Adult Year 2 · Semester 4 — Places, arts, and the road ahead
Four lessons for this semester. When you are ready, take the test for this semester.
Lesson 1: The synagogue and Jerusalem and the Western Wall
The final semester turns to the tradition's places, and it begins with the two that frame all the others: the synagogue, which is everywhere, and Jerusalem, which is one place on earth and the direction of every synagogue's ark. The synagogue first, as a place and not only an institution: Judaism's most numerous sacred building, of which the student has met the inside in Year One — the ark on the Jerusalem wall, the bimah at the center, the eternal light — and whose history the lesson now walks as architecture. The oldest synagogue ruins, at Masada and Gamla and a dozen sites of the late Second Temple age, are assembly halls of benches around an open floor: the congregation seated facing itself and the reader, the building as a meeting given stones. The diaspora's centuries made it everything the exiles needed — prayer house, school, court, hostel, treasury — and its styles married the tradition to every host civilization: the wooden synagogues of Poland, painted with zodiac and jungle; the Moorish and the classical and the modernist synagogues of the emancipated West; the synagogue of Dura-Europos on the Euphrates, its walls covered in the third century with biblical frescoes that astonished the scholars who uncovered them — the imageless tradition, painting its stories in color on its farthest frontier, the exception by which the rule's history is dated.
Jerusalem, the second place, is the tradition's geography concentrated to a single point, and the lesson must give its sanctity in the tradition's own register before the record's. Jerusalem is where Abraham bound Isaac, in the tradition's identification of Moriah with the Temple Mount; where David made his capital and Solomon his Temple; the city of the Psalms' longing — 'If I forget you, O Jerusalem, let my right hand forget its skill,' sung at weddings before the glass breaks — and of the liturgy's daily petitions for its rebuilding; the direction of prayer for every synagogue and every Jew at prayer in the world, the body's compass set to one city's coordinates for two thousand years of dispersion. The school's student should grasp the singularity: no other tradition in this building directs all its prayer, everywhere on earth, to one city — and the direction survived the city's loss, its forbidden entry, its nineteen centuries under other faiths' flags, the longing itself becoming, in the Zionist century, a politics that returned a sovereign Jewish state to the city in 1948 and to its eastern half, with the Old City and the Mount, in 1967 — events the tradition reads, in its camps' several ways, as history, as redemption's dawn, or as the state's business, the argument being, by now in the course, familiarly Jewish and unresolved.
The Western Wall — the Kotel — is the city's point of points, and the lesson ends its survey at the stones. The Wall is a retaining wall of Herod's expansion of the Temple Mount, built around the turn of the era to hold the vast platform on which the Second Temple stood: not a wall of the Temple itself, but the surviving structure closest to the Holy of Holies' site, and therefore, across the centuries when Jews were barred from the Mount above, the place of prayer at the sanctuary's foot. Its plaza, cleared in 1967 from the houses that had crowded its ancient alley, receives the tradition's whole life in a single frame: the bar mitzvah boys chanting on Mondays and Thursdays, the soldiers swearing in at dusk, the notes to God pressed by the million into the cracks between the Herodian stones — cleared twice a year and buried, by custom, on the Mount of Olives, unopened. The Wall's own arrangements are the tradition's living argument in masonry: the mechitza dividing the men's and women's sections, the contested southern plaza where the non-Orthodox movements' egalitarian prayer has been negotiated, suspended, and fought over for a generation — the school recording the argument, at the very stones, as the course's final proof that in this tradition even the holiest place is not a museum but a courtroom, a schoolroom, and a home, all arguing at once.
The lesson's last word sets the two places in their relation, which is the tradition's whole spatial theology. The synagogue is Jerusalem portable: its ark a small Mount, its direction a compass needle, its congregation the city in exile — which is why a people could lose the one place for nineteen centuries and not lose its way, carrying the direction in every room it prayed in. And Jerusalem is the synagogue's promise kept in stone: the proof, in the tradition's reading, that the portable holiness was always a direction and not a destination's substitute. The student who has understood the two places together understands the geography the next lesson miniaturizes onto a table: the scroll that is a portable Torah as the synagogue is a portable Jerusalem, the ark that houses it, and the seder table that is a portable Temple — the tradition's genius, at every scale, for making the holy thing carryable, until the day it can be set down, in the place, at last.
Lesson 2: The Torah scroll and the ark and the seder table
The second places lesson descends the scale from the city to the room and from the room to the table: the Torah scroll, the ark that houses it, and the seder table — the tradition's three portable holy places, each of which the student has met in use and now studies as a place, with its own geography, protocol, and theology. The scroll first, in its materiality, completing Year One's guided overview with the craftsman's facts. A sefer Torah is made of the skins of a kosher animal, prepared as parchment; its ink is compounded to a recipe of gallnuts and soot; its scribe writes with a quill, in the Ashkenazi or Sephardi hand of his tradition, some three hundred thousand letters, crowning certain letters with the little crownlets the tradition calls tagin, and a single error — a letter cracked, joined, or misplaced — suspends the scroll's fitness until a scribe repairs it. The scroll is sewn sheet to sheet with sinews, mounted on its rollers — the Trees of Life, atzei chayim, in the tradition's naming of its furniture from Proverbs — dressed in mantle and breastplate and crown when it rests, and handled in procession with a protocol of honor the student saw in Year One: never touched by the bare hand in the reading, followed by the yad, the silver pointer, lest the oil of skin harm the ink and the hand presume upon the holy. A scroll worn past repair is not discarded: it is buried, in an earthenware jar in the cemetery, like a scholar — the tradition's final word on what the object is.
The ark — aron hakodesh, the holy ark — is the scroll's house and the synagogue's throne room in one, and the lesson gives its geography. It stands on the Jerusalem-facing wall, recalling the ark of the covenant that held the tablets in the Tabernacle's and Temple's Holy of Holies — the synagogue's ark being, in the tradition's own understanding, the successor of that ark, with the scrolls as the tablets' living form. Its curtain, the parochet, recalls the Temple's veil and carries the congregation's dedications embroidered in gold; its doors open for the service's high moments — the taking out and returning of the Torah, the priestly blessing, the Nevi'im's and the Days of Awe's solemnities, when the congregation stands for an open ark as subjects for an opened palace gate. Above it burns the ner tamid, the eternal light, and above that, in many congregations, the tablets of the Ten Words or the verse that states the room's whole direction: 'I have set the LORD always before me.' The school's student should read the ark as the tradition reads it: not a cupboard but a palace in miniature, the one piece of furniture in the building that is treated as an address — prayers are said facing it, grief and joy are announced before it, and the scroll carried from it in procession is received, as Year One described, as a sovereign among his people.
The seder table, the lesson's third place, is the home's claim to stand in this list, and the tradition makes the claim without embarrassment: since the Temple's fall, the table of the Jewish home has been read as the altar's successor — the rabbis' teaching that in the Temple's day the altar atoned, and now a person's table atones, by the Torah spoken over it and the poor fed at it — and the seder table is that doctrine's annual coronation. Its geography is a map of the Exodus in objects, as Year Two's Passover lesson laid out: the plate's six symbols in their order, the matzot in their cloths, the four cups standing for the four redemptions, Elijah's cup and the open door, the cushions for reclining as free people recline, the afikoman hidden like the future. Around the table sits the tradition's whole constitution in miniature: the youngest asking, the elders answering, the stranger invited, the poor provided for, the story told as a legal obligation and eaten as a meal. The school's point, in placing the table beside the ark, is the tradition's own democracy of holiness: the holiest night of the home's year requires no priest, no rabbi, no building but a room and no instrument but a table set with symbols — the sanctuary reduced, by twenty centuries of practice, to the dimensions of a family's dinner, and not diminished.
The lesson's last word gathers the three places into the tradition's single spatial idea, which the final lessons of the course will carry into the arts and the road ahead. Scroll, ark, and table are one argument at three scales: that holiness in this tradition attaches not to sites that cannot move but to a text that can be carried, a direction that can be faced from anywhere, and a meal that can be set in any room — the portable constitution the history semester credited with the survival, here seen at the resolution of furniture. The student who has watched a scroll processed through a congregation, kissed by a hundred prayer books as it passes, has seen the argument performed: the sovereign is a book, the palace is a cupboard of carved wood, the temple is a table — and the people who arranged their holiness so have carried it through every geography on earth without once being separated from it by anything but death, and not always then. The arts in which this people's imagination dressed its portable holiness are the next lesson's subject.
Lesson 3: Art, music, and literature of Judaism
The third lesson of the final semester surveys the imagination of the tradition — its art, its music, and its literature — a survey that must begin with the paradox the student is now prepared to appreciate: a tradition whose second commandment forbids the graven image produced, across three thousand years, one of the world's great visual, musical, and literary civilizations, and the negotiation between the prohibition and the imagination is the survey's plot. The visual arts first. The commandment's classic interpretation forbade the image of God and the idol, not the image as such — and within that boundary the tradition decorated everything it touched: the synagogue floors of late antiquity paved with zodiacs and the binding of Isaac in mosaic, the Dura frescoes of the previous lesson, the illuminated manuscripts of medieval Spain and Germany — the Haggadahs above all, their margins alive with the Exodus in contemporary dress — the papercuts and the mizrah plaques of the folk tradition, the silver of the ritual objects, Torah crowns and pointers and lamps, in which the silversmiths of Yemen and Poland made the tradition's characteristic masterpieces: beauty lavished, by the commandment's own logic, on the instruments of the word rather than on the word's Speaker. The modern age added the painters — the Jewish schools of Paris, Chagall above all, whose floating rabbis and fiddlers and crucifixions carried the shtetl's memory into modernism's center — and the architects of the synagogues and the memorials, until the tradition that began by refusing the image had filled the museums.
The music, second, is the tradition's least archivable and most continuous art. Its strata lie one on another like the texts': the cantillation of the Torah reading, the te'amim whose accents carry the text's syntax and sense in melody, of an antiquity no one can date and a fidelity every community guards; the liturgical chant, the nusach, the prayer modes of the seasons, in which a trained ear knows the festival by the melody before a word is understood; the cantorial golden age of the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, when the great chazzanim of Eastern Europe and America were opera stars of the synagogue, their improvisations recorded on the era's shellac; the Hasidic niggun, the wordless melody that is Hasidism's theology in sound — the tune as a vessel of devotion beyond language, repeated until the singers are, in the masters' intention, praying with the whole body; and the folk strata beneath everything, the klezmer of the wedding bands, the Yiddish theater song, the Sephardi romancero carrying medieval Spain's ballads in the mouths of grandmothers in Salonika and Jerusalem into the age of recording. The school's student should note what the tradition's music proves about its texts: a people that could not always keep its books kept its melodies, and the melodies carried the books' words across the centuries when the books were burned.
The literature, third and largest, returns the student to the course's home ground, now with the whole library in view. Beyond the canon and the Talmud of Year One stand the tradition's twenty centuries of writing in a dozen languages: the midrash and the piyyut, the liturgical poetry that made the prayer book a national anthology; the medieval Hebrew poetry of Spain, Halevi and ibn Gabirol writing love songs and God-songs in Arabic meters; the philosophical and legal summae; the Yiddish literature that flowered in the nineteenth century into a world literature entire — Mendele, Sholem Aleichem, Peretz — and its Hebrew twin, the revival's prose from Bialik to Agnon, the Nobel laureate who wrote Jerusalem's traditional world into modern fiction; the literatures of the diaspora in its languages, from the German and Russian Jewish novels to the American century's Bellow, Roth, and Malamud, and the Israeli literature in the revived tongue, arguing with the tradition from inside its own house. And over the whole survey stands the literature of the catastrophe and its aftermath, the testimony of the survivors and the second generation's reckoning, which the modern reader cannot shelve as one genre among others: it is the tradition's book of Lamentations for its own age, still being written.
The lesson's last word weighs the arts by the school's measure, as the year's other surveys were weighed. The tradition's imagination asks the artist for what its law asks the merchant: fidelity inside a boundary — the image that may not depict its God, the melody that must carry its text, the story that argues with its canon — and it forbids, as the ethics forbade, the claim that the work is innocent of the covenant. What it has made, under that discipline, is an art whose signature across all its media is the word made sensible: letters crowned in silver, texts chanted in modes older than their notation, stories retold until the retelling is the tradition. The student leaves the survey with the course's whole argument in his hands at last: Judaism is a civilization built around a book — its art the book's illumination, its music the book's chant, its places the book's furniture, its ethics the book's law, its calendar the book's anniversaries. The final lesson asks what the student, book in hand, does next.
Lesson 4: Continuing to learn about Judaism
The final lesson of the Judaism school is addressed, as the building's final lessons are, to the student himself: how to go on learning about a tradition that is three thousand years old, fifteen million people strong, and — the gift this subject offers above most in the building — open. The school's first counsel is the one it gave in the introduction and can now give with the course's authority: go and sit with the living readers. Judaism's congregation is not sealed: the synagogue's gallery welcomes the visitor who comes with respect and a phone call ahead; the seder table has an invitation built into its liturgy; the study houses run open classes in every city of the Jewish world, and the movements' introduction-to-Judaism courses — which serve converts, the intermarried, and the simply curious in one classroom — are the tradition's own front door, kept unlocked on purpose. The student who has finished this course is qualified for the only credential the tradition ultimately honors in a learner: a question, asked in a room where the text is open. The school's second counsel is its method, restated as the graduate's discipline: keep the columns the course has kept — the tradition's account of itself, in its texts and teachers; the record, in the historians' and the archaeologists' work; and the testimony, in the memoirs and the living voices — and let each correct the others without letting any one of them be mistaken for the whole.
The working shelf, given plainly as the sister course gave its own: For the texts, the Tanakh in a Jewish translation with the commentaries' voices in the margin — the Jewish Publication Society's and the study Bibles of the movements — and the Talmud in the Steinsaltz or a comparable guided edition, begun anywhere, a page a day being the tradition's own prescription. For the practice, the siddur of any movement, read as the autobiography Year One called it, and the year's cycle lived once at a table the student is invited to. For the history, the historians of the ancient world and of the modern catastrophe alike, and the memoirs — the survivors' testimony above all, while the last of the witnesses are still, at the time of writing, alive to be heard in person, an opportunity whose closing the student should feel as the obligation it is. For the argument, the tradition's own journals and the movements' platforms, where the questions this course left open — the Messiah's nature, the law's authority, the stranger at the modern gate, the women's place at the scroll — are debated weekly by the people whose questions they are. The school adds the counsel of its empty places: this room's congregation, alone among the building's hardest subjects, can be asked — and the student who does not ask has declined the subject's chief advantage.
The third counsel concerns the student's own position, and the school speaks it with the care this tradition's history demands. The student studies Judaism in a world where the caricatures the course warned against are not history but current events — where the oldest hatred, in the phrase the historians use, periodically re-arms itself from the same poisoned wells the lessons recorded from Norwich onward — and the graduate's literacy is therefore not an ornament but a responsibility: to know the tradition well enough to recognize the libel when it recycles, and to say, in whatever room he sits in, what the record actually shows. The school asks no advocacy of its graduate — it is a school, not a synagogue, and it has taught the tradition's critics inside the tradition with the same respect as its defenders — but it does ask accuracy, which is advocacy's honest minimum: the facts in full, the columns separate, the people remembered as people. Between the libel and the romance — for the philosemitic romance, which makes Jews into symbols of virtue, is the libel's mirror and equally a refusal to see persons — stands the position this course has occupied and now hands over: a real people, with a real book, a real argument, and a real table, at which the student has been, for two years of lessons, an invited guest.
The course's last word is the school's farewell to this room, and it borrows the tradition's own closing gesture, as is fitting. When a tractate of the Talmud is finished, the students say Hadran alakh — 'We will return to you' — because the tradition's books are not finished but only paused, the cycle of reading rolling the scroll back to its beginning as Simchat Torah rolls the Torah. The student leaves the Judaism school in that posture: the course complete, the subject not — the seder still to be sat at, the page still to be argued, the question still to be asked in the room where the text is open. The school thanks the student for learning about Judaism in the only spirit in which it can honestly be taught: with its texts in the center, its people at the table, and its God — the One of the Shema, the Creator of the covenant, the God of Abraham and of the stranger — confessed by its believers and described, never impersonated, by its school. Hadran alakh: we will return to you.