Adult Year 2 · Semester 1 — People and stories
Four lessons for this semester. When you are ready, take the test for this semester.
Lesson 1: Albert Einstein: life and legacy
Year Two's people semester opens with the scientist the world made its sage: Albert Einstein — claimed by this room, with the audit the claim requires stated at the outset: Einstein believed in “Spinoza's God” (his own formula, in the famous 1929 telegram: “I believe in Spinoza's God, who reveals himself in the lawful harmony of all that exists”), declined the personal God and the afterlife entire, signed the humanist rosters, corresponded with the movement's leaders, and let the Ethical Culture world claim him as its most famous fellow-traveler — a claim he never corrected, the school noting that the dead cannot correct claims and that this one's own words are unusually explicit on both sides of the fence: the cosmic religious feeling he preached, and the “childish superstition” he called the Bible's legends in the same decade's letters. The life, in the arc the movement tells: the slow-speaking child of Ulm and Munich (the compass at five — the needle's invisible obedience his first wonder, by his own account the experience that set the life); the patent clerk of Bern (the day job at the Swiss office, the evenings that produced 1905 — the miracle year: the photoelectric effect's quanta, Brownian motion's atoms made visible, special relativity's union of space and time, and E=mc² as the year's postscript, four papers that rebuilt physics, written by a twenty-six-year-old examiner of inventions in his spare hours — the biography's standing rebuke to every institution that measures its clerks); the decade of the general theory (the happiest thought — the falling man who does not feel his weight — pursued through the mathematics he had to learn as he went, to the field equations of November 1915 and the Mercury orbit's anomaly falling out of them like a key); the eclipse of 1919 (Eddington's photographs, the starlight bent by the sun's mass as the theory required — the world made him its oracle in a single headline season, the German Jew become the universe's explainer in the year of the peace); Berlin and the gathering storm (the Nobel of 1921 — for the photoelectric effect, the committee carefully not saying relativity; the Zionism he held as a cultural and never a nationalist faith, the Hebrew University founded with his name; the flight of 1933 — the house raided, the papers burned, the price on his head; Princeton, the citizenship of 1940 taken with the civics test's famous barefoot photograph).
The legacy is the lesson's second half, and it divides, as he foresaw, into the physics and the conscience: the physics entire (the general theory as the century's foundation — the expanding universe he resisted and accepted, the black holes he doubted and the gravitational waves he predicted, detected a century later in 2015 to the year's headlines; the quantum mechanics he midwifed and then opposed — “God does not play dice” against Bohr's “stop telling God what to do” — the great debate in which he lost and by losing sharpened the victors: the EPR paper's “spooky action” becoming, two generations on, the entanglement industry's founding document — the legacy's irony being that his refutations built as much as his proofs); and the conscience (the letter to Roosevelt of 1939, signed at Szilárd's urging, that set the American bomb in motion — and the regret he carried publicly for the rest of his life (“had I known the Germans would not succeed, I would not have lifted a finger”); the Russell–Einstein Manifesto of 1955, signed from his deathbed season — “remember your humanity, and forget the rest” — the founding text of the Pugwash movement, the scientists' conscience organized; the civil rights (the Lincoln University address, the friendship with Robeson and Du Bois, the offer to testify for the defense — the FBI file thickening: the sage as the state's suspect, both facts the legacy keeps); and the humanist bequest proper (the essays — “The World As I See It,” the credo of 1930, with its dismissal of the personal God and its reverence for the mystery — the movement's most reprinted short text, and its author's instruction that the mystery, not the doctrine, is the religious thing). The verdict: this room claims him not as a member but as a demonstration — that the examined universe and the examined conscience can be one life's two hemispheres, and that the man who bent the starlight spent his last decade trying to bend the arms race, with the same formula for both: think, and then refuse to stop thinking at the border of the comfortable. Nehru follows: the position in power, the rarer and harder exhibit.
The legacy's last exhibit is a house in Princeton and a brain in a jar — the pathologist's theft of the organ at the autopsy, kept for decades in a cider box, studied in slices by the curious: the relic the position's saint never consented to become — and no genius was found in the tissue. The school's student should file the jar beside the Panthéon's lead coffin of the Curie lesson: the modern world makes relics of its unbelievers with the same hands it used for its saints, and the position's only defense is the one its exemplars left in writing — the work, the words, and the explicit refusal to be anything but read. Read them, then. The jar is empty of everything but the warning.
Lesson 2: Jawaharlal Nehru — a humanist leader: life and legacy
The people semester's second life is the position's rarest exhibit: the humanist in power — Jawaharlal Nehru, the first prime minister of India, who governed a deeply religious civilization for seventeen years as an agnostic of this room's persuasion, and whose The Discovery of India (written in a British prison, 1944–46) is the movement's great statesman's book. The life: born 1889 to the Kashmiri Brahmin aristocracy of Allahabad — Motilal Nehru's son, Harrow and Cambridge, the barrister's wig — and converted, like his generation's best, from the empire's law to its overthrow: Gandhi's lieutenant and frequent dissenter (the disciple who argued with the Mahatma about gods, machines, and economics in letters both men kept — the building's interfaith archive at its most civilized: the saint and the skeptic building one movement on two metaphysics, the partnership the modern world's pluralists cite as the proof of concept); the imprisonments (nine years in total across the Raj's jails, the books written there — the Glimpses of World History as letters to his daughter Indira, the world history from a cell as a father's curriculum: the people semester notes the form, a prison correspondence becoming a people's university); independence and partition (the “tryst with destiny” speech of August 14–15, 1947 — the midnight hour's address, the century's great English oration from a non-native pen; the refugee columns and the massacres administered by a government weeks old; Gandhi's assassination and Nehru's broadcast — “the light has gone out of our lives” — the skeptic preaching the nation's grief in the idiom it needed, the statesman's pastoral office performed by the unbeliever without a syllable of unbelief obtruded: the lesson the movement's chaplains still cite).
The legacy is the building of the secular, scientific state on a religious civilization — and its audit, which the school keeps at full size in both columns: the temples of modern India, in his own famous phrase at the Bhakra Nangal dam (the dams, the steel plants, the institutes of technology and the atomic energy establishment — Bhabha's patronage, the space program's founding: the scientific temper written into the constitution's fundamental duties (Article 51A(h) — “to develop the scientific temper, humanism and the spirit of inquiry and reform” — the only constitution on earth that makes this room's method a citizen's duty, Nehru's bequest in a clause); the secular settlement (the Hindu Code's reforms carried against his own party's orthodox, the state equidistant and interventionist at once — the settlement the Hindu room's modern lesson audited from its side); the foreign policy of non-alignment (Bandung 1955, the third world's co-founding — and its audit: the China war of 1962, the Himalayan frontier's collapse, the old man's heartbreak and death within two years, the policy's idealism indicted by its geography); and the personal bequest (the will's famous paragraph — no religious rites at his funeral, the ashes scattered from an aircraft over the fields of India and a handful to the Ganga at Allahabad “not because of any religious significance” but because the river was the symbol of the culture he had served: the unbeliever's ashes in the goddess's water by his own instruction — the building's rooms, again, sharing a river). The verdict: Nehru is the movement's answer to the question whether the position can govern — it can, for seventeen years, over a sixth of mankind, building the dams and the institutes and holding the plural state together through its founding traumas — and its standing warning about the price: the scientific temper proclaimed from above remained, in the villages, an aspiration audited daily by the civilization it governed, and the gap between the constitution's clause and the street's practice is the legacy's unfinished chapter, still being written by the heirs of both his metaphysics and his Mahatma's. The disease story follows: the position's method at its most triumphant, in the ward and the laboratory.
The legacy's most intimate exhibit closes the life: the Discovery's author in his last years, at the desk in Teen Murti House, keeping — his secretaries recorded — a single poem by Robert Frost where he could see it, its last lines the skeptic's own chosen epitaph-in-advance: “I have promises to keep, and miles to go before I sleep.” The movement claims the poem as it claims the man: not for a membership but for a manner — the promises kept without a promiser's heaven, the miles walked without a destination's promise, the sleep accepted without a sequel. The school's student, who has now met the position in its clerk and its prime minister, owns its two exhibits entire: the mind that bent the starlight and the state that held a sixth of mankind — both built on the one life, both audited by it, both, in the record's judgment, worth the building. The diseases follow, and the dams' engineers would approve the transition: from the statesman to the sewer, the position's true cathedral works.
Lesson 3: How doctors and scientists cured diseases together: the story in full
The people semester's third lesson is a collective biography — the story, told in full, of how the position's method did its most undeniable work: the conquest of the infectious diseases that had culled every generation in this building's history. The story's first act is the germ theory's improbable birth: Semmelweis in Vienna (1847) halving the childbed fever deaths by the washing of hands in chlorinated lime — and dying, rejected and half-mad, in an asylum while the wards went back to killing (the story's permanent exhibit of the method's human cost: the evidence was in his tables and the establishment's hands stayed dirty for another generation — the room's teachers telling it to their novices as the doctrine of the correction's price); Pasteur's swan-neck flasks and the anthrax and rabies vaccines (the boy Joseph Meister, bitten and saved in 1885, growing up to guard the Institute's door); Lister's carbolic spray in the Glasgow wards; Koch's postulates and the tubercle bacillus (1882) — the method acquiring, in one generation, its saints, its martyrs, and its instruments. The second act is the arsenal: Fleming's contaminated plate (1928) and the penicillin it took a war and the Oxford team — Florey, Chain, and Heatley carrying the mold's juice to mass production in the American fermentation plants — to turn into the drug that changed the species' expectation of a bacterial infection from a death sentence to an inconvenience (the story's hinge being industrial as much as intellectual: the method's miracle required the factory, the funder, and the state — the lesson's insistence that the cures were a civilization's work, not a genius's); Ehrlich's magic bullet and the sulfa drugs; the vaccines' succession (Jenner's cowpox of 1796 standing at the story's head as its pre-scientific prologue — an empirical folk practice the method adopted and explained; Salk's killed-virus polio vaccine (field trial 1954, a million and a half American schoolchildren in the largest medical experiment yet run, the results announced on April 12, 1955 to church bells — the scientist refusing the patent: “could you patent the sun?”); Sabin's oral vaccine; and the endgame the story exists to tell: smallpox — the speckled monster that killed more of the species than all its wars — hunted to extinction by the WHO campaign (1967–1980), the surveillance-and-containment strategy of Foege and the shoe-leather epidemiology of a hundred thousand vaccinators, the last natural case a Somali cook, Ali Maow Maalin (1977), the eradication declared in 1980: the first disease abolished, by method, from the earth.
The story's third act is its audit, which the school's columns keep as the room itself keeps it — proudly and without exemption: the method's crimes in its own house (the Tuskegee study's forty years of watched syphilis; the thalidomide the regulators' caution — Frances Kelsey's refusal at the FDA — kept from the American market while Europe's children paid: the audit's two faces being the same lesson, that the method includes its ethics or it is not the method); the unfinished ledger (malaria's annual hundreds of thousands, the tuberculosis that Koch's bacillus still deals to the poor, the HIV years — the plague of the story's own century, answered at last by the antiretrovirals' alchemy of a death sentence into a chronic condition, the activists of ACT UP forcing the method's pace from outside its institutions: the correction arriving, as it does, by pressure as well as by proof); the antibiotic resistance gathering (Fleming's own Nobel lecture warning of it — the prophet auditing his miracle in advance); and the story's meaning for the room, stated by its teachers without triumphalism's full volume: the cures are what the foundations' articles look like with a budget — the one life's value, the method's discipline, the responsibility institutionalized — and the empty chairs at every family's table in the centuries before are the audit of every other arrangement the species tried. The story is told, in this school, at the length it deserves, because it is the position's best evidence that its articles are not a consolation but a tool. The rebuilding story follows: the same articles, after the flood.
The story's final scene is a laboratory in 1980 and a health worker's motorbike in the years after — the eradication's certificate signed, and the same machinery turning, with less glory and more difficulty, to the polio endgame that is still, in the school's present tense, a few valleys in Afghanistan and Pakistan short of the second abolition. The story's teachers end it there deliberately: not at the triumph but at the unfinished valley, because the position's stories are not permitted the older rooms' endings — no final victory this side of the species' own end, only the method, the budget, and the next valley. The student who wants the story's moral in one sentence is given the vaccinators' own, collected by the historians from a hundred campaigns: nobody is coming to save us, so we saved each other, and it worked, and it is not finished. That is the whole of the position, with its sleeves rolled up, in a single breath.
Lesson 4: People who rebuilt after disasters by helping each other: the story in full
The people semester closes with the second collective story — the rebuilding after disaster, told in full — because it is the foundations' responsibility article photographed in the field: no heaven rebuilding, no karma explaining; the neighbors, the strangers, and the slow return of the ordinary. The story's pattern is set by its best-documented case, which the lesson tells entire: Halifax, December 6, 1917 — the collision in the harbor of the Mont-Blanc, a French munitions ship, with the Norwegian Imo; the largest man-made explosion before the atomic age (some 2.9 kilotons), the city's north end erased in the blast and the fires, 1,782 dead by the official count, nine thousand injured, the harbor's water sucked out and returned as a wave, the snowstorm arriving that night on the ruins. The rebuilding's cast is the story's thesis: the special train from Boston — dispatched the same night through the storm, carrying the Massachusetts relief committee's doctors, nurses, and supplies, arriving December 8 through the drifts — the aid that founded a century of the two cities' gratitude (Halifax's Christmas tree, sent to Boston Common every year since, is the story's monument in lights); the blinded hundreds (the explosion's signature injury — the glass of the windows the crowds had watched from — and the city's response: the school for the blind, the pensions, the CNIB's founding impetus in the disaster's ledger); the orphans and the widows housed by the Halifax Relief Commission's planned suburb (the Hydrostone district — the garden-suburb blocks of stone-faced concrete that stand today as the rebuilding's architecture: disaster's child as a neighborhood of unusual beauty, the commission's work audited, in the story's columns, for its paternalism as well as its competence); and the city's own hands (the lesson's emphasis, from the record: the survivors were digging in the ruins before the Boston train was loaded — the outside aid mattered enormously and the first rescuers were, as they always are, the people already there).
The story generalizes, in its second half, across the record the century kept: San Francisco 1906 (the earthquake and fire, the tent cities in the parks, the bread lines — and the insurance and the banks reopening in tents, the city's refusal performed as bookkeeping); the Blitz's East End and the Coventry of November 1940 (the cathedral's ruins kept beside Spence's new one — “Father Forgive” carved behind the altar, the rebuilding's theology in two words, from a room this position does not share and whose sentence it adopts without reservation); Kobe 1995 (the year of the volunteer in Japan — the 1.3 million who came, the disaster that founded the modern Japanese nonprofit sector: the story's institutional form, a society discovering its own hands); the tsunami of 2004 and Aceh's peace (the disaster ending a thirty-year war, the enemies disarming into the reconstruction — the rebuilding as a peace process, the record's most astonishing entry); New Orleans 2005 and the audit it forces (the rebuilding's inequality — the neighborhoods that returned and the ones that did not, the Lower Ninth against the Garden District: the story's second column entire, the responsibility's distribution being the justice question of the values semester wearing waders); and the pattern's name, from the sociologists who study it (Solnit's “paradise built in hell” — the disaster literature's finding, replicated across a century of case studies, that the ordinary response to catastrophe is not the panic and looting of the official imagination but an improvised, joyful, ferociously competent mutual aid — the finding this room adopts as its anthropology's cornerstone: the species, stripped of its arrangements, defaults to helping — the foundations' second article (people can be good) with a century of fieldwork under it). The verdict closes the people semester: the saints of this room are a patent clerk, a prime minister, a hundred thousand vaccinators, and the population of Halifax with shovels — the position's hagiography being, characteristically, a census. The celebrations follow: what such a species does on its days off.
The rebuilding story's last word is the Christmas tree on Boston Common — lit every December since the trains ran, cut each year in Nova Scotia within sight of the harbor where the Mont-Blanc burned, and trucked south by the descendants of the people the Bostonians dug out. The school's student should hold the tree as the people semester's final icon: not a doctrine, not a monument of stone, but a living thing, felled and raised annually, commemorating the discovery the semester's four stories make in common — that when the arrangements fail, the species does not. The clerk knew it at his patent desk, the prime minister at his midnight microphone, the vaccinators in their valleys, and the Haligonians in their ruins. The position merely wrote it down and organized a rota around it. The celebrations that follow are the rota's days off — and they are, the semester will show, the same discovery wearing its good clothes.