Adult Year 1 · Semester 3 — Texts and teachings
Four lessons for this semester. When you are ready, take the test for this semester.
Lesson 1: Books about the universe and how we know: a guided overview
A family without scripture still has a canon, and the guided overview of it must begin by naming its genre: these are books about the universe and about knowing — cosmology, evolution, and epistemology — whose function in the community's life is recognizably scriptural: they are given to the young, quoted at gatherings, pressed on friends in crisis, and reread at the deathbed. The shelf's spine, in rough order of the community's own reverence: Darwin's “Origin” and “Descent” as the founding documents; the popular cosmology line from Gamow through Sagan's “Cosmos” (book and series, 1980 — still the family's most effective act of outreach, watched by hundreds of millions) to Hawking's “A Brief History of Time” (1988 — the bestseller whose unread completeness became a standing joke the family tells on itself) and the modern explainers; the epistemology shelf — Hume's “Enquiry,” Russell's essays, Popper, and the skeptic's manuals (Sagan's “The Demon-Haunted World” with its baloney-detection kit is the genre's standard); and the movement's own polemics, from Ingersoll's lectures — Robert G. Ingersoll, the “Great Agnostic,” was the nineteenth century's most famous freethought orator, filling halls the revivalists envied — to the New Atheist bestsellers of the 2000s.
The overview's critical duty is the school's usual one: the canon has the faults of canons. Its science dates (a 1980 cosmos is a historical document now); its polemics date faster; its demographics are narrow — the shelf is heavily male, heavily Western, and largely silent about the non-religious experience of the global majority, a narrowness the family's own scholars are correcting with the recovery of its women (the freethought feminists of the nineteenth century, from Ernestine Rose to Elizabeth Cady Stanton's “The Woman's Bible,” were written out of both the church's history and the movement's), its Black freethinkers (from Frederick Douglass's complicated faith to Hubert Harrison and A. Philip Randolph's socialism), and its Asian and African skeptics. And the canon's deepest peculiarity deserves the adult's attention: it is a canon that denies canonicity — every book on the shelf insists, in principle, on its own revisability, and the community's reverence for them is therefore of a strange, self-undermining kind: scripture that instructs the reader to check. The student who grasps that paradox grasps the family's textual culture entire.
How the books are actually used closes the overview: not in services (the family mostly has none) but in the passage of life the religions mark with scripture — the hospital bag, the prison library, the gift to the teenager who has begun to ask, the passage read aloud at the humanist funeral (Sagan and Ingersoll are the two most common voices at such funerals in the Anglophone world, with the poets — Auden, Mary Oliver, and the family's unofficial laureate of wonder, Oliver above all — close behind). A canon is known by its funerals. By that test this family's canon is real, beloved, and — in the manner of its contents — provisionally held, pending better evidence, which is the most honest epitaph any shelf of books has ever earned.
The canon's scientific spine deserves one more guided pass, because the adult will be asked for it by name. For cosmology: Gamow's “Mr Tompkins” books for the beginner's wonder, Sagan's “Cosmos” for the cathedral tour, Weinberg's “The First Three Minutes” for the austere version, Hawking and the moderns (Greene, Tyson, Rovelli — whose “Seven Brief Lessons on Physics” brought an Italian poet-physicist's brevity to the family's shelf) for the current state. For evolution: the “Origin” itself, read slowly (it is a better book than its reputation — an argument built like a cathedral, one difficulty at a time), Dawkins's “The Blind Watchmaker” and “The Ancestor's Tale” for the modern exposition, Gould for the contingency and the prose. For how we know: Hume first, then Russell's “The Problems of Philosophy,” Popper's “Conjectures and Refutations,” and the modern literature of cognitive error (Kahneman's “Thinking, Fast and Slow” as the family's book of sins — a catalogue of the mind's defaults, written by a psychologist and received by the family as a spiritual classic, which in its way it is). A student who reads one book from each shelf has the canon in epitome and the family's mind in miniature: the universe, its history, and the instrument's faults, in three volumes.
The polemics shelf needs the audit the overview promised, because it is where the canon's readers are most often misled about the family's actual thought. The bestsellers of the 2000s were written for a moment — post-2001, Iraq-war-era, American — and their arguments (against a literalist, politicized religion that their authors treated as the whole) read, two decades on, as period pieces beside the family's deeper shelf: Hume is more radical than any of them and three centuries older; Ingersoll is funnier; Russell is more precise; Lucretius is more beautiful. The movement's own critics made the point first and best, and the guided overview adopts it as the canon's shelving rule: the polemics are the porch, not the house. A reader who stops at the porch has met the family's loudest members and missed its best ones — an error the religions' readers make about their own canons too, in mirror image, which is why this school builds its shelves deep in every room.
Lesson 2: The writings of Carl Sagan: a guided overview
Carl Sagan (1934–1996) is the closest this family has to a beloved teacher in the religious sense — an astronomer whose books and broadcasts made the cosmos a place of belonging for millions who had left or never entered a church — and the guided overview of his writings treats him with the school's full method: the work, the method, the devotion he inspired, and the audit. The work: “Cosmos” (1980), the book and the thirteen-part series, which carried a generation from the calendar of cosmic time (the universe's history compressed into a year, humanity arriving in the last hour of the last day) to the Pale Blue Dot avant la lettre; “The Dragons of Eden” (1977, Pulitzer Prize) on the evolution of intelligence; “Broca's Brain” and “The Demon-Haunted World” (1995) on the romance and the discipline of science; the novel “Contact” (1985), whose ending — a message found in the digits of pi — is the family's most debated fictional theology; and the posthumous “Billions and Billions” and the lectures published as “The Varieties of Scientific Experience,” in which Sagan, invited to give the Gifford Lectures on natural theology, set out his own position with characteristic precision: no evidence for the God of the Abrahamic traditions as described; an open, wondering reverence for the universe itself; and the famous standard — extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence — that the skeptic movement has since carved over its door.
The method is the writings' real content, and the overview should teach it as he taught it: science as a candle in the dark — his image for the whole enterprise — whose flame is a set of habits: multiple working hypotheses, arguments from authority worthless, quantification where possible, falsification welcomed, and the baloney-detection kit (confirmation of facts independently, encouragement of debate, the spin doctor's fallacies named and shamed) carried at all times. Wrapped around the method is the affect that made him beloved rather than merely respected: wonder as a discipline, the insistence that understanding the universe's scale is not a diminishment of the human but its rescue from a smaller story — “we are a way for the universe to know itself,” the sentence his readers quote the way other rooms quote scripture, and mean it the same way. The devotional facts are on the record and the school records them without embarrassment: his books are read at funerals, his voice is tattooed in paraphrase, his birthday (November 9, “Carl Sagan Day”) is kept by science societies — the family that denies saints keeps producing them, and Sagan is the proof that the production is about gratitude, not doctrine.
The audit, in the school's manner: Sagan's science was of his moment and some of it has dated; his nuclear-winter advocacy and his politics drew the fire of his peers; his treatment of religion, though gentler than the New Atheists' who followed, still flattened the traditions into their least reflective forms when it suited the argument — the theologians' standing complaint, with some justice. And his canonization has its irony, which he would have been the first to footnote: the man who warned against arguments from authority is quoted as one. The guided overview's verdict is the one his own method prescribes: Sagan is not to be believed but to be used — the kit checked, the wonder kept, the errors corrected in the open, as he corrected his own. A teacher who teaches his students to audit him has, by this family's lights, earned the front of the shelf. He would have insisted on the audit. That insistence is why he is there.
Sagan's religious writings proper deserve a closer guided note, because they are the family's most careful statement of its own spiritual position and are usually known only by quotation. In the Gifford Lectures he sorted the world's God-claims with a taxonomist's patience and concluded that the evidence warranted, at most, a reverence he was willing to call religious in Einstein's sense — “the cosmic religious feeling” before a universe that is under no obligation to be comprehensible and yet, in part, comprehends itself through us. His wife and collaborator Ann Druyan has carried the position into the present century (the later “Cosmos” seasons are substantially hers), and the position's name in the current literature — religious naturalism — is the family's fastest-growing self-description, a fact the adult should register: the room that began by refusing the sacred has produced, in its most beloved teacher, a doctrine of the sacred with the ontology removed and the reverence kept. The theologians across the hall call it a halfway house; the family's naturalists call it home; the school calls it, accurately, the live frontier — and notes that Sagan himself, characteristically, called it a question he was still asking when he died, at sixty-two, with the audit unfinished. The unfinished audit is the most Saganian thing about him, and the overview adopts it as his epitaph in this school's keeping.
A practical coda for the student who would read him whole: begin with “The Demon-Haunted World” for the method, proceed to “Cosmos” for the cathedral, then to the Gifford Lectures for the theology and “Pale Blue Dot” for the devotion, and keep “Billions and Billions” — the posthumous miscellany his wife assembled — for the man, whose essays on abortion, on his own dying, and on the “baloney” of his age show the method applied to the life that held it. Read in that order, Sagan is this family's complete curriculum in one author: how to know, what is known, what it means, and how to die inside it without lying. No other figure on the family's shelf covers all four. That is the guided overview's final shelving decision, and it is made — as he would have required — provisionally, and with the evidence cited.
Lesson 3: Children's books of questions and answers: a guided overview
The third textual system of this family is its children's literature — the books through which the non-religious raise their young in a world of other people's scriptures — and the guided overview treats it seriously, because a tradition is what it hands to its children. The genre has a shape: the question-and-answer book (the universe's story told as answers to a child's actual questions — where did everything come from, what is the sun, why do we die), the evolution picture-book (the tree of life as a family album — “Grandmother Fish,” “Our Family Tree,” and their many cousins, which do for the non-religious child what the Garden district of the religious schools does for theirs: install the founding story at the age of wonder), the death-and-grief book (the family's hardest shelf — “Lifetimes,” “The Fall of Freddie the Leaf” in the wider literature, and the specifically secular grief books that must console without a heaven and have learned, at their best, to console with memory, continuity, and the honest sentence), and the comparative-religion book for children — a genre this family prizes beyond the others, because its educational philosophy holds that the child should meet the world's faiths as a respectful visitor early, with the family's own position presented as one house on the street rather than as the street's demolition.
The overview's analysis begins with the genre's problem, which the family's own educators state frankly: the religious traditions hand their children stories with persons in them — prophets, gods, ancestors — while the non-religious hand theirs processes (evolution, entropy, the water cycle), and processes make colder comfort at a funeral or a frightening night. The best of the literature answers not by inventing persons but by leaning on the two narrative resources the family honestly owns: deep time (the child's real ancestry — the fish, the star, the grandmother's grandmother back to the first cell — told as a family saga, because it is one) and the community of inquiry (the scientists and questioners as a cast — Darwin, Curie, Sagan himself — whose biographies carry the virtues the family wants transmitted: curiosity, patience, honesty about error). The result, at its best, is a children's literature of unusual truthfulness: these books do not lie about death, do not promise what they cannot warrant, and treat the child's intelligence as the family's first principle — the child addressed as a small colleague in the inquiry, not a vessel to be filled before the world fills it first.
The adult's closing note is comparative, and it is the reason this lesson stands in a school with twenty-six other ministries: every room in the building faces the same task — the transmission of a world to a child who did not choose it — and the family's literature is the experiment in doing it with the fewest unexamined inheritances. Its failures are the mirror of the religions' (the smug book, the book that teaches contempt for the grandmother's faith, the book whose wonder curdles into a lecture), and its successes are the school's own standard in miniature: accurate, respectful, honest about uncertainty, and warm. The child who asks the questions in these books is the family's hope and its method at once — the next lesson takes up the adults who must answer, and the state of the answering today.
The genre's history is shorter and braver than the adult expects, and the overview should record it. For most of the family's history there were effectively no such books: the non-religious child was raised on the majority's shelf, or on nothing in particular, and the family's parenting was a private improvisation. The modern genre begins in earnest in the 1970s–90s — the “Asking About Sex and Growing Up” model applied to the cosmos, the first evolution picture-books arguing their way past school boards — and flowers in the 2000s with the unaffiliated boom: Dawkins's “The Magic of Reality” (2011, illustrated, addressed directly to young readers — the family's most prominent entry in its own genre, whatever one thinks of its author's other shelf), Ann Druyan's and the “Cosmos” team's children's editions, and a small-press ecosystem of solstice stories, scientist biographies, and grief books that now constitutes a real literature. The school's comparative note is sharp here: the religious rooms built their children's shelves over centuries of institutional effort; this family built its shelf in two generations, in the marketplace, against the headwind of being nobody's establishment — and the shelf's existence is therefore one of the best measures of the unaffiliation's maturity. A position becomes a tradition when it starts writing for its grandchildren. By that test the family has begun.
The genre's frontier is the religions shelf itself, and the overview ends there deliberately. The family's best children's books about the world's faiths — the “what do other people believe” shelf — are written to a standard the school can endorse without reservation, because it is the school's own: each faith stated as its children are taught it, fairly, with the family's own house placed on the same street at the same scale. The failures of the genre are the failures of nerve (the faiths as costumes) and of honesty (the family's house drawn larger). The successes matter beyond the family: in a century when the religious and the non-religious will share every classroom, ward, and parliament, the child who learned the street whole — whose own house, and whose neighbors' — is the citizen both sides are praying, or hoping, for. The family's children's literature, at its best, is that citizen's first school. It has the honor of this building's attention, and it has earned it the hard way: by being fair to the other twenty-six rooms while raising its own.
Lesson 4: Interpretation and study today
How is a canon without a church interpreted, and who may interpret it? The closing lesson of the texts semester maps the family's current state of study — a field with no magisterium, several competing authorities, and one agreed method, arguing in public. The authorities first. The academy: religious-studies and sociology departments now study non-religion as a field in its own right (the Nonreligion and Secularity Research Network and its journals are the institutional markers), with the characteristic finding that the “nones” are not a residue but a population with its own beliefs, practices, and politics, badly served by instruments designed for the churched. The movement's own intellectuals — the philosophers of religion who argue the family's case at full strength (and the theologians who answer them, in a literature of God-debates that is now a genre of its own), the scientists who write for the public, the ex-religious memoirists whose testimony literature (the leaving-story, told in every tradition's exit idiom) has become one of the family's most-read genres. And the digital crowd: the forums and channels where interpretation actually happens for most of the family now — unedited, unaccountable, and, at their best, a genuine commons of inquiry; at their worst, the family's own fundamentalism, with proof-texts from the canon and anathemas for the insufficiently certain.
The method that claims to govern all of it is the one the canon itself prescribes: proportion belief to evidence, hold conclusions revisably, prefer the checkable claim. The adult's audit notes where the method strains against the community's needs — the leaving-story is believed on testimony the teller's new tribe does not audit as it audits the old one's; the movement's heroes are quoted with a reverence their own kit forbids; and the family's interpretation of the religions — the texts it argues against — is often conducted at a level its scholars are embarrassed by in print, the mirror image of the missionary ethnography this school met in the African ministry. The recovery is also visible, and the lesson should end on it: the serious study of non-religion, by its adherents and its scholars together, is one of the humanities' growth fields; the questions it asks — what do the unaffiliated actually believe, practice, and need; how does a lifestance transmit itself; what consoles at the secular deathbed — are the questions this whole school exists to ask about everyone, asked at last about the family that asked them first.
The student's orientation, in closing: interpretation in this room is not the decoding of a revelation but the maintenance of a discipline — the discipline of the open question, kept open honestly in a world of closed answers, including the closed answers of one's own side. The family's best interpreters model it; its worst betray it; and the difference, visible in any week's reading, is the same difference this school has taught in twenty-six other idioms: between the audit and the anthem. Year 1 ends with the practice semester, where the discipline leaves the page: in the laboratory, the library, the quiet room, and the working week of the people who live by it.
The field's methods deserve a final guided note, because they are this family's version of the isnad — the machinery by which it decides what is true about itself. The survey sciences (Pew, the national censuses, the World Values Survey) supply the demography, with the family's characteristic caveat, learned the hard way: the instruments were built by and for the churched — the “belonging” question that means one thing in Stockholm and another in Seoul — and the new scholarship's first work has been instrument repair, designing questions that can hear a lifestance that does not call itself one. The qualitative turn (ethnographies of Sunday Assemblies, of ex-religious networks, of secular hospital wards) supplies the texture the surveys miss; the digital archive supplies the family's first real-time record of itself, with all the audit problems this school met in the African ministry's media migration. The adult's takeaway is the school's universal one, here at its most self-referential: a community's self-knowledge is only as good as its instruments, and this family's instruments are, at last, being built to its own measure — which is why the next decade's account of the non-religious will be the first one the non-religious fully recognize. Interpretation today, in this room, means the family finally reading itself with the care it demanded the world read it with. The demand was always fair. It is finally being met at home.