Adult Year 2 · Semester 3 — Values, ethics, and service
Four lessons for this semester. When you are ready, take the test for this semester.
Lesson 1: Ahimsa — nonviolence to all life and truthfulness as ethics
The values semester opens with the first two great vows as a paired ethic: ahimsa, the non-harming of all life, and satya, truthfulness — which this tradition binds together as one virtue's two faces. Ahimsa's ethical form is the semester's ground, restated from the foundations as a working system: the vow's analysis (the three modes, the three instruments) applied to the modern week's actual decisions (the purchases audited by the supply chain's census; the words audited by the speech's himsa — the tradition's classification counting the lie, the harsh word, and the tale-bearing as violence of the speech, so that the values semester's two vows are, in the analysis, one: the tongue is an instrument of harm exactly as the hand is, and its discipline is the hand's); the professional audits (the doctor's, the soldier's, the judge's — the tradition's casuistry of the licensed harms, conducted in its journals with the householder's settlement: the intention examined, the necessity proved, the regret required, the repair undertaken — the four tests by which a harm may be carried without the vow's breach, the tests being strict enough that the tradition's own professionals publish their failures against them); and ahimsa's positive form (not the mere abstention but the active protection — the shelter, the rescue, the intervention at the cruelty witnessed: the vow as a commission and not merely a prohibition, the bystander's passivity filed, in the analysis, under the third mode — the harm approved by the silence of the witness who could have spoken: the doctrine's most uncomfortable filing, and the semester's first examination).
Satya is the second word, and its Jain form is distinctive: truth is a vow with an ahimsa clause — the tradition's rule being that speech must be true, and must also not harm (the satya of the monks' discipline is defined as speech that is true, beneficial, and measured — and where the truth would kill (the hunter asking the way the deer went — the tradition's own test case, older than Kant's murderer), the rule's hierarchy is explicit in the commentaries: the life outranks the sentence, and the monk's answer is the silence or the word that saves — the building's long argument over the lying-to-the-murderer receiving, in this room, its earliest systematic settlement: ahimsa is the first vow, and satya serves within it); truth's other disciplines (the anekantavada of the foundations as speech's humility — the “in some respect” as the honest person's verbal habit, the claim sized to the standpoint: satya's Jain form being thus doubly disciplined, by the life it must not harm and by the facet it must not inflate); the commercial truth (the community's trademark honesty of the practice lesson, here as ethics: the true weight, the disclosed defect, the price without the ambush — the bazaar's testimony as the vow's longest-running audit); and the truth's interior form (the confession of the pratikraman — the fault named exactly, without the costume of excuse: satya turned on the self, the values semester's hinge between the tongue's virtue and the conscience's). The lesson's verdict joins the pair: ahimsa without truth becomes the sentimentality that will not name the harm; truth without ahimsa becomes the cruelty that names it with pleasure — and the tradition's person is the one whose speech could be audited by both vows at once and pass: true, and safe to hear. Non-stealing and non-greed follow: the hand's and the heart's economies.
The pair's last word is the deer: the hunter's question, asked at the forest's edge in the old story the commentaries never tire of, with the monk's silence for its answer and the deer's life for its stakes. The school's student will meet the case again in every room's ethics — Kant's murderer is its grandchild — and should remember which room answered it first and on what ground: not that the truth is small, but that the life is great, and that a vow is a hierarchy before it is a list. The tradition's whole ethics is in the ordering: ahimsa first, and the truth told within the shelter of the life it serves — the tongue's discipline being, in the end, the hand's, extended by other means. The student who can keep the order under pressure has the pair. The rest of the semester is its applications.
Lesson 2: Not stealing and not being greedy — aparigraha as ethics
The values semester's second lesson joins the third and fifth vows: asteya, non-stealing, and aparigraha, non-possession — the hand's restraint and the heart's, which this tradition treats as one ethic of enough. Asteya first, in the analysis's breadth: stealing is the taking of what is not given (the definition's Jain precision — adatta, the not-given: the vow auditing not only the theft of the law but the whole economy of the ungiven: the wage withheld, the tax evaded, the idea uncredited, the time of others consumed without leave, the commons enclosed, the future's share spent by the present's comfort — the definition's modern extensions being the tradition's own, drawn in its journals from the root sense: whatever is taken without the giver's gift is asteya's matter, and the modern world's characteristic thefts are mostly of this refined kind, committed by persons who would not pick a pocket); the vow's positive form (the economy of the gift — the dana of the merchant tradition, the surplus's return, the commons maintained: asteya's completion being not the locked door but the open hand, the community whose members' wealth is held, by the ethic's own description, in trust for the beings); and the audit's edge (the intellectual and the digital thefts — the pirated text, the plagiarized line: the tradition of the bhandars, which copied other men's books for a thousand years with the scribes' prayers, auditing the download with a casuistry its students find, in the journals, surprisingly gentle and entirely firm: the copying that preserves is the library's; the taking that deprives is the thief's; the line drawn, as always in this room, by the harm and the intention).
Aparigraha is the lesson's crown — non-possession, the fifth vow, the one the tradition itself calls the hardest and the one by which it is known in the modern world's imagination (the naked monk its icon, the merchant's limit its ethic). Its analysis: parigraha is not the having but the grasping (murchha — the soul's infatuation with the thing, the inner clutch by which the possession possesses: the vow's object being the clutch and not the inventory — the monk's nakedness being the clutch's total surgery, the householder's limit (parimana) its management: the ceiling set in advance, in writing, before the community (the vow's classical form: the householder declares his limit of wealth, of land, of goods, and the surplus beyond the ceiling is the beings' by the vow's own conveyance — the ethic as a property law of the soul, self-imposed and witnessed); the clutch's modern forms (the upgrade's treadmill, the portfolio's anxiety, the hoarded experiences and the curated self — the tradition's young teachers translating murchha for the diaspora's suburbs with an accuracy their audiences find uncomfortable: the storage unit as the parigraha's temple, the second home as its monastery of the wrong kind); and aparigraha's fruits, in the tradition's account (the fearlessness of the unclutched — the monk who cannot be robbed, the householder whose ceiling makes him unbribable at the price above it (the ethic's political form: the official whose limit is public cannot be purchased beyond it, the vow as an anti-corruption technology older than the republic's commissions); the lightness (the soul's dust and the house's dust shed together, the metaphor the tradition intends literally: the possessions are karma's favorite address). The lesson's verdict joins the vows: asteya keeps the hand from taking what is not given; aparigraha keeps the heart from keeping what it has — and between the two, the tradition builds its economics entire: enough, declared in advance, with the surplus spoken for. Forgiveness follows: the ethic's solvent, in which the year's accounts are closed.
The vows' last word is a number: the ceiling, written down. In the keeping houses the limit vow is still taken in its classical form — the figure declared before the teacher and the family, the surplus's destination named, the paper kept with the household's documents — and the community's elders testify that the writing is the vow: the unwritten limit drifts with the income, the written one holds. The school's student is invited, as the semester's examination, to perform the act in his own currency and at his own scale: name the figure above which the surplus is spoken for, write it where the household keeps its papers, and let one year audit the difference between the intention and the instrument. The monk's nakedness and the merchant's ceiling are the same vow at two temperatures. The student is not asked for the monk's. He is asked for the merchant's honesty about his own.
Lesson 3: Forgiveness and gentleness as ethics
The values semester's third lesson is the tradition's signature ethic entire: forgiveness (kshama) and gentleness — the virtues Paryushana rehearses and the year embodies. Forgiveness first, in its Jain depth: the tradition ranks kshama first among the ten supreme virtues of the Digambara Das Lakshana list (uttama kshama — supreme forgiveness — heading the ten: forgiveness, humility, straightforwardness, purity, truth, restraint, austerity, renunciation, non-possession, celibacy — the list itself an ethics course, and its headship the tradition's judgment that the whole path stands or falls at the point of the grudge); its analysis (forgiveness in this room is not the cancellation of the other's debt by the creditor's mood but the shedding of one's own karma by the forgiving soul (the anger is the forgiver's bondage — the foundations' first glue — and the forgiveness is therefore, in the system's exact sense, self-interested at the deepest level: the grudge is a weight the grudger carries, and laying it down is nirjara by the heart; the doctrine thus dissolving the modern debate about whether forgiveness must be earned or deserved — in this room it is neither granted nor withheld as a favor; it is dropped, as a stone is dropped, by the hand it was crushing); its scope (the festival's universality domesticated into the ethic's rule: forgive in advance of the asking where the asking cannot come — the dead, the ignorant, the beings of the census who wrong us by their nature (the mosquito forgiven in advance by the doctrine's logic, the school noting the sentence's smile and its seriousness in one breath); forgive the self in the same act (the pratikraman's confession and the forgiveness received from the beings meeting in one rite — the self's faults neither hoarded nor hidden: the ethic's psychology being, the modern literature increasingly notes, a complete therapy two millennia before the word — the grudge audited, the fault named, the pardon exchanged, the account closed annually and the interest stopped); and its limit, audited (forgiveness is not the waiving of justice (the court may sentence while the heart releases — the two accounts kept in separate ledgers by the tradition's own casuistry: the victim's forgiveness of the murderer does not commute the sentence, nor does the sentence forbid the forgiveness — the distinction by which the ethic survives its hardest cases, and by which the community's forgiveness of its historical persecutors has coexisted, for centuries, with its lawyers' excellent work).
Gentleness is the lesson's second word — forgiveness's manner, and the tradition's whole style raised to a virtue: the gentleness of the hand (the broom's ethic generalized — the touch that attends to the touched: the animal handled as a soul, the child as a census of one, the object even (the Jain care of things — the book wrapped, the instrument cleaned, the door closed without the slam: aparigraha's and ahimsa's child, the gentleness toward the inanimate as the training of the gentleness toward all); the gentleness of speech (the measured word of the values' first lesson — the voice's volume itself audited, the tradition's monks speaking softly by rule, the gentleness as an acoustic ahimsa: the shout as a small violence, the interruption as a smaller theft (of the other's sentence — asteya of the ear, in the journals' coinage); and the gentleness of judgment (anekantavada as manners — the opponent's facet granted before one's own is stated, the school's house rule recognized here as this room's native courtesy, exported to the building entire). The lesson's verdict: forgiveness is gentleness toward the past, gentleness is forgiveness rehearsed in the present — and the tradition's person is known, in the bazaars' and the neighbors' testimony across two millennia, by exactly this pair: the soft voice, the unclenched hand, the account closed before the festival. Service and justice follow: the pair at the scale of the society.
The pair's last word is a voice: the community's oldest nun, in the ethnographers' recordings, asked in her nineties what the path had finally taught her, answering — in the voice her rule had kept soft for seventy years — that it had taught her to be angry more slowly. The school's student should take the sentence as the values semester's most exact measurement: not the anger abolished (the census's souls are not promised that, this side of the siddhaloka) but the anger slowed — by the broom's habit, by the formula's annual rehearsal, by the doctrine that the grudge is a weight in one's own hand. Forgiveness, gentleness, the slowed anger: the three are one discipline at three speeds, and its examination is administered, as all this room's examinations are, by the next person who wrongs us. The tradition's whole preparation is for that hour. It comes, the nun would add, soon enough — speak softly when it does.
Lesson 4: Service, charity, and justice in Jainism
The values semester closes with the tradition's social ethics: service, charity, and justice — the vows at the scale of the city. The ground is the census's social form: every being a soul, every soul a fellow-traveler at a different rung — from which the tradition draws a social ethic of a distinctive shape (not equality of station (the ladder is real, and its rungs are earned across the lives) but equality of worth and of ultimate capacity (the ant is a future monk; the monk was an ant: the doctrine's radicalism being temporal — the hierarchy of the present dissolved in the biography of every soul, the school noting the settlement's double edge: it has made this community both the gentlest of neighbors and, in the historians' audit, among the least revolutionary of reformers — the ladder explaining the slums as it explains the ant, the karma doctrine's standing social cost, indicted by the Ambedkarite critique in the tradition's own modern literature and answered by the community's reformers from within the premise: the ladder is climbed by the soul, but nothing in the doctrine licenses the rung's cruelty, and the being on the lower rung is owed, by the census itself, the higher one's protection — the answer's adequacy being the argument the community continues with itself, in the open, as the school's columns require). Service is the ethic's first form (the vaiyavritya — the service of the monks, the sick, and the suffering — ranked among the austerities themselves in the tradition's lists (service as tapas: the karma burned by the bedside as by the fast — the doctrine by which the nurse's shift and the monk's exposure stand in one column of the ledger); the seva of the shelter and the kitchen of the celebrations semester, here as principle: the service directed, by the census's logic, to the beings least able to return it — the animal, the destitute, the dying — the return's impossibility being, in the ethic's arithmetic, the service's purity and its point).
Charity is the second form (dana — the gift — in its four classical kinds, which the tradition enumerates as the community's whole philanthropy in a list: ahara-dana, the gift of food; aushadha-dana, the gift of medicine; jnana-dana, the gift of knowledge (the libraries, the schools, the copied books of the bhandars — the gift this school itself exists by); and abhaya-dana, the gift of fearlessness — protection, sanctuary, the ransom of the doomed: the list's order being the tradition's priorities in a column (food first, then the body's cure, then the mind's, then the life's safety entire) — and the modern community's philanthropy audited against the list by its own accountants with satisfaction the school records: the kitchens, the hospitals, the universities, the shelters, all four gifts institutionalized and running, the list of the acharyas become the budget of a community). Justice is the third form and the semester's summit: the tradition's justice is peculiarly shaped by its premises (no divine judge and no final assize — the karma machine's indifference making the human court more necessary, not less: the justice men do not do is not done at all, the doctrine's political edge, drawn by the community's own jurists (the Jain law tradition of the medieval courts, the community's reputation for the arbitrated settlement — the panchayat's award preferred to the court's war, the dispute dissolved by the elders' mediation as the grudge is dissolved by the festival: justice as a pratikraman with jurisdiction); the modern record (the community's minorities' rights defended by its lawyers in the republic's courts — the sallekhana case as the tradition's own justice claim, the state asked to let its citizens die as their doctrine composes them, the claim's difficulty kept whole in the modern lesson's columns; the animal's standing in the law (the community's litigation for the birds and the cattle — the census acquiring counsel, the Indian courts' animal-rights jurisprudence owing several of its leading petitions to Jain plaintiffs and Jain funds: the premise in a wig and gown, arguing the ant's cousins' case in the republic's highest courts — the values semester's most characteristic modern image); and the school's verdict: service is the ethic's hands, charity its purse, justice its voice — and in this room all three are audited by the same small question the broom asks at the path: who is underfoot here, and have we swept? The places follow: the hill of temples, the standing saint, and the arts of the smallest room.
The justice lesson's final exhibit is a courtroom of the republic's, where the census's smallest cousins had their day: the community's advocates arguing, from the constitution's own articles, for the birds of the city's markets and the cattle of its roads — the premise proceeding in the forms of the modern state with the patience of a tradition that has been filing its case for two and a half millennia. The school's student should mark the scene as the values semester's closing proof: an ethic is alive when it can still bring a case — for the beings who cannot — in the courts of an age that did not write its premises. The Jain ethic can. It does. The docket, like the census, is endless, and the advocates, like the sweepers, show up. The places follow, where the case is kept in stone.