Minister Destiny Marie Morgan Ministries, Inc.

Minister Destiny Testimony Schools

District: AWAKENING

Ministry name: Confucianism

Lessons — Adult Year 1, Semester 3

Adult Year 1 · Semester 3 — Texts and teachings

Four lessons for this semester. When you are ready, take the test for this semester.

Lesson 1: The Analects — sayings of Confucius: a guided overview

The Analects (Lunyu, “Selected Sayings”) is the tradition's heart: twenty short chapters of sayings, dialogues, and scenes — the Master with his disciples, with rulers, with himself — compiled by the disciples' disciples over generations and reaching its present form by the early Han. The guided overview begins with the book's character, because it is unlike every other scripture in this building: it is not a revelation, a law code, a narrative, or a system, but a classroom's memory — fragmentary, repetitive in places, occasionally contradictory in emphasis, and organized by no argument, so that its readers across two thousand years have constructed the system from the sayings as one constructs a face from a sketchbook. Its texture is the overview's first delight: the Master is quotable because he was quoted — “Is it not pleasant to learn with a constant perseverance and application?” (the book's opening line, 1.1 — learning as joy, the tradition's keynote in its first sentence), “I do not open up the truth to one who is not eager to get knowledge” (7.8, the teacher's refusal to do the student's work), the autobiography of 2.4, the silences (on death: “While you do not know life, how can you know about death?” 11.12 — the book's agnosticism in one deflection; on spirits, 6.22's respectful distance), the humor (the Master laughing at his own failures, teased by hermits and gatekeepers as a man “who knows he cannot succeed and keeps trying” — the gatekeeper's line, 14.38, preserved by the school with pride), and the disciples' cameos, each in a sentence.

The overview's second task is the sayings' architecture — the system the sketchbook implies, which the student should be able to assemble: ren, the master virtue, defined variously (as loving others, 12.22; as the five practices of gravity, generosity of soul, sincerity, earnestness, and kindness, 17.6; as restraining oneself and restoring the rites, 12.1 — the definitions calibrated, as the history lesson noted, to the asker); li, the rites as ren's body; the junzi and his marks (he is universal and not partisan, 2.14; he seeks in himself what the small man seeks in others, 15.21; he is distressed by his own lack of ability, not by men's not knowing him, 15.19); learning as the life (the joy of 1.1, the method of 2.15 — “learning without thought is labor lost; thought without learning is perilous”); the rectification of names (13.3 — if names are not correct, language does not accord with truth, and nothing can be done: the tradition's philosophy of language as a political act); government by virtue (2.1, 2.3, 12.19); filial piety (the obedience of 2.7 corrected — without reverence, feeding one's parents differs nothing from feeding dogs and horses: the book's most quietly devastating line on the difference between care and mere maintenance); and the Master's self-portrait scattered through the chapters (his pleasures — music, the river's flow, the students' company; his angers — at pretension, at the rites' theft, at his own disciples' compromises; his prayer — offered, 7.35 records, in his illness, with the wry note that his praying had been going on for a long time: the life itself as the prayer, this room's reflections page in a sentence).

The overview closes with the book's career and its reading today: canonized among the Four Books by Zhu Xi, memorized by every schoolboy of the old China (the Analects as the sound of a civilization's childhood — the chanting classroom, the text learned before it was understood, the understanding arriving across a lifetime, as the Master's own autobiography promises), translated first by the Jesuits (Confucius Sinarum Philosophus, Paris 1687 — the book that taught the Enlightenment its China, Leibniz and Voltaire its readers), and read today in a hundred versions, from the scholars' critical editions to the televised lectures — the school's counsel being the tradition's own: read it slowly, in small pieces, with a commentary (Zhu Xi's for the orthodox depth, the moderns' for the historical), and expect the face in the sketchbook to assemble itself across years, not chapters. The second sage's book follows.

The Analects' strangeness has one more layer the overview should hand the student: the book's last chapters are its most archaic and its most mysterious — chapter 10's meticulous portrait of the Master's daily conduct (his dress, his eating, his carriage, his bows at court — the li of one man's body as a text), the sayings' arrangement defying every system the commentators have imposed — and the scholars' consensus that the book grew by accretion, the disciples' schools each keeping their fascicles, until the Han editors bound the bundle. The consequence for the reader is the tradition's own hermeneutic blessing: the Analects cannot be systematized without remainder, and therefore cannot be finished — each generation's commentary (the Han's, Zhu Xi's, the Qing's, the moderns') is a new construction of the face from the sketchbook, and the student's own reading joins the queue. The school's final counsel for this book is the Master's for all books: to learn and at due times to practice what one has learned — the overview ends where the book begins, at 1.1, with the pleasure.

Lesson 2: The Mencius: a guided overview

The Mencius (Mengzi) is the second of the Four Books and the tradition's most argued-with text: the record of Mencius (372–289 BC), the “second sage,” who carried the Master's teaching through the Warring States courts a century and a half after his death — a book of debates, in which the sage argues with kings, rival philosophers, and his own disciples, in a prose of parables and pressure that reads, still, like cross-examination. The overview's first task is the book's great doctrine: human nature is good (xing shan) — not finished, but begun: every heart has the four sprouts (the feeling of compassion, the sprout of ren — proved by the famous thought-experiment of 2A6: any person who suddenly sees a child about to fall into a well feels alarm and distress, not to gain the parents' favor or the neighbors' praise, but spontaneously — the heart's native motion; shame and dislike, the sprout of righteousness; deference, the sprout of propriety; approval and disapproval, the sprout of wisdom) — and the moral life is the sprouts' cultivation, as the barley grows where it is watered (the farmer of Song who pulled his seedlings to help them grow, 2A2, is the book's immortal warning against forcing virtue), while the hearts that fail are not rotten by nature but starved — Ox Mountain, once forested, stripped by axes and grazing until its baldness is mistaken for its nature (6A8), is the book's ecology of the soul: the environment makes the mountain, and the courtier's corruption is his court's.

The book's second doctrine is its politics, the most democratic in the classical world before the modern age: the people's welfare is the test of rule — the king who shares his pleasures with the people (the park, the music — 1B2's dialogues, in which Mencius teaches King Hui and King Xuan that a king's joy hoarded is a king's joy forfeited) and who secures the people's livelihood first (the constant property that makes constant hearts possible, 1A7 and 3A3 — the economic foundation of morality, stated two millennia before the welfare state) may keep his throne; the tyrant forfeits it, being no king but a “mere fellow” (1B8), and the people's priority is absolute in the famous ranking (7B14: the people most important, the altars of soil and grain next, the ruler least). The dialogues' drama is the doctrine's delivery: Mencius before the kings — courteous, relentless, refusing the gifts that would buy his silence, telling King Xuan to his face that his love of wealth and sex is no obstacle to good government if only he will share them (1B5's audacity) — and departing, again and again, from courts that would not enact the Way, as his Master had, the failure pattern repeating with the same serenity: the teaching's court career is a record of refusals, and its conquest of China was posthumous and total (the book canonized, its author the second sage, its doctrines the examination's orthodoxy — with its most dangerous sentence, on the tyrant, quietly glossed by the emperors' commentators, Zhu Xi himself uneasy at 1B8's edge).

The overview closes with the book's reading today: the Mencius is the tradition's charter for every internal reform — the minben (people-as-root) doctrine from which Chinese democrats, from the 1898 reformers to the modern dissidents, have drawn their native warrant, and against which the tradition's authoritarians have had to argue in the tradition's own language; the feminists' audit finds the book's mother (the moving-house story of the people semester) its heroine and its patriarchy intact; and the environmental readers find in Ox Mountain a founding text. The school's counsel: read the Mencius after the Analects, as the curriculum orders them — the Master's seeds in the second sage's summer growth — and mark the tone's difference as the doctrine's: where the Analects whispers to students, the Mencius argues with kings. The Five Classics follow: the library the two books interpret.

Mencius's own afterlife contains the tradition's neatest irony, and the overview should not close without it: the book that teaches the people's priority and the tyrant's demotion was, for a brief Ming moment, expelled from the temple — the founding Ming emperor, reading 7B14's ranking (the ruler least) and 1B8's license, ordered Mencius's tablet removed from the Confucius temple and an expurgated Mencius issued with eighty-five passages cut, the sage censored by the throne he had tutored. The tablet was restored (the officials protested, one offering his life — “I will die for Mencius” — and the emperor relented), the expurgated edition forgotten, and the unexpurgated book read in the examinations the throne itself administered — the tradition's immune system at work: the school keeps its dangerous books, and the ruler who cuts them is remembered for the cutting. The school's student, reading 1B8 today in any edition on earth, unabridged, has the verdict of seventeen centuries on the argument between the sage and the throne.

Lesson 3: The Five Classics: a guided overview

The Five Classics (Wujing) are the tradition's ancient library — the books Confucius transmitted and edited, older than his school, which his school canonized as the civilization's memory: the Book of Songs, the Book of Documents, the Book of Rites, the Book of Changes, and the Spring and Autumn Annals. The overview tours them as the texts semester requires. The Songs (Shijing): three hundred five poems — folk songs of love and labor from the feudal states, court odes, and the hymns of the Zhou ancestors' temple — the oldest anthology in the tradition, quoted by Confucius for every purpose (a diplomat's whole rhetoric was conducted in its verses; “if you do not study the Songs, you will be ill-equipped to speak,” 16.13), read by the later tradition as moral allegory (the love songs as ministerial remonstrance, in the commentators' heroic misreading) and by the moderns as what they are: the voices of the early Chinese people, preserved because the Master loved them. The Documents (Shangshu): the speeches, charges, and counsels of the sage-kings and the Zhou founders — the Mandate of Heaven's archive, the political theory's sourcebook — and the canon's most battered text (its Old Text chapters proved forgeries by the Qing scholars, after a millennium as examination scripture — the texts' history in one wound). The Rites (the Liji, the Book of Rites, with its sister compilations): the choreography's manual — mourning grades, weddings, sacrifices, the conduct of every relationship — containing, among its ritual detail, two chapters that Zhu Xi promoted into the Four Books (the Great Learning, with its chain from the investigation of things to the peace of the world; the Doctrine of the Mean, the tradition's metaphysical summit, on sincerity and the equilibrium that is also a harmony).

The Changes and the Annals complete the five. The Changes (Yijing, the Book of Changes): the divination manual of the Zhou court become, by its commentaries (the Ten Wings, tradition ascribing them to Confucius), a philosophy of change itself — the sixty-four hexagrams, built of broken and unbroken lines, mapping the situations of a life and their transformations, consulted by kings with yarrow stalks and by the tradition's philosophers as the cosmos's grammar (the one classic the West received whole, in the Wilhelm translation with Jung's famous foreword — the synchronicity essay that made the Changes a Western book too). The Annals (Chunqiu, Spring and Autumn): Lu's court chronicle, 722–481 BC, in a prose so terse that its commentaries outweigh it a hundredfold — the record of accessions, battles, eclipses, and deaths in which the tradition read the Master's praise and blame encoded in single characters (a usurper “recorded as assassinating” his lord rather than “killing” him, the verb carrying the verdict), the Gongyang commentary building the encoding into a jurisprudence and a prophecy. Together the five are the Zhou world's whole estate: its songs, its state papers, its manners, its oracle, and its history — the civilization's memory palace, whose rooms the school (ru) kept, catalogued, and taught for two thousand years, so that to be educated in old China was, precisely, to have these five books by heart.

The overview closes with the classics' fate, which is the texts' history in brief: canonized by the Han (the Erudites of the Five Classics, the stone editions carved to fix the texts — the Xiping stone classics of 175 AD, the fragments in the museums), expanded to Nine and then Thirteen Classics by the later dynasties (the commentaries and the filial and lexical works admitted to the canon — a scripture that grows by scholarship, this tradition's characteristic), displaced at the center by Zhu Xi's Four Books for the examinations, and surviving today as the heritage's core — read in the universities, quoted in the speeches, and kept, in the school's building, as what they are: not the word of a god, but the memory of a civilization that chose its teachers well. The study lesson follows: how the whole library is read now.

The classics' physical survival is the overview's closing wonder, and it is a story of copies: the Qin fire made every surviving text a rescue (the aged Fu Sheng dictating the Documents from memory in the early Han, his daughter translating his dialect for the scribes — the canon saved by an old man's memory and a woman's ear, a fact the tradition records and its modern heirs underline); the Kong wall cache; the stone carvings; the Song printings that multiplied the texts beyond any fire's reach; and the modern critical editions, built on the excavated manuscripts that still surface from the tombs. No other library in the building has been burned by its own civilization and recopied by it so many times. The pattern is the tradition's self-knowledge in action: the books are the ancestors of the mind, and their preservation is a filial duty — the scholar collating a classic is performing, at his desk, the same rite as the grandson at the altar. The texts semester's student now knows why the room's library smells of incense.

Lesson 4: Interpretation and study today

The texts semester closes with the question the whole library poses to its modern reader: how are these books read — by their heirs, their scholars, and their students — today? The map of methods first, which in this tradition is a map of two millennia: the Han's chapter-and-verse exegesis and the Old Text/New Text war (the texts as political charters, the commentators as kingmakers); the Song's philosophical reading (Zhu Xi's commentaries reconstructing the sages' minds, the text as a ladder to principle — and the examination's freezing of his readings into the state's orthodoxy, so that interpretation itself became a civil service); the Qing's evidential turn (kaozheng — the philologists dating, collating, and forgery-hunting with a rigor that dissolved the canon it served, the tradition's own historical criticism, two centuries before the West's biblical critics were matched in China); the twentieth century's double revolution (the Doubting Antiquity school, Gu Jiegang's layered-creation thesis — the sage-kings' biographies growing backward through the centuries, Yu the Great demoted, in Gu's notorious essay, toward a bronze worm on a tripod — and the May Fourth vernacular turn, which made the classics readable and remote in the same generation); and the contemporary settlement's plurality: the mainland's guoxue establishment, the exile New Confucians' philosophical reconstruction, the Western academy's sinology (the Analects read with archaeology — the excavated manuscripts, Guodian's Laozi and the Shanghai Museum's Confucian texts, rewriting the Warring States library from the tombs), and the popular revival's televised lectures and children's recitation classes, whose depth the scholars audit with the tradition's own ambivalence.

The practice of study today, at the student's level, is the lesson's second half — because this library, uniquely in the building, was designed as a curriculum, and its study has a classic form the modern student can still use: the sequence (the Great Learning's chain as the syllabus — the Four Books in Zhu Xi's order: Great Learning for the frame, Analects for the root, Mencius for the growth, Doctrine of the Mean for the summit); the method (recitation before explanation — the text by heart first, the understanding trusted to arrive across the years, the old classroom's wager that the school's own Garden lessons still make with the youngest; then the commentary, read as a conversation with the text's best readers; then the application, the tradition's unembarrassed insistence that a reading that changes nothing is not a reading — Wang Yangming's unity of knowledge and action as the hermeneutic's test); and the company (the study group, the academy, the teacher — this tradition, of all the building's, is the one that cannot be self-taught, because its subject is relationships and its medium is one: the disciple's questions are the Analects' own form). The school's counsel for the modern reader is assembled from these: read the Four Books whole, in a good translation, with one commentary open; read a classic a season, not a book a week; keep the commonplace book (the tradition's readers have always excerpted — the sayings copied by hand are the sayings kept); and let the reading be audited by the life, in Zengzi's three questions, which are this room's examination that no institution grades.

The semester's synthesis: a notebook, a debater, a library, and a method — the adult who owns the map can enter the practice semester knowing what the texts demand: not admiration but enactment. The practice follows: the altar, the bow, the study, and the work — the places where the Four Books become a week.

The study lesson's final counsel belongs to the tradition's own most famous student, because his case is the method's proof across a lifetime: Confucius described himself as a man who, in his eagerness to learn, forgot his food and, in his joy, forgot his sorrows, and did not notice old age approaching (7.19) — and the description, offered without vanity as a self-portrait at seventy, is the curriculum's true diploma: not the degree (the examinations are gone), not the office (the mandarinate is gone), but the condition of a life in which the study has become indistinguishable from the living. The modern student, closing the semester, is not asked to reproduce the old classroom — its rote, its exclusions, its eight-legged cages are in the columns where they belong — but to reproduce the condition: a text kept by heart, a commentary kept open, a life kept under audit by both. The practice semester will now show what the condition builds: an altar, a bow, a desk, and a family's week.

Back to all lessons · Take this semester’s test