Adult Year 2 · Semester 4 — Places, arts, and the road ahead
Four lessons for this semester. When you are ready, take the test for this semester.
Lesson 1: The Jain temple (derasar) and Palitana — the city of temples on the hill
The places semester opens with the tradition's sacred architecture at its two scales: the derasar — the Jain temple — and Palitana, the city of temples on the Shatrunjaya hill, the tradition's holiest address. The derasar first, in its anatomy and its theology: the temple is the Tirthankara's court and the community's house in one (the garbhagriha's image — the ford-maker seated or standing in the stillness of the texts lesson, eyes half-open on the whole universe — attended as a king in retirement who asks nothing: the offerings are flowers, water, sandal paste, the lamp, the rice of the akshat — the worship's substances audited by the census as everything in this room is (the flowers a being's body, the water strained, the fruit whole rather than cut in the strict houses — the puja of this room being ahimsa's negotiation with devotion itself, conducted daily, in sandal paste); the chaityalaya's hall for the congregation's pratikraman and lectures; the upashraya (the monks' residence hall) adjoining in the keeping towns — the teacher's lodging as the temple's annex, the community's two houses (the god's and the guru's) sharing a wall; the bhandar beneath or beside (the library in the basement, the temple as an archive with a shrine attached, in the historians' affectionate formula); and the temple's day (the dawn's first arti to the evening's, the pilgrims' rounds, the lay families' darshan before the shops open — the derasar as the neighborhood's clock and club as much as its sanctuary).
Palitana is the temple multiplied into a city and set on a hill: the Shatrunjaya — the Place of Victory (over the inner enemies, the name glossed) — rising above the Gujarat plain with its two peaks and its saddle covered, across nine centuries of building, with some 860 temples in its walled enclosures (the tuks — the fortified temple-clusters, each a small city of shrines endowed by a merchant prince or a community: the Chaumukha temple of the four-faced image at the summit's heart, the Adinath temple of Rishabha (the hill is his above all — the first ford-maker's footprints (the pagla) under the rayan tree the pilgrimage's goal), the whole built and rebuilt in marble and sandstone by the wealth of the community's trade — the hill as the merchant ethic's monument entire: the surplus of a thousand counting houses, conveyed by the limit vow's logic to the one address that could hold it); the pilgrimage's discipline (the climb of some 3,500–3,800 steps, begun before dawn, the pilgrims fasting or one-mealed, no food carried up and none eaten on the hill in the strict keeping, all down before dark — the hill emptied nightly, by the rule, of every human soul: the city of temples sleeping without a single inhabitant, guarded and god-kept, the only city on earth whose population is entirely diurnal — the school's favorite municipal fact in the building); the great pilgrimages (the Kartika and Chaitra full moons' rivers of white-clad climbers, the sadh-sadhvi's monsoon residence below, the six-month fasters' completions celebrated at the foot); and the hill's audit (the endowments' upkeep against the modern trusts' accounts; the palanquin-bearers' (doli-wallahs') labor carrying the old and the lame up the steps their faith requires and their bodies cannot — the service economy of the sacred, audited as every room's is: the shoulders under the pilgrimage, named and honored in the record). The verdict pairs the places: the derasar is the path at the scale of a street; Shatrunjaya is the path at the scale of a geography — a hill the community has spent a millennium turning into a single sentence in stone: the ford is here, climb carefully, and be down before dark, for the hill belongs at night to the beings. Shravanabelagola follows: the standing saint, and the shelter at his feet.
The hill's last word is its night: the gates closed at dusk, the last pilgrims down the steps with their lamps, the 860 temples darkening peak by peak as the light leaves the plain — and the city of the ford-makers sleeping, as it has slept for nine centuries, without one human soul inside its walls, the gods and the beings in sole possession of the most built-upon hill in the building. The school's student should hold the empty city as the places semester's purest image of this room's whole doctrine: a civilization's surplus, a millennium of marble, a mountain of prayer — and at the center of the arrangement, a nightly act of evacuation, in which the builders themselves withdraw and leave the place to the smallest of its citizens. The hill is swept, in the end, by being vacated. Climb it in the morning, by all means. The night is theirs.
Lesson 2: Shravanabelagola and its great statue and the animal shelter (panjarapole)
The places semester's second lesson joins the tradition's most famous monument to its most characteristic institution: Shravanabelagola — the White Pond of the Ascetics, in Karnataka — where the colossus of Bahubali stands over the town, and the panjarapole at the hill's foot keeps the doctrine's other face. The statue first: Gommateshwara — Bahubali, Rishabha's second son, the prince of the texts semester's story (the duel won against his brother Bharata and renounced in the winning — the disgust at the violence his victory required turning him, on the battlefield itself, to the road: he stood in the kayotsarga posture, unmoving, through the seasons, the creepers climbing his legs, the anthills rising at his feet, the serpents and the deer sheltering in his stillness, until the last knot of pride — the shame that he stood on his brother's land — was named by Bharata's visit and dissolved, and the omniscience came to the standing man) — carved in 981 AD, by the order of the minister-general Chamundaraya of the Ganga dynasty, from the living granite of the Vindhyagiri hill: fifty-seven feet of a single stone, the largest monolithic statue of the ancient world in its kind, naked, serene, the creepers carved up the arms and thighs in the stone's own memory of the story, visible — the town's saying goes — from twenty-five kilometers on the road. The mahamastakabhisheka is the statue's festival (the great head-anointing, every twelve years in the usual cycle: the scaffolding rising up the hill's back for a year, the thousand pots of water, milk, curd, turmeric, sandal, and saffron poured from the platform over the great head before a crowd of hundreds of thousands — the festival of 2018 in the record's figures drawing the faithful and the cameras of the whole country: the anointing as the tradition's most spectacular rite, its substances audited by the census and its splendor defended as the story's due — the standing saint bathed by a civilization, once a generation, in the sight of all).
The shelter at the hill's foot is the lesson's second half, and the pairing is the doctrine's own: the town that keeps the statue keeps also, as every Jain town keeps, the panjarapole — here taken as the institution's type, in depth: the shelter's residents (the retired bullocks, the rescued calves, the old horses, the dogs of the town, the birds of the wards — the census's pensioners, kept for life at the community's charge); its economy (the fodder subscriptions, the merchants' endowments, the festival collections — the shelter as the limit vow's standing beneficiary, the surplus's first address in the keeping towns); its staff (the keepers — often hereditary, the families who have fed the shelter's animals for generations, the work honored in the community as a religious office and audited, in the modern literature, as a labor like any other, with wages and conditions to match: the ethic auditing its own instruments, as this room's ethic characteristically does); its modernization (the veterinary hospital attached in the newer foundations, the standards of the animal science argued into the sheds by the community's own professionals — the argument of the celebrations lesson conducted here as a building program); and its meaning, stated by the tradition's teachers without ornament: the statue is what the path looks like when it is finished; the shelter is what it looks like on a Tuesday — and the town that maintains both, in full view of each other, has the doctrine's whole geography in one address: the liberation above, the compassion below, the steps between them swept. The arts follow: what the smallest room made beautiful, in stone and gold and the miniature's page.
The pairing's last word is a stair: the Vindhyagiri's steps, cut in the granite, up which the pilgrims climb to the standing saint — and at whose foot, in the town's lanes, the shelter's gate stands open for the morning's fodder carts. The school's student should climb the stair once, in imagination or in fact, and perform the town's own act of attention on the way up: the statue grows as you climb, and the shelter shrinks, and at the summit the proportion reverses itself in the doctrine's light — the fifty-seven feet of finished liberation being, in the census's accounting, exactly one soul, and the sheds below containing hundreds. The town has kept both in view for a thousand years without confusing their sizes. That is the whole of the places lesson, and it is taught by a staircase. Go up slowly. The beings on the steps are also climbing, in their way, and the stair is wide enough for all of you.
Lesson 3: Art, music, and literature of Jainism
The places semester's third lesson is the smallest room's treasury — which proves, on inspection, to be out of all proportion to the room: the Jain art of the temple and the miniature, the literature of the story and the system, and a music kept, characteristically, at the level of the hymn. The art first: the temple architecture and sculpture (the marble of Abu — the Dilwara temples' ceilings, where the stone is carved until it behaves like lace and the dome's rings descend in concentric dancers and lotuses: the tradition's artistic summit and the building's standing refutation of the idea that an iconoclastic age or an ascetic doctrine must make a plain art — this room's asceticism produced the subcontinent's most ornate interiors, the paradox the art historians state and the tradition explains: the wealth was the merchants', the work was the vow's discharge, and the beauty is the surplus made visible, aparigraha's overflow in marble); the sculpture's grammar (the Tirthankara images' serene sameness of the texts lesson, the yaksha and yakshi attendants' variety around them, the Bahubali colossus of the places lesson as the grammar's largest sentence); the miniature painting (the Kalpa Sutra manuscripts of the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries — the gold grounds, the lapis skies, the further eye of the Jain profile (the face in profile with the far eye protruding past the cheek — the convention by which a Jain page is known at a glance across a museum), the margins' dancers and wrestlers and acrobats crowding the sacred text with the whole of life: the manuscripts as the tradition's illuminated glory, the bhandars' treasures now the museums' prizes — the Met and the Lalbhai Dalpatbhai collections as the diaspora of the palm leaves); and the modern art (the community's contemporary painters and the temple architects of the diaspora working the old grammar in the suburbs' stone — the treasury still accreting).
The literature and music complete the treasury: the literature is the treasury's bulk (the Prakrit canon and its commentaries; the Sanskrit of the acharyas — Hemachandra, the polymath of the twelfth century (the grammarian of two languages, the historian of the sixty-three, the minister-monk of the Solanki court — the tradition's one-man university); the story literature in a dozen languages (the kathas — the tale-collections by which the doctrine traveled: the fox-and-lion fables' Jain cousins, the merchant romances, the vidas of the saints — the community's fiction being, characteristically, a literature of the counting house and the road, its heroes princes who renounce and merchants who outwit); the vernacular bhakti of the Jain poets (the Gujarati and Rajasthani hymn-writers — Anandghan, the seventeenth-eighteenth century mystic whose songs the community sings still, the Jain tradition's surprising treasury of the devotional lyric, its God addressed in the ford-maker's absence with a longing the theologians file under emulation and the singers under love); and the modern literature (the community's novelists and its historians, the English shelf of the diaspora's self-explanation growing yearly); the music (the stavans — the hymns of praise sung in the temples' evenings and the festivals' processions, the raga-bound melodies of the Gujarati and Rajasthani traditions; the bhajans of the community's gatherings; the dance-dramas of the kalyanakas in the temple towns' festivals — the music's modesty, against the Hindu room's oceans, being itself a doctrine's consequence: the senses audited, the concert subordinated, the hymn kept as the music's ceiling in the strict houses and its floor in the glad ones). The verdict: the smallest room's treasury is a library with a marble ceiling — the story and the system in the books, the surplus in the stone, and the hymn over both — and the student who would know this tradition must read its tales and climb its hills in about equal measure, the two being, as the places semester has shown, the same text in different materials. The road ahead is the year's last lesson.
The treasury's last item is a margin: in the great Kalpa Sutra folios, around the gold ground and the sacred text, the painters crowded the page's edges with the whole of the life the text renounces — the wrestlers and the acrobats, the dancers and the water-carriers, the market and the wedding — as if the manuscript itself could not keep the world out of its margins, and did not finally try. The school's student should take the margin as the treasury's self-portrait: this is a tradition whose renunciation has always had the world painted round it in gold — the merchant's wealth funding the monk's book, the monk's book framing the merchant's world — the two halves of the community holding each other in one page. Every room in this building has such a margin. This room's is the most beautiful. Look at it long, and then read the text it surrounds: the two activities are the tradition's own, in either order.
Lesson 4: Continuing to learn about Jainism
The year closes with the road ahead: how to continue learning about Jainism after the school's map ends — the smallest room's road being, characteristically, the most exactly signposted in the building. The reading road first, in the order the year's teachers assign: the Tattvartha Sutra whole (the skeleton, in Tatia's or a comparable translation — the one indispensable book, per the texts semester); one life whole (the Kalpa Sutra's Mahavira, or Parshva's in the modern retellings); the Acharanga's opening (the root's voice); the story literature in translation (the katha collections — the tales by which the community itself learns, the student's fastest road to the tradition's imagination); and the modern interpreters (the historians of the early community, the ethnographers of the modern one — the studies of the diaspora's temples and the homeland's shelters — with the standing rule of this building: the heirs first, in their own terms, the critics at full strength, the premises always visible under the arguments). The practice road follows, for the student who learns by doing and visiting: the derasar visited at the dawn arti (the places semester's etiquette — the shoes off, the image approached as a mirror, the prasad of the flowers accepted, the library in the basement asked after: the visit's syllabus being the temple's own); the festival attended (a Paryushana evening's pratikraman, with the community's leave — the guest at the forgiveness rite is himself forgiven in the formula's universality, an experience the school's students report as the year's most searching; a Jayanti's blood camp, where the road's student may give the road's most literal gift); the shelter volunteered at (the panjarapole's morning feeding — the practice's examination, as in every room: the premise learned by the hands at the fodder trough, among the pensioners of the census); the table kept for a season (the diet's ladder climbed one rung — the root vegetables' month, the one meal's week — the experiment the tradition itself prescribes for the skeptical, its results collected in the student's own kitchen); and the formula practiced (the day's end audit, the micchami dukkadam spoken where it is owed — the road's cheapest mile and its steepest, as the year's student will find).
The cautions are the year's last teaching, and they are the tradition's own: against the picturesque (the naked monk and the swept path are this room's conclusions, not its costume — the student who collects them as images has the postcard and not the path: the premises are the tradition, and they are unphotogenic — a census, a physics, and a logic — which is why the room is studied less than it is photographed, and why the school has spent the year on the premises); against the dismissal (the premises' antiquity is not their refutation — the census anticipated the microscope's world in form if not in kind, and the many-sided logic is a live option in the philosophy journals of the present century, not a relic: the room's ideas are to be argued with at their strongest, as the room argues); against the conversion of convenience (the tradition does not recruit, and the school does not either — the road is open, the derasar's door is open, the pathshala's welcome is real, and the decision to walk further is the student's own, to be made — the tradition would insist — slowly, with the whole census in view, and only for reasons that survive the pratikraman). The year's final word is the formula itself, which the student by now can hear in its full weight: micchami dukkadam — may my faults be forgiven — spoken by the school, on the year's behalf, to every being its curriculum has used, misdescribed, or stepped past unseeing; and the tradition's answer, which is also its greeting to the departing: the ford is marked, the path is swept, the library is open. Go well — and mind the step, for the road is inhabited.
One more door stands open at the year's end, and it is the derasar's — where the school's student, arriving unannounced at the dawn arti in any Jain town on earth, will be received with the tradition's whole curriculum in one gesture: the shoes taken, the flowers offered, the image shown, the library opened, the breakfast — without roots, before the hour grows late — pressed upon him by people whose doctrine forbids them to let a guest leave unfed or a question leave unanswered. The year's work has been an attempt to deserve that reception in advance: to arrive, for once, knowing whose house it is. The ford is marked, the path is swept, the hill is climbed by being vacated nightly and the statue by being bathed in milk once a generation. The rest is walking. Go well — and the school, borrowing the room's own words for its certificate's reverse, asks the year's pardon for every being its pages have stepped past unseeing: micchami dukkadam.