the argument by which suicide, slavery, and murder fall under one prohibition, since the life is not one's own to take or give. From workmanship flows equality: in the state of nature, which Locke insists is a state of liberty and not of license, all are equal and independent, and no one ought to harm another in his life, health, liberty, or possessions — the law of nature, teachable by reason, which is that law. Property arises when a man mixes his labor with the common earth — the acorns gathered, the field enclosed — subject to the provisos that enough and as good be left for others and that nothing spoil in his hands; government arises when men, finding the state of nature inconvenient for want of a known law, an indifferent judge, and an executive power, consent to unite under a common authority as trustees for the ends they could not secure alone — and when the trust is broken, by a prince who substitutes his will for law, the government dissolves, and the people resume the right to erect a new one. Every phrase of the system was aimed, and the student should hear the aim: the divine right of kings, Filmer's patriarchal absolutism, is the First Treatise's demolished target, and the Second is the demolition's replacement — government by consent, under nature's law, for the preservation of rights that precede it.

The record's second column, given as this school gives every subject's, contains the life's shadows, and they are not small. Locke invested in the Royal African Company, whose business was the slave trade; he served the Carolina proprietors whose Fundamental Constitutions granted every freeman absolute power and authority over his negro slaves; and his theory's own texts struggle at the seam — slavery justified only as the state of war continued between a lawful conqueror and a captive who has forfeited his life, a justification that fits the Atlantic trade's hereditary racial slavery not at all, as the abolitionists who later wielded Locke against the trade were the first to point out. The school's judgment is the tradition's own, stated in the foundations: the doctrine condemns its professor, and the professor's failure is the doctrine's evidence — for it was Locke's principles, not his portfolio, that the enslaved and their advocates carried into the next century's courts and conventions, and the principles were stronger than the man, which is what principles are for. The same doubleness marks his toleration, generous to Protestant dissenters and withheld from Catholics and atheists on grounds his own premises strain against — the tradition's unfinished business, conducted in his name ever since.

His legacy is, by the record's plain measure, the largest of any life in this semester. The Second Treatise became the American Revolution's textbook — Jefferson's Declaration is its principles in a higher key, as the semester's final story will show — and the French Revolution's warrant and its warning, and the standing argument of every constitutionalism since: that governments are trusts, that rights precede them, that resistance to the trust-breaker is nature's law and not rebellion's crime. His epistemology remade philosophy; his toleration, extended past his own limits by his own logic, remade the West's religious settlement; his educational and economic writings shaped the centuries quietly. He died in 1704 at Oates, in Essex, in the household of the Mashams — reading the Psalms, by the account of the lady of the house, and correcting to the end the proofs of his works — and his epitaph, which he wrote himself in Latin, instructs the traveler to seek his mortal remains nowhere but in his works. The school's closing word accepts the instruction and applies it to the semester's design: the doctrine's lives are read in their works and their wounds together, and the next story is the oldest of them — a girl in Thebes, older than every philosopher in this course, who acted the doctrine two thousand years before Locke named it.

Lesson 3: Antigone, who followed a higher law: the story in full

The third story is the doctrine's founding drama, older than its philosophy: Sophocles' Antigone, first performed at Athens around 441 BCE, in which a girl's defiance of a king's edict in the name of the unwritten laws became, for twenty-five centuries of readers, the natural law's type and parable. The story's ground is Thebes after a civil war: the two sons of Oedipus, Eteocles and Polynices, have killed each other before the city's gates — Eteocles defending Thebes, Polynices attacking it at the head of a foreign army — and their uncle Creon, the new king, has decreed the war's settlement in a single edict: Eteocles shall be buried with every honor; Polynices, the traitor, shall lie unburied on the plain, his corpse the carrion birds' portion, and whoever buries him shall die by public stoning. The edict is the play's first fact and its whole problem stated in advance: it is lawful — the king's to make, the city's to enforce, reasoned from the city's safety — and it is, by the older law the play will invoke, an abomination, for the Greeks held the burial of the dead, above all of kin, among the duties no human authority creates or cancels, owed to the gods below and to the nature of the family. Antigone, the dead men's sister, hears the edict and resolves, in the play's first scene, to bury her brother with her own hands and accept the death — telling her sister Ismene, who counsels obedience, the line the centuries have kept: she will lie beside him, beloved with beloved, having committed a holy crime.

The deed and the defense are the story's center, and the school gives the defense entire, because it is the doctrine's first surviving statement in its author's own form. Antigone performs the burial twice — the first a dust-sprinkling by an unseen hand the guards discover, the second in the open, where she is taken pouring the libations over the corpse and crying out over it like a bird over an empty nest. Brought before Creon, she does not deny, plead, or equivocate: she confesses the act and denies the charge, in the speech Aristotle quoted in the Rhetoric as the universal law's textbook. It was not Zeus who published that edict, she tells the king, nor Justice who dwells with the gods below; your proclamation, being a mortal's, could not overrun the gods' unwritten and unfailing laws — for those live not from today or yesterday but forever, and no one knows when they first appeared; and she was not going to pay the gods' penalty for fear of any man's pride. The school's student should weigh the speech's structure, because the whole later tradition is its commentary: the appeal is not to private feeling but to law — unwritten against written, eternal against today's, divine and natural against the edict's enactment — and the defendant's claim is not exemption from law but obedience to the higher of two laws, the claim Aquinas, Cicero, and King will each restate in their own vocabularies.

The catastrophe completes the story, and Sophocles' evenhandedness is the school's necessary note, because the play is a tragedy and not a pamphlet. Creon is no stage tyrant: his edict reasons from the city's wound, his speeches plead the ship of state's safety, and the chorus of Theban elders wavers between the two laws exactly as the audience does. His son Haemon, betrothed to Antigone, pleads for her with the doctrine of the flexible tree that bends in the flood and lives, against the rigid one that snaps; the blind prophet Tiresias arrives with the gods' verdict — the altars polluted by the carrion of the unburied, the city's sacrifices refused — and Creon, broken at last, reverses himself too late: he buries Polynices with his own hands and goes to free Antigone from the sealed cave where she was walled alive, to find her hanged by her own girdle and Haemon, who spits in his father's face and falls on his sword beside her, dying in her arms; and Eurydice, hearing of her son, kills herself at the altar. The school's balance is the play's: the edict's defender is destroyed by the edict's enforcement, and the higher law's witness is destroyed by her witness — tragedy being the form in which Athens told itself that the collision of two laws is not a problem with a solution but a wound with a meaning.

The story's legacy is the doctrine's immortality in literature, and the lesson closes with the record of its readings, because Antigone has been re-founded by every age that needed her. Aristotle cites her as the universal law's witness within a century; the natural lawyers quote her through the scholastic centuries; Hegel made her the collision of family and state, divine and human law, in the philosophy of history's most famous reading of a play; Anouilh's Antigone, performed in occupied Paris in 1944 before an audience of German officers, made her the Resistance's parable with Creon played sympathetically enough to pass the censor and clearly enough to be understood by the occupied; A line of later dramatists has re-staged her for their own edicts. The school's last word is the reason the story stands third in this semester, between the philosophers' lives and the Declaration's drafting: Antigone is the proof that the doctrine is older than its arguments and independent of them — that before there was a theory of the higher law there was a girl with dust in her hands, at a corpse, in the dark, doing it — and that every later statement of the doctrine, from Cicero's grove to the Birmingham cell, is a footnote to her defense. The semester's last story brings the doctrine to its most famous sentence, drafted in a rented room in Philadelphia.

Lesson 4: The writing of 'all men are created equal': the story in full

The semester's final story is the doctrine's most consequential drafting: the composition, in June and July of 1776, of the American Declaration of Independence — the document that carried the natural-law tradition out of the treatises and into the world's politics in a single sentence, 'We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal' — and the lesson tells the writing entire, because the story of the words is the doctrine's biography in miniature. The setting: the Second Continental Congress at Philadelphia, in the second year of a war already begun at Lexington and Bunker Hill, moving at last from resistance to rupture. On June 7, Richard Henry Lee of Virginia moved his resolution — that the colonies are, and of right ought to be, free and independent states — and Congress, not yet ready to vote it, appointed on June 11 a committee to draft the declaration that would justify it: John Adams, Benjamin Franklin, Roger Sherman, Robert Livingston, and Thomas Jefferson, thirty-three years old, a Virginia delegate known for his pen, who had lodgings in a bricklayer's house at Market and Seventh and a portable writing desk of his own design on which, in the committee's assignment — pressed on him by Adams, whose reasons Jefferson recorded: that he was the committee's youngest, its Virginian, and its best writer by Adams's own cheerful admission — the draft was composed in some seventeen days of committee meetings, borrowed phrases, and the Philadelphia summer's heat and flies.

The draft's sources are the story's second movement, and the school gives them exactly, because the sentence's authority is the tradition's whole library compressed. Jefferson, who insisted to the end of his life that the Declaration was neither copy nor invention but 'an expression of the American mind,' drew its philosophy from the air the delegates breathed: Locke's Second Treatise above all — the rights of life, liberty, and estate become, in Jefferson's triad, life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness, whether from George Mason's Virginia Declaration of Rights, adopted that same June with its 'enjoyment of life and liberty... and pursuing and obtaining happiness and safety,' or from Jefferson's own hand improving Locke with the Scottish Enlightenment's vocabulary. The preamble's architecture is pure natural law in the course's technical sense: an appeal, in the first sentence, to 'the Laws of Nature and of Nature's God' as the warrant for the separation; the self-evident truths — the doctrine's primary precepts in political dress, held not as conclusions of argument but as the axioms from which argument starts, exactly as Aquinas's first principles are held; the derivation of just government from consent; the right of revolution on the trust's breach; and then — the doctrine turned to indictment — the long train of abuses, the twenty-seven grievances against George III, drafted as a bill of particulars to prove to a candid world that the breach, and not the colonists' ambition, had dissolved the government. Even the draft's most painful passage belongs to the record entire: Jefferson's clause condemning the slave trade as a cruel war against human nature itself, struck out by Congress at the insistence of South Carolina and Georgia, with the northern slave-trading interest concurring — the document's universal sentence surviving its author's own application of it by the width of a committee vote, in the founding's central irony, which the school states as the tradition states its every betrayal: the standard stood, and condemned the standard-bearers, and was quoted by the enslaved against the republic within the generation.

The editing and the adoption complete the story. The committee made its changes — Franklin's among them, in the tradition that gives him 'self-evident' for Jefferson's original 'sacred and undeniable,' the doctrine's epistemology improved in a word, from revelation's register to reason's — and Congress, from July 2 to July 4, performed the heavier edit: the Lee resolution adopted on the 2nd (the day Adams thought would be celebrated forever), the Declaration debated and cut by a quarter, the slavery clause among the losses, and the whole adopted on July 4, 1776, and sent to the printer, whose broadsides carried it through the colonies. The document's career since is the doctrine's modern history in one artifact: read aloud to Washington's army and to the crowds of every capital it inspired; copied, in its architecture of preamble, principles, and grievances, by a hundred declarations after it; invoked by Seneca Falls for women's rights in its own cadence, by the abolitionists as the republic's promissory note, by Ho Chi Minh against the French and the Americans in 1945 in its own opening lines, and by King at the Lincoln Memorial as the note come due — the sentence's universality proving, in each generation, larger than its drafters' application of it, which the tradition counts not as the sentence's hypocrisy but as its design: a self-evident truth, once published, belongs to whoever can read.

The lesson's last word, and the people semester's, is the proportion the four lives together strike. Cicero gave the doctrine its voice and died by the edict; Locke gave it its system and compromised it in his portfolio; Antigone, who never lived, gave it its eternal type; and a committee of slaveholders in a bricklayer's parlor gave it its sentence — the record being, in every case, the same: the standard articulated by the flawed, betrayed by its articulators, and inherited by the betrayed, who alone have never failed to find it in the armory where its authors left it. The school's student should carry that proportion as the semester's keepsake, because it is the doctrine's answer to the cynic and the flatterer alike: the truth of 'all men are created equal' was never vouched by the men who wrote it. The celebrations semester follows, in which the doctrine's modern heirs keep its feasts — a December day for the Declaration of 1948, and the winter solstice, the doctrine's borrowed festival from the nature it is named for.

Back to all lessons · Take this semester’s test