Adult Year 1 · Semester 1 — Foundations
Four lessons for this semester. When you are ready, take the test for this semester.
Lesson 1: Jainism: an adult introduction
Jainism is the smallest of this building's great Indian rooms — some four to five million adherents, nearly all in India, with a prosperous diaspora — and by its own account among the oldest: a shramana tradition, a path of strivers, that arose in the Gangetic plain in the centuries before the Buddha, and that claims, through its line of twenty-four Tirthankaras (ford-makers, the teachers who cross the river of rebirth and show the crossing), an antiquity reaching back beyond history altogether. The adult introduction must first place the room in the building: Jainism shares its courtyard with the Hindu and Buddhist rooms — the same vocabulary of karma, samsara, moksha, ahimsa — and differs from both at the foundations: against the Hindu room, it knows no creator god and no caste by divine ordinance (its universe is eternal and uncreated, its gods themselves liberated souls or celestial beings still within the wheel); against the Buddhist room, it affirms the soul (the jiva, eternal and individual in every living being) where Buddhism denies it — the two renouncer cousins, born in the same century and the same countryside, dividing on the existence of the very thing their shared path exists to free. Its name is from jina — the conqueror, the victor over the inner enemies (passion, anger, greed, pride) — and its adherents are the conqueror's followers: the tradition's whole character is in the word, a conquest whose only battlefield is the self and whose only casualties permitted are the conqueror's own faults.
The tradition's map, for orientation: at its center stands the soul's predicament and its remedy, stated with a systematic rigor that makes this room the most philosophical of the Indian three — the universe of jiva (souls, in every living thing from the human to the one-sensed beings in earth, water, fire, and air) and ajiva (non-soul: matter, space, time, and the media of motion and rest); karma conceived not as a ledger's metaphor but as a subtle matter (pudgala) that literally sticks to the soul, weighing it down the wheel; the path of the three jewels (ratnatraya — right faith, right knowledge, right conduct) by which the influx of karma is stopped (samvara) and the accumulated store burned off (nirjara) until the soul, lightened, rises to the top of the universe (siddhaloka) and abides there in infinite knowledge, perception, bliss, and energy — moksha, not a heaven of reward but the soul's own nature uncovered. Around the doctrine stands the community's famous division: the Digambaras (sky-clad — their monks naked, their nuns in white, holding that women must be reborn male to attain liberation and that Mahavira's canon was lost) and the Shvetambaras (white-clad — monks and nuns in white, holding that women can attain liberation (their nineteenth Tirthankara, Mallinatha, a woman) and preserving the Agamas as Mahavira's teaching) — the schism of the early centuries, never healed and no longer much regretted, the two traditions sharing the temples' calendars in the diaspora's suburbs and the foundations entire. The laity — the merchants and bankers whose community has been, for two millennia, among India's most prosperous and most charitable — live the path in its householder's measure (the anuvratas, the small vows, against the monks' mahavratas, the great ones), and the tradition's public face is their work: the animal hospitals, the libraries, the temple art, and the diet that excludes even the root vegetables, lest the plant's whole life be taken with the meal.
The introduction closes with the school's method for this room, whose peculiar demand is precision: this tradition argues — its logic of many-sidedness (anekantavada) is the building's most sophisticated epistemology, and its karma theory its most exact moral physics — and the student is asked to learn it as a system before judging it as a curiosity (the naked monk and the swept path are the system's conclusions, not its premises, and the year will derive them); the tradition's hard places (sallekhana, the fast to death, kept in the record's full legal and ethical argument; the Digambara doctrine on women's liberation, stated as held and as contested within the tradition itself) will be given whole, in the school's columns, without the building's thumb on the scale; and the student's posture is the one the tradition commends to its own novices at the temple door: the mouth covered, in spirit, until the facts are in — the mask's lesson being that even our breath is an act with consequences, and the first of them is on the smallest lives around us. The foundations proceed: the soul in everything, the matter that binds it, and the truth that is many-sided because reality is.
The introduction's last orientation is demographic: the Jains are India's most urban and most literate religious community, concentrated in Maharashtra, Gujarat, Rajasthan, Madhya Pradesh, and Karnataka, with the diaspora's temples in the suburbs of London, Toronto, and Antwerp — a community whose influence on the building vastly exceeds its numbers, because its premises (the animal ethic, the many-sided logic, the fast and the forgiveness festival) have a way of being adopted by the neighbors. Gandhi — formed in a Gujarati household under Jain influence, his mentor Raychandbhai this room's philosopher — is the adoption's most famous case: the twentieth century's ahimsa was substantially drafted here. The student who understands why the smallest room supplied the largest century's central doctrine has the introduction entire.
Lesson 2: Every living thing has a soul (jiva) and ahimsa — never harm any living being in depth
The foundations' second lesson takes the room's first article in depth: the jiva — the soul in every living thing — and the ahimsa that follows from it as this tradition's absolute. The jiva first, in its system: the soul is eternal, individual, and by nature omniscient and blissful — consciousness is not the soul's product but its substance (the Jain soul does not have awareness; it is awareness, clouded) — and it inhabits, in the wheel's economy, every living body in the universe's census, which the tradition draws with a biologist's patience two millennia before the microscope: the one-sensed beings (ekendriya — the earth-bodied, water-bodied, fire-bodied, air-bodied, and plant-bodied souls, possessing only the sense of touch: the tradition's most distinctive doctrine, extending soulhood to the elements themselves and to the nigodas, the microscopic beings clustered in all matter, whose existence the modern student cannot help hearing as a premonition of the microbial world, and which the school's columns file as the tradition's own claim, astonishing in its anticipation and different in its kind — the nigoda is a soul, not a germ, and the resemblance is a parable, not a priority claim); the two-sensed (worms, with taste), the three (ants, with smell), the four (bees, with sight), and the five-sensed (animals and humans, with hearing, and some with mind) — the census as a ladder of embodiment up which the soul climbs by its karma across the lives, the human birth being the ladder's one rung from which liberation can be reached. The doctrine's emotional logic is the lesson's heart: if the ant and the tree and the water-drop are souls as one's own is — clouded, striving, capable of suffering and of eventual glory — then the world is not a warehouse of resources but a crowd of fellow-travelers, and ethics is not a policy but a recognition.
Ahimsa is the recognition's practice, and in this room it is not the gradient the Hindu room keeps but the absolute the vow requires: the first of the five great vows (mahavratas) of the monks — non-harming, truth, non-stealing, celibacy, non-possession — and the first of the householders' small vows in its measure, defined with the system's precision as the avoidance of himsa in its three modes (done oneself, caused to be done, approved when done by others — the audit's three doors, by which the householder who orders the meat he would not slaughter is inside the doctrine's jurisdiction entire) and its three instruments (body, speech, and mind — the angry thought a himsa of the mind, the careless word of the speech, the doctrine examining the interior as the Hindu room's karma did, with the same conclusion: the thought is an act). The practice's famous forms are the system's deductions, and the lesson derives them rather than marveling at them: the monk's mask (the mukhavastrika, worn lest the breath harm the beings of the air), the broom (the rajoharana, of peacock feathers or soft wool, sweeping the seat and the path before the foot falls), the water strained, the meal taken before dark (lest the lamp draw the insects to their deaths in the kitchen's light), the vegetables audited by the census (the root vegetables refused — the bulb is a whole being's body and a colony of the small lives; the greens, whose taking spares the plant, permitted in the householder's measure) — each practice a theorem from the census, and the school's student is to hold them as such: this is what the world looks like when one premise — every living thing is a soul like yours — is followed without flinching for two thousand years.
The lesson closes with the article's audit, kept as the room keeps it: the absolute's cost (the monk's life is the cost's display — the tradition does not pretend the premise is cheap, and its householders' graded vows are the honest settlement between the premise and the plough); the modern collisions (the laboratory's animals, the medicine's animal-tested mercies, the vegan Jain of the diaspora extending the census to the dairy the homeland's practice kept — the tradition arguing with itself in its journals about the cow's milk its temples have always used, the argument being the premise at work on its own heirs); and the article's gift to the building, which the Hindu room has already acknowledged: this room is the absolute's keeper, the north by which the other rooms' gradients are measured — and its own teachers, at their most characteristic, decline the honor's comfort: the ant's soul is not a metaphor for the human's duty, they say; it is the ant's. The karma lesson follows: the matter that binds the soul, and the engineering of its release.
The census's last word belongs to its smallest citizens: the tradition holds that the earth under a single step contains more souls than the city above it contains people — and the monk who knows this walks differently, in a different relation to the ground: as a guest in an occupied house, whose host is too small to announce himself. The student is not asked to adopt the census, only to perform its experiment once: walk one familiar street attending to its beings — the pigeons, the weeds in the cracks (each a soul's whole address), the spider in the doorway — and report whether the street is the same street. The tradition's wager is that it is not.
Lesson 3: Karma sticks to the soul through actions and the soul can become free (moksha) in depth
The foundations' third lesson is the room's moral physics entire: karma as matter, its sticking and its shedding, and moksha as the soul's recovered lightness. The mechanism first, in the system's own engineering: the soul, by its very nature, vibrates through its activity (yoga — the word here meaning the soul's movement through body, speech, and mind), and the vibration draws the karmic matter (the pudgala particles, the universe's finest dust) toward it as a magnet draws filings — this is asrava, the influx. Whether the matter sticks, and how hard, depends on the soul's moisture: the passions (kashaya — anger, pride, deceit, greed, the four great glues) make the soul sticky as oil makes the cloth take the dust; the dispassionate act draws the particles and sheds them as the dry surface sheds. The bound karma (bandha) is of kinds the system enumerates with a chemist's patience — eight natures (prakriti): the knowledge-obscuring, the perception-obscuring, the feeling-producing (pleasure and pain's very capacity), the deluding (the passions' root and faith's cloud), the lifespan-determining, the body-making (which body, which senses, which station on the census's ladder), the status-determining, and the obstructing (which blocks even the good act's completion) — each with its duration and its intensity, ripening (udaya) in its season as the life's circumstances, and falling away when spent. The adult should mark what this physics accomplishes as a theodicy and as an ethic: no god keeps the books because no bookkeeper is needed — the matter is the bookkeeping; no act is lost because the universe is a closed system of souls and dust; and the responsibility is total and impersonal at once, the system's comfort and its terror being the same fact: the machine does not hate you, and it does not forgive you; it only adheres.
The release is the mechanism reversed, and the lesson gives its engineering with the same care: samvara, the stoppage of the influx (the vows as valves — each kept vow a channel closed; the carefulnesses (samiti) and the restraints (gupti) of the monk's rule as the stoppage's daily form; the passions starved, the soul drying, the dust ceasing to stick); nirjara, the shedding of the accumulated store (by its natural ripening — the slow way, the wheel's ordinary economy — or by austerity (tapas) deliberately undertaken, which burns the karma as friction burns the rope: the fasts, the exposures, the meditations of the monk's life as a technology of dissociation, the store of lifetimes discharged in a life by the heat of the practice); and the end, when the last particle falls: the soul, its nature unobstructed, rises — by its own buoyancy, as the gourd freed of its clay coating rises in the water, in the texts' own image — to the siddhaloka at the universe's crown, there to abide forever in the four infinitudes (infinite knowledge, infinite perception, infinite bliss, infinite energy), individual forever (the Jain moksha keeps the soul's separateness — a heaven of infinite monads, each omniscient, none merging: the doctrine's most distinctive note against both the Hindu room's ocean-drop and the Buddhist room's blowing-out), and never to return. The path's timetable is the lesson's honesty: the store of lifetimes is not shed in an afternoon — the tradition's own saints take lives at it, and the householder's path is frankly preparatory (the small vows as the training of the soul's dryness across the births until the great vows become possible) — the system's patience being, in the school's judgment, its pastoral realism: nobody is damned, everybody is dusty, and the dust can be shed.
The lesson closes with the physics' audit: the doctrine's rigor is its apologetic problem (the karma that explains the child's suffering by the child's own past is the building's hardest sentence in this room's most exact form — the tradition's teachers answering, as the Hindu room's did, that the doctrine explains and never excuses, that the sufferer's claim on our ahimsa is total precisely because his karma is his business and his suffering is ours — the settlement kept, with the tension visible, as the school's columns keep it everywhere); and its rigor is its gift (the moral universe without a judge is also without a tyrant: no Jain was ever burned for heresy by a church that does not exist, no inquisition is constructible from these premises — the system's tolerance being not a policy but a physics, which the next lesson's many-sided truth raises into an epistemology). The ford-makers follow: the truth's many sides, and the teachers who crossed.
The physics' last word is its gentlest: because the karma is matter and not judgment, the system knows no unforgivable act and no eternal sentence — the worst soul in the census is a soul with more dust, and dust can always be shed; the murderer and the saint differ in tonnage, not in kind, and the road's length is the only sentence the universe pronounces. The tradition's teachers draw the pastoral consequence without flinching: there is no one to despair of — not the criminal, not the addict, not oneself — because the physics guarantees what the other rooms' mercies promise: the account can always be worked down, starting from this act, this hour, this breath taken carefully. The school's student should mark the sentence as the foundations' most portable: the dust is real, and so is the broom.
Lesson 4: Many-sided truth — anekantavada and the Tirthankaras show the path in depth
The foundations close with the room's crown: anekantavada — the doctrine of the many-sidedness of reality — and the Tirthankaras, the ford-makers who embody the path the doctrine maps. Anekantavada first, in depth: reality, the Jain analysis holds, is anekanta — many-ended, infinitely faceted (every real thing possessing infinite qualities, standing in infinite relations, persisting through infinite modes) — from which it follows that any single statement about it is a naya, a standpoint: true from its side, partial as a whole, and false only when it claims to be the whole. The doctrine's famous instrument is syadvada, the doctrine of “in some respect” (syat — “maybe,” “in a sense”) with its sevenfold predication (saptabhangi): of any thing one may say, in some respect it is; in some respect it is not; in some respect it is and is not (successively); in some respect it is inexpressible (the is-and-is-not grasped at once, which words cannot carry); and the three combinations of inexpressibility with the first three — seven true sentences where the dogmatist and the skeptic each insist on one. The blind men and the elephant is the doctrine's parable (each man's report true, each man's total false — the parable the building has met in the Hindu room's keeping, its Jain origin being the school's note: the parable is this room's patent, licensed to all the neighbors). The doctrine's purpose is the lesson's emphasis: anekantavada is not relativism (the elephant is one, and the omniscient kevalin sees it whole — the truth exists and is total; it is only the embodied knower who sees it in facets) and it is not mere tolerance (it is a logic with a metaphysics under it: the facets are the reality's own, not the knower's invention) — it is, in the tradition's own summary, the intellectual form of ahimsa: violence begins, the Jain philosophers argue, where a partial view arms itself as the whole (the ekanta, the one-sided absolute, being the seed of every persecution the record keeps — the doctrine thus making this room, by its own logic, the building's most principled pluralist: not from politeness but from physics).
The Tirthankaras are the doctrine's witnesses: the twenty-four ford-makers of this time-cycle, from Rishabha the first (the culture-bringer of the myths — the teacher of agriculture, marriage, and the arts to the first men) to Mahavira the twenty-fourth, each a soul that shed the whole store, attained omniscience (kevala), taught the path, and left the crossing marked for others. Their status is the lesson's precision: they are not gods who made the world (the universe is uncreated), not saviors who carry the devotee (each soul sheds its own dust — no Tirthankara can shed another's, the doctrine's austere mercy), but teachers and proofs — the path is walkable because they walked it, and their images in the temples (serene, identical but for the emblem at the base — the bull, the snake, the conch by which the twenty-four are told apart, the sameness itself the doctrine: liberation has one face) receive a worship the tradition explains as emulation, not petition (the Tirthankara, liberated, hears nothing and grants nothing — the prayer before his image is the devotee's address to his own future, the worship as a mirror: the building's most unusual theory of what a temple is for). The community's calendar keeps their five great events (the panchakalyanaka — conception, birth, renunciation, omniscience, liberation — celebrated for each, Mahavira's at the year's festivals) and their line is the history semester's plot. The foundations' synthesis: a universe of souls, a dust that binds them, a truth too many-sided for any one sentence, and twenty-four witnesses that the dust can be shed entire — the adult who can state the four owns the architecture, and every later semester is a room in it. The history follows: the ford-makers' centuries, from the mists of the first to the records of the last.
The doctrine's last word is its founder-generation's own demonstration, which the foundations should end by recording: when the Buddha's disciple and Mahavira's disputed the same question in the early texts, and when the Jain monks debated the Hindu logicians of the medieval courts, the tradition's controversialists practiced their epistemology as a courtesy — stating the opponent's naya at its strongest before answering it, on the doctrine's own logic that the opponent's facet is also the elephant's. The school adopts the practice as the building's house rule for every argument in its curriculum, and credits this room with the patent: state the other side's truth first, in its strongest form, and only then your own. The student who can do it for the doctrines he most opposes has learned anekantavada in the only form that finally matters — not as a list of seven predications, but as a habit of the mind at the moment it would rather be certain. The ford, the tradition says, is crossed at exactly that moment.