Adult Year 2 · Semester 4 — Places, arts, and the road ahead
Four lessons for this semester. When you are ready, take the test for this semester.
Lesson 1: The church and Bethlehem
The final semester begins with the faith's holy geography at its two poles: the church building — the faith's universal local address — and Bethlehem, the little town where its geography begins. The church building first, in its anatomy, because the student has attended its services all year without being given its plan: the historic church is an oriented building (its altar to the east, ad orientem, toward the rising sun and the returning Christ — “oriented” is the building's own word become the language's metaphor), entered through the narthex (the porch of the catechumens and penitents in the ancient discipline), opening into the nave (navis, the ship — the vessel of the people's voyage, the congregation's room, with its aisles and its galleries), crossing at the transept in the cruciform plan (the building itself a cross laid on the landscape), and rising to the sanctuary — the chancel, the altar on its platform, the bishop's chair (cathedra — a cathedral is the building that holds one), the choir's stalls, the reredos and rood screen or iconostasis dividing and joining the people's room and the holy place, the baptistery (by the door, in the ancient and Baptist logic: entry at the entry), the tower and spire over all (the finger pointing up, the bells calling the parish's hours and griefs and weddings — the soundscape of the Christian centuries). Its styles are the history semester in stone: the basilica of Rome's law courts adapted, the Romanesque's round arches and fortress walls, the Gothic's pointed heaven (Suger's St-Denis, 1140s — light as theology), the Renaissance's dome, the Baroque's theater of glory, the meeting-house's white simplicity, the storefront's rented room, the megachurch's auditorium — the varieties of one program: a people, a word, a table, a font, under a roof that preaches before a word is said.
Bethlehem is the geography's other pole: the little town of Judah (Micah's “too little to be among the clans”), David's birthplace before it was Jesus's, five miles south of Jerusalem, where the Church of the Nativity — the oldest church in continuous use in the world — stands over the cave of the birth. Its history in depth: the cave venerated from the second century (Justin and Origen both know it), the basilica built by Constantine and Helena (consecrated 339) and rebuilt by Justinian after the Samaritan revolt's fire (the present church, substantially his), entered by the Door of Humility (the low doorway, walled down in the Ottoman centuries — to prevent horsemen riding in, the guides say, and to make every pilgrim bow, the school observes), down to the Grotto of the Nativity: the silver star set in the marble floor (inscribed Hic de Virgine Maria Jesus Christus natus est — Here Jesus Christ was born of the Virgin Mary), the Altar of the Manger beside it, the three custodial churches (Greek Orthodox, Armenian, and Franciscan-Catholic) sharing the shrine under the Status Quo — the Ottoman-era settlement of the holy places' rights, whose frozen courtesies and frozen quarrels (the immovable ladder of the Holy Sepulchre is its famous symbol) govern Bethlehem as they govern Jerusalem. The town around it — Palestinian, Christian in its ancient core and dwindling under the pressures the modern world lesson knows — keeps the feast with its Scout bands and its midnight Mass in Manger Square, broadcast to the world, the little town's one night as the faith's front page.
The pairing's synthesis: the church is the faith everywhere, Bethlehem the faith somewhere — the religion of a universal book keeping, at its origin, a cave with a star in the floor, and the pilgrim's road running from the parish's font to the Grotto's steps as one geography. The next lesson stands at the geography's center and its sorrow: Jerusalem, the cross, and the window of colored light by which the churches learned to tell the stories to those who could not read.
Bethlehem's modern sorrow belongs in the places lesson's closing column, because the geography cannot be honestly taught without it: the little town's Christian population — the descendants, in part, of the families who have kept the grotto's lamps for seventeen centuries — has dwindled under occupation, emigration, and the wall that now separates the town from the Jerusalem it faces, until the feast's custodians are a minority in their own shrine town, and the midnight Mass in Manger Square is celebrated by a community holding its ground with its schools, its hospitals, and its Scout bands. The tradition's response is the pilgrims' duty stated plainly by the local church's own pastors: come and see — and when you come, spend your nights and your money with the living stones, not only at the dead ones; the phrase “living stones” (1 Peter's image for the believers) is the Palestinian church's own name for itself, and the school adopts it as the geography's final lesson: a holy place is not a site but a community, and the star in the grotto's floor marks a birth whose heirs are the town's embattled families. The pilgrim who has learned that has learned Bethlehem.
Lesson 2: Jerusalem and the cross and the stained-glass window
This lesson joins the faith's holiest city, its central symbol, and its most beloved art in one view: Jerusalem, the cross, and the stained-glass window. Jerusalem first, in depth: the city of David and the Temple, of the crucifixion and the empty tomb, holy to three faiths and administered, in its Christian geography, by the Status Quo's ancient partition — the Church of the Holy Sepulchre (consecrated 335 on the sites Constantine's builders identified, by tradition through Helena's finding, as Golgotha and the tomb) housing under one roof the last stations of the cross, the Stone of Unction, the rock of Calvary with its altar over the crack the pilgrims touch, and the Aedicule — the little house around the tomb itself, where the Holy Fire of the Orthodox Holy Saturday emerges to the packed church's roar, and where the Greek, Armenian, and Latin custodians, with the Coptic, Syriac, and Ethiopian chapels in the roof and walls, keep the faith's most crowded and contested acre. Beyond it: the Via Dolorosa's fourteen stations through the bazaars, the Garden Tomb of the Protestant affection (a nineteenth-century identification, kept as a garden of prayer with the honesty about its dating that its custodians themselves practice), Gethsemane's olives (some old enough, the gardeners say, to have been saplings of the agony's trees), the Mount of Olives' churches of the Ascension and the tears (Dominus Flevit), Bethany, and the whole city's palimpsest of the story — the pilgrim's Jerusalem being, as it has been since Egeria walked it in the 380s with her diary, the faith's fifth Gospel: the land itself read as the text's illustration, with the archaeologist's and the custodian's columns kept, as this school keeps them, side by side.
The cross is the city's gift to the world's iconography: the instrument of execution become the faith's universal sign — an outcome no observer of the first century would have predicted (the cross was Rome's obscenity, the Christians' earliest graffiti include the Alexamenos caricature of a donkey-headed crucified god, drawn by a mocker in a barracks — the sign began as a joke against them) — transformed by the resurrection's vindication into the sign of God's self-giving: traced on the forehead at baptism and a thousand times a day (the sign of the cross, the believer's shorthand prayer), worn at the neck, raised on the spires, carried in procession, and theologized in its forms (the Latin cross, the Greek, the Orthodox with its slanted footboard, the crucifix — with the body — of the Catholic and Orthodox devotion, against the empty cross of the Protestant emphasis on the resurrection — the family's variety legible in its jewelry). The window is the cross's light made narrative: stained glass — the art the Gothic builders perfected (Chartres's two hundred surviving windows, c. 1200, including the famous blue; the Sainte-Chapelle's walls of glass, 1248, a reliquary the size of a chapel) — as the poor man's Bible (the phrase is the tradition's own: the stories in light for those who could not read the book), its craft a theology in materials (the pot-metal glass colored in the melting, the lead cames as the drawing's lines, the grisaille and the silver stain of the later centuries) and its modern survival an argument for the art's power: the cathedrals' windows still stop the tourist mid-sentence, as they stopped the peasant, the light doing the teaching.
The lesson's synthesis: city, sign, and window are the faith's geography, grammar, and illumination — the place where it happened, the mark it makes, and the light by which it is read — and the student who has stood, even in imagination, in the Sepulchre's rotunda at the Holy Fire, traced the sign at a font, and watched the afternoon come blue through Chartres, owns the places semester's method: this faith is not an idea that acquired buildings but a memory that keeps addresses. The arts lesson follows, and then the road.
The window's light has one more property the lesson should record before the arts survey, because it is the art's theology in physics: stained glass is the only major art that is invisible without its source — the window in a dark church is a wall of lead and grey, and its glory is entirely transmitted, the sun doing the painting anew every hour, so that the same window is a different sermon at matins and at vespers and no sermon at all at midnight. The medieval builders, who knew their doctrine, built the fact into the faith's central metaphor without needing to state it: the church's light is not its own. The modern conservators, cleaning the grime of centuries from Chartres's glass, report the windows brighter than any living memory — the blue deeper, the reds like embers — and the school's student may take the restoration as the places semester's benediction: the light was never gone; the glass was dirty. It is the tradition's own favorite account of reform, told by its windows for eight hundred years.
Lesson 3: Art, music, and literature of Christianity
The arts of Christianity are the largest in the building — two millennia of a faith that made images, music, and books its second language — and the survey follows the year's pattern from the altar outward. The visual arts: beginning under prohibition's shadow (the catacombs' sparse symbols — the fish, the anchor, the Good Shepherd borrowed from Apollo's shepherd — the early church wary of the idol in a pagan world), flowering with the empire's peace into the basilicas' mosaics (Ravenna's glittering apses, Justinian's Christ in gold), dividing at the icon (the East's window into heaven, defended at Nicaea II, 787, against the iconoclast emperors — the theology of the image grounded in the incarnation itself: because God became visible, he may be depicted — the argument that licenses all the West's art to come), and reaching the summits the world keeps: the Romanesque tympana, the Gothic glass and sculpture, Giotto's flesh-and-blood gospel at Padua, the Renaissance's marriage of faith and antiquity (Fra Angelico's cells, Michelangelo's ceiling and dome, Raphael's Madonnas), the Baroque's ecstasy (Bernini, Caravaggio's street-cast apostles), the moderns' retrievals (Rouault's clowns and Christs, the abstract windows of postwar Coventry), and the world's own Christs (the African Christ of the mission churches' carvings, the Asian Madonnas, Latin America's crucified campesino) — an output so vast that the survey's honest summary is the historians': for fifteen hundred years, in the West, art history and church history are substantially the same subject.
The music is the faith's glory in the building's judgment: the chant of the synagogue become the church's (Gregorian chant — the single line, unaccompanied, the office's voice for a millennium, and the seedbed of Western notation and polyphony), the polyphony's cathedrals in sound (Léonin and Pérotin at Notre-Dame, Josquin, Palestrina — whose Missa Papae Marcelli legend makes him polyphony's savior at Trent), the Reformation's congregational answer (Luther's chorales — the people singing in their tongue, the hymn as the Reformation's pamphlet that sang; the metrical psalms of Geneva), the Baroque's summits (Bach — the Lutheran cantor whose Passions and B-minor Mass are the faith's musical Summa, signing his scores Soli Deo Gloria; Handel's Messiah, the oratorio that made Easter and Christmas one concert), the hymnody of the evangelical centuries (Watts, Wesley's six thousand hymns, the spirituals of the enslaved — the faith's music carrying its most oppressed believers' theology in code and consolation), the gospel and worship music of the modern age, and the Orthodox and Oriental chant traditions (Byzantine, Znamenny, Ethiopian — the ancient lines unbroken) — the whole constituting the largest continuous musical tradition on earth, most of it written for use, not performance: sung prayer, the assembly's own voice trained by its masters.
The literature completes the survey where the texts semester began: the Confessions of Augustine (the autobiography invented as a prayer), Dante's Comedy (the medieval faith's universe in a poem — the poem of the faith, as the teachers call it, against which all later Christian literature is measured), the mystics' prose (Julian's Showings — “all shall be well” — Teresa, John of the Cross), the sermons (Chrysostom the golden-mouthed, Donne's bells), Bunyan's Pilgrim's Progress (the most translated Christian book after the Bible, the tinker's allegory as the Puritan soul's map), the novelists of the faith's modern argument (Dostoevsky's Brothers, Tolstoy's crisis, Graham Greene's whisky priests, Flannery O'Connor's violent grace, Marilynne Robinson's Gilead), and the poets from Herbert and Hopkins to Eliot's Quartets — the tradition's literary judgment being the survey's close: the faith that began with a book has never stopped writing them, and its classics are read, in this school's building, as the arts' testimony that the doctrines of Year One are not propositions only but a world, furnished. The road lesson closes the ministry.
The arts survey closes with the tradition's own anxiety about its treasure, because the anxiety is part of the record: the faith that produced the Sistine ceiling also produced the iconoclasts who whitewashed the parish churches, the reformers who smashed the rood screens, and the modern puritans of every family who suspect the arts as the gospel's rivals — and the argument is not a defect but the tradition's permanent internal audit of its second language: the image must serve the word, the music the prayer, the story the truth, and when the servant becomes the master the hammers come out, in every century, wielded by the faith's own children. The school's verdict, after the year's survey, is the incarnation's own: a faith whose God became visible, audible, and readable will make art as inevitably as it breathes, and will argue about the art as inevitably as it argues about the God — the argument and the art being, together, the sign that both are alive. The road lesson follows, and it is short, because the road is long.
Lesson 4: Continuing to learn about Christianity
AWAKENING's final lesson in this ministry is the road map beyond the school, and in this room — the building's largest and the student's likeliest home tradition or neighbor tradition — the road is the best furnished in the world. The stations, in the order the tradition commends them: the assembly, attended (the Sunday of Year One's lesson, in a tradition not one's own at least once — the student who has only ever seen his own family's Christianity has seen a dialect and mistaken it for the language; the school's prescription is three Sundays: an Orthodox liturgy, a Catholic Mass, a Pentecostal or Black church service, with the student's own if he has one — the faith's range learned by attendance, not description); the book, continued (the year's reading plan grown into the habit: a Gospel whole, an epistle whole, the Psalms daily — then the classics the arts lesson named, Augustine and Dante first, as the road's high passes); the prayer, kept (the office's one hour, the examen's ten minutes, the Jesus Prayer on the walk — the practice chosen and kept small enough to survive); the table, shared (the parish's food bank shift, the Alpha table, the neighbor's feast day kept with them — the community's knowledge being, as every room teaches, table knowledge); and the holy places, dreamed or done (the local church's own history first — the parish is a holy place with an address the student already has — then, as means allow, the land: Bethlehem's grotto, the Sepulchre's rotunda, the Iona shore, the Assisi hill, the Guadalupe basilica — the geography of Year Two's places semester walked in person, in whatever order life permits).
The road's special difficulties, in this room, are the ones the year has equipped the student to name. The first is familiarity: the student who thinks he already knows this faith — from childhood, from the culture, from its enemies — must perform the year's hardest exercise, which is to have actually listened (the school's test is unglamorous: can he state the other family's position — the Catholic on the Pope, the Baptist on the font, the Pentecostal on the Spirit — in terms its holder would sign?). The second is the scandal of the divisions: twenty centuries of a divided house, whose members' charity toward one another is the road's own examination — the student joins the argument by joining a community, and the school's counsel is to join the argument charitably or not at all. The third is the faith's entanglement with the student's own civilization — its laws, its holidays, its sins of empire and its hospitals on the same page — which the two columns of the history semester were built to hold without either the patriot's whitewash or the prosecutor's brief: the record, whole. And the fourth is the claim itself, which this room, uniquely in the student's likely experience, will not leave him alone with as a spectator: the resurrection is either the world's hinge or its most successful fiction, and the road's last mile is the student's own verdict, which the school has equipped and will not make for him.
The school's record closes for this ministry: Garden's meetings, Rooted's fuller tellings, Stand's examined depths, AWAKENING's adult architecture — one ministry of twenty-seven, the building's largest, studied with the same courtesy as the smallest. The faith's own benediction for a departing student is its Lord's last word to his first students, and the school adopts it as the room's last word because it contains the whole curriculum in one sentence — the presence promised, the world addressed, the age spanned: “And behold, I am with you always, to the end of the age.” Peace — and the road, in this room, begins where it always begins: at the nearest church door, on the next first day of the week, where the assembly is gathering as it has gathered, in unbroken succession, since the morning the tomb was found empty. Go and see.
One last piece of equipment belongs in the graduate's kit, and it is this room's version of the school's oldest instrument: a community that will tell him the truth. The Christian road is not walked alone in the tradition's own design — the assembly, the small group, the spiritual director, the friend who asks the examen's questions — because the faith's anthropology holds that the self is the last reliable narrator of its own progress, and the road's dangers (the pride that dresses as zeal, the despair that dresses as humility, the drift that dresses as rest) are all, characteristically, invisible from inside. The graduate is therefore advised to take the road in company and under correction, as the monks did, as the classes of the Methodists did, as the base communities did — the form varies, the function does not. The building is the faculty; this room is its largest department, and its register — like every room's — is a door, not a diploma. The door stands open on Sunday. It has stood open for two thousand years. Go in.