Minister Destiny Marie Morgan Ministries, Inc.

Minister Destiny Testimony Schools

District: AWAKENING

Ministry name: Juche

Lessons — Adult Year 2, Semester 4

Adult Year 2 · Semester 4 — Places, arts, and the road ahead

Four lessons for this semester. When you are ready, take the test for this semester.

Lesson 1: The Tower of the Juche Idea in Pyongyang and the Mansudae Grand Monument

The final semester turns to the sacred geography of the system, and it begins with the two monuments that face each other across the Taedong River in Pyongyang as the doctrine's thesis and antithesis in stone: on the east bank the Tower of the Juche Idea, on the west the Mansudae Grand Monument. The Tower, completed in 1982 for the founder's seventieth birthday, rises 170 meters — a stone pillar of 25,550 granite blocks, one for each day of the founder's seventy years by the state's count — crowned by a twenty-meter torch of red glass, illuminated at night, whose flame signifies the Juche idea lighting the world. At its base stand sculptural groups of the doctrine's estates — worker, farmer, intellectual, soldier, artist, student — and behind it a wall of stone plaques sent by foreign Juche study groups and sympathetic organizations, the monument's congregation rendered as masonry. An elevator carries visitors to the platform below the torch, from which the capital's ceremonial axis lies displayed: the square, the river, the monuments in their order. The school's student should read the Tower as the doctrine's self-portrait: an idea, not a man, given the capital's highest form — the system's claim that its founder's thought, and not merely his person, is the monument.

The Mansudae Grand Monument, on Mansu Hill in the city's center, is the counterweight: the persons themselves. The original monument of 1972 raised the founder's bronze statue twenty meters over the capital, one arm extended over the city he built; in April 2012, for the centenary of his birth and months after his son's death, the monument was remade as a pair — Kim Il Sung, his pose softened in the recasting to a smile the sculptors' revision made famous among the trackers, and Kim Jong Il beside him in his parka, the two founders, as the state now styles them, presiding together over the square of rallies below. Before the statues stretches the mosaic mural of Mount Paektu, and the plaza where the delegations of Year Two's celebrations lessons lay their flowers and bow — in the order of protocol, in the dress the occasion demands, photographed in the posture the whole country learns as a child. Flanking the hill stand the monument's companion sculptural groups, the anti-Japanese struggle and the socialist construction in bronze ranks, so that the hill reads as the state's history with its two sovereigns at its summit.

The two-column record of the monuments is quickly given, because the monuments are the columns' common ground: no party to the record disputes what stands in Pyongyang, and the dispute is only over what the standing means. The state's column: the Tower and the statues are the people's own work and the people's own love, raised by voluntary labor and subscription in the accounts' telling, visited by the citizen as the capital's heart and by the foreign guest as the nation's introduction — the first stop of every official itinerary, where the visitor's flowers and bow are the protocol the hosts expect and the record's photographers document. The critics' column: the monuments are the cult's fixed capital, built and rebuilt at costs the accounts estimate against a poor country's needs, maintained by a protocol of compulsory reverence — the bow required, the photograph of the statues regulated so that no image may crop the founders' bodies, the badge over every citizen's heart carrying the faces the statues monumentalize. The school adds the comparativist's note it has earned by now: every capital in this building's world monumentalizes its founders, and the difference the student is weighing is of degree that becomes kind — the founders here are not remembered but enthroned, their images not honored but worshiped with a liturgy the state administers and the citizen may not decline.

The lesson's last word is the view from the Tower's platform, which the school uses as the semester's vantage. From below the torch, the student of the photographs sees what the doctrine built in its capital: the axis of square and stadium, the mausoleum across the river's bend, the study house and the party monument and the arch of triumph — a city arranged as a text, in which the Juche idea's tower and the founders' statues face one another as the system's two poles, the thought and the bloodline, each incomplete without the other in the doctrine's own logic. Year One taught that logic in the texts; Year Two has walked it in the streets. The school leaves the student on the platform with the river between the poles, and turns him next to the third point of the capital's sacred triangle — the palace where the founders lie, and the square where the living assemble beneath them.

Lesson 2: The Kumsusan Palace of the Sun and Kim Il Sung Square

The second places lesson joins the capital's tomb to its forum: the Kumsusan Palace of the Sun, where the two dead leaders lie in state, and Kim Il Sung Square, where the living nation assembles — the two poles of the cult's practice, reverence for the dead and mobilization of the living, which Year Two's celebrations lessons have already shown in motion and which this lesson enters as places. Kumsusan first. The building began as the Kumsusan Assembly Hall, the founder's office and residence palace from 1976; after his death in 1994 it was remade, at a cost the outside estimates place in the hundreds of millions of dollars in the famine's own years, as his mausoleum, and after 2011 as the joint mausoleum of father and son, renamed the Kumsusan Palace of the Sun. The founders lie in glass sarcophagi in hushed halls, preserved by the embalmers' art whose specialists the record traces to the Moscow laboratory that maintains Lenin's body — the school notes the lineage without ornament, because it is the fact the comparativists note: the twentieth century's revolutionary states developed a technology of the incorrupt founder, and Pyongyang's palace is its fullest surviving practice.

The visit to the palace is the system's most solemn liturgy, and the record's descriptions — the state's protocol accounts and the foreign visitors' and defectors' testimony agreeing, for once, on the choreography in detail — run as follows. The visitor is prepared before entry: dress inspected, cameras and bags surrendered, shoes cleaned by machine, the approach made through long marble corridors and a hall of the founder's portrait before which the group bows. In the sarcophagus halls the visitors file past in ranks, bowing at the body's sides in the prescribed number, in silence broken, in the testimony's recurring detail, by the weeping of the North Korean visitors — grief at a decade's or a generation's distance from the death, which the state presents as the people's undying love and the outside record reads variously as sincerity, as performance, and as the two in the proportion this room has learned not to pretend to measure. The palace's halls of orders and gifts — the founder's medals from a hundred states, the train carriage and the car of his journeys preserved as relics — complete the pilgrimage, whose foreign performance is required of visiting dignitaries and offered to few tourists, in small numbers, under escort.

Kim Il Sung Square, the lesson's second place, is the mausoleum's opposite in everything but importance: open where the palace is sealed, loud where it is hushed, the nation's living room where the palace is its tomb. The square — granite-paved, holding by the usual estimates a hundred thousand people, ranked among the world's great ceremonial squares — fronts the Taedong opposite the Juche Tower, beneath the Grand People's Study House whose traditional roof crowns the west bank as the Tower crowns the east. Its year's round is the celebrations semester's calendar made spatial: the mass dances of the holidays, the rallies of denunciation and of welcome, the parades whose dots mark its stones, the torchlight processions of the youth. The school's student has read the square already in the parade lesson; this lesson adds only its standing meaning, which the state's own name for it states: it is named for the founder, as the palace is his tomb, so that the living assemble, for every great occasion of their collective life, on ground that bears the dead man's name — the geography of the doctrine's claim that the leader is eternal, drawn on the capital's map.

The lesson's closing word sets the two places in the school's two columns for the last time in this semester. In the state's column, palace and square are the people's own: the palace their father's house, kept by their devotion; the square their forum, filled by their joy — and the column can point, truly, to the crowds' scale and the tears' recurrence as its evidence. In the critics' column, palace and square are the cult's engine room: the palace consuming a famine year's treasure to house two bodies as the state's holiest objects, the square a stage whose every crowd is summoned, rehearsed, and dispersed by the organizations — and the column can point, truly, to the cost estimates and the mobilization files as its evidence. The school's student stands, in this lesson's final image, on the square at dusk with the Tower lit across the river and the palace behind the trees to the northeast, in a capital arranged — as no other capital on earth is arranged — as one doctrine's diagram of itself. The arts that fill this diagram with feeling are the next lesson's subject: the songs, images, and stories in which the system's imagination, and its people's, actually live.

Lesson 3: Art, music, and literature of Juche

The third places-and-arts lesson turns from where the system stands to how it imagines: the art, music, and literature produced under the doctrine's direction — the field, the student should note at the outset, in which the second leader's own hand was heaviest, for Kim Jong Il's path to power ran through the arts, and his treatises On the Art of the Cinema (1973) and on opera and drama remain the system's aesthetic canon. The doctrine of art in those texts is stated without ambiguity: art is a weapon of the revolution and a textbook of the people's life; its method is socialist realism remade as Juche realism, its content the leader, the party, the masses in their ranks, and its criterion the seed — the ideological kernel each work must carry, from which, in Kim Jong Il's theory, the whole work organically grows. The school's student, arriving from this building's older rooms with their centuries of sacred art, will find the structure familiar in everything but its candor: every tradition here has made art to teach and to bind; this one publishes the theory of doing so, examines its artists on it, and permits no other.

The works themselves fill the record at a scale the lesson can only sample, and the sampling follows the state's own hierarchy of honor. First the revolutionary operas and films: the Sea of Blood and The Flower Girl, the founder-era classics remade under the son's direction into the model works of the stage and screen, their melodies in every citizen's ear; the cinema that Kim Jong Il built into his personal instrument — including the record's strangest chapter, the 1978 abduction of the South Korean director Shin Sang-ok and the actress Choi Eun-hee, held and compelled to make films for the North for eight years before their escape in Vienna, an episode attested by the couple's own tapes and testimony and long denied in Pyongyang. Then the visual arts: the Mansudae Art Studio, the state's atelier of thousands, whose painters and sculptors produce the monuments and the leader portraits — and whose overseas arm built the grand monuments of several African and Asian states for hard currency, an export the studio's critics and defenders read in their columns' ways. Then the music of the everyday: the revolutionary songs and the Moranbong Band's electronic pop, the state ensembles' polished stages, and beneath them the songs the market era actually hums, South Korean ballads crossing the border on the same media as the dramas, illegal and unstoppable in the testimony's account.

The literature of the system completes the sample, and returns the student to the canon of Year One with the artist's eye. The leaders' own works crown the shelf; below them the sanctioned literature of model lives — the novels of the forest and the factory, the poetry of the anniversaries — produced by the writers' union under the seed theory's discipline, awarded by the state's prizes, and read in the study sessions. Against this shelf the outside record sets the literature of the wound: the camp testimony published abroad under pseudonyms, the defectors' memoirs that are this room's testimony in book form, and the single most discussed North Korean literary work in the outside world, the stories of the writer known as Bandi — 'firefly' — smuggled out and published in 2014 as The Accusation, whose authorship, by a writer still inside the system by the publishers' account, the state has never acknowledged. The school places the two shelves side by side as it has placed the two columns throughout: the art the system makes of itself, and the art its people make of the system, the second shelf smaller, hunted, and — the critics add — the one the future will read.

The lesson's last word weighs the arts by the school's standing measure, and finds the weighing harder here than anywhere in the year, which is itself the finding the student should keep. The system's art asks everything of the artist — the whole talent, the whole career, the seed in every work — and forbids the one thing the older rooms' sacred arts, for all their disciplines, structurally preserved: the subject's ambiguity, the icon that gazes back with a meaning its makers did not command. What it has made includes real mastery the record's least sympathetic critics concede — the mass games' choreography, the studio's craft, melodies a whole people carries in memory — made inside a total direction whose cost the abducted director's tapes state more plainly than any analysis. And beneath the directed arts, the people's own imagination persists in the form the testimony keeps reporting: the joke in the kitchen, the forbidden ballad, the smuggled manuscript in a firefly's hand. The school ends the lesson there, with the two shelves and the one small light, and turns to the year's final question — how the student who would go on learning about this room should proceed, in a field where the subject is alive, armed, and still writing its own account.

Lesson 4: Continuing to learn about Juche

The final lesson of the Juche school is addressed, as the final lessons of this building's courses are, to the student himself: how to go on learning about a subject that is a living state, a closed archive, and an open argument. The school's first counsel is the year's method restated as a discipline for life: keep the columns separate. The doctrine's texts — the canon of Year One, now joined by the third leader's works as they appear — are the record of what the system teaches; the state's acts are the record of what it does; the testimony of those who have left is the record of what it is like inside; and the scholarship is the record of what can be verified across the three. The student who has finished this course owns the habit the school most wanted to teach, which is not a conclusion about North Korea but a way of holding four kinds of evidence without letting any one of them impersonate the others. Every future source the student meets — the news photograph, the defector's memoir, the state's broadcast, the satellite study — has its column, and the school's graduate is the reader who asks of each, before believing or dismissing it: which column are you, and what would your kind of evidence know?

The second counsel concerns the sources themselves, and the school gives the student the working shelf plainly. For the doctrine: the published works of the three leaders in the Foreign Languages Publishing House's editions, read as this course read them — seriously, as the system's own account, neither as gospel nor as joke. For the acts: the monitoring record — the United Nations' reports and the Commission of Inquiry's archive, the satellite analysts' open publications, the aid agencies' operational histories, and the trackers of the leadership and the arsenal whose work the year's lessons cited. For the inside: the testimony in its growing library, read with the school's cautions — memory's shaping, the market for sensation, the impossibility of verification — and with its respect, because the testimony is the only column written by the people the doctrine is about. For the scholarship: the historians of the guerrilla years and the famine, the comparativists of the cult, and the Koreanists of both Korean states, whose disagreements among themselves the student should read as the field's health, not its failure. The school adds the counsel of humility its empty chair taught in Year One: the shelf's largest gap is permanent for now — the North Korean reader's own account of his doctrine, unmediated — and the honest student keeps the chair empty rather than filling it with his own ventriloquism.

The third counsel is about the student's own position, and the school speaks it carefully because this room, alone in the building, is studied from inside a live conflict. The student reads this curriculum in a world where the two Korean states remain formally at war, where the doctrine's state possesses the weapons Year Two recorded, and where every government concerned maintains its own account of the subject for its own purposes — including, the school notes without exempting anyone, the governments under whose protection this school itself operates. The graduate's discipline is therefore double: against the state's propaganda, which would have him repeat the columns' first as the whole; and against the counter-propaganda of contempt, which would have him treat twenty-six million people's inner lives as a punchline — the school has recorded the jokes the North Koreans themselves tell, and they are better than the ones told about them. Between the two stands the position this course has tried to occupy and now hands over: the doctrine taken seriously, the record kept whole, the people — the masses the doctrine names history's subject and the record keeps in silence — held in view as the subject of the student's respect, whatever he concludes about the system that rules them.

The course's last word is the school's farewell to this room, and it is short. The student entered, two years ago in the curriculum's fiction and some hours ago in fact, a room unlike the building's others: the youngest doctrine here, the only one with a living state, a sealed congregation, and a founder within the age of the newsreel. He leaves it — if the school has done its work — unable to say the easy sentences in either direction, and able to say the harder ones: what the doctrine claims, in its own words; what the record shows, in its kinds; where the evidence stops, and the empty chair stands. The building's other rooms await the student who continues — older faiths with open doors and living readers he can sit among and question — and the contrast will teach him, as it has taught the school, what this room's silence meant. The school thanks the student for learning about Juche in the only spirit in which it can honestly be taught: with the facts in full, the columns separate, and the people — all twenty-six million of them, masters of their destiny in the doctrine's promise and subjects of its state in the record — remembered, at the end of the course, as its reason.

Back to all lessons · Take this semester’s test