Adult Year 1 · Semester 3 — Texts and teachings
Four lessons for this semester. When you are ready, take the test for this semester.
Lesson 1: The Torah: a guided overview
The texts semester opens with the book at the tradition's center, and the overview begins with the object itself, because Judaism's reverence for the Torah is physical before it is literary. A Torah scroll — sefer Torah — is handwritten by a trained scribe, a sofer, with quill and ink on parchment prepared from a kosher animal's skin, some three hundred thousand letters copied under rules that make a single malformed letter a defect rendering the scroll unfit for public reading until repaired. The work takes a year or more; the scroll is dressed in its mantle and silver ornaments, crowned in many communities with a crown of silver — keter Torah — and kept in the ark, the aron, on the synagogue's Jerusalem-facing wall, behind a curtain recalling the Temple's veil. On Sabbaths and festivals the scroll is carried in procession among the congregation, who touch its mantle with a prayer book or the fringes of a tallit and kiss the fingers that touched it, before it is laid on the reading table and unrolled to the week's portion. The school's student should understand the choreography before the contents: this is a community that treats its book as other nations treat a sovereign — housed in a palace, dressed in a crown, attended in procession — because in its constitution, that is what the Torah is.
The contents, in guided outline: five books, and the student should be able to walk their arc. Genesis — creation, the patriarchs, the descent to Egypt — the book of beginnings and of the covenant's family. Exodus — slavery, Moses, the liberation, Sinai and the Ten Commandments, the building of the Tabernacle — the book of the people's birth and its constitution's giving. Leviticus — the priests' book: sacrifices, purity, the holiness code with its ethical summit, 'you shall be holy, for I the LORD your God am holy,' and the command to love the neighbor placed, the student should note, in the ritual book's heart. Numbers — the wilderness generation: censuses, rebellions, the long dying of the slave generation and the rise of the freeborn at the Jordan's bank. Deuteronomy — Moses's second law and farewell: the covenant renewed, the Shema, the blessings and the curses, and the death of the prophet within sight of the land he may not enter, with which the scroll ends — and is rolled back, on the autumn festival of Simchat Torah, to Genesis's first word before the congregation's eyes, the reading never finished because the book is never finished.
The reading of the Torah is itself one of the tradition's institutions, and the overview names its machinery. The five books are divided into fifty-four weekly portions, parashot, read entire in the synagogue over the course of a year — the annual cycle that makes every literate Jew a companion of the whole text — each portion chanted from the unvocalized scroll by a trained reader to a melody fixed by the cantillation marks, the te'amim, printed in study editions. The reading is followed by the haftarah, a paired passage from the Prophets chosen across the centuries for its echo of the portion's theme. Around the public reading stands the private obligation of study: the commandment of Talmud Torah, learning, which the tradition ranks as equal to all the other commandments because it leads to them all — studied in the home at the Sabbath table, in the study house in pairs (the chavruta method, two students arguing a text aloud, which is Judaism's characteristic learning technology), and in the sermon that applies the week's portion to the week's life.
The overview's last word concerns the Torah's authority and its interpretation, the hinge on which the next two lessons turn. In Orthodox teaching the Torah is divine dictation: Moses wrote at God's word, and every letter is God's — a claim the tradition states without embarrassment and the academic column examines with its tools, dating the text's composition and editing across the first millennium BCE and identifying, in the documentary hypothesis and its successors, the strands of sources woven into the five books the student has just walked. Conservative and Reform teaching stand between and beside: revelation real but mediated, the text inspired and humanly transmitted, its authority covenantal rather than dictational. The school gives the range as the tradition's own living argument — conducted, characteristically, over the same scroll, in the same study houses, by people who kiss the same mantle in procession. The guided tour proceeds from the five books to the library that surrounds them: the Tanakh entire, the Hebrew Bible in its three wings.
Lesson 2: The Tanakh — the Hebrew Bible: a guided overview
The second text of the semester is the whole library of which the Torah is the first wing: the Tanakh, the Hebrew Bible, whose very name is the guided tour's map — an acronym of its three parts, Torah (Teaching), Nevi'im (Prophets), and Ketuvim (Writings). The canon closed, by the rabbis' account, in the centuries around the turn of the era, and its twenty-four books — the same texts the Christian Old Testament counts as thirty-nine by a different division — have been read by Jews in this order and this grouping ever since, an order that is itself an interpretation: where the Christian arrangement ends with the prophets and Malachi's promise, the Tanakh ends with Chronicles and the Persian king Cyrus's decree sending the exiles home — the Jewish Bible's last word being not prophecy but return, history's door left open into the student's own course. The school walks the three wings in turn, as the overview requires, at the pace of a guide who knows the student will return.
The Prophets, Nevi'im, divide into the Former and the Latter. The Former Prophets — Joshua, Judges, Samuel, Kings — are history written as theology: the conquest and settlement, the charismatic judges, the rise of the monarchy through Samuel the kingmaker, David's kingdom and Solomon's Temple, the schism into Israel and Judah, and the long decline to the two destructions, of Samaria by Assyria in 722 BCE and Jerusalem by Babylon in 586 — a national epic whose narrators judge every king by one measure, fidelity to the covenant. The Latter Prophets are the preaching books: the three great scrolls of Isaiah, Jeremiah, and Ezekiel, and the Book of the Twelve, the minor prophets from Hosea to Malachi. Here the tradition's ethical voice sounds at its most uncompromising — Amos demanding that justice roll down like waters, Isaiah imagining the nations' pilgrimage to a Jerusalem of peace, Jeremiah forging the idea of a covenant written on the heart, Ezekiel carrying the exiles a vision of dry bones that the modern world has never stopped quoting. The haftarah cycle of the previous lesson draws on this wing, so that the synagogue's year is a dialogue between Torah and Prophets, law and its conscience.
The Writings, Ketuvim, are the library's most various wing — the proof, the school suggests, that a canon can hold a civilization's whole inner life. The Psalms, the prayer book of the Temple become the prayer book of every Jew, 150 poems of praise, lament, thanksgiving, and rage at God that the tradition ascribes to David and the liturgy uses daily. Proverbs and Ecclesiastes, the wisdom books, argue with each other inside the canon — Proverbs certain that the righteous prosper, Ecclesiastes answering that all is vapor and the race is not to the swift — and the book of Job, the Bible's great theodicy drama, sides with the questioner against the comforters who defend God with falsehoods. The five scrolls, the Megillot, attach to the festivals: the Song of Songs at Passover, Ruth at Shavuot, Lamentations — the eyewitness poetry of 586 — on the Ninth of Av, Ecclesiastes at Sukkot, Esther at Purim. Daniel and Ezra-Nehemiah and the Chronicles complete the wing: apocalypse, restoration, and the whole history retold from the priests' side — the canon closing, as the lesson began by noting, with the exile's homecoming decree.
The overview's last word is about how the Tanakh is read, because the student's next lesson — the Talmud — is nothing but that reading become a library of its own. Judaism reads its Bible through commentary as a matter of principle: the plain sense, peshat, pursued by the medieval grammarians of Spain and France — Rashi of Troyes, whose commentary on Torah and Talmud became so canonical that it is printed in the margin of every study edition, the text and its reader facing each other on the page — and the homiletic sense, derash, by which the rabbis drew the text into every corner of life, law, and hope. No generation reads alone: the printed page of the Tanakh in its great Rabbinic Bible edition surrounds the verse with Targum, Rashi, and the medieval voices arguing across the centuries in the margins, the chavruta of the dead and the living conducted in type. The student who understands that page — text at the center, interpretation as its atmosphere — understands the Jewish book, and is ready for the library where interpretation itself became scripture's partner: the Talmud, the teachings of the rabbis.
Lesson 3: The Talmud — teachings of the rabbis: a guided overview
The third text is the tradition's second sea: the Talmud, the vast record of the rabbis' teaching between roughly the third and sixth centuries, which the previous lessons have quoted on every page and which the student now meets as a book — or rather, as the school must first explain, as two books and a continent. At its core stands the Mishnah, the code of Jewish law compiled in Hebrew by Rabbi Judah the Prince in the land of Israel around 200 CE: six orders, sixty-three tractates, covering agriculture and festivals, marriage and damages, sacrifices and purity — the Oral Torah's first written frame, terse as a telegram and meant to be unpacked by memory and debate. Around the Mishnah the rabbis of two centers built the Gemara, the Aramaic discussion that argues the code line by line: the Jerusalem Talmud, completed in the Galilee around 400 CE, and the Babylonian Talmud, the Bavli, completed in the academies of Sasanian Persia around 500–600 CE, which history made the authoritative one — the Talmud, unqualified, in every study house since, running in its standard edition to 2,711 folio pages.
A page of the Bavli is the guided tour's necessary exhibit, because its geography is the tradition's mind made visible. At the center, the Mishnah's paragraph and the Gemara's discussion of it; in the inner margin, Rashi's commentary explaining the words; in the outer, the Tosafot, the medieval Franco-German glosses arguing with Rashi and the text together; around the edges, cross-references, later codes, and the notes of five further centuries — a page that must be read in several directions at once, in two languages and a dozen typefaces, by students who learn its map as children learn a city's streets. The discussion's method is the dialectic the student met in the chavruta: a ruling is cited, an objection raised from another ruling, a distinction drawn, a story told — for the Talmud is roughly a third law, halakha, and the rest aggadah: narrative, parable, theology, medicine, dream-lore, and the rabbis' astonishingly frank talk about God, death, and each other. Nothing human is foreign to it, including doubt about its own enterprise: the same tractates that legislate the Sabbath's thirty-nine labors preserve the story of the oven of Akhnai, in which the rabbis overrule a voice from heaven itself — 'It is not in heaven,' the Torah's verse is made to say; the law, once given, is Israel's to interpret — and God, in the story's famous ending, laughs and says, 'My children have defeated Me.'
The Talmud's authority in Jewish life is the overview's third station. For traditional Judaism it is, with the Tanakh, the constitution: the codes — Maimonides' Mishneh Torah, the Shulchan Aruch — are its distillations, the yeshiva's curriculum its continuation, and the daf yomi, the daily folio by which a worldwide fellowship of learners completes the whole Talmud in seven and a half years, its most democratic modern institution, filling stadiums at each cycle's completion with tens of thousands who studied the same page on the same day. The movements read it variously, as the course has shown throughout: Orthodoxy as binding law's source, Conservatism as the law's historical record and continuing court, Reform as the treasury of the tradition's ethics and imagination, binding in neither letter nor system. The academic column reads it as the great archive of late-antique Jewish life, edited across centuries, its attributions and layers the subject of a scholarly literature of its own — and the school's student, by now practiced, will hold the columns without confusion: the Talmud is at once a law code, a national literature, and a historical source, and each reading is true to a part of it.
The overview's last word returns the student to the school's own method, because the Talmud is the closest thing in this building to the school's ideal of a subject: a tradition that preserved its disagreements as its scripture. 'These and these are the words of the living God,' the Talmud says of two rival schools' contradictory rulings — the house of Hillel's leniencies prevailing in practice, the house of Shammai's stringencies preserved on the page forever, honored as Torah though not followed. A library that canonizes its minority opinions, that records the argument and not only the verdict, that lets a heavenly voice lose — such a library trains its readers in a discipline the student of every room in this building can envy: fidelity without unanimity, authority that argues. The texts semester closes with the question the Talmud's existence poses to the present: how this ocean is navigated now — the study, translation, and argument of the living tradition, interpretation and study today.
Lesson 4: Interpretation and study today
The texts semester closes in the present tense: how the Torah, the Tanakh, and the Talmud are interpreted and studied now — by the tradition's own institutions, by the universities, and by the ordinary Jews whose study the commandment of Talmud Torah was always meant to command. The first fact of the present is scale. The yeshiva world — the full-time academies of the Orthodox, from Jerusalem and Bnei Brak to Lakewood, New Jersey, now among the largest such institutions in Jewish history — enrolls more full-time Torah students than any previous age of the tradition, supported by a communal economy that treats the scholar's learning as the community's collective mitzvah. Beside it stand the movements' seminaries — the Conservative, Reform, and Reconstructionist rabbinical schools — and the universities, where Jewish studies is an academic discipline with its own journals and chairs, reading the same texts with the historian's and the philologist's tools the course's academic column represents. And beneath the institutions runs the democratization the printing press began and the internet completed: the Talmud translated entire into English and a dozen languages, the whole library of the tradition digitized and searchable, the daf yomi learned by commuters from a phone — study that once required a master's permission and a village's library now requiring a connection.
The methods of the present are the tradition's old methods at new speeds, plus one genuinely new argument the lesson must give in depth: who may study, and who may teach. For most of the tradition's history, the Talmud's academy was male — the commandment of study, as the rabbis read it, obliging men and exempting women, whose Torah education ran through the home, the women's prayers, and in many communities a rich vernacular literature of devotion written for them. The modern age has contested the exemption in every movement: Orthodox feminism founding women's Talmud programs and, in some communities, ordaining women under titles the Orthodox world argues about fiercely; the non-Orthodox movements ordaining women as rabbis since 1972 — Regina Jonas, ordained in Berlin in 1935 and murdered at Auschwitz, recovered by historians as the first — until women now lead congregations, head academies, and sit on law committees across most of the Jewish world. The school presents the argument as it has presented the tradition's others: as Judaism arguing with itself, in its own categories, about fidelity — the conservatives citing the exemption's antiquity, the reformers citing the tradition's own principle that the Torah's study is the whole people's crown.
The second new fact is the conversation between the study house and the university, which the present conducts at full volume and the student should learn to hear as one conversation. The academic study of the Bible — source criticism, archaeology, the comparative Near East — sits in the same Jewish reader's library as Rashi and the Talmud, and the movements have each made their peace or their war with it in their fashion: Orthodoxy's spectrum from refusal to the religious Zionist universities that teach both columns in adjacent classrooms; the non-Orthodox seminaries requiring the academic methods as the rabbinate's tools. Translations mark the conversation's progress: the Jewish Publication Society's Tanakh, the Koren and ArtScroll and Steinsaltz Talmuds — Steinsaltz, who translated the Bavli entire into modern Hebrew and then English, explaining it for the common reader, being the age's emblem of the democratized text. The school's own curriculum is a small citizen of this world: it has taught the tradition in two columns throughout precisely because the living tradition now studies in two columns, and the student's literacy in both is the course's definition of an educated reader.
The lesson's last word, and the texts semester's, is about the student's place in the chain he has been studying. The tradition's own image for study is a chain of transmission — Pirkei Avot, the Mishnah's tractate of the fathers, opens by tracing the Torah from Moses through the prophets and the rabbis to the present, and enrolls every new student as its next link — and the image is not a metaphor the tradition uses lightly: to study the text in the chavruta's argument, to ask the question the margin has not answered, is in its account to stand in the chain and extend it. The school, which is not the tradition and speaks for no synagogue, can still honor the image by borrowing it for its farewell to the texts: the student who has walked the Torah, the Tanakh, and the Talmud with this course has not mastered them — no one has; the sea has no far shore in the rabbis' own saying — but he has learned their geography, their languages of argument, and the way in. The practice semester now shows what the texts look like when they leave the study house and enter the week: the candles of Friday evening, and the day of rest they kindle.