Adult Year 1 · Semester 4 — Practice and daily life
Four lessons for this semester. When you are ready, take the test for this semester.
Lesson 1: Studying the Juche idea in groups in depth
The practice semester opens with the doctrine's daily office: the group study of the Juche idea — the sessions by which the canon is carried into every workplace, school, and neighborhood of the state, in depth. The system's anatomy: every citizen belongs to an organization (the party for its members; the youth league, the women's union, the trade unions, the agricultural workers' union for the rest — the organizational life (jojik saenghwal) from which, in the doctrine's design, no adult stands outside), and every organization studies: the weekly sessions (the standard pattern of lectures and study hours built into the working week — the Saturday study and the Wednesday session of the usual accounts, the daily morning reading of the party paper's editorials in many units, the quarterly and annual study plans descending from the party's propaganda apparatus with their themes, texts, and questions); the method (the text read aloud in extracts, the questions prepared in the summaries, the answers given from the text — the study as recitation and application: the passage expounded, its meaning for the unit's own work drawn out by the session's leader (the unit's party secretary or study instructor), the members' notebooks kept and inspected, the examinations periodic: the form's resemblance to the building's other text-communities (the yeshiva's page, the monastery's lectio, the party schools of the older communist world from which the form descends) noted by the comparativists, with the difference of scale — this is a whole nation's timetable, the study session as a universal institution like the school and the clinic); and the self-criticism (the session's second form — the saenghwal chonghwa, the life review, in which the members criticize their own and one another's conduct against the doctrine and the Ten Principles, confess the shortcomings, and receive the collective's judgment: the practice's interior edge, attested by the defectors' accounts as the system's most intimate instrument — the conscience examined in public, weekly, for a lifetime — and described in the state's account as the collective's loving correction of its members, the two descriptions kept, as throughout this room, in their columns).
The study's content and its career fill the lesson's second half: the syllabus follows the state's calendar (the founder's and the leaders' works in their seasons — the birthday months' intensified study, the new line's texts when a plenum or a New Year address issues them, the history of the revolution as the canon's narrative spine); the study's products are the system's measures of a citizen (the study record in the personnel file, the zeal or its absence noted at the songbun's margins — study as the loyalty's most regular performance, and therefore, the outside accounts observe, its most ambiguous evidence: the session attended by all and believed by an unknowable fraction, the record's silence again at the center); and the study's modern pressures (the market day competing with the study hour in the population's actual week — the session shortened, the attendance negotiated, the donju's time bought at rates the doctrine does not publish: the ethnographers' fragments suggesting a system performing its forms with a fidelity that varies, as all such systems' fidelity varies, by place, by unit, and by the price of rice). The lesson's verdict: whatever the doctrine is elsewhere, in the study session it is a practice — a people assembled, weekly, around a text, for the whole of their lives — and the student who would understand this room must begin from the session's plain sociology: twenty-six million people cannot be assembled around a book for seventy years without the book becoming, in some measure no outsider can take, theirs. The revolutionary sites follow: the study's geography, the nation's pilgrimage.
The study lesson's last word is a sound: in the accounts of those who have lived inside the system, the study session's most remembered feature is not the text but the hour — the week's rhythm bending around it, the notebook's particular smell, the leader's voice reading the passage in the formula's cadence, the members' answers in chorus or in turn. Rituals are remembered by their senses before their doctrines, in every room of this building, and this room's are no exception: the defectors who describe the sessions describe them, often, with the same mixture of boredom, fear, fellowship, and — in the honest accounts — occasional genuine illumination that the building's other alumni describe of their own formations. The school's student should let the mixture stand. It is the most human sentence in the practice semester, and it belongs to the readers in the empty chair.
Lesson 2: Visiting revolutionary sites and monuments in depth
The practice semester's second lesson is the doctrine's pilgrimage: the revolutionary sites and monuments — the sacred geography of the state, visited by its citizens in organized reverence across a lifetime. The geography's map: at its summit stands Mangyongdae, the founder's birthplace village at Pyongyang's edge (the thatched house of the poor peasant family, preserved as the nation's first shrine — the schoolchildren's pilgrimage begins here, the delegations' itineraries begin here, the site's keepers reciting the family's poverty and patriotism at the cradle of the state: the birthplace as the doctrine's Bethlehem, the comparativists' word, recorded as theirs); the battle sites of the guerrilla epic (Pochonbo, with its monument and its museum; the secret camps of the Paektu forests, the “revolutionary battle sites” preserved with their slogan-bearing trees (the bark inscriptions attributed to the guerrillas, preserved under glass — the relic's arboreal form); and Mount Paektu itself, the sacred mountain of the Korean nation long before this doctrine (the mythic birthplace of the Korean people's founder in the old mythology) adopted as the revolution's holy peak and, in the official biography, the second leader's birthplace (the log cabin at the Paektu secret camp, where the official account places Kim Jong Il's birth in 1942 — the Soviet records placing it in the Far Eastern village of Vyatskoye in 1941: the two columns' most famous single divergence, stated here as the year's method requires, each in its source's terms). The capital's monuments are the geography's second half: the Mansudae Grand Monument (the bronze statues — the founder's, raised in 1972 for his sixtieth birthday, joined after 2011 by the second leader's — twenty meters of bronze on the hill above the capital, before which every delegation, every wedding party, every school class bows and lays flowers: the city's ritual center, its protocol fixed — the photograph taken, the bow made, the flowers bought from the state's stalls for the purpose); the Tower of the Juche Idea (1982 — 170 meters of stone torch over the Taedong, its flame the doctrine's own monument to itself); the Arch of Triumph (1982, modeled on Paris's and built deliberately taller); the Monument to Party Founding (1995 — the hammer, sickle, and writing brush of the worker, peasant, and intellectual); and the Kumsusan Palace (the founder's former residence and office, converted after 1994 into the mausoleum of the two leaders — the embalmed bodies lying in state in the glass sarcophagi, the visitors filing past in the prescribed dress and silence, bowing at the statues and the bodies by the protocol the keepers enforce: the mausoleum as the state's holiest interior, its comparativist parallels (Lenin's and Mao's) noted and its scale exceeding both).
The visit's practice is the lesson's core: the pilgrimage is organized, not spontaneous (the school class, the work unit, the delegation moving by itinerary, the guide's recitation at each station, the visitors' book signed, the photograph as the visit's certificate — the form's resemblance to the building's other pilgrimages (the guided party, the stations, the relic, the souvenir) being total except in one respect the comparativists underline: attendance is a duty of citizenship, and its record, like the study's, is kept); the sites' pedagogy (the museum at each site teaching the episode's official history with the artifacts as its proofs — the founder's rifle, the second leader's childhood sled at the cabin: the relic as the argument, the child's visit as the doctrine's catechesis in its most effective form, by the testimony of the defectors who remember their own school pilgrimages with an ambivalence the record preserves whole — the boredom, the pride, the tears at the mausoleum that some report as the genuine article and others as the performed one, the two reports being, in the school's judgment, both true of a population as of any other); and the sites' outer face (the foreign visitor's itinerary — the same stations, the same bows requested, the monuments as the state's self-presentation to the world: the tourism of the doctrine, in which the guest's performed reverence is the visit's price and its point). The lesson's verdict: a state that builds its doctrine a Bethlehem, a calvary of battle sites, a resurrection palace of embalmed founders, and a tower for its idea has built, whatever its theology's name, a pilgrimage church entire — and the student who walks its stations in the documents has the practice semester's geography entire. The collective field follows: the doctrine at work, in the furrow and the factory shift.
The pilgrimage's last word is a wedding: on the capital's weekends, the brides and grooms of Pyongyang pose, in their hundreds, before the Mansudae statues — the bride in her chima jeogori or her white dress, the groom in his suit, the flowers bought for the statues before the couple's own photograph is taken — the founder presiding, in bronze, over the founding of the family's next generation. The comparativists file the custom under the cult's domestication; the couples, in the few accounts that reach the record, file it under what one does — the monument is the city's front parlor, and the photograph is the family's certificate that the marriage began in the right place. The school's student should hold both filings, as he holds the mausoleum's tears: the sacred and the ordinary are not opposites in this room's practice, any more than in the building's older ones. They are the same afternoon.
Lesson 3: Group farming and collective work in depth
The practice semester's third lesson is the doctrine at work: group farming and collective labor — the cooperative farm and the mobilization, the forms in which most North Koreans have spent most of their working lives inside the doctrine. The farm first: the land was collectivized in the 1950s (the cooperatives completed by 1958, the state's farms a minority sector), and the cooperative's structure is the doctrine's agriculture entire (the workteam and the sub-workteam as the unit of labor and of payment — the team assigned its fields and its plan targets, the harvest divided by the state's procurement first (the tax in kind and the state purchases at the state's prices), the remainder distributed to the members by workpoints (the labor-day units recorded against each member's contribution) — the system by which the peasant's year is converted into his share; the farm's political anatomy mirroring the state's (the party secretary and the management chair, the study sessions and the self-criticism of the practice's first lesson conducted in the farm's hall, the revolutionary site's corner in the village (the local history room, the founder's guidance-visit monument where his route touched the parish: the geography of the second lesson at the scale of a village); and the private plot (the small household allotment — the system's licensed exception, whose produce (for the family's pot and, in the tolerated practice, for the market) has out-produced its area in every study the record offers: the plot's few percent of the land supplying, by the defectors' and the scholars' estimates, a wholly disproportionate share of the food actually eaten — the collective system's standing internal audit, conducted in vegetables).
The mobilization is the lesson's second half — the collective work beyond the farm: the state's characteristic instrument for every large task is the assembled population (the construction brigades and the shock campaigns (the speed battles) by which the dams, the tideland walls, the highways, and the capital's monuments were built — the doctrine's labor ethic in its purest form: the task announced as a battle, the units competing on the boards, the work done by the hundred thousand hands with the machines as the minority partner: the method's genuine achievements (the postwar reconstruction's speed, the West Sea Barrage's eight kilometers of tidal dam) and its genuine costs (the quality, the safety, the labor's price in the bodies of the mobilized — students, soldiers, and office workers at the sites for their seasons, the “economic service” of the universities' calendars) stated in their columns); the factory's collective (the Taean work system of 1961 — the founder's management doctrine: the factory run by its party committee, the manager and the party secretary and the engineer in the system's triangle, the supply guaranteed by the state's allocation rather than the market's purchase — the system's elegance on paper and its sclerosis in practice (the hoarded materials, the plan's fictions, the enterprise's survival by the informal exchanges its doctrine forbids) recorded as the record gives it); and the collective work's modern condition (the market era's corrosion of the mobilization's premise — the worker's time worth money the state wage does not pay, the attendance at the collective task bought out, negotiated, or performed at the pace the wage justifies: the practice's present tense being, by the ethnographers' fragments, a negotiation between the doctrine's forms and the economy's facts, conducted daily, in every unit, without a name). The lesson's verdict: the collective is this doctrine's monastery and its factory floor in one — the place where its theory of man meets the rice — and the rice, across seventy years, has returned the mixed verdict the history semester recorded: the fields fed the state in the good decades and failed it in the bad, and the plot and the market fed the people in both. The family-and-work lesson follows: the doctrine in the home, and the home's own economy inside the doctrine.
The collective lesson's last word is the private plot at dusk: a strip of hillside or a yard's corner, a few meters of beans and peppers and a pig in a pen of scavenged boards — the licensed exception on which, by the record's best estimates, the family's actual survival has depended through the worst decades — tended after the collective's hours by the same hands that spent the day in the collective's fields. The doctrine's account calls the plot a supplement; the ethnographers call it the economy's truth told small. The school leaves the two descriptions in the furrow where they both grow, and notes only what the plot's keeper knows: that the beans do not care which description is correct, and that the hands that tend them are the same hands the doctrine claims as history's subject. In the plot, at dusk, unobserved, the claim and the critique are reconciled in the only court that feeds anyone.
Lesson 4: Practice, family, and work
The practice semester closes with the doctrine in the home: practice, family, and work in the North Korean week — described, as this room requires, from the state's own account and the outside record together. The family's place in the doctrine: the family is the cell of the society in the official phrase, and its formation is the state's business from the start (the marriage registered and, in the keeping form, celebrated with the leaders' portraits presiding (the wedding photograph taken before the statues of the second lesson, the couple's first act as a household being the bow at the monument: the family's foundation rite in the doctrine's church); the children's formation (the nursery and the kindergarten of the state's pride — the boarding week of the industrial districts' nurseries in the system's classic form, the child's first teachers the state in its maternal office; the school uniform, the red scarf of the Young Pioneers, the league in its turn: the formation's ladder by which the child ascends the organizations of the study lesson from the age of seven); the home's interior (the portraits on the wall — the founder's, joined after their deaths by the second leader's, in the place of honor, cleaned with the special cloth, inspected in the keeping districts by the neighborhood unit's rounds: the home's altar in fact, whatever the doctrine's name for it, its care prescribed by the Ten Principles' second article and its condition a matter of the family's standing); and the neighborhood unit (the inminban — the twenty-to-forty households under their appointed head, the state's smallest organ and its most intimate: the unit that organizes the street's cleaning, the night watches, the study's attendance, and the knowledge of every household's comings, goings, and guests — the system's capillaries, described by the state as the neighbors' mutual care and by the outside record as its finest-grained surveillance, the two descriptions kept, in this room's manner, side by side and unsynthesized).
Work and the week complete the lesson: the working day and its frame (the eight hours of the constitution, the study and the meetings at its edges, the Sunday rest of the formal calendar; the second economy of the actual week (the market's hours, the private repair and transport and tutoring by which the moneyed and the skilled supplement the state wage that the market era has reduced, in many employments, to a formality: the family's real budget assembled from the plot, the market stall of the wife (the markets' traders being, by the record's consensus, mostly women — the market era's transformation of the family's economy and of women's position within it being the modern North's largest social fact, documented by the ethnographers from the defectors' accounts and acknowledged by no official text); the husband's state job kept for its rations, its pension's promise, and its songbun's safety while the wife's trading feeds the house — the doctrine's household inverted by its economy, the fact stated without the school's adornment); and the family's audit by the doctrine's own measures (the loyalty performed, the study attended, the portraits kept, the children formed — the family's standing in the songbun's ledger reviewed at every move, school place, and marriage: the heredity of the classification making the family's past its children's future in a sense the doctrine's first principle — man the master of his destiny — sits beside, in the record, without reconciliation). The semester's synthesis: the doctrine's practice is a total environment — the study, the site, the field, the portrait, the unit — and its people's lives inside it are, by every account that reaches the record, lives: worked, married, traded, grieved, and joked through, under a sky of doctrine whose weather the outsider can describe but whose climate in the individual soul he cannot. The people semester follows: the second and third leaders' lives, the guerrilla epic, and the famine, in full.
The practice semester's last word is the joke — the one the defectors' accounts agree is told, in some form, in every North Korean workplace and kitchen where two trusted people are alone: its text varies and cannot be printed here with confidence, but its existence is the record's most consistent small fact, attested across forty years of testimony by people who agree on little else. The school's student should file the joke beside the portraits and the study notebooks as the practice's third term: a population that jokes about its doctrine is neither the doctrine's portrait of itself nor its critics' portrait of the population — it is a people, living the ordinary life of irony inside an extraordinary system, as peoples have inside every system this building studies. The year does not end here — the people and their stories follow — but the practice does, and it ends, fittingly, in a kitchen, in a whisper, in laughter the record can hear but not transcribe.