Adult Year 1 · Semester 2 — History
Four lessons for this semester. When you are ready, take the test for this semester.
Lesson 1: The origins of Judaism
The history semester begins where the tradition begins its own account, and the school's method with ancient origins is the one the student has met in other rooms: the tradition's narrative given in full and with respect, and the historians' reconstruction given beside it, each in its own column, neither used to mock the other. The tradition's narrative opens not with a nation but with a family: Abraham's call out of Mesopotamia, the covenant, the descent of his grandson Jacob's twelve sons into Egypt, their enslavement, and the Exodus under Moses — the events the foundations semester studied as faith's content. At Mount Sinai, in the narrative, the family becomes a people under law; in Canaan it becomes a tribal league, then a kingdom — Saul, David, Solomon — with its Temple built in Jerusalem around the tenth century BCE; and in 586 BCE the kingdom falls to Babylon, the Temple burns, and the exile begins in which, the historians and the tradition agree on this much, the religion the world knows as Judaism was decisively formed.
The historians' column works from the ground and the neighboring archives. The earliest outside reference to Israel is the Egyptian Merneptah stele of about 1208 BCE, naming a people Israel in Canaan; the archaeology of the highland villages of the following centuries shows a new population whose material culture — its houses, its avoidance of pork in the bone record — fits the emergence of early Israel largely from within Canaan's own people rather than by the conquest the book of Joshua describes at full scale. The Exodus, the historians say with care, has left no Egyptian record at the Torah's scale, and most reconstruct a smaller historical kernel — a group, perhaps the Levites among others, that did come out of Egypt bearing the worship of the God whose name the tradition confesses — around which the national memory gathered every Israelite into the story, as the seder's command to see oneself as personally redeemed requires. The school presents this column as scholarship, not as verdict: the tradition's claim for the Exodus was never chiefly an archaeological one, and the student who confuses the columns will misjudge both.
What the record does establish beyond serious dispute is the transformation of the exile and the return. In Babylon the deported Judeans — deprived of land, king, and Temple — built the portable Judaism that would outlive every empire: the Sabbath and circumcision kept as identity's marks in a foreign land, the Scriptures gathered and edited, the synagogue's ancestor in the assembly of exiles, the God of Israel confessed as God of heaven and earth whose house could be a people's memory. Under Persia's permission, exiles returned; Ezra the scribe read the Torah publicly to the assembled people in Jerusalem — the scene in Nehemiah that scholars call Judaism's founding moment as a religion of a book — and the Second Temple rose, to stand for nearly six centuries as the faith's sacrificial center. Around it grew the world the student will meet in the texts semester: priests and scribes, Pharisees and Sadducees, the Greek and then the Roman empires pressing in, and a people's life increasingly carried by interpretation of the written Torah — the development that would let Judaism survive the Temple's second destruction.
The origins lesson's last word is the survival itself, stated as the historical fact it is, because the rest of the course is unintelligible without it. In 70 CE Rome destroyed the Second Temple, as Babylon had destroyed the First, and this time there was no return and no rebuilding: the sacrificial system that had centered the religion for a thousand years ended forever. What happened next is the tradition's own account of its genius and the historians' agreement with it: under rabbis like Yohanan ben Zakkai, who obtained Rome's permission for a study center at Yavneh, Judaism re-founded itself on the portable pillars the exile had prepared — Torah study, prayer in the synagogue 'in place of sacrifice,' and the mitzvot of the home and the market — and became, in that form, the religion that has now carried a scattered people through nineteen further centuries. The origins of Judaism are therefore double in time as well as in column: a Bronze and Iron Age people's birth in Canaan, and a rabbinic rebirth after catastrophe, and the student holds both because the tradition does.
Lesson 2: Abraham and the early community
The second history lesson lingers with the patriarchs, because the tradition does: the book of Genesis devotes more chapters to Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob than to creation and flood together, and the early community it portrays — a family, not yet a nation — is Judaism's self-portrait of its own beginnings. The narrative, in the Torah's order: Abraham's call and covenant, studied in the foundations; his journey to Canaan, his sojourns in Egypt and Gerar, the birth of Ishmael to Hagar and of Isaac to Sarah in her old age; the binding of Isaac; Isaac's quieter life, the well-digger of Beersheba; and Jacob, the younger twin who takes the blessing and Esau's birthright, dreams at Bethel of the ladder between earth and heaven, wrestles at the Jabbok with the mysterious stranger until dawn and receives the name Israel — 'he who strives with God' — and fathers, by Leah and Rachel and their servants, the twelve sons whose names the tribes will carry. The student should notice what kind of ancestors these are: chosen, promised, and blessed — and deceivers, fugitives, and failures in the same chapters, a family the text refuses to idealize, whose God keeps covenant with them not because they are righteous but because He promised.
Around the narrative the tradition built its readings, and the lesson gives the early community as the rabbis saw it, because that seeing is the history of the text's life. Abraham becomes, in the Midrash, the discoverer of God by reason and the world's first missionary, his tent open on four sides; Sarah, the matriarch whose laughter names her son, a prophetess in her own right in the rabbis' ranking; Rebecca, who perceives which twin carries the promise and acts on it; Rachel and Leah, whose rivalry and sisterhood the commentators read as the nation's own divided heart. The early community's institutions, in the tradition's reading, already contain the later religion in seed: Abraham prays and intercedes — the rabbis credit him with instituting the morning prayer; Isaac, the afternoon; Jacob, the evening — circumcision marks the covenant, hospitality crowns the virtues, and the burial cave at Machpelah makes Hebron the first of the holy cities, the patriarchs' and matriarchs' tomb a pilgrimage place to this day, in a city whose modern tensions the lesson notes as the ancient story's unfinished business.
The historians' column, applied to the patriarchs with the school's usual care, asks its different question: not what the stories mean, but when their world was. The narratives' details — the camels, the Philistines, the Aramean wanderings, the customs of adoption and inheritance paralleled in the second-millennium archives of Nuzi and Mari — led an older scholarship to date the patriarchs to a historical 'patriarchal age' in the early second millennium BCE; a later scholarship, noting details that fit the first millennium better, reads the stories as the nation's self-understanding composed in the kingdom's and exile's centuries, whatever older memories they carry. The individual patriarchs stand beyond the reach of outside attestation either way — no Egyptian or Mesopotamian text names Abraham — and the school states the scholarly position exactly: the stories cannot be verified as biography, and were not preserved as biography, but as the covenant's family album, whose truth for the tradition lies in the relationship they narrate. The student who needs the columns to fight has misunderstood both: archaeology can date a camel bone; it cannot date a promise.
The lesson's last word follows the early community to Egypt, where Genesis leaves it — seventy souls gone down, in the Torah's count, to become in four centuries a multitude of slaves — and marks the transition the next lesson takes up. The family becomes a people in the house of bondage; the God of the fathers becomes, in Exodus's burning bush, the God who has heard the groaning of a nation; and the promises made at tent doors and wellsides are cashed, at the sea, as national redemption. The early community's legacy to everything after is the pattern the whole tradition repeats: election of the unlikely — the younger son, the barren wife, the fugitive shepherd — and a covenant kept through the chosen ones' failures by the Chooser's faithfulness. Judaism will spend three thousand years arguing about what that pattern obliges. It begins arguing, as the next lesson shows, the moment the people becomes a kingdom, a scripture, and a diaspora — the long growth, change, and reform of the tradition's middle years.
Lesson 3: Growth, change, and reform
The third history lesson follows the tradition through its long middle — the centuries in which the rabbinic Judaism formed at Yavneh grew into a civilization, met Islam and Christendom, philosophy and persecution, and produced, in the modern age, the movements that call themselves its reform and its conservation. The first growth is textual and total: between the second and sixth centuries the rabbis of the land of Israel and of Babylonia compiled the Mishnah, the Jerusalem and Babylonian Talmuds, and the great Midrash collections — the Oral Torah in its classic form, an ocean of law and story in which the Bible's every verse is argued into daily application. Around the text grew the diaspora's institutions: the synagogue and the study house, the local court and the charity fund, the calendar fixed by calculation when the Sanhedrin's witnesses could no longer proclaim the new moon — a people's portable constitution, working identically in Baghdad and in Mainz, which is the institutional secret of the survival the origins lesson named.
The medieval centuries give the tradition its philosophy and its poetry, and its martyrology in the same binding. Under Islam's rule, in Spain's golden age, Jewish courtiers, poets, and philosophers — Hasdai ibn Shaprut, Solomon ibn Gabirol, Judah Halevi — wrote in Arabic and Hebrew at a civilization's center, while Maimonides in Egypt gave Judaism its Aristotelian summa, the Mishneh Torah code and the Guide for the Perplexed, and became the tradition's most argued-over mind. Under Christendom the record darkens: the Crusades' massacres in the Rhineland, the blood libel born in Norwich in 1144, the disputations and Talmud burnings, the expulsions — England 1290, France repeatedly, Spain 1492, the catastrophe that scattered the Sephardic world across the Mediterranean and seeded new centers from Amsterdam to Istanbul. The tradition answered catastrophe as it had answered Rome: with text and with mysticism — the Zohar and the Kabbalah's flowering at Safed, the Shulchan Aruch's code from the same small Galilean city — and with the discipline of a people that had learned to carry its country in its books.
The modern turn begins, as so much modernity does, with an argument about citizenship: the Enlightenment and the French Revolution offered Jews emancipation — the rights of citizens — at the price the era named frankly, of ceasing to be a nation within the nation. Moses Mendelssohn, the Berlin philosopher who translated the Torah into German to bring his people into European culture while keeping the law himself, stands at the gate of the age. From emancipation's pressures and hopes the movements of the introduction were born: Reform in Germany, re-shaping worship and re-reading the law for the citizen age; the positive-historical school that became Conservatism, holding the law's authority and its history together; and the neo-Orthodoxy of Samson Raphael Hirsch, arguing that full observance and full modern culture could be lived in one life. In Eastern Europe, un-emancipated and Yiddish-speaking, the same centuries produced Hasidism's revival of joy and the yeshiva world's intensified study, Zionism's answer that the nation needed its land, and the great emigration that moved the Jewish center of gravity across the Atlantic — all of it before the catastrophe of the twentieth century, which the next lesson must face entire.
The lesson's last word is about the pattern of the growth, because the student who sees it holds the tradition's own philosophy of its history. Judaism has changed in every century — in language, in philosophy, in law's application, in the center of its world — and has experienced every change as an argument about fidelity: the reformer and the conservative in each age cite the same texts against each other, and the argument itself, recorded and studied, becomes the tradition's continuity. The school's phrase for it, offered to the student as this lesson's keepsake, is that Judaism survives not by standing still nor by dissolving, but by arguing — in the academy's idiom, the Oral Torah never closes; in the people's, the conversation at the table has not ended in three thousand years. Growth, change, and reform are therefore not the modern period's names only: they are the tradition's permanent condition, which the modern world merely accelerated — and into that acceleration, of emancipation, destruction, and rebirth, the final history lesson now goes.
Lesson 4: Judaism in the modern world
The final history lesson covers the century that remade the Jewish world: the destruction of European Jewry in the Holocaust, the founding of the State of Israel, and the re-centering of Jewish life between Israel and North America — the three facts within which every contemporary form of Judaism, including the student's own course, exists. The Holocaust first, and the school will not hurry it. Between 1941 and 1945, Nazi Germany and its collaborators murdered approximately six million Jews — two-thirds of Europe's Jewish population, a third of the world's — in ghettos, in mass shootings by the Einsatzgruppen that killed over a million in the open air of the East, and in the extermination camps, Auschwitz-Birkenau above all, built for the industrial murder of a people. The world of the previous lesson — the yeshivas and the Hasidic courts, the Yiddish press and the shtetl towns, a thousand years of European Jewish civilization — was annihilated in four years, with a completeness the survivors' testimony and the perpetrators' own records document together. Jewish memory keeps the catastrophe as the Shoah, and the tradition's theology has argued with it ever since — in the questions the survivors themselves posed about the covenant, providence, and the God of history — an argument the school records as the tradition's own and does not presume to settle from outside.
Out of the same decade came the rebirth the tradition had prayed toward for nineteen centuries: on May 14, 1948, the State of Israel was proclaimed in Tel Aviv, under the United Nations' partition resolution of the previous year, and survived the war that followed to become the ingathering the liturgy had imagined — absorbing Holocaust survivors, the Jews expelled and fled from the Arab lands in the decades after, the Jews of Ethiopia in the airlifts of 1984 and 1991, and a million Jews of the former Soviet Union after 1989 — until, in the present century, Israel became home to the largest Jewish population on earth, a Hebrew-speaking state in which the tradition's calendar is the public calendar and its ancient arguments are conducted as national politics. The school presents Israel as the lesson's subject requires: as the central fact of modern Jewish life, the object of the tradition's own intense internal argument — between religious and secular Israelis, between Israel and the diaspora, between the state's Jewish and democratic definitions of itself — and as a subject on which the tradition's teachers disagree with each other, in public, as Jews. The student learns the fact and the argument together, or learns neither.
The diaspora's modern center, meanwhile, crossed the ocean. The United States — which received the great emigration of 1881–1924 and closed its gates after — became after the war the home of a Jewish community roughly equal to Israel's, and the laboratory of the movements at full scale: suburban synagogues and day schools, the denominations' seminaries, a Jewish culture woven into the host civilization's literature, science, and public life at a depth emancipation's dreamers scarcely imagined — and, in the same decades, the assimilation that is the open society's tax: intermarriage rates the community's demographers track with anxiety, affiliation's decline, and the counter-movements of return — the baal teshuvah phenomenon, the outreach movements, the day-school boom — by which a portion of each generation walks back toward observance. The school's balance in this lesson is the tradition's own: modern Jewish life argues, in both its centers, between survival through openness and survival through boundaries, and the argument is conducted by people who agree on the stakes and on little else.
The lesson's last word, and the history semester's, belongs to the continuity the four lessons together display. A student who entered the semester with Abraham's family in tents has arrived at a world of two great centers, a sovereign state, a revived language — Hebrew, the only ancient tongue ever returned to daily speech — and a tradition arguing about its future in printing presses and parliaments its founders could not have pictured, in the same categories its rabbis fixed in Babylonia. The school's closing judgment is modest and exact: Judaism in the modern world is neither the museum of a finished civilization nor a faith dissolved into its surroundings, but the oldest continuous argument in the student's curriculum still in session — about God, covenant, law, land, and memory — carried now by fifteen million people who disagree about nearly everything except that the argument is theirs and it matters. The texts semester opens the argument's books.