Adult Year 2 · Semester 4 — Places, arts, and the road ahead
Four lessons for this semester. When you are ready, take the test for this semester.
Lesson 1: The science museum and the planetarium
AWAKENING's final semester begins with this family's sacred architecture, and the adult should approach it without irony, because the buildings are real and the devotion in them is measurable: the science museum and the planetarium are where this family keeps its wonders, teaches its children, and takes its visitors to be converted by scale. The museum first. Its genealogy is double, as the community lesson noted — the cabinets of curiosity and the imperial collections, baptized by the Enlightenment into public instruction — and its mature form (the great natural history and science museums of the nineteenth and twentieth centuries, and their interactive descendants, the science centers, of which San Francisco's Exploratorium, founded 1969 by Frank Oppenheimer, is the type: “a library and a gymnasium for the senses,” hands on everything, no exhibit behind glass that could be in a visitor's hands) is this family's cathedral in function whatever its founders intended: a hushed, vaulted, object-filled space where the faithful bring their children to stand before the relics — the moon rock under its guard, the Darwin manuscripts, the blue whale suspended over the hall like a god's own leviathan — and where the liturgy is the label, the demonstration, and the gasp.
The planetarium is the family's chapel of ease and its most frankly devotional room: a dome, a darkness, a voice — and the stars, wheeling in their courses at the lecturer's command, with the congregation reclined and silent in the posture every tradition recognizes as receptivity. Sagan's “Cosmos” was, in effect, a planetarium that came to the home; the planetarium show remains the family's most reliable conversion instrument, particularly for children, and its directors know their liturgy cold: begin with the familiar sky, remove the light pollution the audience lives under, show the sky their ancestors saw, and then pull back — the planets, the galaxy, the deep field — until the Pale Blue Dot meditation can be delivered not as a reading but as an experience the room has just had. The adult's comparative note is the semester's thesis: every room in this building has a technology for producing the small-self-in-a-vast-order feeling that the religions call worship and this family calls wonder, and the planetarium is this family's — the most efficient ever built, and the only one whose vast order can be checked against the sky outside the door, which is either its limitation or its glory, depending on which room's student is asked. This family, characteristically, calls it the glory, and has the better of the argument on the evidence: the sky outside does match. It always matches. That is rather the point of the family's whole building-within-the-building, and the planetarium is where it is most simply true.
The museum's own audit closes the lesson, in the family's manner. The great collections are entangled, as the African ministry's restitution lesson showed from the other side, with the empires that gathered them — the bronzes and the mummies and the sacred objects in the evidence-cathedrals were not all come by honestly, and this family's institutions have been slower than their principles in facing their stores. The adult records the movement now under way — the returns, the re-labelings, the source-community curators — as the family's honesty discipline arriving, late, at its own relic cupboards, and notes the structural lesson with the school's pleasure: an institution whose god is evidence eventually audits its own provenance, because provenance is evidence. The planetarium, by contrast, is innocent — its collection is the sky, which cannot be looted — and perhaps that is why this family loves it best of its buildings: the one cathedral whose treasures are exactly where they always were, over everyone's head, unownable. The semester's places thus form a pair of their own: the museum, where the family's wonders are kept and its sins are filed; the dome, where the wonder needs no keeping. Between them, the student has the family's whole sacred geography in two rooms — and the honesty to label both.
Lesson 2: The library and a quiet spot under the stars
From the family's public buildings to its private ones: the library and the dark place under the sky — the two addresses where this family's inner life is actually lived, and the adult treatment gives them the same seriousness the other rooms give the cell and the hermitage. The library first, public and personal. The public library is, as Year 1 named it, the family's true cathedral — and the claim deserves its evidence: it is the one institution in the modern city that is free, warm, silent, universal, and dedicated to the proposition that the world's knowledge belongs to whoever walks in; its librarians are the family's most trusted clergy-analogues (the reference desk as confessional for the curious — “I have a question I am embarrassed to ask” is heard there daily, and answered without a flicker); and its defense, in every budget fight, is conducted by this family's members with a fervor their neighbors find disproportionate until they attend one of the hearings and hear the testimony: the library as the place the immigrant learned the language, the unemployed filed the applications, the child of the chaotic house found the quiet chair. The personal library — the shelf as autobiography, the kept books as the self's furniture — is the domestic form, and the family's essayists treat its arrangement and its lending (the book pressed on the friend, the book never returned and never regretted) as the household's liturgy of transmission.
The quiet spot under the stars is the library's outdoor twin: the dark place — the hill outside the town's light, the desert campsite, the beach after the bars close, the backyard with the porch light off — where the family's other book is read. Its practice was the subject of Year 1's reflection lesson; its place is the subject here, and the adult should understand the place's scarcity as the family's environmental doctrine in miniature: the dark sky is a commons being destroyed by light pollution at a measurable rate (most of the world's children now grow up unable to see the Milky Way — the family's astronomers cite the figure the way other rooms cite a closing church), and its defense — the dark-sky reserves, the lighting ordinances, the International Dark-Sky Association's sanctuaries — is this family's preservation movement, complete with its own sacred geography (the certified dark places as pilgrimage sites, the eclipse paths as movable feasts). A tradition is known by what it counts as desecration. For this family, the list is short and sincere: a burned library and a flooded sky — the two books it reads by, the printed one and the original — and the student who has stood in a true dark with the Milky Way overhead and felt the ancestors' sky return has had the family's central religious experience in its unmediated form. It requires no belief. It requires only darkness, which the modern world is making rare enough to need defending — and this family, to its credit, is on the barricades with its star charts.
The library's future is this family's live argument, and the lesson should end inside it rather than above it. The printed library is besieged by the same economics that besiege everything in print, and the digital library — the family's canon now substantially living in the network's stacks — raises the room's oldest question in its newest form: a canon that lives on servers is a canon with landlords, and the family's historians, who remember when its books were banned, are properly nervous of a shelf that can be switched off, edited silently, or priced. The counter-movement is characteristic: the open-access campaigns, the pirate libraries and their legal martyrs, the Internet Archive's lawsuits — the family's free-speech and free-knowledge fights of the present decade are, structurally, the Bradlaugh fights with better bandwidth. The adult's closing note for the places semester's middle lesson is therefore a vow the family keeps renewing and the student is invited to witness rather than to take: the books stay readable, the sky stays dark, the doors stay open. A tradition is its vows kept at cost. By that measure this family, in its libraries and under its stars, is a tradition — whatever its census form says.
Lesson 3: Art, music, and literature of Agnosticism, Atheism and Non-religion
The arts of a family defined by a negation are a paradox the adult should enjoy before resolving: there is no atheist iconography, no godless liturgy's chant — and yet the family has produced and patronized a distinctive body of art, music, and literature whose themes are legible across three centuries: the cosmos as sublime, the mind as hero, the church as beautiful problem, and death as the great clarifier. The visual arts first. The family's characteristic images are the scientific sublime's: the nebula photographs (the Hubble deep fields as the era's altarpieces — printed, framed, and hung in this family's homes with a devotion their owners would deny and display), the Earthrise and Pale Blue Dot photographs (the two most reproduced images in the family's keeping), the anatomical and botanical illustration of the Enlightenment, and — in the older line — the vanitas still life, which the family claims as an ancestor: the skull, the hourglass, the snuffed candle, preaching mortality without a heaven in the frame. Its architecture is the museum and the library of the previous lessons; its sculpture, increasingly, is the memorial without religious furniture — the secular war memorials and the AIDS quilt's panels (a folk masterpiece the family shares with the grieving of every faith, and studies as proof that the unchurched grieve in fabric as the churched do in stone).
The music divides into the borrowed and the made. The borrowed is vast and unembarrassed: this family's funerals run on the same Bach and Barber as everyone else's (the “Agnus Dei” sung over an atheist is a commonplace the family defends with its doctrine that beauty is not owned by its composers' beliefs — the mirror of the religions' use of unbelieving artists, and equally sincere), its weddings on the Mendelssohn of the surrounding culture, its protests on the spirituals and union songs of older movements. The made is smaller and characteristic: the freethought hymnals of the nineteenth century (the ethical culture and secular societies sang, to borrowed tunes, words of their own — “Ours is a joyful hymn” is the genre's temper), the folk-protest line from Woody Guthrie (whose “This Land Is Your Land” is the family's unofficial national anthem in America, verses about property and all), the comic songsters (Tom Lehrer, Tim Minchin — the family's jesters, whose precision and nerve make them its licensed truth-tellers in the modern court), and the cosmic rock of the space age. The literature completes the survey where the texts semester began: the family's novels are the novels of the examined life under a silent heaven — George Eliot (who translated Strauss and Feuerbach before she wrote “Middlemarch,” the family's candidate for the greatest novel of the moral life without God), Thomas Hardy (whose heaven is famously unanswering), the modern line through Iris Murdoch (the family's philosopher-novelist of goodness without God) to the present shelf. The adult's verdict: the family's arts are not a separate canon but a reading of the whole canon — the world's art, audited for the works in which the human stands alone and stands up. It is a defensible anthology, and its table of contents — Eliot, the nebulae, the vanitas, Guthrie, the Dot — would grace any room in this building, which is the school's comparative benediction for this family: its taste, like its ethics, is better than its theory of itself.
The arts' newest chapter is the digital one, and it closes the survey at the present tense. The family's images now circulate at the speed of the feed: the deep-field photographs as phone wallpapers (the altarpiece become the lock screen — a demotion or a democratization, the family's critics argue both), the space agencies' image feeds as a daily office of wonders, the data-visualizations of the climate and the genome as a new illuminated manuscript tradition, executed by instruments and read by millions. Its music has acquired the space program's own soundtrack and the film scores that taught two generations what awe sounds like in strings; its literature has acquired the science-fictional mainstream, in which the family's questions — the mind's nature, the cosmos's indifference, the ethics of the created intelligence — are now the culture's common property, argued in paperback by readers who have never heard the word humanism. The adult's final verdict on the family's arts is the school's, and it is a benediction of the comparative kind: a family that owns no images has ended by giving the world its most shared ones — the blue marble, the pale dot, the deep field — photographs, not paintings; evidence, not icons; and yet hung in the heart's front room by hundreds of millions who could not name the family that taught them to look. The arts, in the end, out-argue the arguments. They usually do, in every room of this building.
Lesson 4: Continuing to learn about Agnosticism, Atheism and Non-religion
AWAKENING's final lesson in this ministry is the road map beyond the school, drawn in the family's own idiom: there is no graduation in a tradition whose first principle is that the inquiry does not close, and the student's continuing education is therefore not a program to be completed but a set of habits, shelves, and companies to keep for life. The habits are Year 1's practice, matured: the prediction written down, the adversary's book read each season (the school now formally assigns the graduate of this ministry the strongest theology on the building's shelves, and the graduates of the other ministries this room's strongest books — the building's whole design is that assignment, institutionalized), the error log kept, the quiet room kept, the sky watched. The shelves are the canon, extended by the rule the canon teaches: follow the footnotes of the books that changed you, prefer the primary source to the summary and the summary to the slogan, and let the shelf's growth be audited annually against the question — what have I read this year that I hoped would be wrong? The companies are the family's institutions at their best: the society, the assembly, the club, the reading group, the volunteer shift — chosen not for agreement but for the quality of their questions, since a company that asks well will keep a mind honest longer than a library will.
The road's special difficulties, in this room, deserve the candor of the earlier lessons. The first is the echo chamber: a family constituted by a refusal can curate its information until the refusal is never again tested, and the graduate's defense is the adversary's-bibliography habit, kept as a vow rather than a taste. The second is the hardening of the position into an identity — the point at which “atheist” stops being a conclusion held at the evidence's temperature and becomes a tribe's name, defended at the tribe's temperature — against which the family's own founder-figure, Huxley, left the standing warning: agnosticism is a method, and a method cannot be a tribe without ceasing to be a method. The third is grief, which will come for the graduate as for everyone, and at which the lifestance will be asked for the thing it is least practiced at providing: not an argument but a presence. The family's wisdom for that hour is in its keeping already — the celebrant's number, the friends who will sit, the texts that are read at its funerals, the nurse of the foundations lesson who stayed — and the graduate is advised, in the school's plainest sentence, to arrange those things before they are needed, as the religious arrange theirs. A lifestance, like a faith, is finally judged by its conduct at the graveside. This family's conduct there, at its best, is the record's answer to its critics, and the student has now read the record whole.
The school's record closes for this ministry: Garden's questions, Rooted's reasons, Stand's examined arguments, AWAKENING's adult depths — one ministry of twenty-seven, the one with no god in it, studied with the same courtesy as the twenty-six with. The family's own benediction for a departing student is not a blessing, by its own logic, but a charge, and the school adopts it as the room's last word because it could serve, unaltered, over every door in the building: keep the questions honest, keep the kindness uncommanded and prompt, keep the sky in view — and when the evidence changes, change. Peace — in this room's translation: go well, and keep wondering.
One last piece of equipment belongs in the graduate's kit, and it is this family's version of the school's oldest instrument: a teacher. The family officially has none — no priesthood, no guru, no magisterium — and unofficially it is made of them: the professor whose office hours change a life, the elder of the society who has read everything twice, the friend whose questions are better than one's own, the dead authors who function, in every honest reader's life, as a faculty. The road's wisdom is to assemble one's faculty deliberately — across the building, not only across this room — and to keep it in session: the annual rereading, the standing argument, the letter written to the author who will never answer and the living one who might. The family's first principle was that no one may do one's thinking for one; its mature form is subtler and truer: no one can do one's thinking for one, and no one thinks well alone. Between those two sentences lies the whole of the adult education this school exists to provide, in this room and in the twenty-six others — whose doors, the student is reminded at the threshold of this one, all open. The building is the faculty. Enroll for life.