Age 16 · Semester 4 — Diversity inside Christianity
Four lessons for this semester. When you are ready, take the test for this semester.
Lesson 1: Branches and movements
Christianity's two billion followers are organised into branches and movements so varied that a visitor could attend worship in an Orthodox cathedral, a Catholic basilica, a Baptist chapel, and a Pentecostal warehouse in one city and wonder at the range. The main branches are usually counted as three: Roman Catholic, Eastern Orthodox (with Oriental Orthodox churches as a distinct, older family), and Protestant — itself a family containing Anglicans, Lutherans, Reformed, Methodists, Baptists, Pentecostals, and many more. Understanding the map requires knowing the two great divisions that produced it and the movements that keep redrawing it from within.
The first great division, in 1054, separated East and West. Causes accumulated over centuries: different languages, Greek and Latin; different emphases in theology, including a dispute over the wording of the creed concerning the Holy Spirit, known by the Latin word filioque; different church customs; and a contested claim by Rome's bishop to universal authority. In 1054 legates and patriarch excommunicated each other, and the split hardened, tragically confirmed when western crusaders sacked Constantinople in 1204. The Eastern Orthodox churches that resulted are a communion of self-governing churches — Greek, Russian, Antiochian, and others — united in faith and worship, rich in icons, chant, and monastic tradition, and led conciliarly rather than by a single head.
The second great division, the sixteenth-century Reformation, split the West. What began as protest against abuses became, as earlier lessons traced, new churches ordered around Scripture, faith, and grace, and the Catholic Church's own reforming response. From that root grew the Protestant families: Lutherans in Germany and Scandinavia; Reformed churches from Calvin's Geneva; Anglicans, shaped by the English settlement under Elizabeth I into a self-described middle way; Anabaptists and later Baptists, insisting on believer's baptism; Methodists from John Wesley's revival; and many others. Each family developed its own confessions, worship, and church government, and the map multiplied further as these churches planted themselves worldwide through missions and migration.
Movements cut across branches, renewing or disturbing them. Monasticism, from the desert fathers and mothers of Egypt to Benedict's Rule and modern new-monastic communities, has renewed prayer in every age. The evangelical movement stresses conversion, the Bible, the cross, and activism across many denominations. Pentecostalism, beginning in the early twentieth century in places including Los Angeles's Azusa Street, emphasises the Holy Spirit's present work and has become the fastest-growing movement in Christian history, reshaping worship across the Global South and influencing Catholic and Protestant charismatic renewal. The ecumenical movement works the other way, toward unity: the World Council of Churches, founded in 1948, gathers most traditions for dialogue and common service, though full communion remains incomplete.
For the student, branches and movements are best learned as a family history, with real griefs and real gifts. Division is not a detail: Christians themselves lament it as contrary to Christ's prayer that his followers be one, and the ecumenical task is taken seriously at the highest levels. At the same time, diversity carries genuine theological conviction — about authority, sacraments, Scripture, and the Spirit — and cannot be reduced to mere stubbornness. The examiner's skill is to identify any Christian community accurately: which branch, which movement, which emphases, and what it shares with all the others — one Lord, one Bible, baptism, the creeds' core — beneath the very real differences that this lesson has mapped.
Lesson 2: Paul, the apostle and reform
Paul is the most influential Christian after Jesus himself, and understanding him is essential to understanding the faith's shape. Born Saul of Tarsus, a Jew of the Pharisee party and a Roman citizen, he was a fierce persecutor of the early church who approved the stoning of Stephen, its first martyr. On the road to Damascus, around the year 35, he encountered the risen Jesus in a blinding vision — an event told three times in Acts — and was transformed from persecutor to apostle. He understood himself as called, like the prophets, from birth, and specifically as apostle to the Gentiles, the non-Jewish nations, a mission that would change the demographics and destiny of Christianity permanently.
Paul's work combined travel, community founding, and letter writing on an extraordinary scale. In journeys across Cyprus, Asia Minor, Greece, and eventually to Rome, he founded churches in cities such as Corinth, Ephesus, Philippi, and Thessalonica, supporting himself by tentmaking and enduring imprisonment, beatings, shipwreck, and eventual execution in Rome under Nero, by tradition. His letters — thirteen bear his name in the New Testament, though scholars debate the authorship of some — were written to real situations decades before the Gospels, making them the earliest Christian documents we possess. Romans, his most systematic letter, and the Corinthian correspondence, his most pastoral, remain foundational texts for every branch of the church.
The word reform in this lesson's title points to Paul's theological earthquake: his teaching on justification. Reading Abraham's story, Paul argued that a person is put right with God — justified — by faith in Christ, not by works of the law, and that this gift is for Jew and Gentile equally, without Gentiles first becoming Jews. The Jerusalem council in Acts 15 vindicated his mission in principle, though tensions with more conservative leaders, including a famous confrontation with Peter at Antioch over table fellowship, show the reform being fought for in practice. This teaching redefined the boundaries of God's people around faith and baptism rather than ancestry and food laws, opening Christianity to the world.
Paul's afterlife is a second career as large as his first. Augustine's theology was ignited by Romans; Luther's reading of Paul — the just shall live by faith — detonated the Reformation; Karl Barth's commentary on Romans reshaped twentieth-century theology; and modern scholars of the New Perspective on Paul have reread him within his Judaism, correcting caricatures of both Paul and Jewish faith, and stressing covenant and community alongside individual faith. Feminist and postcolonial readers debate his texts on women, slavery, and authority — passages that have been used to restrict and, reread in context, to liberate — and the debate itself shows a living author, not a museum piece.
Paul remains, finally, a demanding figure to study fairly: brilliant, urgent, tender, and severe by turns; convinced the world's time was short; organising collections for the poor in Jerusalem even while arguing theology across an empire. His own summary of his reform is Galatians' declaration that in Christ the old dividing walls — Jew and Greek, slave and free, male and female — do not determine worth or belonging. Whether a reader receives him as apostle, reformer, or historical problem, no account of Christianity is complete without him: the persecutor who became the faith's second founder in influence, and whose letters still set the terms of its deepest arguments.
Lesson 3: Moses in the Bible and tradition
Moses belongs first to Judaism, where he is the greatest prophet and the giver of Torah, and Christians receive him entirely from Israel's Scriptures — a fact this lesson states plainly, because fair study of Moses in Christianity begins by honouring his primary home. In the Bible's account, Moses is born to Hebrew slaves in Egypt, hidden in a basket among the reeds, raised in Pharaoh's household, and driven into exile after killing an Egyptian overseer. At the burning bush on Mount Horeb, God calls him to lead Israel out of slavery. Through Moses, God sends plagues on Egypt, leads the people through the divided sea in the Exodus, and at Mount Sinai gives the covenant and the Ten Commandments, the moral heart of the law.
Within the Bible itself, Moses is presented with unusual honesty. He is the intercessor who pleads for Israel after the golden calf apostasy, the lawgiver who receives and teaches the commandments through the wilderness years, and the leader whose own failure — striking the rock in anger — means he will see the promised land from Mount Nebo but not enter it, dying in Moab with God himself, the text says, burying him. Deuteronomy closes the Torah with his farewell speeches and the verdict that no prophet arose in Israel like Moses, whom the Lord knew face to face. The tradition of Mosaic authorship of the five books of Torah is ancient; modern scholars generally describe those books as composed and edited over centuries from older traditions, a scholarly view students should know alongside the traditional one.
Christian tradition reads Moses in three main ways. First, historically and morally: Moses is a hero of faith in the New Testament's own list, his law's commandments — on murder, theft, honesty, parents, and coveting — remain the church's basic moral teaching, and Jesus himself says he came not to abolish the Law and the Prophets but to fulfil them. Second, typologically: Christians see patterns, or types, fulfilled in Christ — Moses the prophet like whom another would come, the Passover lamb of the Exodus echoed in Christ the paschal lamb, manna in the wilderness echoed in the bread of life discourses, the lifted-up serpent echoed in John's account of the cross. Third, contrastively: Paul sets Moses' law and Christ's grace in tension, veiled and unveiled glory, to explain what he believes is new in Christ — a reading Christians conduct, at their best, without disparaging the law's own goodness, which Paul also affirms as holy and good.
Beyond the texts, Moses shapes Christian practice and imagination in ways easily missed. Michelangelo's Moses and Handel's Israel in Egypt carried his story into art and music; spirituals of enslaved African Americans sang Go down, Moses as a coded cry for liberation, and Moses became a central figure of Black church preaching and of liberation theologies worldwide, the liberator who proves God hears the cries of slaves. Moses also stands at the centre of interfaith conversation: he is a prophet in Islam, Musa, among the most mentioned figures in the Qur'an, and a shared figure around whom Jews, Christians, and Muslims can study together, each tradition reading him with its own emphases and reverence.
For the student, Moses is therefore a test of the whole course's method. To study him only as a Christian type is to miss the towering figure of Israel's own faith; to study him only historically is to miss why three religions revere him. The accurate picture holds together the Bible's narrative, Judaism's living tradition of Torah, Christianity's moral and typological readings, Islam's prophetic honour, and scholarship's questions about composition and history. Few figures better reward such care: the slave-child in the basket who became, in the memory of billions, the man who met God on the mountain and brought down words by which communities still order their lives.
Lesson 4: Disagreements handled with respect
Christianity's history contains deep disagreements — over doctrine, worship, authority, ethics, and politics — and this lesson examines how Christians at their best handle them, and how the tradition itself instructs them to. The starting point is that disagreement is not treated as a modern accident. The New Testament records a sharp dispute between Paul and Barnabas that parted their mission, a public confrontation between Paul and Peter, and a council in Jerusalem that resolved the Gentile question by listening, testimony, Scripture, and compromise. The earliest church, in other words, modelled argument inside fellowship: opponents remained brothers, and the goal of argument was truth held together with unity, not victory at any price.
The tradition developed tools for this work. Creeds and councils defined the centre — who Christ is, how God is Trinity — while leaving wide areas of practice and speculation open, a distinction later summarised in a famous maxim attributed in various forms across the churches: in essentials unity, in non-essentials liberty, in all things charity. Adiaphora, things indifferent, became the technical term for matters on which Christians may differ without dividing: days, foods, and many forms of worship. Paul himself taught this principle in Romans 14, instructing stronger and weaker consciences not to despise or judge one another, but to be convinced in their own minds and to keep the peace of the community as the higher law.
History also supplies the negative examples, and honest study keeps them in view. Disagreement curdled into schism in 1054 and 1517; into coercion when churches held state power; into violence in the wars of religion; and into the persecution of dissenters by Christians of every branch — Anabaptists drowned by Protestants and Catholics alike stand as a permanent warning. The modern ecumenical movement is, in part, an act of collective repentance for this record: churches have exchanged apologies, lifted ancient excommunications — Rome and Constantinople did so in 1965 — and signed agreements such as the 1999 declaration on justification, discovering that some dividing disputes rested partly on misunderstanding and the language of another age.
Handled with respect, then, has a recognisable method that students can apply far beyond church life. State the other position in its strongest, fairest form — the form its holders recognise. Distinguish the person from the position, and the centre from the edges. Listen longer than feels efficient, especially to those with least power in the argument. Use shared authorities where they exist, and name honestly where they do not. Accept processes and timetables rather than demanding instant victory, and let shared work — feeding the hungry together is the churches' classic example — rebuild trust that argument alone cannot. Churches also teach their members the discipline of speech that underlies it all: no lying about opponents, no contempt, no gossip dressed as concern, and a readiness to be corrected that is treated as strength, not defeat.
This lesson closes the Age 16 year because its subject is the year's method as much as its content. A student who can describe Catholic, Orthodox, Protestant, and Pentecostal positions on Paul, worship, leadership, and ethics — fairly, in terms their holders accept, while still thinking critically — has learned the core skill of religious literacy. Christians would add that the skill is also a virtue their faith commands: speaking the truth in love, in Paul's phrase, is a single act, not two. Truth without love becomes a weapon; love without truth becomes flattery. The tradition at its best refuses both, and a school devoted to understanding faiths can do no better than to make that refusal its own house rule for every disagreement it will ever host.