Adult Year 1 · Semester 2 — History
Four lessons for this semester. When you are ready, take the test for this semester.
Lesson 1: The origins of Christianity
The history semester opens at the source: the origins of Christianity in the world of Second Temple Judaism under Roman rule. The setting must be built first, because the faith is unintelligible without it: Judea and Galilee in the first century were Jewish lands under Roman occupation — ruled from 63 BC by Rome through client kings (Herod the Great, then his sons) and prefects (Pontius Pilate, 26–36 AD) — seething with the questions occupation asks a covenant people: how long, O Lord; by what means will God act — a messiah (an anointed king of David's line) to expel the Romans, a prophet like Moses, a priestly reform, a withdrawal to the desert (the Essenes of Qumran, whose Dead Sea Scrolls are the era's library), a collaboration (the Sadducees of the Temple establishment), a resistance (the Zealots, whose road ended in the revolt of 66–70 and the Temple's destruction)? The Pharisees — the lay teachers of Torah observance whose rabbis would rebuild Judaism after the catastrophe — complete the map: a religious landscape of extraordinary intensity, literacy, and hope, awaiting a deliverer whose job description no two parties agreed on. Into this world, around 4 BC (the calendar's famous miscalculation), Jesus was born in Bethlehem of Judea, and around 28 AD he began to preach in Galilee that the kingdom of God — the awaited deliverance — was at hand, in his own person and ministry: the origins' hinge, from which everything else in the semester swings.
The movement's first transformation is its defining improbability: the messiah was crucified — Rome's punishment for slaves and rebels, a death the Torah itself called accursed (Deuteronomy 21:23) — and the movement did not end, as every comparable movement of the age ended (the followers of Judas the Galilean, of Theudas, of John the Baptist's sterner sects scattered or became footnotes), but exploded: within weeks, by the community's account, the crucified was proclaimed risen in Jerusalem itself, the Spirit poured out at Pentecost, thousands baptized, and a community formed that shared possessions, broke bread in homes, and taught in the Temple courts under the apostles — Peter, John, and James the Just, Jesus's brother, at its head. The historian's two columns open here and never close in this room: the community's explanation is the resurrection and the Spirit; the record's audit can trace everything except the cause — the empty tomb traditions, the appearances Paul lists within years (1 Corinthians 15, the faith's earliest document, a creed Paul says he received), the transformation of the witnesses, the movement's survival of its messiah's shame — and must leave the empty place where the cause goes, which the church fills with Easter and the skeptic with psychology, sociology, or silence. The school's discipline, here as everywhere: state what each column holds, and let the student's verdict be his own.
The origins' second transformation carried the faith out of Judaism's frame: the mission to the Gentiles. The question that split the first generation — must a Gentile convert become a Jew (circumcision, food laws, Torah entire) to follow the Jewish messiah? — was settled, after the argument the New Testament itself preserves (the Jerusalem Council of Acts 15, c. 49 AD), in Paul's favor: the Gentiles enter as Gentiles, by faith and baptism, and the faith became portable — a universal religion detachable from one people's law, the single most consequential decision of its first century and the precondition of everything the history semester will survey. By the time the Temple fell in 70 AD — the catastrophe that ended the Jerusalem church's centrality and confirmed the separation of church and synagogue — the faith Paul planted ringed the Mediterranean: Rome, Corinth, Ephesus, Antioch, Alexandria. The origins close with the faith's first documents still being written (the Gospels, 65–100 AD, the texts semester's subject) and its first martyrs dying (Peter and Paul, by tradition, under Nero in the 60s): a Jewish sect of a few thousand, in one generation, had become a Mediterranean movement with a universal claim. The next lesson goes back to the man at the hinge.
The origins' archaeology deserves the closing note, because the first century has become unusually visible: the ossuary inscriptions and the Pilate stone (the prefect's name in Caesarea's theater, found 1961 — the crucifixion's administrator in limestone), the synagogue and house-church strata at Capernaum, the Nazareth of the excavators (a village of perhaps a few hundred — the Gospels' “can anything good come out of Nazareth” as demographic realism), the crucified man's heel bone with the nail still through it (Yehohanan, Jerusalem, found 1968 — the only physical remain of a Roman crucifixion, confirming the burial practices the Gospels describe), and the Dead Sea Scrolls' library showing the mother religion's own diversity at the moment of the birth. The adult's two columns gain, from the spade, a shared floor: whatever verdict the resurrection receives, the world it happened in is no longer a stage set but a place — with tax receipts, ossuaries, and a prefect's dedication stone — and the school's student is expected to know the floor is real.
Lesson 2: Jesus of Nazareth and the early community
The history semester's second lesson is the man himself, and the community that formed around his memory: Jesus of Nazareth, as the sources allow him to be known, and the early community that carried him. The sources first, with the adult's candor: for Jesus's life we have the four Gospels (Matthew, Mark, Luke, John — written a generation or two after his death, by believers, as proclamation rather than biography in the modern sense), the letters of Paul (earlier, but concerned with the risen Christ more than the earthly life), a handful of Roman and Jewish notices (Josephus's two references, one partly interpolated by Christian copyists; Tacitus's hostile paragraph confirming the crucifixion under Pilate), and nothing written by Jesus himself. The historical Jesus research of the last two centuries — the “quests” — has produced its scholarly core of high confidence: a Galilean Jew, baptized by John, who preached the kingdom of God in parables and aphorisms, healed and exorcised (even skeptical scholars treat the reputation as historical — his enemies attributed it to sorcery, which is its own attestation), ate with the outcast, debated Torah with the Pharisees, created the Twelve as a symbol of restored Israel, and was crucified by Pilate in Jerusalem at Passover, having enacted a prophetic sign against the Temple's commerce. Around that core the portraits arrange themselves by the portraitist's lights — apocalyptic prophet (the scholarly mainstream's center of gravity), wisdom sage, social revolutionary, the church's incarnate Lord — and the school's student should hold the core firmly and the portraits as portraits, the Gospels' own theological tellings being, for the community, not obstacles to the man but the man's intended medium: they were written, as John's Gospel says, “so that you may believe,” and they ask to be read as testimony, not transcript.
The life, in the outline the four testimonies share and the year has room for: born in Bethlehem (Matthew and Luke) to Mary and Joseph, raised in Nazareth of Galilee, a tekton — a builder/craftsman — until about thirty; baptized by John in the Jordan, tempted in the wilderness, then preaching in Galilee's villages around the lake: the kingdom announced in parables (the sower, the prodigal son, the good Samaritan — stories that have entered the world's bloodstream), the sick healed, the table opened to tax collectors and sinners (the fellowship meals that were his social revolution in miniature), the Sermon on the Mount's ethic (Matthew 5–7: the Beatitudes, the enemy-love command, the Lord's Prayer) taught as the kingdom's law. The final journey to Jerusalem for Passover: the entry on a donkey (Zechariah's king), the Temple action, the last supper with the Twelve (the bread and cup that become the Eucharist), the betrayal by Judas, the arrest in Gethsemane, the hearings before the council and Pilate, and the crucifixion on Golgotha under the titulus “King of the Jews” — the Roman irony the church reads as the truth told by accident. The burial by Joseph of Arimathea, the empty tomb found by the women (Mary Magdalene first, in all the accounts' core), the appearances, and the ascension complete the Gospels' arc — the events the texts semester will read in their documents.
The early community is the lesson's second half: the Jerusalem church of the Acts — Spirit-filled, communal (the goods held in common in the first fervor), Temple-going and house-breaking bread, led by the apostles and then by James — and the diaspora churches Paul founded, whose letters are the community's self-portrait at twenty years: assemblies in houses, of slaves and senators' households together, arguing about food and sex and spiritual gifts, collecting money for Jerusalem's poor, singing the hymns Paul quotes (Philippians 2's Christ-hymn, perhaps the earliest Christian text of all), and already, in the creeds Paul transmits, confessing the story whole: Christ died for our sins, was buried, was raised, appeared. The community's distinctives, as its neighbors saw them (Pliny's famous letter to Trajan, c. 112, is the outsider's snapshot): pre-dawn meetings, a hymn to Christ “as to a god,” a shared meal, an oath against theft and adultery, and a stubbornness under torture that the governor reports with puzzled respect. The next lesson follows that community out of the catacombs and onto the throne.
The early community's economics deserve the lesson's closing paragraph, because they are its most imitated and least sustained experiment: the Jerusalem church's holding of goods in common (Acts 2 and 4) was voluntary, local, and — by Paul's later collection for Jerusalem's poor — apparently not self-sustaining, yet it set the pattern the monastic orders would institutionalize (the community of goods as the counsels' economic form), the Anabaptist Hutterites would maintain for five centuries to this day, and the modern church's common purses and covenant communities would repeatedly attempt. The outsider's verdict stands in the Acts itself, in Gamaliel's counsel to the council — if this is of men, it will fail; if of God, you cannot overthrow it — the historian's own agnosticism preserved in the community's scripture, which the school commends to the student as the origins' most honest sentence: the community canonized the test by which it might be falsified. Two thousand years on, the test is still running.
Lesson 3: Growth, change, and reform
The history semester's third lesson is the faith's long middle: fifteen centuries of growth, change, and reform, from persecuted sect to Christendom to the Reformation's fracture. The growth first: from perhaps ten thousand Christians in 100 AD to some six million by 300 — a growth the sociologists compute at a steady forty percent a decade, achieved not by mass rallies but by networks: households, workshops, the care of the sick in the plagues (the Christians nursed their own and their pagan neighbors when the priests fled, a witness the emperor Julian later complained of), the inclusion of women and slaves as full members, and a message of resurrection in a world of fatalism. The persecutions — Nero's scapegoating (64), Decius's and Diocletian's empire-wide attempts (250, 303–313) — made martyrs whose deaths the church remembered as seeds (Tertullian's phrase: the blood of the martyrs is the seed of the church), and then the reversal: Constantine's conversion and the Edict of Milan (313), the councils that defined the creeds, the empire's Christianization (Theodosius making it the state religion, 380), and the church's assumption of Rome's carcass — its law, its roads, its bishoprics mapped on the empire's cities — as the empire in the West collapsed around it. The medieval church that resulted built the cathedrals, universities, hospitals, and monasteries of Europe; preserved the ancient world's books in its scriptoria; sent missionaries from Ireland to China (the Nestorian stele in Xi'an, 781, marks how far); and divided, East from West, in the schism of 1054 — while holding, through it all, a unity of creed and sacrament that made “Christendom” a civilization's name.
Change and reform are the era's constant counterpoint, because the church's possession of power generated, in every century, the movements to recall it to its source: the monastic reforms (Cluny, the Cistercians, the friars — Francis and Dominic sending their brothers barefoot into the new cities), the reforming councils and the papal reform of the eleventh century, the Waldensians and Lollards and Hussites who pressed the Bible on the laity and paid for it, the Renaissance's double fruit (the humanists' return to the sources — Erasmus's Greek New Testament, 1516 — and the papal court's corruption that made the sources explosive), until the reform became the Reformation: Luther's Ninety-five Theses (1517) against the indulgence trade igniting, within a generation, the Lutheran, Reformed (Zwingli, Calvin's Geneva), Anglican (Henry VIII's breach, then the Elizabethan settlement), and radical (the Anabaptists) reformations, and the Catholic Counter-Reformation answering (the Council of Trent, 1545–63; the Jesuits; Teresa and John of the Cross) — Europe's one church becoming its warring confessions, with a century of religious war (the French wars, the Thirty Years' War's devastation) as the fracture's price.
The lesson's assessment keeps the era's two columns as this school always does: in one, the record of a faith that carried literacy, law, charity, and art through a continent's dark centuries, built the hospital and the university, and produced, from within itself, an unbroken line of reformers holding it to its own book; in the other, the crusades' and inquisitions' violence, the corruption that sold indulgences, the wars of religion that taught Europe toleration by exhaustion. The adult's synthesis is the era's own lesson, which the modern world semester will inherit: the church grows by witness and is deformed by power, and its reforms come when the deformity is named from inside, by its own scriptures, in its own name. The next lesson brings the story to the student's own century — the faith's strangest hundred years, in which it lost Europe and gained the world.
The era's reforming line has a prehistory the lesson should honor before closing: the Gregorian reform of the eleventh century, which freed the church from lay control at the price of the clerical caste it created; the Devotio Moderna of the Low Countries, whose “Imitation of Christ” (Thomas à Kempis) became the faith's most-read book after the Bible and taught the interior reform the century before Luther; and the conciliar movement, which tried to govern the church by council and failed at Basel, leaving the papal monarchy to face the Reformation unreformed in structure. The pattern the adult should extract is the era's law: reform in this church is always ressourcement — a return to the sources (the Bible, the fathers, the apostolic age) wielded against the present by the present's own children — and its failures are as instructive as its triumphs: Hus burned at Constance under safe-conduct (1415) taught the next century that the council's word could not be trusted, and Luther, remembering Hus, refused to come to Worms without an army's worth of princes behind him. History's lessons are sometimes literally life-saving.
Lesson 4: Christianity in the modern world
The history semester closes with the faith's last three centuries — the centuries that made the world the student inhabits, and remade the church within it. The challenges came first, and in sequence: the Enlightenment's reason enthroned against revelation (Voltaire's écrasez l'infâme; the French Revolution's dechristianization, the Goddess Reason enthroned in Notre-Dame in 1793 — and the church's answer in the Vendée's blood and the revival that followed); the industrial revolution's cities, where the parish system collapsed under populations it could not house (and the Methodists, the Salvation Army, and the Catholic religious orders built the working-class Christianity of chapels, schools, and settlements in answer); Darwin's evolution (1859) and the historical criticism of the Bible, which split the Protestant world into the modernist and fundamentalist parties whose argument still structures its politics (the Scopes trial of 1925 as its theater); two world wars that broke Christendom's moral credit in its heartland (the German church's compromise with Nazism — and the Confessing Church's Barmen Declaration of 1934 against it, Bonhoeffer's martyrdom as its seal); and the secularization of Europe, where the cathedrals stand full of tourists and empty of congregations, the faith's ancestral home becoming its mission field — the modern world's most quietly astonishing religious fact.
The growth came simultaneously, on the other side of the world, and it is the era's headline: the missionary movement of the nineteenth century (Carey to India, Livingstone to Africa, the China missions, the translation of the Bible into hundreds of languages — the faith's book becoming the most translated in human history) planted churches that, in the twentieth century, became the faith: Africa's Christians grew from some ten million in 1900 to over six hundred million today; Latin America, Catholic for five centuries, saw a Pentecostal transformation that has made a quarter or more of Brazil Protestant; China's churches grew under persecution from under a million in 1949 to tens of millions; Korea became a Christian stronghold; and Pentecostalism — from the Azusa Street revival in Los Angeles (1906) to half a billion adherents — became the era's characteristic Christianity: expressive, healing-centered, Spirit-expecting, and largely independent of the Western denominations that once claimed to own the faith's future. The ecumenical movement (the World Council of Churches, 1948; the Second Vatican Council, 1962–65, opening the Catholic Church to the modern world and to its separated brethren) and the era's martyrs (the twentieth century produced more Christian martyrs, by the church's counts, than all previous centuries combined — under the totalitarianisms of right and left alike) complete the picture's light and dark.
The modern world's assessment, in the school's two columns: the faith that the Enlightenment pronounced dying has become, demographically, the most dynamic it has ever been — younger, poorer, browner, more southern, more Pentecostal — while its historic heartlands practice a cultural Christianity of baptisms, weddings, and funerals over a hollowed core; its intellectual life argues with a science it partly fathered; its moral teaching, once the West's default, is now one voice in a pluralism it is still learning to address without either surrender or contempt; and its internal argument — between the heirs of fundamentalism and modernism, Rome and Geneva and Azusa Street, the cathedral and the storefront — continues at full strength into a century in which, for the first time since Constantine, the faith holds power almost nowhere and grows almost everywhere except where it once held it. The student who can hold that sentence whole owns the modern world semester. The texts semester follows: the book at the center of it all, read in depth.
The modern era's quietest transformation belongs in the closing audit: the Bible's translation into the vernaculars — the work the missions made their first labor — has now rendered at least portions of scripture into over three thousand languages, the whole Bible into more than seven hundred, and the consequence is a faith whose book belongs, in a sense no previous century could claim, to its readers rather than its custodians: the African pastor, the Chinese house-church elder, and the Brazilian Pentecostal read the same Romans in their mother tongues, and the interpretations they build — prosperity's distortions and liberation's insights alike — are the modern church's uncontrollable vitality. The school's student should close the semester with the fact the era's critics and celebrants share: the center cannot hold because there is no longer a center — the faith Constantine gathered into an empire has dispersed into a world, and its unity, such as it is, is now the unity of a book, a name, and a Sunday, kept on every continent at once.