Adult Year 1 · Semester 3 — Texts and teachings
Four lessons for this semester. When you are ready, take the test for this semester.
Lesson 1: The Humanist Manifesto: a guided overview
The texts semester opens with the movement's founding document — which is three documents, and the overview reads the succession as one argument across seventy years. The first Manifesto (1933): thirty-four signers, published in The New Humanist, drafted principally by Raymond Bragg (the Unitarian minister who edited the journal) with the philosopher Roy Wood Sellars among its authors — and its fifteen articles state the position as “religious humanism”: the universe self-existing and not created; man a part of nature, his mind not separate from his body; the supernatural's guarantees of human values rejected; religion redefined as the shared devotion to the good life; the profit economy indicted (the article the later documents quietly drop: the first Manifesto's socialism, the Depression's watermark on the text); and the closing aspiration — “man is at last becoming aware that he alone is responsible for the realization of the dreams of his own kind” — the sentence in which the movement's whole program is already present. The overview's audit is the document's own strangeness to the modern ear: it is a creed against creeds, complete with an anathema's confidence (its articles begin “we assert”) and a church's machinery envy — the historians noting that the position's first self-statement was made by ministers, in a journal, in the forms of the thing it was replacing, and that the movement has been renegotiating the inheritance ever since: the 1933 text is the movement's childhood photograph, in its parents' clothes.
The second Manifesto (1973) is the position's maturity and its most ambitious document: drafted by Paul Kurtz and Edwin Wilson, signed by thousands eventually — Isaac Asimov and B. F. Skinner, Sakharov and the scientists, theologians' names conspicuously few — its preface renouncing the first's optimism as the century had refuted it (the wars, the Holocaust, the bomb stand in its first paragraphs where 1933 had put the dreams) and its program planetary: ethics autonomous and situational; reason and science the hope; the supernatural's “guarantees” refused again; human rights, the democratic world order, the population's balance, the planet's ecology — the document of a movement that had read the century and decided to be a politics as well as a lifestance. Its famous controversies are the overview's honesty: the sexual-ethics passages (between consenting adults, the document's liberalism) that made it a byword in the culture wars and a embarrassment, within a decade, to some of its own signers as the AIDS years rewrote the context; the euthanasia article, ahead of its law by half a century; and the text's sheer length — seventeen articles of program where 2003 would put a page of affirmations: the second Manifesto is a platform, and platforms date. The third (2003) — Humanism and Its Aspirations, drafted under Kurtz's successor generation, signed by twenty-one Nobel laureates among its notables — is the correction: six brief affirmations (knowledge by inquiry; humans as nature's outcome; fulfilment in this life; ethics from need and interest, tested by consequence; the common good of the planetary community; and the working maxim — “we are responsible for the character of our lives and the world we build”), the movement's doctrine reduced to what seventy years had proved durable in it. The school's counsel: read the three in one sitting, as one text in three drafts — the same convictions at three temperatures: the chapel's, the platform's, and the aphorism's — and mark which articles each age kept, which it dropped, and which it was embarrassed by: the movement's fallibilism, documented in its own canon, the canon being — uniquely in this building — a set of texts that expect to be revised. The Declaration follows: the attempt to say it once, for the world.
The overview's last word is a reading instruction the documents themselves suggest: the three Manifestos should be read aloud, in company, at least once — because their genre is not the treatise but the proclamation, and a proclamation's truth is partly in its sound: the 1933 articles' chapel cadence, the 1973 platform's parliamentary swell, the 2003 page's aphoristic calm are three voices of one movement growing out of its parents' pulpit, through its own parliament, into its study. The school's students, who have now heard a year of the building's voices, will recognize the pattern as every room's biography in miniature: the children sound like the house they left until, suddenly and permanently, they sound like themselves. The Manifestos' sound changes in 2003. The student who can hear it has read them. The Declaration — the same voice, addressing the world — is next.
Lesson 2: The Amsterdam Declaration: a guided overview
The texts semester's second document is the movement's world charter: the Amsterdam Declaration — adopted in 1952 at the founding congress of the International Humanist and Ethical Union, and revised at the fiftieth-anniversary congress in 2002 into the form the movement now keeps as its official definition of Humanism. The overview reads the 2002 text in its seven articles, which the student should be able to recite as this room's creed: (1) Humanism is ethical — it affirms the worth, dignity, and autonomy of the individual and the right of every human being to the greatest possible freedom compatible with the rights of others; it rejects theologies of the elect and every ethics of the in-group. (2) Humanism is rational — it seeks to use science creatively, not destructively; it values artistic creation and imagination and recognizes the transforming power of literature and the arts (the article the polemical versions forget: the charter's science is yoked, in its own text, to the imagination). (3) Humanism supports democracy and human rights — the fullest possible development of every human being as its aim, democracy and development held as matters of right, not of cultural permission (the article aimed, in 2002, at the relativisms of the hour). (4) Humanism insists that personal liberty must be combined with social responsibility — the free person is not the unbound person; the charter's own balance, against the libertarian misreading. (5) Humanism is a response to the widespread demand for an alternative to dogmatic religion — it does not define itself against religion (the article's care is the Declaration's diplomacy entire: the demand is answered, the neighbors are not indicted) — and it values the education that teaches children to question as it teaches them to know. (6) Humanism values the arts and the examined imagination — stated, in the text, as the cultivation of the ethical and creative life. (7) Humanism is a lifestance aiming at the maximum possible fulfilment through the cultivation of ethical and creative living — and offers itself, in the closing words, as a basis for a common life for all who share it, “an ethical and rational way of life” for the planet's citizens. The overview's analysis: the Declaration is the movement's ecumenical document — drafted to be signable by the ethical culturist and the secularist, the congregationalist and the campaigner — and its generality is therefore both its function and its audit (the critics within: a definition everyone can sign defines, perhaps, nothing in particular; the defenders: a charter is not a catechism, and the movement's specificity lives in its local forms — the argument being the same one the building has heard over every room's shortest text).
The Declaration's career is the overview's second half: adopted as the IHEU's (now Humanists International's) definition, it is the text by which the world body accredits its members and states itself at the United Nations (where the organization holds consultative status and its interventions — on the blasphemy resolutions, the freedom of conscience reports, the apostasy cases — cite the Declaration as the lifestance's charter: the document as a diplomatic instrument, the lifestance presenting its credentials in the assembly of the religions as one among them — the status the founders intended and the theologians of several rooms contest, the argument over whether a lifestance is a religion's peer being the Declaration's permanent footnote in the world's forums); in the national movements it functions as the confirmation course's text (the Norwegian teenagers memorizing, for their civil confirmation, a creed whose first virtue is that it is not one — the paradox the teachers keep with a straight face and the students, reportedly, with delight); and in the school's own judgment it is the building's most successful attempt at the genre the Quaker room calls a testimony and this room calls a lifestance: seven articles, no anathemas, one invitation. The library follows: the books a movement of readers keeps when its canon is a method.
The Declaration's final audit is linguistic, and the overview should end with it, because it explains the document's survival: the text contains almost no words its opponents own. It does not say “atheist”; it does not say “secular”; it says ethical, rational, dignity, freedom, responsibility, fulfilment — a vocabulary chosen, with a diplomat's care that its drafters (a resistance generation) understood in their bones, to be deniable by no one and ownable by everyone who lives it. The critics call this vagueness; the drafters called it an invitation; and the document's seventy years — revised once, at fifty, by the simple method of asking the world's members what they still believed — suggest the drafters understood their genre: a charter is not a fence but a door, and a door is judged not by what it excludes but by who, in the event, walks through. The world's unaffiliated walk through this one daily, mostly without reading it. The confirmands of Norway could tell them what it says. It says: you are welcome, the life is yours, the responsibility is yours, the fulfilment is the point.
Lesson 3: Books of science and philosophy for all ages: a guided overview
The texts semester's third lesson is the room's library — which is not a canon but a curriculum: the books of science and philosophy by which the position reproduces itself, arranged, per the title's promise, for all ages. The children's shelf first, because this room reproduces by the bedtime book as surely as any room by its catechism: the evolution picture books and the universe stories (the “You Are Stardust” genre — the child addressed as the cosmos's own product, the materialist's wonder in its purest literary form); Ann Druyan's and the Cosmos tradition's juvenile heirs; Dawkins's The Magic of Reality (2011) — the movement's most deliberate children's book, its chapters taking the myths of the world's rooms one by one and answering each with the reality the title claims is more magical — the school's audit keeping both the book's genuine wonder and the building's objection: the myths are the other rooms' scriptures, and the children's shelf of this room teaches its neighbors' children that their grandmothers' stories are the false answers to the real questions — the peace of the building requiring the fact stated, and the room's own better authors (the “wonder first, adjudication later” school of its children's literature) supplying the correction from within; and the philosophy-for-children shelf (the “Big Questions” books, Sophie's World's juvenile empire — Gaarder's novel of the history of philosophy selling in the tens of millions, the position's most successful missionary being a Norwegian novelist's fiction: the library's permanent lesson in what actually carries ideas).
The adult shelf is the overview's main room, arranged by the year's needs: the science of the world (Sagan's Cosmos and The Demon-Haunted World — the latter the movement's most beloved book outright, its “baloney detection kit” the method's household form and its final chapter's candle-in-the-dark the position's threnody and manifesto in one; the modern succession — Hawking's Brief History as the century's best-selling unread masterpiece, the audit kept with affection; Tyson's and Cox's televised heirs; the evolution shelf from Darwin himself — the Origin read as literature, its final sentence's “grandeur in this view of life” being the position's first scripture in spite of its author's intentions — through the modern syntheses); the philosophy of the position (Russell's essays and his “Why I Am Not a Christian” — the lecture as the genre's classic; Ayer and the Vienna inheritance; the modern manuals — Grayling's The Good Book, the humanist's bible arranged as one, audited as the movement's most debated artifact (the form confessing the need it fills); Comte-Sponville's atheist spirituality; the ethics shelf — Singer's practical ethics as the position's most consequential living philosophy, its drowning-child argument the foundations' responsibility with the excuses removed); and the consolation shelf, the library's most honest section (the books for the grieving unbeliever — the “grief beyond belief” literature, the deathbed anthologies, the poets the celebrants actually use: the marked-up Mary Oliver and the worn Larkin in every celebrant's bag being the library's true canon, as the year's practice will show — a movement is known, in the end, by the books it reads at gravesides). The overview's verdict: this room's library is the building's most open — nothing in it is forbidden, little in it is required, and its unity is not a doctrine but a direction of the spine labels: toward the world, examined. The study lesson follows: how the room reads, argues, and keeps its books alive.
The library's last word is the librarian's, and it is the same in every room of this building: the shelf that matters is the one that is used at 3 a.m. The movement's official bibliographies are admirable; its actual canon is the celebrant's worn Larkin, the chaplain's marked Meditations (the Stoic emperor being, by the pastoral workers' testimony, this room's most borrowed devotional — the ancestry's long revenge), the parent's third copy of the stardust book, the teenager's Gaarder with the spine gone. The school's counsel to the year's student is therefore the library's own: build the 3 a.m. shelf deliberately — one science book that makes the world larger, one philosophy book that makes the self honest, one poet who can be read at a graveside, and the manifestos for the history — and let the rest of the library be a lending collection, argued over in the book group and returned with the argument unfinished. A movement of readers is not finished with its books. That is rather the point of it.
Lesson 4: Interpretation and study today
The texts semester closes with the room's reading life: how a movement whose canon is a method studies — the interpretation and study of its texts today. The forms first, which the student will recognize as the building's common furniture in this room's arrangement: the book group (the movement's characteristic cell — the humanist society's reading circle, the Skeptics in the Pub's lecture and argument, the university societies' discussion nights: the position reproducing itself by conversation, its “scripture study” being the new paperback argued over beer — a form the movement's sociologists judge both its strength (no priesthood of the text) and its ceiling (no discipline of the text either: the room's classics are more bought than read, its Origin and its Russell surviving, as the Hindu room's Veda does, as warrant rather than reading — the school's student recognizing, by the year's end, that every room's canon has this double life, and this room's honesty about it is merely better documented)); the lecture and the podcast (the movement's pulpit migrated to the feed — the long-form conversation as the position's sermon, its scientists and philosophers as the preachers, the audience in the millions the chapels never reached: the study's modern form being, for most of the position's adherents, a voice in the earbuds on the train — the audit kept: the feed's algorithms are no one's idea of a curriculum, and the movement's educators now build syllabi for the medium their founders would have killed for); the formal study (the humanist studies programs, the celebrant and chaplain trainings' reading lists — the professionalization of the position's ministry creating, at last, a discipline of its texts: the trainee celebrant reads the grief literature with a supervisor, the chaplain the ethics with a cohort — the movement acquiring, in its second century, the study structures its first thought it had abolished with the seminaries).
The interpretation debates are the lesson's second half, for the room argues about its books as faithfully as any: the manifestos' status (relics, platforms, or living documents — the 2033 centenary already debated: revise again, or let the Declaration stand as the final form — the movement's constitutional argument, conducted in its journals with the building's customary stakes: everything, at low volume); the new atheism's shelf, ten years on (the Horsemen's books as the position's dated bestsellers — their arguments absorbed, their tone audited, their authors' later careers (the political wanderings of Harris and the others) filed as the standing lesson in the difference between a book and a banner); the canon of the consolation shelf (the celebrants' poets against the philosophers' manuals — which books actually carry the position's adherents through the ward and the graveside being an empirical question the movement has begun, characteristically, to survey); and the neighbors' books (the room's mature reading including, increasingly, the building's other shelves — the humanist book groups reading the Gita and the Tao in translation, the chaplains trained in the religions' grief literatures as a professional requirement: the position's study completing its circle, the method applied to the neighbors' wisdom with the adjudication — mostly — suspended: the school's peace, kept in a reading group). The semester's synthesis: a movement of readers, whose texts are a method's memoirs and a library's argument with itself — the adult who owns the map can enter the practice semester knowing what study demands in this room: not assent but attention, and the willingness — the room's whole doctrine in one study habit — to have one's shelf rearranged by the next book. The practice follows: the thinking, the helping, the celebrating, and the work.
The study lesson's final counsel is the room's own examination question, set by its teachers to every graduating student of the position, and the school adopts it as the semester's close: name the last book that changed your mind — not confirmed it, changed it — and if the answer is more than five years old, the study has stopped, whatever the reading has done. The question is the method's whole discipline turned on the reader, and it is unanswerable by the shelf, the feed, or the group: only by the rearranged convictions of the person. The year's student should sit with it before entering the practice semester, whose first lesson — thinking carefully — is merely this question with a calendar attached. The texts are done. The thinking, in this room's cheerful doctrine, is the part that is never done, and the not-done-ness is not the failure of the study. It is the study.